IN or OUT: Carey Mulligan in Erdem at the 2014 Harper’s Bazaar Women of the Year Awards

What do we all think of this, ladies? Let’s gather ’round and judge.

PinCarey Mulligan attends the 2014 Harper’s Bazaar Women of the Year Awards at Claridge’s Hotel in London, England in an Erdem dress paired with a Sophie Hulme clutch and Sophie Webster pumps.

PinErdem Spring 2015 Collection

Pin

Pin

Pin

Okay first, we will stipulate that the hair is a tragic mess. We wil also stipulate that the belly cutout isn’t flattering and the fabric looks like ’90s hotel upholstery. Also: the satin-y Christmas shoes are a no.

But we think we like the idea of this look for her more than the actual look. We can see her working some edgy, modern take on the Dior New Look given the right styling and fabric choices. So we don’t hate this totally. You get the final say, though.

Bitter Kittens make the call:

IN!  I like it. It’s totally her.

OUT! Nope. Couch with arms.

Sofia Vergara’s wrapping paper dress was inexplicably voted IN by a commentariat that had to have been drunk at the time.

[Photo Credit: Getty Images]

• Carey Mulligan
• Erdem
• Harper’s Bazaar Women of the Year Awards
• Sophie Hulme
• Sophie Webster