Andy, this is remarkably disappointing.
That’s the problem with nerdy-hot guys. They can so easily tip over into just nerdy.
Everything here is bad, from the cut of the Bar Mitzvah suit to the Rachel Maddow hair and glasses. He looks so cute on his show (which is hilarious, by the way). Maybe he should consider just dressing up like his character from now on. Or hiring a stylist, at the very least. This pretty much screams DIY styling. We’re pretty sure he found that tie at the bottom of his closet.
[Photo Credit: Ben Gabbe/Getty Images]