Julia Roberts in Stella McCartney on David Letterman

We think this may be the first time we’ve ever considered subjecting a coat to an “IN or OUT” vote.

Julia Roberts at the Ed Sullivan Theater in New York City for an appearance on the “Late Show With David Letterman” in a Stella McCartney coat paired with Rachel Roy shoes.

But that seems wrong somehow. On the other hand, this coat seems wrong somehow. It’s … old-looking; borderline dowdy. We can see that the color-blocking should be providing visual interest which should be making this pop a little, but it’s just not coming together, to our eyes.  On the other hand, her shoes are super-hot.

So let’s hear it, kittens. Coats are one of those fashion things (like shoes and bags) that garner strong and immediate opinion-forming, we’ve found. We’re pretty sure puh-lenty of y’all love this coat and are about to yell reasons why at us.

And we might as well step in it all the way: that scarf ain’t looking so fresh and modern either.

[Photo Credit: Dara Kushner/INFphoto.com]

• Julia Roberts
• Late Show with David Letterman
• Rachel Roy
• Stella McCartney
• TV Style