We’re finding it hard to render a judgement either way on this one, which is why we’re once again turning it over to all y’all.
Evangeline Lilly attends “The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug” New York Screening in a PAPER London maxi gown.
PAPER London Circuit Dress
Here are our thoughts in random order: that color combination looks really fantastic on her. She’s always had an athletic build, so simple, bold pieces that almost resemble activewear tend to work really well for her. Which means there’s a part of us that pretty much loves this on her. But that’s one bigass white skirt and we’re not sure she’s working it all that well. The proportions, along with her natural shape, just make it hang off her, like a tablecloth.
Also: whoever’s doing her hair needs to be exiled from human contact, but that may be overstating it.
Bitter Kittens make the call:
IN! I dig it. It’s turning my head.
OUT! She looks like she hasn’t finished getting dressed.
Previously on IN or OUT: Saoirse Ronan’s stained-glass Peter Pilotto dress was fiercely debated by the Precious Unborn Fawn Debating Society, with the final vote being IN.