In or Out: Anne Hathaway in Valentino

We’re not feeling this Annie look, dolls.

Anne Hathaway attends the Princess Grace Awards Gala in New York City in a Valentino couture gown paired with Christian Louboutin pumps.

Valentino Fall 2011 Couture Collection/Model: Allaire Heisig (FORD)

Christian Louboutin Pumps

It’s a very pretty dress with very pretty shoes. We can’t say it’s an exciting look, and that top half looks a bit too busy and heavy, but it’s all tasteful and relatively pretty, even if the fit in the bust isn’t so great. But what really needs discussing, girls, is the state of her makeup. WAY too heavy for such a colorless look, right? And she’s all shiny and her hair’s kind of flying away, and well, we’re just gonna say it. Annie honey, you look exhausted here. We suppose you’re the kind of girl who can’t say no to a Princess Grace Awards Gala, but if you’re still shooting your Catwoman scenes during the day, then we can see how you might look ready for a nap.

Vote Now!

IN! She looks sweet and twinkly. Like a grown-up Tinkerbell.

OUT! She looks washed out and tired. Like Casper in a cocktail dress. 

The final votes on Blake Lively’s 1984 boardwalk slut outfit and Joe Manganiello’s unkempt mob enforcer getup were both OUT. You kittens took no prisoners yesterday.

[Photo Credit: Getty, style.com, shopsavannahs.com]

• Anne Hathaway
• Christian Louboutin
• In or Out
• Valentino