IN or OUT: Anne Hathaway in Givenchy

Posted on May 09, 2013

All right. Enough sloppy celebs on the street. Let’s get back to the reason God put us on the earth: celebrity red carpet bitchery.


Anne Hathaway attends the Tate Americas Foundation Artists Dinner in New York City in Givenchy.

Givenchy Spring 2013 Collection

We applauded her willingness to fuck with her hair – a rarity among A-list ladystars – but now that the Met Gala is over, it’s time to return to reality and all hammer out the big issue here: What do we think?

We’ll tell you what; we think Michelle and Carey have this side of the street locked up and no one’s really looking for another A-List actress with a bleached-out pixie cut. It’s good for the initial shock value, but now that we see her dressed and styled a little more conventionally, it’s not really working for us. Truth be told, we never thought the pixie was her friend, but she styled it well all through the Fantine poledance and we came to appreciate it. But if she feels the need to move on, then we suggest starting to grow it out rather than dyeing it another color. Everything about her face cries out for dark hair with some length to it to set it off. That’s just us.

Also: pale pink has suddenly been removed from her wheelhouse now that the only contrast she offers are her eyes. The whole effect is kind of weird. She’s like this ghostly figure with oddly dark eyes and brows. Fab shoes, though.

The rest is up to you.



Vote Now!


IN! I can’t get enough waifs in my life!


OUT! Oh, HONEY. I’m booking you an appointment with my girl right now.


The kittens almost unanimously loved Cameron Diaz’s New Wave Hitchcock femme look, voting it IN by a wide margin.



[Photo Credit: Getty,]

  • Previous post:
    Next Post:
    • hughman

      Star Trek Snuggie.

      • Adella Thompson

        Seriously was about to make the same comment!!

        • hughman

          You gotta be fast here in T-Lo comments! It’s Rule #1 in my new book “The Unauthorized Guide To Commenting on Tom and Lorenzo”! (Just kidding, I am wayyy too lazy to write a book.)

      • grouchywif

        I was thinking Star Wars myself.

        • Celandine1

          It’s definitely something from Princess Leia’s closet.

      • Candigirl1968

        Yes. Give this dress to Zoe Saldana for her Star Trek pole dance.

      • MartyBellerMask

        OK, that is funny but she’s still in. :)

    • Miss_Led

      It’s like a miniskirted Snuggie.
      From the future.



      This has Star Trek Sickbay Nurse written allll over it.

    • Dora K.

      That’s a really scary close-up.

    • foodycatAlicia

      IN. I don’t want her to stay blonde for long, but I love a brown-eyed blonde. I also like the dress even though I expect her to be carrying a backpack when she turns around and I think the matching manicure is a step too far.

      • misstressofsylar

        but Cate f**king Blanchett did this look already and there is just no comparison..hating the shoes but since she refuses to wear anything leather and prefers the vegan kind, she gets a pass

    • jennifervney

      Out. No bueno. That hair color is too light or something.

      • Candigirl1968

        Yup. It’s not flattering at all.

      • VictoriaDiNardo

        Too gold I think. As a bleach addict myself, I think if this was a whiter blond it would look more,striking and not so “this is as light as they could get it” which may be the case. That’s the only way the dark brow works – you have to Debbie Harry it.

        • VictoriaDiNardo

          Oh, and I hate the dress. Out.

        • Amelia Logan

          I was going to say the same thing. It’s very yellow.
          My hair is the same shade, and if she dyes it regularly then it probably had too much deposit to lift.

          • VictoriaDiNardo

            Yeah, I’ve been here a few times. Purple shampoo until you can fix it!

        • Glammie

          So true. Hathaway’s color and mine are quite similar and I look ill in most blonde wigs. You’re either dark or one step away from white–because white hair actually looks good. Yellow doesn’t.

          Anyway, she shouldn’t do this forever, but it’s been what? Two days? She can do it for a little longer. Plus, her hair is actually kind of shiny, she’s getting good care.

          Oh, and while I like Michelle Williams hair, I don’t like Carey Mulligan’s color–it’s not a good one for her.

          • Rhonda Shore

            Agree! Don’t think Mulligan’s all that. Like someone above said, it’s only been a few days and she looks cute. IN!

    • Sara Brams-Miller

      I hate those shoes. They look like glittery Gellies.

      • marlie

        I don’t like them either. :P

      • ballerinawithagun

        I can’t believe the boys liked them!

    • StellaZafella

      I like her…a lot, especially in unexpectedly comic performances. Maybe that’s why the blond doesn’t work for me, but I think, if she wants a big change in her coloring, she could try a high Auburn or real deep red. her eyes are too dark for the blond. And the dress would be better here in black.

      • VioletFem

        That’s exactly what I was telling someone the other day about Anne’s new color! She looks soooo much better as a brunette, and although she did style it really well for the Met Gala, here it is not working for me. She could definitely pull of a red hair color.

    • muzan-e

      Ice-green eyeshadow?
      I’m trying to think of a more effective way for her to make the dark eyes look like an anomaly, but damned if anything’s coming to mind.

      • Sarah

        I just got some ice-green eyeshadow, and I really like it. Brightens me peepers. Then, I’m blue-eyed, and strawberry blonde, so I have little in common with her coloring.

        • muzan-e

          Oh, the colour is beautiful! It’s like gorgeous minty ice, and I love, love it on blue eyes.

          But the blonde’s left her positively nordic, all the ice on the eyes is doing here is making her huge, dark doe-eyes larger and darker and more contradictory.

          • Sarah

            Yes, I agree. She needs a bridge from the hair to the eyes an shadow could do it – maybe a coppery color.

    • sara

      Dress is blah, makeup/hair combo is HORRIBLE.

    • Michelle Young

      Exactly! Her eyes are so bold on her face now she kind of looks like a cartoon!

    • Pam Meers Purtle

      Annie, honey, if you are going to bleach your hair, you must consider the brows. Just too stark of a contrast. Otherwise everything is ok. just ok.

      • Kristin McNamara

        Glad I scrolled before commenting… was gonna say this exact thing!

      • Anne

        I agree – yet I always find died eyebrows end up looking orange. One of my BF’s in HS had naturally very blond hair, green eyes and dark eyebrows. I guess because it was her natural look that it worked? Not working for Annie. She should go back to brown in a few days.

        • Sarah

          My friend looks like that too, green eyes and all, but her roots are naturally darker than her very blonde ends. I think that’s why it doesn’t look weird. If you have hair blonde enough to be white at the roots naturally, then you’re gonna have the matching eyebrows and lashes.

    • Reality TV Casting

      out out out tacky mctackerson called and wants his hair back

    • Sally Brownson

      IN. I kind of love the vibe. If she keeps doing that heavy eye makeup with the hair color, I’m going to keep loving it. I wish the dress were in a darker color, but she looks good enough to me.

      • ampg

        I agree with you – it’s so unexpected that it works. But I give her a month, tops, before the shock value wears off and she starts to look stupid, so I hope she goes back to brunette pretty quickly.

    • jetpackdino

      Hm. Hathaway in a little pink slanket by Givenchy…

      I’m giving it an in, but just barely. Even though I have similar concerns about her hair etc., there’s something kinda cute about this look as a whole.

    • annabelle archer

      I’m looking for the plastic surgery that she must have had and is using the hair as a distraction.

    • gabbilevy

      My first impression was pretty positive, but I’m liking it less and less the more I look. The shape is better on Anne than on the model but the color isn’t working with her hair.

      On balance, out.

    • crash1212

      OUT. I don’t like the color of the dress and shortening it threw the proportions all off. In this instance, it needed the length to make any sense. As for the hair – I don’t hate it, but she can’t be wearing such non-colors with acres of non-color legs poking out and topping it off with non-color hair…ghost-like with fierce eyes pretty much sums it up.

      • marlie

        We’re usually screaming at the ladystars to appropriately hem their dresses, but this time, she pulled a Heidi and went too far.

    • Introspective

      OUT. ive got nothing witty to say. (sue me its 20 mins to 5pm) just none of it works.

    • Deborah Lipp

      The blond hair is out but everything else is so in. This is sharp and unusual and NOT body hugging. Hello stars who can look great without playing the slinky card or the nearly naked card.

      • sekushinonyanko

        I don’t know if we need to be passing out points for avoiding nearly naked when the thing is hemmed almost up to her lady business…

    • marlie

      OUT. The bleached hair was great for shock value, but the dark hair compliments her coloring so much better. Plus, she’d have so much of a better chance taking over the mantle of dark-haired pixie from Ginnifer Goodwin, since she doesn’t often get it right. And Maggie Gyllenhaal is in a category by herself.

    • Melissa Brogan

      Out. Not a good look for her.

    • Anathema_Device

      I like the runway version of the dress so much more. This just doesn’t work in pink, plus the longer length is more interesting.

      The blonde on her? Not really feeling it. Not great with her coloring.

      Just talked myself into an Out vote. Sorry Anne.

    • Coco Cornejo

      Prefer her hair spiked out like she had it at the Met ball

    • Anplica Fiore

      For some reason, I’m getting a Cher vibe from both the shoes & the dress. Out. And I really don’t like her as a blonde…

    • MilaXX

      small IN. I don’t mind the hair, but she may need to dye the brows just a shade lighter. I think she’d look better as a red head though. It would look great against her pale skin. I don;t like those shoes paired with this dress, but overall a decent look.

    • NurseEllen

      Out. She looks like one of those big-eyed, pallid waifs that were painted on velvet and were sold in the 70s.

      • Donna Tabor

        She looks like no matter how her hair is.

    • filmcricket

      I’ve loved the pixie on her so long as it was styled right; I’ll be sorry if she goes any longer than that fabulous post-break-up bob she had when she dumped that fraudster on his ass. But I agree, the blonde is not really working for her, and that pale pink is right out until she goes dark again.

      The dress itself? The runway version looks kind of “bondage angel” while the shortened looks more “stingray.” I like it better than a lot of the stuff she wore during her poledance, but I don’t know if I *like it* like it. And I hate the shoes. Hmm. Small out, I guess.

    • ChristopherM

      The role of Justin Bieber has already been cast. Out.

    • Ashley Ellen Wilson

      In all honesty the color is lovely and it was nice for the Gala, but I immediately thought what you said “I don’t want another Michelle Williams!” She needs to go BACK to brunette.

    • Kenisha Hill Phillips

      I actually love the pixie on her, but I prefer her as a brunette.

      Overall, I can’t sign off on this look.

      • Donna Tabor

        Ditto. And I like her hair so much I had mine cut that way, from a bob.

    • Erica_Vuitton

      I’d switch out the shoes for a less strappy pair but other than that IN. Also, I really love the icy blonde hair and dark brows. When you look back at the short brunette shots now she looks so mousey. This color really gives her some edge and honestly… a little bit of sex appeal.

    • teensmom99

      IN. You’re right about everything but she looks good.

    • flamingoNW

      OUT. Hate that dress. Agree about the hair

    • alyce1213

      Out. The dress is kind of interesting on the model, but she made it too short.
      Complete agreement on the hair. It’s not for her.

    • JuliaInBlack

      Is it just me or do the sleeves sort of look like floppy elephant ears? I don’t think this plays to her looks at all; only the shoes and pedicure are working for me. OUT

    • Janet B

      Love the dress on her.
      It’s an OUT until the blonde hair is gone.

    • Gwyndall

      She looks like a nurse on the Enterprise…

    • SewingSiren

      I like the original length better, but over all she looks good.

    • tereliz

      When it was edgy it worked, but this is too twee.

    • carnush

      That’s not her hair. Not working for me. OUT.

    • Kim Brightman

      OUT. Horrible dress that is too short, and NeNe Leakes wants her wig back.

    • Cameron Turner


    • Eva_baby

      Out. Hair color looks wrong for her skin tone.

    • Fordzo

      She looks like a Real Housewife with that hair color.

    • berkeleygirl

      Like Julia Roberts, she should never be blonde…

    • Lori

      Out. I’m not tremendously angry at this or anything, but there’s way too much that’s not working. Obviously I hate her hair. I think the dress looked better in the slightly longer runway version because that length balanced out the major sleeves better. I also think the blue would have been a better choice than the not-enough-contrast pink, although some other color altogether would have been better still. I do kind of love the shoes.

    • Sheneve Butler

      I absolutely love it! IN!

    • Qitkat

      I’m on the fence, dress is too short, hair is too blonde, brows are too dark, shoes are too ?vinyl? yet she still looks very pretty. Mmm, out, the blonde was fun for the Met Gala, but she’s a brunette, through and through.

    • Tanya Wade

      Serving Joey/Lola Heatherton realness. “I want to bear your children!”

    • random_poster

      Go back to your brunette self, Anne, and then we’ll talk. Out!

    • MarissaLG

      I wrote a haiku about her hair:
      No no no, Annie. /
      No no no no please, no./
      No no no just stop. /

    • Anne

      I am completely lukewarm and non-committal on this one, but wanted to add a voice for – WOW GREAT MAKE-UP. She truly has such an amazing smile and pair of eyes. I am surprised she doesn’t do more stagework because we really has features that would project to the back row.

      Eyebrows are too dark for that yellow hair, agreed, however, I’m still going to have to go with IN based largely upon her make-up artist who has made her face pull off that dress.

    • Brick Mercury

      Remember when Julia Roberts dyed her hair blonde and played Tinkerbell…

    • IMNAngryLiberal

      I had pale, pale, blonde hair when I was young and was always dyeing it dark red or dark brown or black. My friends with gorgeous auburn and brunette hair were always bleaching their hair blonde … you just gotta walk on the other side of the street once in a while.

    • nannypoo

      I’m seeing an elephant. If she had a trunk coming out of her navel then you would all see it too. Hate the hair.

    • Bert Keeter

      Lost in Space….literally!

    • Jackie Atkins

      Gotta say OUT. The only thing I like is the shoes.

    • Lily

      IN because I think she’s really interesting looking with this hair color. It sure made me look longer than if she had her natural brown, and isn’t that what all this is really about anyway?

    • kerryev

      I agree on the floating eyeballs problem. Hair in, for the next 2.5 weeks. Then fix it.

    • Aniela Marie Perry

      Out. The shortened skirt and her aww shucks demeanor take it from sleek, futuristic minimalism to something that looks like a fleece throw tacked to her bra straps.

    • Shawn EH

      Stewardess from 2001: A Space Odyssey. You’d think that would be an in, but no: OUT!

    • Barbara Affolter

      Before she goes back to the dark hair, she should send her colorist’s contact info to Carey and Michelle. Send it to Gwyneth Paltrow while she’s at it. See how soft and shiny her hair looks, even though she just put it through a harsh chemical treatment? Just about every other Hollywood blonde needs someone in their life who can make that happen on their head.

    • Constanza Álvarez Espinoza

      She’s already in my irrational hate list. Now there’s one more reason for her to be there. OUT.

    • RebeccaKW

      Out. Hate the dress. I’m fine with the dyed hair, but I think she needs to let it grow.

      Damn, that dress is ugly.

    • jilly_d

      IN! The hair is fun (for a while) and I think works with her big dark eyes and brows. COol dress, and (I see I’m in the minority here) I like the shoes. You werq that Gwen Stefani head, girl!

    • ojosazules

      Don’t mind her blond (definitely prefer her “natural” color), but the overall effect is bland- plus the dress is just awkward and weird. Out.

    • Agatha Guilluame

      OUT! I can’t tell if the outfit is bad or not because her face is distracting me. Her features aren’t delicate enough to pull off the blond pixie. Blame Mia Farrow.

      • Amelia Logan

        She looks like she traded faces with Morena Bacarrin.

        • Agatha Guilluame


    • MartyBellerMask

      Love this love this love this.
      But Annie, WHY couldn’t you have worn something like this for the Oscars??


    • colleenjanel

      I actually love this look, but if she’s going to do blonde, she needs to lighten the brows and adjust the eye makeup.

    • Judy_S

      I like it. I like the pale pink waifiness of it. Just for one night.

    • Christine

      OUT with gold stars on it. Can’t stand the hair — why do beautiful brunettes dye their hair to that bright yellow shade?

      I also went out because of….didn’t anyone else notice that her boobs seem, um, unbalanced?

    • Sara__B

      Ghostly, indeed. OUT.

    • Contralto

      OUT. That shade of blonde is so bad on her.

    • VioletFem

      OUT She should have gone with the blue version of this dress (while stil keeping the same shape that she chose to wear, not the looser one that the model is wearing). It would have given it more contrast with the blonde hair, but I’m not convinced that the blonde really works for her.

    • Diego!

      I only liked the shoes. OUT!

    • Angelo

      The outfit is cute, she just needs to change her hair FAST. It washes her out way too much.

    • MajorBedhead

      Out.I really dislike her hair this color. It’s too harsh for her skin/eyes.

      ETA: The dress is just weird, and as several have said, too sci-fi snuggie.

    • Kate4queen

      In I actually like her blonde. :)

    • heartbot

      Is the hair for a role maybe? I think the dress looks fantastic on her but: 1) not with that hair, and 2) not with those shoes.

    • another_laura

      Out and totally with you on the hair color appt. I’m going to my guy next Saturday, darling, come along…

    • Synnamin

      IN. I love it, and I think that cut looks stunning on her

    • conniemd

      In. She looks like a unique style in this. Wouldn’t recommend it for any length of time, though. But kinda sheik and different.

    • carolynmo

      Out. Dislike everything but the shoes.

    • Julie Chase

      So out. I’m too tired to critique each aspect of her look, it’s all just one big BLERG.

    • Tracy_Flick

      I don’t mind the dress in theory, but the way it fits makes it look like her breasts are somewhere around her belly button, and way out to the sides.

      I’m leaning towards OUT, though I think it’s not a terrible effort.

    • LaSylphide

      Out. The dress looks better in the longer version, although even that’s not great. Do like the shoes.

    • demidaemon

      I actually really like this and the alterations she made. The slut cut tightened up the proportions nicely. IN.

    • stagmania

      OUT. That hair color worked in the context of the Met Gala, but it just looks odd for every day.

    • Snailstsichr

      In. Once – for trying something fun and different. But, please go back to brunette before I take it back.

    • unbornfawn

      OUT. The whole bleached hair and her recent clothing choices have a stink of desperation to it, which is odd, but she’s kind of freaked out ever since she won the Academy Award and lost her identity. Nothing wrong with going back to her lovely dark long locks. She really would look much better. Blondes in Hollywood are a dime a dozen.

    • Caterina Maria

      It actually suits her. IN.

    • msdamselfly

      IT’s the styling not the color of the hair that is so unflattering

    • Jangle57

      I applaud the risk taking but no, OUT

    • BuffaloBarbara

      I like the headshot, as far as the dress goes — in other words, the shot where you can’t see much of the dress. It’s ugly and unflattering.

      I don’t think bleached out hair looks especially good on anyone, and I was over the pixie cut before Emma Watson got one. Okay, I was never under the pixie cut.

    • snarkykitten

      My first thought was sanitary pad :/

    • trisker

      OUT. just WEIRD.

    • bellafigura1

      OUT. Girl, that is not your hair.

    • l_c_ann

      Out. A bad case of the galloping blands.

    • MissMariRose

      OUT. The slut cut ruined the dress.

    • PeaceBang

      OUT. But mostly because I loathe the neckline on her. Ruins the whole thing.

    • BrooklynBomber

      Hmmm, I don’t think Carey’s so good as a blond. Nor is Anne, but it’s the stingray dress that bothers most.

    • Sweetpea176

      I love the pixie cut on Anne. I especially loved it when it was very short. Do not like the blond. Hate this dress on her. Shortening it ruined the proportions and made an otherwise possibly cool-looking garment into a ridiculous-looking one. Even if it did look ok on her, I’d still object on principle to anyone wanting to be a fashionista choosing to show off her legs at the expense of the actual fashion. OUT, and several fashion icon points deducted.

    • bailey debruynkops


    • MissAmynae

      More out than a banana clip and hypercolor.

    • MandyM

      I kinda liked it. IN (although I’ll be outvoted I’m sure!)

    • Michelle O’Brien

      Out. I have her coloration too. We were not meant to be blonde. And she does need to grow it out, too.

    • Imasewsure

      I say IN but not a huge in… hope the hair goes away soon but it’s not awful. It just doesn’t suit her. LOVE the shoes

    • Lisa_Co

      Out, out OUT.

    • quiltrx

      OUT. Looks like Yeoman Rand’s nightgown.
      And this is one time I have to say (channeling my best Fred Gwynne)…”sometimes, longah is bettah.”

    • TSkot

      She looks great: IN

    • Nonmercisansfacon


    • silaria

      OUT. So very much out.

      I actually like the dress, weird as it is, and the accessories work well with it.

      That out of the way, the hair is TERRIBLE. The color is completely wrong, and it looks so, so fake. I really hate dark brows with bleached hair, gah. I’d love to see her with rich brown hair, though, that matched her eyes. I’ll bet that would be lovely…

    • Anniebet

      IN. The dress is unusual. I like it shorter than the one on the model, and adore that little collar. I’m finding the blonde hair and pale pink to be just fine. What’s a problem for me as well are the dark brows and eye makeup. Looks too artificial.

    • rainwood1

      I’m with you on the hair, T Lo. The blonde isn’t flattering and her features aren’t delicate enough to work a pixie cut. The blonde just emphasizes that.

    • JauntyJohn

      I haven’t gone through all the comments, but surely I’m not the only one thinking, “Honey, try a red.” Not an orange-red, but a rich auburn. Or, if that’s not fun/edgy enough for her, what about like a deep, grape-tootsie-pop kind of purple. I’m serious — that might look incredible.
      As for the rest, I want to like it, but that shape says “angel wings” to me, so with regret, I say “OUT.”

    • formerlyAnon

      Brunette is better for her. And this is a weak look, once past the shoulders.

      Nonetheless, IN because I do still like the hair a lot, and the shoulders of the garment somewhat, and I’m feeling benevolent.

    • sleah_in_norcal

      nonono. i thought when i saw the thumbnail that this was alaska. blonde is not her friend. and i love me some pink, but this looks like she dipped her dress in pepto bismal.

    • Merneith

      Out. The dress was cool when it was a little longer but the shorter skirt makes the wings look clipped. And that’s a horrid shade of blonde for a dark complected girl.

    • Ummy

      That first picture is terribly unflattering in the chest area. Like she has one randomly droopy boob. Cannot unsee. Out out out. Also, ditto to everything about the bleach blonde.

    • dashwoodstole

      In. I think she looks good, and I’ll let her off a bit with the hair – it’s just reaching the awkward point of growing it out, bleaching it draws attention away from that.

    • hotpaprika

      She’s not a blonde girl. She can get away with it because she’s young but it doesn’t do anything to her. The dress is interesting enough and I think it would look more interesting with her natural hair colour, which would add contrast. As it is she looks like a half-finished home Barbie project.

    • E. D.

      I like her hair, but the shoes and the jewelry are no good with that dress. I’d almost rather see JLo’s wedge sneakers than those strappy monstrosities.

    • Aaminah Khan

      I actually…don’t hate it? But I’d love to see that exact hairstyle in a darker colour. Imagine it in a deep auburn or something. That’d be fab.

      Still, I love that she’s smirking like she just had the best sex ever, so IN.

    • Max Haland

      I say a weak IN. I’ve actually been a fan of her hair cuts lately (especially the “in-between” length), but I agree that her hair color really is not her friend. Maybe if her hair was still dark I might like this pale pink better? As it stands, the shape is very Star Trek, yes, but it ALMOST works. I like the red carpet length & color a lot better than the runway version, for sure – that one looks like bizarre mental patient robes. The weird little turtleneck is a big minus, though.

    • Jessica TallGirl Freeman

      OUT. Its her dark eyebrows and bright blonde hair that make it look so awkward. Just a few shades darker and then maybe. I like the pixie, but not the blonde pixie.

    • theblondette

      I say IN, because it’s only been a few days so she can go back to brunette soon enough, I’m sure, and in the meantime she really looks like she’s having fun, which to me makes the outfit seem like a cute vacation from her ordinary life along with the hair.

    • Aly Light

      I think she’s styled this fabulously, and the changes from the runway version are perfect. IN.

    • thecitysleeps

      I liked her hair at the Met Gala, but definitely not styled like this. OUT.

    • GorgeousThings

      The good news is she ditched the Pinterest nails.
      The bad news is the rest of the look.

    • Jaeda Laurez

      I feel like she could seriously work a Liza with a Z! look if her hair was dark. But this blonde has got to go. But I like the outfit (with dark hair) and the shoes are awesome. Literally everything is dope EXCEPT her hair color.

    • Aurumgirl

      The metal shoulder plates match the Zanotti platform wedgie sneakers JLo was wearing the other day. Which makes this a polio dress (especially on the runway version).

      This Brass blonde is the wrong blonde for Anne.

    • BigWhiteGrannyPanties

      Someone needs to give her a box of Clairol now. NOW.

    • Renaissance_Man_ATL

      IN! I like the blonde and I like the look. Not saying she should stay blonde forever tho…

    • stubbornthoughts

      IN. I prefer Annie as a brunette, but she’s working those blonde locks for me. Besides, Carey has been failing hard on her bleached-out pixie, so Annie might as well help out.

      Not a huge fan of the dress, but I think she looks classy as hell.

    • jw_ny


      The dress is interesting and suits her quirky side…I actually like it. The hair however…it’s a NO to the blonde for her, although I kind of like the pixie cut for her. This overall look would have looked so much better in her natural brown shade.

    • lizlemonglasses

      Out! Awkwardly short, unflattering hair color, and hell to the n-o on those shoes. Her eye makeup looks pretty, but I’m distracted because her wings are on backwards.

    • Sara Padilla

      That color would’ve been fine for a brunette. If she keeps the blonde, she’s got to revise her palette accordingly.

    • Not applicable

      i think she looks terrible in that shade of blonde. sorry- had to be said.

    • kvlm

      Sandy Duncan. Peter Pan.

      • Marie Fessler


    • lalahartma


    • lobsterlen

      No to it all. Hair cut, color and dress. Wasn’t she suppose to disappear for awhile? It hasn’t been nearly long enough.
      OUt on all counts.

    • CatherineRhodes

      I actually love the hair and makeup, hate the dress. OUT

    • ThaliaMenninger

      I hate all of it and the peroxide look is not her friend. So out she might as well be in Siberia. Which, honestly, she could be, because she’s reminding me of those odious Russian ice dancers with the terrible hair.

    • Colleen

      I’m actually loving it all… except the lipstick.

    • pepper76

      Actually, I think she is trying to grow it out, but it takes a LONG time. She probably bleached it to try to distract from the awkward length. I’ve been there.

    • kikisayshi

      Ugh, just no. WTF with the hair? It’s awful! And that is not her dress. OUT (in case that wasn’t clear).

    • Sonja Brisson

      Star Trek, all the way!

    • largishbearishAtlish

      I so much liked this better in the pale blue…

    • Charlie

      Marilyn drag. The girl needs some Marilyn drag. Tousled and full and getting off the plane to shoot Prince and the Showgirl. Some weight and heaviness to break it up.

    • Sally3000

      I can’t explain it, considering Liza is a brunette, but blonde Anne Hathaway reminds me of Liza Minnelli. Maybe it’s the added emphasis to eyes and brows, I don’t know.

    • ballerinawithagun

      The hair color was fabulous for the Met Gala. I just assumed she would go back to brunette immediately after.

      Hate pink, love the dress in the blue.


    • Beth Ann

      I agree that she looks much better with her face framed by longer, darker hair. The pixie cut was maturing in a way that her actress her age does not want. She looked like a wealthy PTA, middle aged mom. The dark brows and eyes combined with the bright bleached blond hair give her face a harsh look. She needs the softening effect of those longer, dark locks to make her features pop right.

    • Marie Fessler

      This: Everything about her face cries out for dark hair with some length to it to set it off.

      Because otherwise I just think her nose looks too big, instead of seeing a pleasing whole face.

    • librarygrrl64

      OUT. Mostly for this very reason: “[P]ale pink has suddenly been removed from her wheelhouse now that the only contrast she offers are her eyes.”