Fashion Face-Off: Miley Cyrus vs. Rosie Huntington-Whitely

Posted on March 26, 2013

Darlings, consider the following pictures and attempt to form an opinion as you scroll down. We know you have it in you.

 

Miley Cyrus attends ‘Seacrest Studios’ event held at CHOC Children’s Hospital in Orange, California.

Rosie Huntington Whiteley attends the Chanel Pre-Oscar dinner at Madeo Restaurant in Los Angeles, California.

It doesn’t seem fair to pit a pop star (so to speak) against a model, but we met Miley briefly and trust us, the girl is no bigger than most models herself and she’s quite a bit prettier in person. Besides, we saw Miley’s pictures first and thought she looked pretty good. Unfortunately, Miss Rosie can make just about any garment sing and she’s doing a much better job of working this look. Rosie’s necklace is a far better choice than Miley’s, as is her muted lipstick vs. Miley’s clown mouth. In fact, much as we love this jumpsuit, the more we look at it on Miley, the more we think she looks a little bit like an insane mime. Miss Rosie, on the other hand, is demonstrating both the power of accessories and the power of posing the shit out of something.

So, who do you think wore it best, darlings?

[Photo Credit: Getty]

    • Meg0GayGuys6

      Poor Miley. Never stood a chance.

      • http://www.facebook.com/sheneve Sheneve Butler

        i agree. I thought it looked good on her when I first say it, but showing the same outfit on a model. Tsk Tsk.

      • Introspective

        seriously. Rosie oozes fierce out of her pores. plus the effortless vibe she has going works better than Miley’s obvious “im trying hard to look cool” hair and clown makeup.

        • Alexina04

          Completely agree. Rosie looks a million times better.

    • http://www.twitter.com/anneofnogables AnneNotHathaway

      I think the orange lipstick with the stark black ‘n white is giving Miley a very “I’m a sexy prison bitch” kind of vibe, which might just be a warning to us all.

    • https://twitter.com/Gayer_Than_Thou Gayer Than Thou

      I didn’t know who this other woman is, and my first thought was “She certainly stands in that dress better than Miley.” On the other hand, Miley is at a Children’s Hospital — maybe she’ll be making balloon animals later.

      • gabbilevy

        And yet they both look like incarcerated clowns.

        • SugarSnap108

          Incarcerated clowns. Yes. Perfect.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Misfor-Moose/100001978210849 Misfor Moose

            They both look like models in the Project Runway Stilt challenge.

            • DebbieLovesShoes

              HAHA, that’s RIGHT!

      • Introspective

        i took a swig of my morning OJ at my desk and then read the last line of your post, and damn near ruined my laptop!!!! thanks for a good laugh and a near disaster!

    • http://twitter.com/PhDKnitter marlie

      Miley looks good, but Rosie wins this one because of the accessories and the makeup. Miley’s lipstick is downright garish there.

    • http://twitter.com/DarthJaeda Jaeda Laurez

      Miley is too short for that. Maybe if the hem were short enough to show a little shoe- you can’t be short and rock the “Gumby” hem.

    • http://twitter.com/lindseyirvin Lindsey Irvin

      I don’t totally hate Miley in this, but from what I can tell she’s got total stripper shoes on and that’s never good. RHW forever.

    • sarahmichelef

      Miley coulda won it with better accessories & makeup.

      • formerlyAnon

        I’d give it to her with just a makeup correction. Mostly because I prefer her hair.

    • Jecca2244

      there is such pain in admitting a lipstick doesn’t work. but, sadly, this one doesn’t work for Miley. or at least not with this outfit. How old is Miley? Late 20s?

      • NC_Meg

        20.

    • Janet B

      Miley: Her lipstick looks crazy, otherwise she looks fine.
      Rosie: She a model, of course she looks good.

      Anytime before 7am my opinions are more grumpy than coherent and concise.

    • JDreesen

      this is one of those cases where venue is important – i’m not exactly on Team Miley, but i also don’t think it’s necessarily a fashion crime to look like Patch Adams if you are attending an event held at a Children’s Hospital.

      (that being said, i think the outfit is altogether more appropriate for a pre-Oscar dinner, so Rosie gets my vote.)

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=768540908 Badriya Al-Badi’a

      Miley, definitely–she looks like she’s enjoying the hell out of her outfit, as opposed to dutifully wearing what her stylist (or contractual obligation) told her to wear. She might look less suave or sophisticated, but she has personality in buckets.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1208138556 Sara Munoz Munoz

        This this this.

      • j_anson

        That’s how I felt! Her technical score is lower, but she looks like she’s enjoying it rather than practicing modeling and posing on her off hours, which is how I always feel about Rosie Huntington-Whitely.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=610791985 Aniela Marie Perry

        I think Miley’s look is more appropriate to this silly jumpsuit. It just seems to call for not being taken too seriously.

    • Lolo Andre

      Whoever did Miley’s makeup should be fired. She looks like a clown

    • claudemtl777

      The jumpsuit is wearing Miley…

    • MsOlympia

      The tattoos and harsh styling definitely give Miley a bit of an inmate vibe.

    • Diego!

      Sorry Hannah Montana, go back to Disney. You have no chance against Ms. Rosie.

    • miagain

      strapless jumpsuit??? What the hell happens when you sit down???

      • Imasewsure

        One does not sit in this outfit

        • Melizmatic

          EVER.

          *lolz

    • Sobaika

      Rosie definitely, although had you asked me whose jumpsuit that was it definitely seems very Miley. She just dropped the ball on accessorizing.

    • jw_ny

      Clown lipstick aside, Miley looks pretty good in this outfit. No contest tho who wore it better; Rosie is some pretty serious competition for even the best of the best to go up against.

    • kaycem

      i disagree — i love the poppy-colored lipstick and shorter necklace with this!

      oh well, it won’t be the first time i’ve chosen boom over boring (or anyone/-thing over rhw, for that matter)… granted, rhw is posing better, but who cares? miley has the je ne se quoi to pull off the look generally, and idek why rhw tried to “sweet secretary” what’s clearly an outfit made for a bad bitch.

      i vote miley.

      #TheCheeseStandsAlone

    • http://twitter.com/manon_eileen Manon Eileen

      Rosie. Clearly.

    • http://joyouslifesf.wordpress.com Kiltdntiltd

      Rose, for the win.

    • lobsterlen

      Honestly its hard to compare. I like the jumpsuit on both of them. Rossie had a better back drop. Miley looks like she is having more fun. I’d give it to Miley.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/37TPKASIMXVUPYK5BNQFOL43KU Carina

      Miley needs to stop. Stop with the makeup, leave the hair alone, and just stop. I don’t care for the outfit either way, but Rosie wins.

    • Jennifer Coleman

      It just boils down to Miley looking like she’s trying too hard vs. Rosie Whatever-Whatever looking elegantly effortless.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1447060898 Lori Wade Miller

      They both look like prisoners.

    • nannypoo

      The only thing I like about Miley Cyrus, now or ever, is her edgy haircut. This outfit is better on her than most of the crap she wears, but clearly it’s better on Rosie. That said, it really is a dumb outfit for anyone.

    • Lilithcat

      I think exactly the opposite.

      RH-W’s necklace detracts from the look. It ruins the line of the top, and looks cheap (even though I’m sure it’s not). She’s trying to appear glamorous in something that’s not; it’s a jumpsuit for cryin’ out loud! Cyrus is having fun with a garment meant to be fun.

    • http://kingderella.tumblr.com/ kingderella

      they both look pretty good. although, that first shot of cyrus screams GIANT HYPNO-VAG.
      huntington-whitely knows how to work a garment, but she also seems more distant and less personable. id say its a draw.

      • http://twitter.com/PhDKnitter marlie

        Giany Hypno-vag. YES.

    • schadenfreudelicious

      I just cant get past Miley’s “makeup applied with a trowel” look…even though its a wee bit Hamburglarish for my taste, Rosie takes it…

      • TropiCarla

        Seriously … she looks like she ripped those eyebrows off some poor helpless muppet.

    • par3182

      …Pre-Oscar dinner…

      I’ve heard of getting in early but that’s freakin’ ridiculous.

    • sleepycat

      After you mentioned the lipstick issue on Miley, Rosie won the challenge.

    • BuffaloBarbara

      That is a seriously fugly outfit one way or the other. Rosie is wearing it better, though. Something about the legs seems to be making Miley’s legs a little stumpy.

    • VeryClaire

      Neither, it looks like a circus tent. Too much stripes for any one person.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=811053804 Stacy Parker Cole

      They both look like they’re going to the circus.

    • VicD

      I thought Miley looked better – more fresh and contemporary as befits the lines of that unfortunate garment. Of course, winning a face off that features a prison striped clown jumpsuit is nothing to brag on, but RHW doesn’t have the attitude to carry this off. She’s trying to make it ladylike, and it can’t be done. In particular, I thought her long pearl necklace was a hideous choice with this.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2CNDPMVO4W23R5TVC2QMTJ5BZE Heather

      I think it’s a Sophie’s Choice, actually, because I HATE all jumpsuits but especially striped ones. (And these stripes in particular are making my eyes twitch.) But if I had to choose I’d say … Miley. I prefer her styling, minus the orange lipstick and too-heavy brows.

      Also: Miley seems to have actual personality, whereas Rose Whatever comes across as a modelbot. Personality always trumps in my opinion.

    • lehen

      rosie by 1,000,000

    • Alyssa

      Rosie wins, hands down. She doesn’t even look like she’s trying! Miley is doing a pretty good job, but she can’t best Rosie. Not today, anyway.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Cortney-Dean/100002491593625 Cortney Dean

      Rosie, the styling did it 100%.

    • zelavie

      I don’t care for the jumpsuit, but it’s Rosie all the way.

    • http://twitter.com/foodycatAlicia foodycatAlicia

      Is this Stella McCartney? It seems to have some of her fingerprints on it.

    • http://www.ellenciompi.com/ NurseEllen

      If forced to make a choice between which person wore the same ridiculous outfit better, I would, oddly, go with Miley. Somehow it suits her personality better, despite the indefensible makeup, and the personal sorrow her tattoos cause me. I like the shorter, more severe necklace, and the shorter hair. She also looks happier. Rosie looks like a fish out of water–a beautiful, elegant, stylishly attired fish out of water, mind you, but essentially uncomfortable nonetheless.

      Really, though, this is a silly use of beach umbrella fabric.

    • http://remedialstitcher.blogspot.com/ Sara Leigh Merrey

      Rosie, hands down.

    • MzzPants

      First of all, let us note that we are discussing a prison-striped strapless jumpsuit. Say that out loud with me.

      I give Miley the win on this one and here’s why:
      1. “Prison-striped strapless jumpsuit” immediately reads more ‘rock-n-roll’.
      2. I prefer the way it fits Miley. Rosie is gorgeous, but the fitted bodice does nothing for her hips and breaks the stripey flow.
      3. Classy doesn’t always mean better. Rosie wins on the sophisticated front, no lie. But considering the garment, I think a buzz cut, some Bozo lips, and a bad attitude really make this sing. Even if it is a rocker-chick-wannabe-nashville-twang kind of singing.

      • http://twitter.com/PhDKnitter marlie

        I *did* say it out loud, and it certainly sounds hilarious AND ridiculous at the same time. ;)

      • capybara_cafe

        I prefer Rosie’s fit because it DOES break up the stripey flow. This jumpsuit makes me dizzy! But I agree, it is a more rock-n-roll look.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

      To be honest, its not fair to put anyone up to our Rosie here. I think it suits Miley’s personality, but Rosie is showing us how it’s done.

    • Angela_the_Librarian

      Sorry, all I see on both of them is stilt walker clown.

    • butterflysunita

      Unfair competition, Rosie (whoever she is) wears it so much better. On the other hand, if you ask me who looks more fun to be around, I pick Miley.

    • l_c_ann

      To me, Rosie makes outfits looks as if they are as bored with the world as she is. So, Miley, because (as some others have said), she’s enjoying this and it shows

    • gsk241

      Rosie, being a trained model, does wear it better, I suppose. But Miley looks like she’s actually enjoying it, so Miley for the win!

    • NDC_IPCentral

      Strapless prison jumpsuit – on either of ‘em. I agree with MizzPants.

    • sweetlilvoice

      I agree with my uncles-Rosie wore it better. Miley’s makeup is way to harsh for the look. Rosie is serving up face in every shot.

    • PastryGoddess

      Rosie wins hands clown…I mean down

    • spooki C

      That lipstick and those spider lashes are doing poor Miley no favors. I don’t think this bizarre outfit looks good on either though. It’s like a pair of pants hiked way, way up to cover the tits.

    • Judy_S

      You know what? I think it’s great that a piece of high-fashion clothing looks this good on two such different women.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/BJTY6KY7LOR7MDOD6QCZUC3VVI Donna Tabor

        Well said. Since I happen to agree. :-)

    • IMNAngryLiberal

      Miley, hands down. I agree with TLo about the lipstick, but I hate that necklace Rose has on with the fire of a thousand suns (at least with that jumpsuit).

    • http://gabyrippling.tumblr.com/ Gabriella M

      Rosie’s is clearly the correct necklace for the look, as well as the correct posing. Rosie’s practically got a doctorate in fierce. Miley’s posing is just emphasizing that it looks like prison stripes, unfortunately.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/Q65AXARU4PZNGCUAPC7IITDB4Q Edward

      I liked it better when Beetleguise wore it. Shame they both left off the jacket though.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1208138556 Sara Munoz Munoz

      That’s not really fair. Rosie is a professional and can wear whatever. Miley is having fun. Rosie trying to make this chic is almost ridiculous.

    • OrigamiRose

      Rosie, hands down – the poise, the make-up, the accessories, all just stunning.

    • Indigo54

      Rosie! No contest! She’s killing it!

    • http://www.facebook.com/judy.julian77 Judy Julian

      Rosie, for sure. Miley looks awkward.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Julie-Chase/731391326 Julie Chase

      Ugh. Circus tent.

    • charlotte

      I vote Rosie. Miley is trying too hard to be edgy and whatnot, but in the end she’s just vulgar.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000905542323 Rhonda Shore

      I like Miley’s necklace but the lipstick was a bad choice. Rosie knows how to posey-y, so Rosey wins by a nose-y! (Forgive me, but i’m ill and a bit delirious.)

    • Susan Collier

      Stilt vs Stiltwalker. Miley had no chance.

    • librarygrrl64

      Actually, I think it fits Miley’s public persona more than it does Rosie’s. Plus, Miley looks like she’s having fun with it, and that’s the right attitude to take with a broad-striped jumpsuit, no? So Miley gets my vote. :-)

    • Jangle57

      oh obviously Rosie wins this one

    • ErmengardeGreen

      Miley looks a little better than she usually does, and Rosie looks a little worse than she usually does. So even though RH-W looks yacht-ready and Miley looks like she’s on tour with an improv troupe circa 1992, I am inclined to give this one to Miley. She looks like she’s having fun with it. And the bustline is giving RH-W boob pancake.

    • RedRaven617

      Rose for the win.

    • http://www.facebook.com/CameronETurner Cameron Turner

      Rosie looks beautiful… Miley looks like a clown….

    • http://twitter.com/cornekopia Shawn EH

      I actually think it’s really close, except Miley looks more cray-cray. I like her gold choker better than Rosie’s Chanel bling.That much cleavage needs something to draw the eye up, not further down.

    • http://twitter.com/nuanc Nancy SM Waldman

      Yeah, I’m going with Miley on this one. I agree that her overdone make-up distracts, but the outfit itself suits a young, lighthearted, free-spirited look/person/occasion. Rosie’s body and languid posing could make anything look good, but the outfit doesn’t suit her. At all. Miley wins!

    • hellkell

      I’m surprised, but I have to go with Miley on this one. Do I need a nap or more coffee?

    • another_laura

      They get very different effects from the same piece and they both look good, IMO.

      It’s hard not to give it to the model, though. Rosie for the elegant win.

    • http://aldonsusi.blogspot.com/ Susi R

      Rosie wins.

    • Melizmatic

      The model wore it better, obviously… but looking at them both, I just can’t help but wanting to yell out;

      Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice!

    • MoreShoes

      They both look like clowns on stilts. You got this from the designer, it doesn’t mean you have to wear it too.

    • shanteUstay

      miley’s makeup is H-A-R-S-H
      Pardon me for saying but it looks bad when people with fair/pale skin wear orange or orange red lipstick. If she were tanner, the story would be different.

    • mhleta

      I TLo agree completely. On MC it looks like a massive field of prison stripes leading up to a baby clown head. On Rose it looks kinda elegant. The necklace and her hair add much needed balance. Miley could have used a belt or something to break it up.

    • Imasewsure

      Love it on both (although Rosie is supreme). Makeup is awful on Miley

    • VioletFem

      Rosie wore it best. It’s not even a fair comparison for poor (so to speak) Miley.

    • Jacqueline Wessel

      I’d give it to Miley. Rosie looks too classy for a striped strapless jumpsuit while Miley looks perfect for it.

    • SugarSnap108

      “Insane mime” implies there are sane mimes. I guess it’s possible. You’re absolutely right, of course — the necklace, makeup and Rosie-ness make her the clear winner. But I can’t get down with the circus tent vibe of the garment itself.

    • MilaXX

      I don’t hate either look to be honest. If anything Rose gets a slight edge because she is a model and knows how to work a look better, but neither have made major missteps in my book. Miley’s hair/ makeup(although I dislike the lashes she’s wearing) & accessories fit her personality and age, and the same can be said of Rose.

    • EEKstl

      Rosie for the win. With the hair, the necklace, the lipstick…Miley’s version smacks too much of Gamine Gone Wrong.

    • Zippypie

      They both look like stilt walkers in a circus but Rosie looks better just because she’s taller and knows how to stand in it. Ugly as hell jumpsuit.

    • Louise Bryan

      I actually like the jumpsuit better on Miley, but Rosie’s accessories and makeup are more polished.

    • korilian

      I assume that’s a retorical question? :)

    • warnerave

      this is not a fair comparison..

    • marilyn

      Rosie. Miley needs to fire her stylist. She looks like she is in her 30′s. That may be rather novel to her, since she probably isn’t going to be carded with that look. But, all too soon she will need to look like that. She should enjoy her youth.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001998855370 Fatima Siddique

      No contest. Next to Rosie, Miley looks like the third member of Insane Clown Posse. She really should have dialed back the make-up and gone with a necklace that didn’t look like it was on loan from the Mister T collection.

    • http://twitter.com/MelanieM_Texas Melanie Morgan

      Miley, because she looks like a very perky, cheerful clown, and that’s what this garment calls for. The other woman lookzzzzzz….. oh, sorry, I drifted off there.

    • Therese Bohn

      Miley reminds me of a female blond Justin Bieber in that last picture…must be the expression. Rosie framed it perfectly with the long necklace.

    • http://twitter.com/#!/Space_Kitty Space Kitty

      Lost it at blonde Betty Boop and never recovered.

    • j_anson

      I cannot disagree with anything you’ve said here. I think it’s just that I sort of find the “insane mime” take humorous and thus it’s working for me. But objectively, Rosie clearly did it better. But then, that’s kind of her thing.

    • ankali

      This is harder than I would have thought, since they’re both going for different vibes, with Rosie going sophisticated and Miley going fun/edgy. I prefer sophisticated & thus prefer Rosie, but it’s not like MIley’s doing it wrong; she’s just doing it differently. It’s a credit to the designer that such an unusual garment can serve both looks.

      • http://twitter.com/kerryev kerryev

        What ankali said.

    • http://profiles.google.com/awilsongirl Amy Wilson

      I’m going with Miley on this one. She looks like she is just flat out loving wearing that jumpsuit. Plus I secretly wish that she was my little sister because she seems like lots of fun.

    • TonyGo

      This looks like something that was designed for the stilt walker challenge on PR. Yikes.

    • formerlyAnon

      I agree that Miley’s makeup and lack of stance put her 2nd. But I like her hair sooo much better that if someone went in and fixed the face, I’d reverse myself.

    • JMEL

      I can’t believe I am saying this, but I prefer Miley’s look. Rosie can rock the hell out of anything and she looks great, but she is taking it too seriously and I don’t like the pearls. Miley is having fun. The lips are strong, but I think they go with the look.

    • Tree

      What is that little tiny thing on Miley’s waist off to one side? It looks like a small silver button. Its not on Rosie’s version. For whatever reason, that tiny detail amuses me and makes me give the win to Miley. Why is there a tiny silver button? But somehow it looks right.

      • VictoriaDiNardo

        I saw that also and am wondering it is a jumpsuit or a really perfectly matched pants an top, and the button connects it. That strapless top is so well fitted, which is hard to do with a jumpsuit.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=535548244 Kim Baker Vidas Davey-Irvin

      rosie looks far more elegant, and manages to work the line(s) of the jumpsuit in a relaxed and attractive way. while that first picture of miley is more like a frontal assault, with an extended vertical target suspended between her crotch and her ankles. and i don’t think she wants anyone aiming THERE.

    • jetpackdino

      I hate her because she’s beautiful, but Rosie wins this easily.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=194100254 Mary Christa Jaramillo-Bolin

      Rosie, for sure.

    • ccm800

      I gotta say Miley. She has the better “spirit” for it? It just suits her better.

      • minnye

        My thoughts too.

        • BrooklynBomber

          Me three.

    • fursa_saida

      Huh. I actually feel the opposite. I liked the graphic choices of the lip color (along with fairly clean eyes and strong eyebrows) and retro-futuristic necklace (and her hair works into that) better than RHW’s sort of…luxuriant approach (hair, necklace). And RHW’s posing just annoyed me.

      I also think Miley may have benefited from the brighter, whiter light (for me, because I’m into the graphic thing–people who are having a mime issue with her version are probably more put off by that since it emphasizes the black/white contrast).

    • Trisha26

      Rosie, hands down. I think Miley looks okay but got a distinct “clown vibe” overall.

    • http://profiles.google.com/shannonlstewart Shannon Stewart

      I think Miley needed to go the opposite direction (and fix that hair color — that’s the color you get from home bleaching kits before you tone it with blond dye, I know, I’ve been there…) Rather than going for the glamour and sophistication of Rosie, she needed to go very rock-and-roll-edgy with the accessories and the hair and face. It would have worked much better for her.

    • calimon

      I like the way Rosie’s necklace hangs low enough that it breaks up the extensive verticality of the lines. I wouldn’t mind Miley’s so much, but would it be too much to ask for her to wear this with a belt?

    • Tatiana Luján

      I hate Miley’s makeup, but at least this jumpsuit seems to have some sense (of fun) on her.
      It just looks as a ridiculous piece of clothing on Rosie.

      • BrooklynBomber

        exactly.

    • CatherineRhodes

      They both look awful. Hate the outfit.

    • http://www.facebook.com/darva.sutra Darva Sutra

      Rosie for sure! The Chanel pearls/chains are 70′s fantastic, I die for them. Wonder if they’re vintage? Agree with T Lo, Rosie’s posing is spectacular, where Miley’s is pedestrian. Surprised so many of you all are voting for Miley. I don’t have anything against her, but she’s out of her league here.

    • capybara_cafe

      I can see Miley’s lipstick from space. I think the top fits Rosie better, Miley’s looks a little baggy around the rib cage. I feel like a belt would have made this jumpsuit easier to look at.

    • crackineggs

      Rosie by a mile. Love the necklace with this.

    • http://www.facebook.com/jeremy.porta Jeremy Thomas Porta

      You stupid bitch, why is this even posed as a contest? You must be trying to humiliate Miley.

    • greyhoundgirl

      It’s adorable vs. elegant.

    • Colin

      Very sadly, I choose Rosie. But I don’t like that decision because Rosie just made it a look of nonchalance, which is naturally an easier vibe to pull off considering it’s a jumpsuit, and given that models are just non-chalant pretties until they prove otherwise. I think Miley tried to make an impact with it, and I’m happy she’s trying to do that with a jumpsuit. The make up is too crazy though. I think she was trying for poppy red lips to contrast the black and white, but somehow went all killer clown somewhere along the way.

    • SorayaS

      Miley is working it surprisingly well but Rosie wins, partly due to the styling but mostly due to being Rosie Huntington-Whitely (ie: a walking WERQ)

    • BrooklynBomber

      Miley.

    • DiverK

      Sheldon Cooper wore it best!

    • snarkykitten

      Rosie by far. You’re spot-on, as usual. Miley looks like she belongs in Joker’s army

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=20401589 Michelle Jackson

      Can I vote neither b/c of the lack of hemming?

    • Contralto

      Rosie.

    • phrenk

      I like both, and since I figure more people will say Rosie, I’ll vote Miley.

    • http://twitter.com/HDizzay Hayley

      I like both, but prefer Miley’s. I think she is kind of channeling Gwen Stefani, which is good!

    • gracedarling

      Rosie’s probably wearing just as much spackle as Miley – the lighting in Miley’s picture’s is much, much more harsh. Even with the passport-photo lighting, though, I’m going to vote Miley. She actually looks comfortable in it – grinning as though to say, can you believe this insane garment that I adore even exists?

      (No, not really. But girl, have fun with your choices.)

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1266410766 Phyllis Craine

      Stiltwalkers at a carnival

    • http://profiles.google.com/scaponigro Sarah Caponigro

      They both needed a belt but I kind of love it on both of them.

    • conniemd

      Amazing the difference the necklaces make. I’m surprised the long necklace looks so good with the jumpsuit, I’d never have picked it off hand.

    • bd73

      rosie wins, but miley looks good too. all of your points about rosie’s accessorizing are spot on. miley may be sample sized, but she isn’t tall and that makes a difference, especially with this vertical stripe.

    • demidaemon

      Rosie, without a doubt. Miley’s lipstick ruined the entire look for me.

    • lrhoff

      Oh, please….Rosie won it hands down.

    • oldbobbydraper

      rosie, without question or breaking a sweat.

    • Anniebet

      Well, since Miley looks like a circus tent fell on her, I pick Rosie.

    • CarolinLA

      Stilt walkers.

    • http://twitter.com/Eovaai Eovaai

      No competition. Rosie, hands down.

    • http://twitter.com/TVcastingcall Reality TV Casting

      agree rosie takes it… would love more like this!

    • Costumedzyner

      While Miley doesn’t look awful here, Rosie clearly wins. Miley’s top is cut about an inch higher than Rosie’s, and that makes all the difference. Miley’s top looks like her pants have swallowed her boobs, while Rosie’s lower neckline is more flattering, more adult, and more chic. Plus, you are quite right in saying the accessories cinched the deal.

    • Sally Brownson

      Miley’s mime face is absolutely ruining it for her. Otherwise, she’d probably look pretty good. Maybe not as good as Miss Rosie, but certainly good.

    • a_liking

      Rosie might objectively be wearing it better, but I think Miley’s works better. the oddness clashes with Rosie’s chicness, where as Miley’s… eccentricity goes better with it.

    • kathrineb

      Rosie sure as hell knows how to pose! I think she wins it because I prefer the softer make up and this getup looks better on a super tall woman.
      I usually go for the more edgy take but Miley’s make up is pretty harsh but I still really like the short hair on her.

    • H2olovngrl

      Another make-up artist needs to be slapped. Poor Miley. She really is quite a cute girl, but not with that Crayola mouth.

    • http://profiles.google.com/sauchih Sau-Chih Feng

      I stand with Miley. I think the short necklace and her punk-ish hair works better with the suit. Rosie looks good, but her stylish is too demure for fashionable prison mate.

    • http://www.facebook.com/tom.r.markiewicz Tom Markiewicz

      Rosie.

    • julnyes

      I think Rosie looks better, but Miley looks pretty darn good as well.

    • http://twitter.com/SarahVotes Sarah Bailey

      Rosie, by a few miles. Miley looks ridiculous.

    • http://twitter.com/AnniNoone Erin_MJ

      Ooooh. Poor Miley. Rosie FTMFW.

    • http://profiles.google.com/ballinger.jl Jessica Ballinger

      Love the fashion face off. Can we have more of these?

    • barbarienne

      How is this even a question? Miley’s overdone face is killing her. If she wore this outfit and Rosie wore a greasy trash bag, but they both had the same makeup/hair/body-language as they do here, Rosie would still kick her ass.

    • ThaliaMenninger

      Miley looks like a clown on stilts. Rosie looks lovely.

    • oohsparkley!

      I’m going to give it to Miley. If I saw someone posing like Rosie in real life, I think I’d want to smack her (wouldn’t but would want to). Rosie’s pictures have a more flattering background too, uneven playing field. It would be fun to see them next to each other. Miley probably comes up to her chest.

    • allie wallie

      Miley looks like a circus tent. Rosie has figured out the only way to pose to make that outfit not appear like a circus tent.

    • guest2visits

      It’s such a loud piece of clothing; that it looks pretty natural for Miley… almost sophisticated for her actually. If not for
      the clown-orange lips, and the arm scribble – this would look very good on her. Of course it looks downright chic on Rosie.
      Love the lip-color and styling.

    • sashaychante

      this outfit looks ridiculous on both of them

    • http://cheekypinky.wordpress.com cheekypinky

      Actually, I think they both look great! Miley is working the youthful edge, and Rosie is making it elegant. It’s hard to rock a Beetlejuice jumpsuit, and they’re both pulling it off.

    • http://twitter.com/JaniceMSmith joy peace

      I like Miley better. The red lipstick stands out better against the stripes. Her necklace doesn’t clash either and stays up high.

    • Mistie Holler

      Miley looks like she’s dressed to visit a kid’s hospital benefit. Rosie looks like she’s dressed to attend a glamorous event. The same outfit worn very different ways and equally well.

    • DesertDweller79

      The outfit looks good on both of them. However, the model’s makeup and accessories are way better. If Miley’s makeup was more muted, I think she would look fantastic.

    • Frank Lithium

      Miley doesn’t look bad in it, but her youth is simply screaming through that outfit.