Liv Tyler in Proenza Schouler

Posted on November 15, 2012

Miss Liv took a great little edgy dress and turned it into office clothes. Tsk.


Liv Tyler attends The Ninth Annual CFDA/Vogue Fashion Fund Awards in New York City in Proenza Schouler.

Proenza Schouler Spring 2013 Collection/Model: Lida Fox

Granted, the dress went through some major changes as it traveled from runway to red carpet, but still. She could’ve edged this up with a killer belt. She could’ve done something a bit more showy with that great head of hair she’s got. She could’ve worn some jewelry and picked a bag that doesn’t look like a file folder. She could’ve burned those hiddy shoes as an offering of penance to the shoe gods and picked a pair with a little more oomph.  She could’ve opened up the skirt a little and maybe put on some tights or colored hose.

You have offended us, Liv Tyler; offended us with your poor styling choices. Feel shame.


[Photo Credit: Getty,]

    • Sobaika

      At the very least, undo a few of the buttons at the neck. Tsk tsk, Liv.

    • WordyDoodles

      I’m cryin’, Liv Tyler. My biggest tears here are saved for your hair– it’s gorgeous, but who could tell from this picture? Shake it down and you could have saved this from being full-on schoolmarm. Sigh.

      • Corazon Nunez

        My biggest tears are from laughing at TLo. Hil-ar-i-ous!

    • Jessica TallGirl Freeman

      To be fair, the runway version is pretty ugly itself.  It could have been much better.  Those shoes are hideous and the biggest offenders of the look. 

    • PeggyOC

      If that dress is sad and offended, it can come over to my house.  I promise to treat it right.

    • MajorBedhead

      Holy crap. That pattern is so busy and repetitive that it makes her look like a huge block of blue and black. Think and stumpy, which is not something  I’d ever associate with Liv Tyler. I can’t tell where her waist ends and her arms begin. It’s hideously unflattering.

      As are the shoes, the bag and the hair. Blech. 

      • Aurumgirl

         My thoughts too.  If a dress can make Liv Tyler look like a thick and repressed receptionist, it’s the dress that is failing, not Liv.

    • bionicgyal1

      I think she should pack this up and send it to Christina Hendricks.

    • LesYeuxHiboux

      Wow, I love that dress. Truly dismal choices in styling: what was the thinking behind that ponytail? I feel like someone (me) could yank her behind that hedge, take down the hair and muss it up a bit, unbutton a few buttons, loan her a belt, and send her back out looking a hundred times better than she does now. 

    • cooperalden

      Looks like HSN’s Twiggy line to me.

    • Lisa M. (ReVoir) Kramp

      What.The.Hell. She’s one of my favorite stars and she’s achingly gorgeous. Who told her that looked good? Shoot them, shoot them now.

    • Amanda

      some red lipstick would have helped elevate it from looking “Monday Morning I really don’t want to be at the office”

    • MilaXX

      Shame because she’s one of the few people I think could have gotten away with the model’s version.

    • ankali

      I’m so confused about the changes separating the runway and the RC versions — they don’t really preserve the original idea behind the dress to me. Something hipster & nerd-rock-n-roll turned into something very dowdy that I don’t think would have been saved by better styling choices.

      Not that I particularly like the runway version, either. Proenza Schouler almost always goes over my head.

    • kayleymaybe

      Ugh, such beautiful colors wasted!

    • Alexandra Pimenta

      Wow, this pattern is a major seizure giver for me. 

    • Isana Leshchinskaya

      she’s so beautiful i don’t care

    • Laura Schultz

      That runway version is WWWAY more interesting. Wonder why they dumbed it down so much? It wasn’t like it was a crazy impractical runway dress. 

    • Patricia Gillett

      Motel curtains.

    • B_C_J

      This dress is HIDEOUS.  No amount of styling can save it. It was hideous in the runway version (those cutouts are pathetic) and just as bad in the red carpet version sans cutouts. Burn it.

    • Kiltdntiltd

      My biggest problem is that that complex, bright print is utterly obliterating her shape.  She is just a lump of blue and black laundry.

      • CPK1

         with two black lumps for feet

    • nannypoo

      I’m not sure this unflattering mess could be saved with even the best styling choices. 

    • Monabel

      Even so, it would not be a good dress.

    • YousmelllikeAnnaWintour

      Has she made any movies lately? 

    • j_anson

      I like how tights have gone from “verboten, evil, ugly, a sign of utter schlumpiness” to “something you’ll get critiqued for not doing”. It’s such a classic fashion-industry thing. To be clear, not critiquing TLo here: they’re totally right that tights would have been nice here, and part of fashion is in fact about knowing what’s in style and will resonate with viewers. But I’ve always preferred tights because I have legs that are decently shaped but don’t have great skin, and over the past five years or so that’s gone from hopelessly passe to totally on-trend, without the actually effect on how I looked changing at all.

    • Kathleen

      That looks like an ugly dress I wore back in the 80’s!!

    • Vienna Marriott

      This looks like it comes from Guh guh guh…  guh guh… …  *snap* Goodwill.

    • Tatiana Luján

      The dress isn’t good, nor the runway version, or the one Liv is sporting. The fabric is pretty, though.

    • Aj/Melia


    • Jason M. Galloway

      She’s just so pretty though, so I forgive her…hasn’t aged a day.

    • StellaZafella

      Nuns in Hawaii…”These are my beachy sandals for doing baptisms on Waikiki!”

    • Lochery

      She took an ugly dress and continued to make it ugly.

    • Rrroza

      What’s with the centered black button placket? Makes no sense with the buttons on the skirt. The original swirl of the dress is destroyed. Don’t love the print but the constellation of shiny buttons and longer hem and flash of leg on the model helped make it something…smething that looked interesting in motion. I don’t think this is a stand-and-pose dress.

    • Call me Bee

      Yeah–I think I wroe this dress to my job as Customer Services Coordinator in 1984. 

    • foodycatAlicia

      Those shoes hurt my soul.

    • Judy_J

      She could have picked another dress.

    • BarbaraW

      Now this is the kind of dress that Mayim Bialik could wear and be a little less frumpy than usual. Assuming, of course, that she made better accessory choices than poor Liv here. Mayim is pretty short, so it would probably come down below her knees. It is possible to be covered up and still fashionable.

    • Kim Baker Vidas Davey-Irvin

      … what?  i don’t even … how did she manage to frump this up?

    • decormaven

      The cool design elements of the dress as shown on the RC model make it interesting, and they’ve all been removed! Why? And she’s got the legs to show off, and there’s no glimpse of thigh here. Boo!

    • Lilak


    • bellafigura1

      She’s got a great face but always looks sloppy to me.

      • tereliz

        I don’t think she ever looks “sloppy”, but it’s true that she picks some silhouettes that I, as a similarly figured gal, would steer clear of. She tends to go for a slightly edgy aesthetic, which doesn’t always gel with her gorgeous face, if that makes sense. 

        She’s also an actual size, not a 0-4, so she probably never gets free clothes. Which must suck, but doesn’t explain why she doesn’t have better accessories. And her hair is the best accessory of all, so I really don’t understand why she doesn’t let it down more. 

        I’d love to see her opt for a more traditionally feminine style once in a while, just to mix it up. Something that defines her waist, yet flares over her hips. You don’t have to be a rock-star’s daughter all the time, Liv!

        • bellafigura1

          Absolutely! And when I say sloppy it is no way related to her figure, I hope it didn’t sound that way. I think of her as head to toe gorgeous but unable to let go of her hipster-mom vibe which she carries from the streets to the red carpet. It’s a little juvenile.

    • BigWhiteGrannyPanties


    • tereliz

      While I’m all for raising the dropped waistband and removing the lace inserts, it would help if the dress defined her actual waist a bit more. Or if a belt were deployed. The black button placket and collar pull focus and the asymmetry that made this dress so fun is completely lost. The sandals might have worked better if she was flashing a little thigh, but I would have gone for metallic or oxblood shoes and bag.

      Great face, though. 

    • unbornfawn

      HATE the changes, it does not need breast pockets or that contrasting stripe and button down the front. FUGLY.

    • J MN

      I whimpered a little when I got down to her shoes.  Why?  They’re so butt ugly.  That and carrying a zippered portfolio are shame worthy.  The runway style is great, the reworked look is not.  

    • quiltrx

      I’m going to put this one on whoever alters things from runway to rack.  They took away every bit of edge it had and gave it a lot of frump.  For shame, because I really like the print.

    • Jackie4g

      It’s demure, which might be a bad word in some circles. Can’t say I care for either the runway shoes or Liv’s choice of shoe, but I do like the black and blue print very much. It’s a useful dress that can work for day and go out to dinner. Is that damning with faint praise? Even celebrities deserve useful dresses.

    • Sarah Adams

      I prefer what she’s doing to the way it looks on the runway. Her look has subtle edge. The runway is screaming “I’m EDGY! Seriously I am edgy! Look, slits!” I prefer subtle. 

    • Contralto

      The colors really bring out her eyes.  So there’s that.

    • guest2visits

      I don’t like the dress for anyone. The color and the print are good but nothing else. And the shoes are awful, Liv.

    • andreawey

      UGG! looks like Kmart clothes!

    • ThaliaMenninger

      Frump a dump.

    • AnneElliot

      Just fugly, on so many levels.  Words fail me.

    • Larkin21

      … and yet, I’d still jump fences for her.