IN or OUT: Kristen Stewart in Balenciaga

Posted on November 05, 2012

We’ll keep this very simple. You see, Daddy and Daddy are fighting again, and it’s all Kristen’s fault.

Kristen Stewart attends the premiere of ‘On The Road’ during the 2012 AFI Fest in Balenciaga.

Balenciaga Spring 2013 Collection/Model: Kristin Liljegren (SCOOP)

Lorenzo thinks she looks bold, chic, and fabulous. Tom thinks she looks like she’s wearing a very strange long-line bra paired with manpants.

Which one is correct, kittens? Which Daddy do you want to have custody of you?

Vote Now!
IN! Lorenzo is my Daddy!
OUT! Tom is my Daddy!

Voting on Solange’s crazed office temp look is still open and awaiting your opinion.


[Photo Credit: Jason Merritt/Getty Images,]

Please review our Community Guidelines before posting a comment. Thank you!

  • Ann Erickson

    Tom. That is so blech.

    • Tom FTW. OUT.  I don’t get it at all.  That is one ugly and inconvenient bra.  Not that I’ve worn that many bras in my day…

      • joything

        Tom.  The model seemed to have the MaxiBra tucked into the pants, while KStew does not.  I don’t know if it’s even possible. 

  • joancarol

    She looks cold to me.

  • A. W.

    I want very dearly to love this, but I think it doesn’t quite work. OUT. She’s fierce as hell, of course.

    • gabbilevy

      The sides of the bra are untucked on Kristen and tucked on the model, and I feel like that makes all the difference in the world. OUT. And so easily fixed too… 

  • I just can’t sign off on this. Team Daddy Tom all the way!

  • ralish

    Tom wins, especially given the color of the “shirt.” It may have worked in a different color and fabric. Out.

  • Just. Awful.

  • Out! Tom 2012!

  • 3boysful

    Poor Kristen!  She’s living the nightmare where you go outside not fully dressed; in her case, pants and bra!  Oh, wait . . . this was intentional?

    Team Tom.

  • Team Tom. This is ridiculous. 

  • Tom, you’re my daddy.  What is K-Stew thinking with that hideous tankini?  Me no likey!

  • alyce1213

    OUT. I’m with Tom. She looks half-dressed.

  • fnarf

    That’s the ugliest bra I’ve ever seen.

  • IN. I think she looks great. Do wish the fit of the pants were a little different, but alas.

    • 3boysful

       What’s the poochy think on her right hip?  Is it just the pocket puffing out in that stance, or some extra fabric element added to a woman’s hip?!?  The model has a similar problem.

      • SoAustentatious

        I agree. I thought it was some detail near the right pocket since both KS and the model had it. Upon closer inspection, it looks like a normal pocket, but the puffiness on both is odd.

      •  There’s absolutely no reason those pants should have pockets at all.

      • It’s because of the pleats in the pants, they create extra space (thus fabric) in the front panel of the pants. I think the bulging happens because the pants are cut slim all-over so the extra fabric from the pleat has no place to go but out.. It looks quite horrid together with the crotch issues

        •  Reason 5,607,471 why Pleated Pants are Revolting, Seriously, Get Rid of Them.

          • librarygrrl64

            Agreed. They are The Devil’s Handiwork.

          • Nice Hairpin reference. 🙂

          • luciaphile

            This stuff comes and goes. It’s like today’s skinny jeans which do not look good on most women. I hate these pants and I hate her bra. Out.

  • I have no idea why I like this look, but she’s WERQing it. In.

    • TaurusKW

      I completely agree.  A few things about the fit and the lines are slightly off to my eye, but in spite of it all, she looks fierce.  That’s gotta be an IN.

  • granddelusion

    Lorenzo’s right; she looks fabulous.

  • Anathema_Device

    Out. Man pants indeed. And the necklace hiding in her cleavage is awful.

  • Vaniljekjeks

    I vote OUT with daddy Tom.  She looks like she is playing dress up.  

  • jonnyf8

    Lorenzo can be my daddy and not just because he likes Kristen’s look.  😉

  • I like it, but it feels like it’s missing something. A fab wrap, or jacket maybe? It looks…empty.

  • shoneez

    OK I’ll be first. I’m with Daddy Lorenzo. I think she looks fierce.

  • Isana Leshchinskaya

    grumbly in. 

  • I’m with Lorenzo!  I think she looks great and that she’s one of the few people who could pull this off.

  • lucyloo222

    Tom is definitely my daddy.  And the makeup!  Gah! Halloween is over.  Eyes or lips, not both.  My “gym hair” looks more put together than that.  And…… my vitriol is spent (for now).

    • RebeccaKW

       I agree…I don’t really like the look, but I might have been persuaded had the hair and makeup not been so…well, crazy.  Out.

      Also, I can’t figure out if the fit in the pants is off, or if it’s poufy around the hips b/c of how she’s standing.

  • Lots of love to Lorenzo–I love this and she looks fierce. as. shit.

  • jmorino08

    Out! Her face is gorgeous! The rest is just sad…

  • MissMariRose

    *looks down, shuffles feet* Um, well, I like her nail polish a lot.


  • Joyce VG

    OUT.  I don’t like the style of the top or the pants. And together they are wrong. And her make up is awful. 

  • lovelyivy

    Outfit would be in BUT that makeup is atrocious. It’s all I can see, and turns the look as a whole into an OUT.

    • MoHub

       I actually had to work to get my eyes past the hair and makeup so I could even begin examining the outfit.

  • asympt

    I rarely vote, but I have to throw some love to Lo. I think it’s just odd enough to work.

  • Inspector_Gidget

    The bottom half of that… bra is doing weird things to her figure. You can’t even see the cutouts half the time.  Looks a bit like a medical brace. Did she crack a vertebra?

  • Wrenaria

    Ew. Out.

  • HomeOfficeGirl

    I’m with Tom… this is OUT!  It works (a little) better on the model because she’s an amazon and the top is tucked in so that it looks more like a leotard(?).  The way it’s hanging out on Kristin bugs – but that’s not the main issue.  She looks too bare and too pale.

  • snarkykitten


    (the outfit, not her)

  • Patricia Gillett

    Tom all the way. This is a practical joke from her stylist. And WTH is up with her hair?

  • gsk241

    I’m going with Daddy Lorenzo on this one!  IN!

  • Jessi03

    Out out out!  I’m with Tom.

  • Out. The not-a-shirt, the weirdly fitted trouser–eugh. No.

  • mjude

    i dont like picking sides with my daddy’s but i am really torn on this.  i think its an OUT

  • I side with Tom here: As I saw the pictures I thought what a difference a long high-waisted skirt (no bare midriff!) could have made..

  • annrr

    Out Tom is my daddy

  • leftcoastpickle

    Tom is my daddy! total old lady bra!

  • teensmom99

    IN-ish but she doesn’t look comfortable.  This is IN as a red-carpet look that no one should wear in real life. But she is back to hunching and the air &  make up just look wrong for this.

  • I’m with Tom!!

  • minnye

    If only they were smooth front cigarette pants and didn’t have those wonky pleats! argh.  Nonetheless IN.

  • Pennymac

    In! Lorenzo is my daddy!

  • Kirsten Henry


  • manpants


  • TieDye64

    Tom’s my daddy. OUT!

  • In_Stitches

    I love the idea of that top with high waisted pants, but not high waisted PLEATED pants.  They’re the devil.  OUT. 

  • PeggyOC

    Out.  Tom is my daddy.  The top doesn’t look bad on the model, but it wasn’t altered for a non-model torso, so the x shape is lost on her and the trousers look strangely diaper-y.  Bleach.

  • piecesofconfetti

    IN. It is perfect for her. 

  • Can I say in just because she’s finally done something with her hair?

  • mike__tv

    At first she looks bold, but then the top looks like one of those huge bras you need after surgery…but still, IN. 

  • carolynmo

    Out. Love ya, Tom. Sorry, Lorenzo, she looks bad.

  • slightlybitterkitten

    It’s like Madonna circa 1989…. only a sad copy.

  • Are we kidding here? 
    Look at how that top is supposed to fit. Then look at how it is hanging on Kristin. That is awful.
    Almost as awful as the fit on those pants. Look at what they are doing around her crotch and hips when she is just standing there! You’d think she had them on backwards. That is a no.

    I’m not opposed to the idea of this look, but the execution is about as wrong as you can get.

    No, I’m siding with Tom, and I think you better make an optometrist appointment for Lorenzo ASAP. 

  • Tom’s my daddy. She looks like she is wearing some bizarre post-surgery “please don’t let me pull out my stitches” garment. 

  • OUT. Big Daddy Tom called it on this one. When I saw these photos this morning I just knew she would show up on the site today since you guys love to feature the ladies wearing their lady pants on the RC. Unfortunately, in addition to her lady pants, KStew looks like she’s also wearing child nappies as a substitute for a top. 

  • Cathy S

    I have to go with Tom. He’s described it perfectly.

  • Lizzyisi

    It’s weird and confrontational, but like a couple people have said, she looks fierce as hell. IN! I would have preferred a flat-front trouser, but I love how the pointy shoes continue the long line down.

    Love the rings and the nail polish. I’d have gone low chignon, not floppy messy pontytail, however.

  • I’m with Tom on this one.

  • Jessica O’Connell

    Even if I didn’t hate her with the passion of a million suns, I think I’d still choose Tom’s side on this one. It looks better tucked in or with the blouse shortened, like on the model. Also, I think the makeup looks a little too harsh, the lip color is awful, and her hair, as always, looks AWFUL. Big ol’ OUT.

  • Don’t make me choose between my Daddys!

  • A better fit and I’d be Team Lorenzo, but this looks frumpy in 3 out of 4 photos. Out!

  • kelsita421

    Team Tom. Sorry, Lo!

  • Trisha26

    OUT! Horrible.

  • Out. If those trousers were sleeker, maybe..? I don’t know

  • call_me_schmeg

    Signed off with a seal of approval. I always knew Lorenzo was my poppa. IN!

  • mrssage

    Tom. and apparently my 3-year-old was her make-up artist for the evening. I’ve been there.

  • No! Don’t make me choose! 

  • YousmelllikeAnnaWintour

    I just don’t get her appeal.  I find her about as attractive as road kill.

  • Tom all the way!

  • She should’ve tucked the blouse in like the model is wearing it, but even then I’m not sure I could embrace this outfit. OUT.

  • Out. Ew. And for once it has nothing to do with the fact that I dislike her.


  • notoffred

    Tom. It’s just too awkward.

  • Allyson Wells


  • A B

    I’m with Tom!  That is hideous from head to toe!

  • Kristy Evans

    I feel like I would call Tom “Daddy” and Lorenzo “Papa.” Just saying.

    ANYWAY. OUT. I want to like it, but it’s too weird. 

  • IN by a mile

  • OUT! Daddy Tom! Those pants do no favors to her crotch.

  • Eclectic Mayhem

    Oooh – tricky!

    I think I’m with Tom on this one – I’d’ve been happier with a fuller trouser leg – like a pallazzo pant.  That would make more sense to me.

  • j_anson

    I usually lean Lo, but today I am going with Tom. That top is a generally bad idea, but at the very least, she should have tucked it in as it was on the model. Having it outside the pants is just weird, and not in a bold, awesome way.

  • Tom’s my daddy!  Please let these granny pants die!

  • Luneowl

    Doesn’t look like she has a long enough torso to wear that top. It fits like clothes used to on my Barbies: stiff with weird fold lines.

  • Janet B

    Totally Fierce! 
    (but she’s just too small)

    Out, sadly.

  • SophiaPehawkins

    I saw on twitter that Patrick Dempsey’s wife is her makeup artist. She’s done good work before, but yikes that is so not her face paint.

    I have to agree with Tom. The entire look is ridiculous. I don’t hate it on the model though. Maybe because it’s more fitted?

  • Knightley

    I’m not as repulsed as I normally am by her.  Does that make it a win?  

    • YousmelllikeAnnaWintour

      ROFL.  “I’m not as repulsed as I normally am by her” – MUST work that into a conversation!!!  🙂

  • Daddy Tom is my favorite!  I really have a hatred for those pants.  Although her hair and make up are really good…and it appears as though she’s a bit more comfortable in front of the cameras.  

  • Julie Fountain

    Daddy Tom for the win – this looks like a bad Project Runway outfit. 

  • rissa42210

    I could never choose between you.  I think the outfit is starting to be something I like, but a few things were not done right.  The pants need to be re-fitted.  They are too big in some places.  Maybe it’s how she’s standing, but whatever.  Also, her makeup is not quite right.  She’s got a face that can carry makeup, but this has her looking thin-lipped, heavy-lidded and, well, a little trashy.  I don’t hate it though, so I guess IN?

  • It’s weird but fits her well. I think the pants are appropriately highwaisted for that kind of top. It may look similar to a bra, but at least the designer considered support! She looks confident, and it’s clearly the kind of sexiness she’s comfortable with.

  • In! Come on over Daddy Lo 😉

  • Daddy Tom is da MAN.  That is a big no way of an outfit, no mater HOW much she wants it to work for her.  And she does, oh but she does.

  • Hangin’ with Tom on this one.  OUT.  If there was ever a “concept” look that should have stayed on the runway, this is it.  There are better, more chic, more beautiful ways to show off that fantastic body of yours, KStew.


  • dsco3031

    Out– if you’re going to try to pull this off, make sure it fits perfectly. The pants are ballooning in weird spots (if there’s ever a good spot for pants to balloon) and the bra portion of the “shirt” just makes me sad.

  • Bad fit. Out.

  • Jennifer Coleman

    Are the people who loan samples to celebs just stupid? That top is tailored for some long-torsoed model. It would have been great on her if it fit, but it looks like somebody wrapped her up with tube socks. OUT.

  • Lorenzo es mi papa’. Se ve comoda.

    Lorenzo is my daddy.
    She looks comfortable, for once.

  • OUT! Tom is definitely my Daddy! And did she trip and fall into a vat of MAC on the way to the red carpet – she looks kinda prostitute-y to me….just sayin’…   

  • JoDo11

    Super out.  But I do like her bracelets and rings!

  • Jangle57

    The nicest thing I can say is she doesn’t look any worse than the model; it’s just one fugly top and no one could do justice to it.  I’m with Daddy Tom: OUT

  • I’m with Tom-out

  • TSkot

    OUT; but tucked in like on the model, it would have been an IN

  • TOM. She’s way out.

  • Mostly Tom. The top *might* be fine if it were in a different color (whites, beiges, and pinks will always skew “bra), and the pleats of the pants fight the sleekness of the top. 

  • Judy_S

    Tom, you see the truth.

  • Vanja

    As always: Tom is my Daddy. The top looks like it’s made out of foam and the trousers are hideous. OUT!

  • She looks fierce and in her element. I think it’s working for her, so IN.

  • jilly_d

    IN, because she’s one of few people who can make this not look utterly fug.  Love the jewelery and makeup too.  It would be a WERQ if not for the hair, and the fact that I can’t stand her.

  • BobStPaul

    While I think Tom is basically correct, I’m going to side with Lorenzo on this one.  I doubt anybody else could pull off this outfit (perhaps Gwen Stefani?).  

  • Jacqueline Wessel

    IN and IN

  • ojosazules

    She is wearing a strange long-line bra and manpants and she makes it look fabulous. In.

  • clevRcat

    I’m in the middle, leaning toward IN territory.  It is a look only a very tiny, very young person should attempt but she just might be pulling it off.

  • charlotte


  • pattyw


  • Tracy_Flick

    Tom! Out. It only works from the knees down.

  • neofashionista

    Tom wins if she wasnt miss slouchy pants and it looked like it did on the model it would be awesome but i hate how the hip windows are all scrunched up it looks like a bra diaper

  • TOM FTW…

    I just can’t with her at all, but confining the critique to what she’s chosen to wear to the step and repeat. 

    Its. A. BRA!

    Those. Are. MANPANTS! complete with insane crotch.

    The hair is a died and fried disaster, pulled back into a ponytail I wouldn’t wear to Curves, let alone to an RC appearance.
    I envy her porcelain skin, but the eye makeup is heavy and it’s fighting with the maroon lip.

    Tom is indeed my daddy….

  • I don’t care what they say! IN!!!! she looks fabulous and fresh. maybe a lighter lipstick color.

  • decormaven

    Papa Tom is correct. The top looks like loose bandaging that is about to unravel. And the pants are so ill-fitting, they are rubbing at the waistband and leaving a visible red mark. How many more days until this Momentous Movie Event takes place? We should start a pool on how many styling fails will come from its RCs.

  • BrooklynBomber

    Boys, boys, you’re both pretty!

  • Old lady bra. OUT

  • I side with Daddy Tom! Out!

  • baxterbaby

    I hate to take sides when daddies fight; but if I were forced, FORCED mind you, then Daddy Lo gets custody.  I like her style, and I should hate this, but I love it on her.

  • Rex


  • As ever, Tom is my daddy.  OUT!

  • MilaXX

    IN! I like this look on her.

  • crash1212

    IN! However, I do wish the pants fit a bit better as I’m not totally enamored with what’s happening in the crotchal area, but the same thing is happening on the model, so maybe they’re ‘designed’ to do that! Other than that quibble, I think she looks fab from the tip of her little faux-hawk pony, to the tips of her manicure and jewelry – and I like her shoe choice better than that of the model. There…IN.

  • Balenciaga must have been having a seriously bad day when they had those pants made. Hard to believe they are couture. 

  • Out.  If it actually fit her correctly, I would reconsider.

  • Imasewsure

    I think you are both right but it’s an IN for me because it’s unexpected and I like it (even if it does look like a weird bra and man pants)

  • BayTampaBay


  • Jenna621

    Siding with Tom on this one.  She looks ridiculous.

  • Like Lorenzo, I think she looks great. These types of looks suit her.

  • fungstyle

    I side with Tom on this one, but not because of the outfit actually. It’s the hair and makeup not working for me here. The eyes and lips are both too heavy, and the hair is a right mess. i believe there is a way to make this chic, but as it is she looks like she had a professional pick out her clothes and an amateur work everything north of her neck. 

  • I’m with Lorenzo.

  • shirab

    OUT. The Emperess has no clothes.

  • Athenrein

    I really like her makeup and jewelry, and I forgive her hair because mine is the same type and it’s impossible to manage, but the clothes are ridiculous. Refraining from judgement on this one.

  • MissFern


  • The top needs to be tucked in, or Daddy Tom is right. Nip in the size and she looks pretty sassy, per Daddy Lorenzo. 

  • jjfg

    Tom.  No question!

  • I side with Papa Tom more often than not, but I think this works on her – and maybe only her. However, I wish she’d tucked the top into the pants like in the runway shot. IN.

  • beebee10

    IN daddy Lo

  • sweetlilvoice

    Tom is my daddy today! Those pants are just sad.

  • karena10

    Out.  I’m sorry Lorenzo, but I don’t get this at all.

  • candice tobin

    From the thighs down she looks great!

  • Out. I might have been able to sign of on the bra, but not paired with those pants. She also looks washed out and pale and her makeup is terrible. Eyes or lips honey. Not both (okay, now I’m just parroting ‘What not to wear’)

  • AuntJentie

    OUT – Tom is my Daddy!

  • kittenwithaquip

    Here’s where I will defend this look, despite also agreeing that the top looks a bit like a long-line bra: she looks like she feels pretty badass in that outfit. It suits her edgy/tough side in my opinion.

  • girliecue

    Lorenzo is my Daddy today. Kristen’s face totally sells this outfit. Face #1 says she loves this outfit. Face #2 says she doesn’t give a flying fuck what you think of the outfit. Face #3 says she’s feeling totally comfortable and natural in this outfit. Face #4 taunts you to vote it out. Her ‘tude takes complete ownership of the outfit and wins the day. IN!

  • egl48


  • GorgeousThings

    Sorry Lo, I have to go with Daddy T on this one. It definitely looks like something you would see in the back pages of a Victoria’s Secret catalog.

  • elleg929

    In so many ways, OUT.

  • l_c_ann

    Tom for the out.
    (She’s too short through her torso to do justice to the design.)

  • Mary229

    I think the outfit is fine.  She’s pulling it off.  But the hair and make-up is tragic.

  • bertkeeter

    OUT! The two pieces just don’t sem to go together! 

  • nannypoo

    Tacky and whorish.

  • tired_mommy

    In. She actually looks relaxed/slightly happy too.

  • Mexxoo

    OUT!  The pocket is poking out weirdly, and that curved V centered on her crotch is too distracting.  Tom is my daddy!

  • ZnSD

    Makeup from the 80’s; wardrobe from the 90’s. OUT.

  • frannyprof

    Out!!! Mainly because of the weird fit in the pants.

  • Fierce, yes… but she doesn’t look like she’s loving it. And that’s why it’s not working for me.

  • Aly Light


    Also, I’d love to see a series of this “which daddy do you love the most?” posts linked together, so I can see if I tend to favor Tom or Lorenzo’s decisions more.

  • ThaliaMenninger

    OUT. Definitely a strange long-line bra with bad 80s pants. Look at the tummy pooch! Those pants are terrible.

  • kirkyo

    Lorenzo’s right about the pants. Tom got the bra thing however.

  • OUT. The tall hair makes her face too rectangular, the makeup looks like a kid playing at Mommy’s dressing table, and the top – which looks bra-like even on the model – doesn’t seem to fit Stewart properly, looking like a starched waistcoat a size too big.


  • elzatelzabelz

    Tom. That is one weird outfit, very Madonna in the 90s.

  • TigerLaverada

    I’m with Tom. HATE the eye makeup, in addition to everything else.

  • marilyn

    Out.  The top looks like bandages.

  • Scarlet39

    OUT.  It’s just ugly

  • sleepycat

    I don’t know, I like this, although it does look like a bra, I am going to go with IN even though I side with tom’s opinion 

  • IMNAngryLiberal

    OUT – she is too short for this look and it doesn’t fit her particularly well.  

  • Ana_ragu

    OUT! Welcome, Daddy-Tom!

  • shawnhunter

    oh man this is such an IN for me. i’m with lorenzo on this one. i feel like this is right up her alley and for once i like the hair and make-up too.

  • Qitkat

    I suppose it must be different when one walks the red carpet constantly, but I’d feel more naked in this than in a bikini on the beach. But then I haven’t been on the beach in a bikini since nineteen uhhhhh….never mind.

    Today, Tom’s my daddy!

  • altalinda

    Though it pains me, Lo, Tom is my daddy.  Combined with the sloppy hair, it does look like she forgot to put on a shirt when she ran out of the house.

  • Ooh, honey. No. She’s WERQing it for all she’s worth, and almost makes this work, but no. Sorry dear, those pants are heinous. OUT.

  • BuffaloBarbara

    I’m with Tom.  Ugly outfit and she’s wearing it badly. 

  • The bra is pretty damn cool, and the accessories are great…but pleated, pegged slacks??? What the holy fuck, KStew. 

  • Good lord, no. No, no, a thousand times, no.

    Team Tom. Jesus. My eyes are burning now. 

  • Tatiana Luján

    I’m with Lorenzo.

  • So friggin out. I have a bra that is the same material as the white ‘top’ but of course isn’t cut like that. She’s gorgeous (if a bit ‘entitled seeming)-I think it’s fun for her to wear things that she might not be able to get away with in 20 years (Hell, 10 or 5? who knows?). I wonder what “The Dutchess” would have to say about her ‘crazy crotch’. I sum it up with a word that is way too overused on the internet-“FAIL”


  • librarygrrl64

    Gotta go with Tom on this one. OUT. Hair and makeup are working for me, as is the idea of pants, but THESE pants? And THIS top? Sorry, no.

  • leave_Blake_alone

    Out. This look sucks.

  • SO OUT. This is just gross and unflattering in every way imaginable.

    Like the hair, though. 

  • *packs bags for Daddy Tom’s house*

    She’s certainly got the figure for it, but it looks like ass even on the model.  The fit of those pants is a horror show.

  • She looks like she’s been wounded and treated by a 19th-century battlefield medic.

  • Luv Ya Tom.

  • littlemissstrange

    Tom, you’re my daddy, shield me from the hideousness of this bitch’s outfit! *runs behind Tom*

  • Tiffany Birch


  • pookiesmom

    This couldn’t be more out if it cut off a chunk of my hair in the middle of the night. OUT OUT OUT. I may have to wash my eyes out with soap.

  • jw_ny

    IN  Lo’s my daddy!

    she’s got enough edge to her that she can pull of wearing an odd shaped bra with man pants, in public.  Makeup is great.  Love her nail polish color.  

  • Monabel

    Oh, Tom. Look how the pants pouf out, not in a good way.

  • RoxieRider

    In. Nothing Tom said about this look is false, but I think she’s pulling it off.

    • formerlyAnon


  • Tom is my daddy…OUT

  • demidaemon

    I’m sorry, but Tom is my daddy today. Ugh. OUT.

  • Her make-up is grotesque, but I like her jewerly with this look.   If only she would stand up straight, the pants would look fine. 

  • Fierce as shit. 

  • Out. It’s just all wrong. Bad, so bad.

  • Zippypie

    Yuck.  Tom, you are definintely my daddy!

  • Out!  Bra and manpants!

  • aristida_girl

    IN daddy Lo! I think she is workin it for all shes worth…

  • Nazzzy

    No one should ever fight over KS. She’s not that interesting. OUT

  • margaret meyers

    proportion is everything with this look.  KS needed to have the straps shortened, and she needed to tuck the side tails of the blouse in.  Is she a petite?  Cause I also think the rise on the pants is too high.

    The styling for this look is very narrow.

  • Donna Schmidt


  • Out!  Tom is my daddy because those are grandpa pants and a really ugly bra.  But her hair is clean! Even if the styling is uh… weird looking.  What is that?  A half-assed pompadour via ponytail?  The rest of her is fine.  But I don’t really like that lip color on her.  Nails are fine, shoes are basic, jewelry does not bother me.  Still Out though.  Thank you KStew, please try again.

  • J MN

    OUT.  Daddy Tom knows best.  

  • kimmeister

    The top half is ok, but the gross pleated pants make it an OUT.

  • She’s pulling it off, even though it’s the epitome of outfits I should hate. In.

  • Verascity

    I’m actually gonna go with Lo and say IN… except that it’s driving me nuts the way the shirt/bra overlaps the pants. But otherwise, I think she’s making it work.

  • Daddy Tom! I really like the top, but those are NOT the pants for them. At least not on her body. She looks like she’s carry extra weight in her crotch :s

  • Snailstsichr

    I’m voting for Tom on this one.

  • JD

    Tom, you’re my daddy.

  • Out. Balenciaga is KStew’s brand, she rocks it better than almost anybody, but her torso is not long enough to make this work, and the pants needed to be better fitted. I can imagine how she could make this work, but she didn’t. 

  • PaulaBerman

    Tom 100%. Those pants do NOT fit and the top is… ill-advised.

  • Ugly outfit, but she wears it was well as possibly. OUT anyway.

  • Lorenzo: IN. good on her for rocking the shirt-bra, it’s something very few people can pull off. i just wish her hair was different.

  • Lorenzo is MY daddy. In the minority, it seems, but definitely IN.

  • out because as usual the lack of life in her eyes makes her look like a mannequin and the pants give her childbearing hips

  • bitchybitchybitchy

    Tom is my daddy.  Why oh why do designers persist in trying to use bras as actual garments? I will give KStew points for smiling.

  • Lisa Kramp

    Lorenzo, but I hate her hair. Down and wild would have taken this to the edge it needs.

  • In. Just loving it.

  • Iam with Lorenzo, IN!

  • Lorenzo, I love you, but Tom is my spirit-uncle.  KStew up there looks like Sue Ellen Mishkin. ETA: That means OUT, in case that’s not clear.

  • Bailey Debruynkops


  • understateddiva

    It’s like she’s cosplaying herself sometimes.  Out.  

  • Daenyx

    Lorenzo!  There aren’t many people who could pull that off, but she’s doing it.  

  • myristica_fragrans

    if this outfit were to make some damn sense, the pants would have to be super slim and hemmed.

  • Tom, all the way.  I don’t think she’s pretty in general, and this makes her look like she ought to be changing cinema film reels in the 40’s (not in a good way).

  • julnyes

    I like it – I’m with Lorenzo on this!

  • plinkiedoodle

    Oh, Daddy Tom, you are so right.  It looks like a bra from the Star Ship Enterprise.  

  • SapphoPoet

    IN. I think this is the sort of thing that works really well on her. She needs edgy outfits (although this one could be better fitted). 

  • Laylalola

    In. Needs different shoes though.

  • aquamarine17

    Tom. I just don’t like these pants any more on women, especially with that shape at the shoe. They seem so over for 2012. That top would look o.k. with jeans in a warm climate with some beautiful sandals.

  • KatrinaAtienza


  • Frank Li

    So tacky. OUT.

  • unbornfawn

    OUT. Tom is my daddy! The outfit looks awkward. I like the makeup

  • poohbah1


  • harleydear

    IN. But I heart you both equally. 

  • Amy

    I thought I always sided with T but this time, it’s Lo that has it right!

  • quiltrx

    I’m going to have to stay Switzerland on this one.  I like the top (though I would have gone for a shorter, more rock n’ roll necklace), and I like the IDEA of the pants…but the fit is so bizarre.  Why are they all humpy around her ladybits?  It’s an almost look, at best.

  • I almost like this, which makes it practically a WERQ for her. I think she’d have been better with flowing palazzo pants or at least something that fits her on the bottom half. And the top would have been better in a colour. Maybe a deep red? But she looks comfortable in it, which is such an improvement for her that I’ll give it an IN with a side helping of Could Do Better Next Time.

  • Presumptuous Insect

    IN. I like the white thing.

  • prettybigkitty

    Sorry Lo, Tom wins.   I want to like it.  I really, really do, but it just doesn’t quite work.   Valiant effort though.  Out.

  • emily mcginnis

    Tom. and that make-up is hideous. 

  • Chic and well timed given recent Balenciaga news. Lorenzo has it right. It also helps that she looks happy, which isn’t always the case..

  • MaryanneGirl

    I’m with many others – I want to like it, but pleats just immediately cancel it out… Tom is my daddy! 🙂 

  • AnneElliot

    I love you both, but I have to go with Tom.  It’s just odd, and I hate the fit on the crotch.  OUT. 

  • TLJezebel

    Is she actually smiling?

  • Pterodactyl111


  • Emily Roach

    In but I love both of you! She looks different and unique, yet really comfortable. She’s working it better than the model did, and she oozes sex even when wearing pants that come up above the belly button and blouse out. Wonderful!

  • phrenk

    IN, though not without qualms!

  • IN IN IN! Sharp as Hell IN!

  • IN! So fab.

  • IN. Only thing I think she should’ve done like the runway model and tucked her ‘shirt’ into her pants, because the runway model does look better than Kstew, imo. BUT Kstew is still unconditionally and irrevocably in.

  • out tom is my daddy

  • Judih1

    Lorenzo if someone else was wearing this (Tilda) this would be an IN – even if it looks like a bra. But given that it is KStew and October (making it inappropriate for the time of year – I am going with team Tom

  • I think it looks weird (I like the bra, and I like the pants, but I don’t like them together), but I give her credit for wearing it. 

    That is a very unfortunate photo of her face in the last shot. 

  • Samantha Irene

    Tom is my Daddy!!! OUT

  • trisker

    IN!  but only Kristen could do it.

  • formerlyAnon

    You’re both right.

    Because it’s calculated and she’s on the red carpet & no mere mortal, I’ll go with Lorenzo. (Though I always worry when I stray from my usual side of the fence, squarely with Tom.)

    She *wanted* to look like a rather glamorous crazed vampiric revenant, one who left life while trying on foundation garments at Nordstrom’s. There’s a movie series to shill, y’all.


  • DinahR

    Siding with Tom.  OUT  This doesn’t look good. It’s not the right kind of edgy for her and looks like she’s trying too hard.  None of this is flattering to her lovely figure. It all looks sloppy. Then again I don’t think those pants would be flattering on anyone.  But it’s not just the clothes, that necklace is not even trying.  I think the bodice might work on someone with more polish and the right attitude. Basically, it’s meant for Gaga.  

  • RzYoung

    Lorenzo’s ma daddy (sorry Tom!)

  • Claudia Fernandes

    Lorenzo is my daddy: she looks fierce has hell, love the jewellery! she´s 20 and few, for god sake, she can use bra outside

  • DTLAFamilies

    OUT. Those pants are of the devil, bad makeup and bandages for a top. I can’t believe anyone thinks this looks good.

  • Tom wins.  Out. 

  • Noelle Haland

    FUG!  Totally and utterly fug. OUT.

  • ChaquitaPhilly

    TOM is the winner! Kristen, not so much:(

  • lalahartma

    Tom’s my daddy!

  • Cheesely

    IN! Love the pants, the bra top works too! This is red carpet, not like she’s going to buy dogfood or something. She’ll never wear it again, she looks amazing! Plus lets give some love to nicolas ghesquiere!!

  • I’m with Lorenzo. Kristen looks awesome.

  • pugluv

    Pants pull across the crotch and hip, one size larger and fit problem would be solved.  Bra top looks better on a longer torso, like the model, it looks scrunched and more sports bra like on KStew.  Make up is just horrible, either heavy eye, or heavy lip…not both and her lips are a bit too thin for such dark color. Plus she gets a big fail for always wearing the same jewelry to tempt the Twilight fans, same bracelet, same ring, same necklace, in every shot on the red carpet with every event..that makes me cringe.  She is trying hard, I will give her that but it is still a fail.

     So I side with Tom…this is an out

  • tereliz

    OUTRE. This is so bad. The only thing right is her lippy. And the nail/spike bracelet. I do want one of those. Sorry, Unkie Lo.

  • Out! Sorry Lo 🙁

  • I’m too fixated on her thumb ring to judge the top/pants …

  • watchmeboogie

    Ouuuuuuut out out out.

  • In

  • Lorenzo, ab fab sweetie darling

  • pippitypup

    Tom FTW.

  • In!  Lorenzo!  The arm/hand jewelry looks amazing, too.  And super lezzerleaning.  Hello, thumb ring 🙂 (one can always hope)

  • I don’t know, I think this should be on KStew’s wheelhouse, but the top arrangement makes it look clumsy and odd. And I don’t like the styling. It’s an OUT.

  • mmc2315

    The top is a bad fit on KStew. It needs to be fitted like on the model.  Tight. Wrapped.  

    Don’t make me choose!

  • gubblebumm

    I just cant stand her.  So she makes anything I might like yucky. She cant act for (*%# so she needs to go away

  • elemspbee

    In. Guess that makes Lorenzo m’daddy.

  • Hermione_Granger

    Love you, Daddy Tom!

  • Tom is my daddy! She looks terrible.

  • It’s not even her – this looks terrible on the model as well. Just flat out ugly. 

  • I’m with Ton. Out…padded cross your heart is not a good look for a top. Horrible, horrible. 

  •  Team Lorenzo! Tom’s not wrong – she is wearing a very strange long-line bra and man pants – but I think she STILL looks bold, chic, and fabulous, so IN!

  • kategs

    Tom.  That outfit is idiotic.

  • LeifBallard

    I keep going back and forth but overall for Kstew it works for her…its the whole “I don’t give a F about you and I am bada**” haha

  • oohsparkley!

    In. Lorenzo’s my Daddy.

  • fashionzombie

    Daddy Lorenzo, please tell me you noticed that crazy crotch. Uncle Michael Kors would’ve noticed it. 

  • KSuKim

    Tom, I guess, but less because of the clothes and more because her hair and makeup look just plain trashy.

  • lizlemonglasses

    Tom. She has a special gift for making anything look cheap.

  • Siege Johnson

    Tom FTW. All I could think when seeing this is “But..but where is the shirt?” Also, that is too much jewelry on one hand, and pull that pendant out of your boobs, young lady! On the other hand, I think this may be the best her head has ever looked. It even appears that her hair may have been brushed sometime in the last 10 – 12 hours!

  • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

    Tom is my daddy – OUT.

  • Elleachaudaucul

    Qualified In. Not digging the makeup, and something about the fit isn’t working for me. But ‘in’ in theory.

  • kolokOlchik

    Absolutely, positively OUT.  So fugly!

  • kmk05

    I KNOW WHAT THIS IS! This is the pants version of that Marion Cotillard dress. Same colour scheme, only K STew doesn’t pull it off.

  • Judy_J

    I know I’m too late to vote, but when I saw this, all I could think of was the Seinfeld episode where Elaine gives her braless friend a bra, and the friend wears it as an outer garment, causing Kramer to wreck his car.

  • In.  Fierce.

  • Out, Out, OUT. Hate, Hate, Hate the bra top.

  • Tom. That is ugly. OUT.

  • Tom.  “Well, my band director said we had to wear a white top and black pants to the concert–I’m just following instructions! Sheesh!” OUT. OUTOUTOUTOUTOUT!!!

  • Kate Lorenz

    That crotch!  I bet Michael Kors would have ten colorful metaphors for it.  I actually like the look, hair, make-up, everything, but all I can see are those crotch-pulling lines.  Awkward. 

  • thehousesparrow

    I always thought I took more after Lorenzo. Sorry Tom 🙁

  • littlemac8

    Tom, can I sit in your lap???

  • Nope. Her midsection’s waay too short to pull this one off. OUT.

  • I think it’s kinda cool, for someone her age.  Now if it were someone older, it would be an automatic out.  But for Kristen, I will give this a (slightly grudging) IN.

  • FrayedMachine

    Admittedly, I like the look. Unfortunately, however, I do not like the look on her. She lacks the fierceness that’s needed to pull this look off.

  • AngelaGreen

    Daddy Tom is right.  Love you Daddy L!

  • guest2visits

    A nice looking pair of pants worn over a bathing suit; not a great look.

  • eight_of_nine

    It’s an awkward look, but she is serving up some serious Blue Steel in that second shot.

  • pokokpuding

    I don’t understand how she makes it work, but she does. IN.