In or Out: Zoe Saldana in Louis Vuitton

Posted on June 14, 2012

Zoe Saldana’s clothes-wearing bona fides have long been established, as far as we’re concerned. She can wear beautiful things and make them even more so, and she can wear average-looking – and sometimes even ugly – things and make them look pretty good. It’s a talent.

But we’re not quite sure how to take this attempt:

Zoe Saldana attends Persol Magnificent Obsessions: 30 Stories Of Craftmanship In Film Event in NYC in Louis Vuitton.

Louis Vuitton Pre-Fall 2012 Collection

Louis Vuitton Pre-Fall 2012 Collection

Persol ‘PO3025S’ Eyewear

Is this fun and cheeky? Or does she look a little bit like a society matron in her seventies? Except for the strip of belly showing, of course.

We don’t really have much to say here in terms of breaking this one down. This is an immediate-impact, first-impression kind of look. Either you love it or you think it looks ridiculous. Because there are two of us, we can’t quite come down on either side of the question. Lo leans toward loving it and T leans toward thinking she’s gonna need a walker to get through the Met fundraiser.

 

 

Vote Now!
IN! She did it again! How DOES she do it?

 

OUT! Not even the Saldana could make this work.

 

 

Selena Gomez’s Macy’s two-piece was voted OUT by the Bitter Kittens, many of whom were seen to be rolling their eyes.

 

[Photo Credit: Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images, zappos.com, elle.com]

    • AmandaCathleen

      Out. This is a rare instance when the model looks better than Zoe.

      • Qitkat

        I agree with you.
        Why on earth did she shorten the top? Pants fit quite poorly. Colors/pattern are beautiful on her though.

        • http://www.facebook.com/shreya.aren Shreya Aren

          The shortening of the top skews the proportions horribly.

          • Eileen R. Vanhoose

            If she can’t make it work, maybe nobody can...DemoforFrank.blogspot.com

        • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

          Oh! I hadn’t noticed that she shortened the top.  No wonder the proportions look off!  Thanks, Qitkat!

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

      OUT. Apparently shoulder pads are coming back so big, they now look like football shoulder pads.  

      • Louise Bryan

        I was wondering if there were shoulder pads under the sweater.  Way too bulky up top, skimpy looking from the waist down.  Interesting shoes, though.

    • Judy_S

      Out. Sorry, but it looks silly. If she can’t make it work, maybe nobody can.

    • Sobaika

      It’s a sassy granny outfit and I LOVE it. IN!

      • call_me_schmeg

        i’m with ya. snaps, granny Z. IN!

      • BerlinerNYC

        I kind of love it too, and I’m even coming around to liking what I thought at first was an overly plain face. I don’t think every woman (especially one like La Saldana, who clearly doesn’t need a lot of help with what nature gave her) needs to be totally “done” and walk around with a pound of slap on her face, but even just a tinted lip gloss or something might have given this look a little more *pop* that would have driven the sass home…

    • MilaXX

      As much as I love Zoe, I don’t like these pants. The lentgh and cut don’t work with the shoulder pats in the top mkingher look like a giraffe with extemely short legs. If they were straight skinny pants I could buy it. As it is it’s thisclose to an In.

      OUT

      • Pennymac

        Yes, I think the little flair at the bottom of these pants completes the “propotions of these are wonky” look. If they were skinny I think this would work (but not werq) I love the color, and love the shoes, and tolerate the jacket/top,  Mini in.

    • http://twitter.com/carlatheviking Carla Pereira

      No.

    • http://theargiehome.blogspot.com/ Gus Casals

      She did it again, love it on first sight, and thus, IN
      Second look shows an odd fit in the pants, but I love the color palette and her casualness about the whole thing. Love the shoes too.

    • http://twitter.com/foodycatAlicia foodycatAlicia

      OUT – sorry Zoe love, the fit is awful, you look tired and your hair is hurting your head.

    • http://pleasewelcomeyourjudges.com/ Brian @ PWYJudges

      Love it! Total IN.

    • Roosevelt 85

      IN!!!! Fierce as Fuck

    • alwaysanswerc

       That jacket is what would happen if the Highlander and a matador had a baby.

      IN, because I cracked myself up with that mental image.

    • VioletFem

      I love the color palette of this outfit, but the proportions of each piece seems way off. The pants look a little too baggy oh her. I think that top might look better with a slimmer pair of pants or a slim skirt. Also, not a fan of shoulder pads. 

    • DebbieLovesShoes

       I don’t like it; I think the pants are WAY too big on her.  (But the shoes are amazing.) 

    • http://www.lippsisters.com/ Deborah Lipp

      Out. The proportions are wrong. The jacket inspires awe but she looks like an inverted triangle. Those pants are sloppy and bulgy and weird.

      • http://profiles.google.com/anplica Anplica Fiore

        Yes.  Out for all these reasons.

    • ThatPeterG

      I love it. It works on her, and probably her alone.

    • MK03

      Ew. Nobody should wear that.

    • http://twitter.com/obscureobjects David Calder

      It’s an out. If you need me, I’ll be in mourning.

    • Nicole Chubb

      Total scrolldown fug. I thought it was a cute dress. The proportions are just weird.

    • lrhoff

      The model looks WAY better, in fact!  She’s out…..the belly thing is not cute.

    • Super_Red

      yeouch! No. Sorry, Fabulous Zoe, but you’re out this time. chin up, sweetie- even fabulous needs a break sometime. Fire someone, and you’ll feel much better, mmkay?

    • http://twitter.com/Lily1129 Lily

      Out, because of the fit. There’s just something off about the whole thing that I can’t put my finger on.

    • Summer On The Beach

      Out.  She could have made that jacket work if she hadn’t stolen the pants of a 4’11” octogenarian golfer.
       

      • Nayasabrina

        Indeed— do they even make SANS-A-BELT slacks anymore?  Anybody here old enough to remember the Ed McMahon ads?

        ETA- OUT

    • BazoDee

      OUT. My first Saldana out. 

    • Joanna Schuth

      Noooooooooooooo.

    • http://twitter.com/jennawaterford Jennifer Ford

      In. She is pulling this off by the skin of her teeth, and she definitely is wearing it much better than the model did.

    • http://twitter.com/msjwatt J.Watt

      Sassy seventy society lady. IN.

    • Judy_J

      OUT.  Those pants don’t fit her.  Too big in the waist, and the crotch is baggy.  I don’t particularly like the shape of that blouse, either.

    • hughman

      It’s like if Michael Jackson had a Cosby sweater. No thanks. 

      • formerlyAnon

         Perfect!

    • Charmella

      When I saw this earlier, my first thought was YIKES…those pants don’t fit right. They don’t…and they’re a tad too shiny…the sweater is gorgeous, but the silhouette is wacky! Ahhhhhh…sorry, she should know better! OUT!

    • http://twitter.com/PhDKnitter marlie

      I love it! The jacket is TO. DIE. I wish the pants sat a shosh higher on her hips – maybe she should have gone with a smaller size? Otherwise, I think she looks great. I’d give her an 8/10.

    • http://twitter.com/democracydiva Democracy Diva

      Sargeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, but IN.

    • j_anson

      OUT. Like the concept, can’t deal with the cut/fit of those pants.

    • http://twitter.com/Kathy_Marlow Kathy Marlow

      Can I just have those shoes? They’re pretty fab. 

    • KateShouldBeWorking

      Cool-ass chick in wonky clothes: OUT

    • SapphoPoet

      OUT. The proportions are all wrong and those are some very aggressive-looking shoulders. Even Zoe can’t save this outfit. 

    • oatmealpie

      Out. The bit of tummy ruins it.

    • VicksieDo

      The pants are cool, but too big.  She’s probably too small for a size 0 :-(

    • Jellybish

      Love it, even though the pants don’t fit right.  Her fierceness transcends.

    • In_Stitches

      Cropped pants that flare don’t work on anyone.  OUT.

    • Courtney Brown

      IN. She looks cool. 

    • wisenhar

      I think the outfit is super-cute, but the fit is just wrong.  It’s a shame, I think she totally could have rocked this outfit, but she needed a couple of more fittings.  One of her fabulousness should have known better, so I have to fall on the side of OUT.

    • claudemtl777

      SASSY…frst word to pop to mind…by virtue of that :IN!

       

    • TSkot

      Shudder! OUT

    • TheOriginalLulu

      I think if everything were a bit more fitted, she would be rocking the shit out of this look, but as is the pants fit horribly and the top looks too boxy on her. Sadly, it’s an OUT.

    • Trisha26

      She’s so tiny that the huge shoulders just look ridiculous. At the same time the pants don’t look like they fit at all. And matchy shoes. Model looks far superior.

    • belfebe

      OUT.  The pants don’t fit.  That’s what’s bringing this look down.

    • fashionzombie

      OUT, but I blame the clothes, not Zoe. 

      Really, though, the pants look fine in the model shot, but when Zoe stands like a red-carpet human in them, they make her body look all sorts of weird. I’m willing to bet these pants look good in one stance only. And I flat-out don’t like the top. 

    • http://www.facebook.com/seelebrennt Christina Diaz

      out. i really hate the pants.  i think it’s just the fit though

    • Gabriella Soza

      Love. In. I want this.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Julie-Chase/731391326 Julie Chase

      Oof. No. Killer shoes though.

    • http://opinionandamovie.blogspot.com/ Deitra S.

      I think it’s just a skosh off.  Had the pants NOT been cropped, this could have been magnificent.  Also, while I love the shoes, they do seem a bit matchy-match with this particular outfit.  I’d have to say a rare, and near OUT.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/M2D277JWFM4BUI7PWTTGYM67XI Mathilde

      In, even if not a fan of the belly-strip. Love all those pieces as separates, and enjoy it en her. Except for belly… It’s okay, but just this time. I feel this could have been so much better without the belly strip ! There were other ways to make this outfit more youthful…

    • http://www.facebook.com/RocketStarling Ashley Ellen Wilson

      she looks like she walked out of the Goodwill dressing room. shut that shit down. ugly, ill-fitting pleated pants make her look super scrawny and skeletal. OUT fo sho.

    • BobStPaul

      Out.  Over-sized, under-fitted,and the hair makes it worse.

    • mjude

      its late afternoon & i am being nice, so IN.

    • Little_Olive

      Maybe if she wasn’t swimming in it

    • Dhammadina

      I love the top but those look like droopy old man pants that belong on some geezer drinking from 10 AM on at the clubhouse. Even though the shoes and sunglasses are great, it’s an out.   

    • http://iamthelizardqueen.wordpress.com Lizzie

      I might like to tweak some of the details, but I really like it overall.  IN!

    • Sara__B

      Out. The fit on the pants is awful — they look like cheap polyester grandpa slacks — and the proportions are wrong, too. Zoe’s magic isn’t working for me with this outfit.

    • vanjar

       I agree with Tom.
      “she’s gonna need a walker to get through the Met’sCattle Baron’s Ball fundraiser.” I see someone has been watching Dallas.

    • altalinda

      In, though the fit around the waist seems off.

    • RL McGruder

      I love it.  The awkward stance is what’s ruining it for me; I’ll bet that it looks amazing on-the-go, or when she’s casually standing and chatting.

    • amywinns

      It’s an interesting look she could have pulled off if everything fit her properly (in other words, it was couture/made to fit). But it does not, and as is so often the case, poor fit ruins the party.

    • Lisa Dugan

      I think the top is fabulous but the pants fit her terribly.  She’s thin but they make her look way too frail.

    • sunandmoon24

      In! She’s working the hell out of (what is something not so pretty, actually). I don’t know how she manages it.

    • Sue_Asponte

      Well, she looks better than the model. But it’s still a strange outfit. I can’t call it either. Well, I wish she’d worn something else. So I guess that makes it an OUT.

    • http://twitter.com/#!/Space_Kitty Space Kitty

      Not even the Saldana.

    • judybrowni

      SERIOUS fug.

      Any outfit that can make the model look like a cow with a pinhead — and fug up Zoe at the same time — doesn’t even merit the Goodwill rack.

      • judybrowni

        hate, hate, hate the color combo, NFL shoulder pads, zipper-revealing fly PLUS rick rack combined with metal studs, fringe, and Chinese frogs!!!!

        It’s like the ’80s ate an indigestible meal, and threw it back up.

        Purge this from my memory, please.

      • Ogden1990

        Pinhead!

    • carolynmo

      I love it! Zoe Bingbing!

    • RebeccaKW

      Out.  I actually do like the idea of the look.  I love the top and the shoes.  I like the color of the pant.  But the fit on those things is crazy.  

    • http://twitter.com/chylde bellalozza

      Out. Too much blingarama
       

    • LuluBI

      Out! Is it just me, or do those baggy cropped pants look like Banana Republic soccer mom?

    • Kimberly Cooperrider

      For some reason this is giving me Jada Pinkett Smith vibes. Like others have said, maybe if this fit better, but as is… OUT.

    • ChelseaNH

      Out.  If the pants fit better, she could have pulled it off.

    • trisker

      OUT.  the OUTfit is crazy.

    • Trebawa

      A valiant attempt, but there’s only so much ugly you can remove from some things.

    • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

      Nope. Not this time, Miss Zoe. OUT.

    • AlexisPayne

      Out, the proportions look off and almost baggy on her.

    • http://cheekypinky.wordpress.com/ Rebecca

      Out. The crotch makes her ladybits look droopy.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=610791985 Aniela Marie Perry

      I almost spit my coffee on my monitor when I saw this. A LOL-worthy OUT.

    • fungstyle

      tone down the volume on those shoulders and it’s an in. 

    • Miss_Led

       Doesn’t fit. WTH 1980’s shoulder pads. OUT.

    • http://profiles.google.com/xelad007 C Deal

      Those pants are hid-tastic! Out.

    • twocee

      Ridiculous.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3JSTXMWWVZN2QNP2UEKJMTWD7U Isabel

      What I wrote for Diane Argon applies here also.

      Isn’t it summer? Why is she wearing something that would look great in October?

      So, it’s a NO

    • Klocked

      Close but out. I love the shoes. I think I like the top. The sunglasses and clutch are cute. I’m not going to begrudge her such simple hair and make-up when she’s so stunning. But those pants ruin everything. 

    • Adrienne Dobson

      OUT.  She looks like one of Madame Rose’s Toreodorables. 

    • eight_of_nine

      OUT. The proportions are horrid.  Make the pants slim all the way down, and the top a bit longer and less boxy, and it could have worked.

    • Scarlet39

      OUT

      This just doesn’t work

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Linda-Harris/1358701372 Linda Harris

      OUT, the pants don’t fit

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1129137319 Paula Pertile

      Those pants look like they belong on an old man.

    • sagecreek

      IN. The pants don’t fit, no, they don’t, but I get what she was going for.

    • sagecreek

      IN. The pants don’t fit, no, they don’t, but I get what she was going for.

    • http://twitter.com/SparklyCasanova UglyCasanova

      I actually don’t mind it.  Lukewarm.

    • http://twitter.com/SparklyCasanova UglyCasanova

      I actually don’t mind it.  Lukewarm.

    • rainwood1

      I laughed out loud at the runway model’s teeny head sprouting from those huge shoulders.  

    • rainwood1

      I laughed out loud at the runway model’s teeny head sprouting from those huge shoulders.  

    • rainwood1

      I laughed out loud at the runway model’s teeny head sprouting from those huge shoulders.  

    • kimmeister

      Out.  Some hips are needed to balance the fullness of the shoulders.

    • Eva_baby

      Ooooh, OUT.

      The top screams Dame Edna.
      The pants scream Carlito’s Way.
      The whole outfit makes me want to scream.  And not in a good way.

    • marilyn

      Out.  The pants are way too big and the sweater is way too short.  I never realized how slim she is.  But, this outfit does not compliment her.  It makes her shoulders look big and the top half of her torso very long, whild the lower part is very short.  It makes her look like she has figure problems when she does not.  She deserves better than this.

    • CheriCPat

      Horrible.  Out, out, out.  No saving this.  

    • jmorino08

      I fall in the ridiculous camp. Definitely an Out!

    • nannypoo

      The pants are awful and they don’t fit. The top is pretty but it’s too short and the sleeves make it look too wide. Her hair looks like an afterthought and she needs makeup. Bad all around.

    • http://needtherapy.tumblr.com/ skadi1

      Kind of love the jacket, DEFINITELY love the shades, but those pants are so heinous, the genetically-gifted model can’t pull them off standing still. Sadly, I think they take the whole look into out territory.

    • Elias Pineda

      in,  i like it!   

    • another_laura

      Out.  Ye gods, those pants!

    • NCDFan

      Ugh!  Those pants are hideous and ill fitting. (I don’t like them on the model either but at least they seem to fit.) The jacket? is cute and paired with a skirt would be okay. Top half in, bottom half out.

    • jilly_d

      IN!  though I would like it better if those were just skinny pants, not flared.

    • mom2ab

      I am having bad 80’s flashbacks…OUT

    • http://www.facebook.com/samuel.j.donovan Samuel Joesph Donovan

      I love it, but I mostly just love her.

    • rissa42210

      Out.  She looks short, deathly thin and severe.

    • deliadee

      IN!  I think she looks great and much better than the model, whose top is sadly too big and pants unflattering.  Not really thrilled with the drum major feeling, but Zoe makes it work.

    • jennifervney

      I’m gonna say In! It’s not perfect, but I love all the parts. Perhaps better hair and make up would’ve erased any lingering doubts. 

    • jennifervney

      I’m gonna say In! It’s not perfect, but I love all the parts. Perhaps better hair and make up would’ve erased any lingering doubts. 

    • formerlyAnon

      Out. Even she.

    • http://journostyle.blogspot.com Alana

      Out out out out out out. So awful.

    • http://twitter.com/MandySCG MandyJane

      Out. I don’t like the shape of the sweater. Those jewel tones look great on her, but it’s too bad the sweater has such big poofy shoulders.. or something. It’s hard to point at just one thing that’s not working. 

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ZNK2YOGTJVHW2MWCSUDM3RKMC4 Dave

      Oh, Zoe.  Just….noe.  OUT.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=589049560 Jill Satterfield

      Out. The proportions are off. Didn’t look that disproportionate on the runway.

    • JuliaInBlack

      Feh! The top is part marching band, part Krystle Carrington and the pants are 100% pure unpasteurized fug. I love you Zoe, but OUT

    • pookiesmom

      Eesh, I think this looks horrible. OUT.

    • GTrain

      I think it’s cute. IN

    • http://asskickingadviser.com/ Ass Kicking Adviser

      IN. My first reaction is that I liked it so, per your instructions, I will vote IN.

    • http://www.youtube.com/user/toodleskitty79?feature=guide AWS

      Matchy, matchy.  Icky, icky.

      OUT

    • allisankelly

      Maybe she should have cut the 3 inches off the bottom of the pants and not the bottom of the top? It’s an interesting look, but it’s an OUT.

      Was there a requirement for sunglasses and severe hair at this event? This is 2 ladies (Zoe and Jaime King) now with shades and tight hair.

    • sk8tfan

      Out. Pants look ridic. Love the shoes. The top could have been gorgeous but didn’t fit (my single biggest kvetch on the red carpet) and should have been with a skirt or part of a dress. Zoe, you let me down!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CQPXLNCBM5CZSHZZXJDHPVFS7E Buffy

      Nope!

    • poketom

      What’s a septuagenarian’s equivalent of Satan’s pants? If she had been wearing this just out on the street to go shopping or something we would be saying huzzah. But for an event I think it’s a strange choice to begin with. That top and those shoes with a dark skinny jean…

    • guest2visits

      Even though the colors are very good on her, those pants are just a terrible fit for Zoe and the model.
      I don’t think cropping the top helped, either. I like Zoe’s shoes and accessorizing much better than the model.

    • bailey debruynkops

      IN BUT THE HAIR IS WAAAY TOO HEADACHE INDUCING

    • MzzPants

      IN.  Chic.

    • PeaceBang

      Out. Doesn’t work.

    • littlemissstrange

      Oh god no. OUT. It could’ve worked with some pants that actually fit her but this…. this is crotch insanity.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2P2ANLRZ6YAVGONA36I2AQJYGI VicD

      Oh crap, a rare misstep.  Out.

    • CatherineRhodes

      OUT. Ugly.

    • ThaliaMenninger

      No. OUT. Ugly.

    • http://eclectictsunami.blogspot.com/ Cassie

      I like it. At first, I was annoyed by the strip of belly (she’s better than that!) but it does make it look a bit more youthful. And, hey, it’s Zoe. IN.

    • Jangle57

      I agree with everyone who said the proportions are all wrong because she shortened the top.  Zoe makes a misstep – OUT

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Emily-Smith/12431153 Emily Smith

      In!  fun!  fuck conventional fashion!

    • alyce1213

      Those pants are just butt ugly.

    • EveEve

      OUT. None of it is working but the sunglasses and the shoes. Everything in between is ridiculous.

    • quiltrx

      OUT.  I love the top on the model.  The pants are icky.

      SHE IS TOO SKINNY.

    • granddelusion

      The pants don’t fit right, and the sweater makes her look top-heavy. Out.

    • holdmewhileimnaked

      leaning towards the walker but only cos her pants dont fit. if they fit, she’d look fine as always.
      the way she does it is by being thing as a whippet, great clothes hanger proportions. good face, decent dollop of style.

    • Ksagun13

      OUT!  Pants look ill-fitting, too short, too green (and I love green). Top is too busy.  And I hate the hair, too severe.  Sorry, Zoe.

    • ziarah

      Hideous. 

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_B53PQYXSJR4YJBV3J6BWYSICRQ Jamie

      a little too Michael Jackson for me – OUT

    • lesmaha

      OUT. Those pants look so cheap!!  The whole look is ug.

    • http://twitter.com/Eovaai Eovaai

      OUT.  This would look awesome on a funky 75-year-old

    • http://gabyrippling.tumblr.com/ Gabriella M

      IN. Feisty matador chic. 

    • Terence Ng

      In.

    • Cat_In_A_Hat

      Love it. The pants look a little baggy, which is a worry but still IN!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JSGAZPEESHQT47ATH55GNOHHBY Erin

      OOOOOUUUUUTTT!  Holy hell.  Nobody get near those pants with nail polish remover; one drop could dissolve the whole garment.

    • Geoff Dankert

      Out. The crotch is insane.

    • fursa_saida

      Keep the sunglasses and maybe the shoes and torch everything else. This is flat-out stupid.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/J2VE4NE2FY2BP4QD2XOYKJGLPI Laura

      Pants are the problem…

    • http://www.facebook.com/douglas.rodrigues Douglas Rodrigues

      IN

    • kikisayshi

      It is interesting enough, but the proportions are off and the pants are not fitted well at all. She looks large up top (which I get is supposed to be the look) and it isn’t working for her. OUT.
      ETA: Looking again, I absolutely hate the top.

    • silaria

      The top is a size too big and the pants are way too short.  Which is a pity, ’cause I want to love this.  The pants ruin it, though.  Alas, OUT.

      Also, I hate those shoes.

    • Imasewsure

      It’s weird but fun but it’s only IN with the shades on!

    • leave_Blake_alone

      Wait, really? This is an easy IN for me. I think it’s saucy and a little chic while really not being that aging at all.

    • sashaychante

      OUT  Those pants have GOT to go.  I don’t really understand this length of pant.  Are they pants?  Are they shorts?  Did they shrink?  Are they too long?  GET RID OF THEM!

    • Candigirl1968

      OUT.  Due to the strange proportions of the big boxy sweater and how it looks on her tiny frame, coupled with the small “accidentally got shrunk in the dryer” pants, this looks like an accidentally ill fitting outfit rather than a “look.” 

    • unbornfawn

      OUT. The fit is terrible on those pants and those shoulders are too big on her and the hair is too severe.

    • PastryGoddess

      IN 

      this works ONLY on La Saldana due to her fierceness.  Other ladystars need not apply

    • lifetime_student

      The top is too wide and too short throwing off the proportions of the whole outfit. Out.

    • http://twitter.com/poptartsjen Pop Tarts Jen

      Oooh. At first I said, OUT, but then she put the sunglasses on and I thought it might be an IN.

      Then I came to my senses and decided, nah, it’s still too out-of-proportion and weird.

      OUT. (Sorry Zoe, I still love you!)

    • elemspbee

      In. she’s working this. First foto–so much ‘tude kept this from society matron territory. pants are ill-fitting. but looks sharp!

    • mila_8

      From the waist up she almost has it but those pants are hiddy, out!

    • BigWhiteGrannyPanties

      Out.  Society matron in her seventies, FROM the seventies.  Nope.

    • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

      Well, I love the color combination of blue and green.  The jacket is fantastic, except the proportions just don’t seem quite right to me.  The pants look too big and too wrinkly.  Love the shoes.  Her hair seems a little too severe, and her accessories are just boring.  She doesn’t look happy or comfortable, so for me, it is an OUT.

    • curiouserandcuriousest

      If it’s the gut reaction you’re after, I’m afraid it’s an OUT. The fit on those pants bothers me. A lot.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sierra-Delta/100003182924700 Sierra Delta

      It’s never In when I can see the top of your zipper.  Oh, Zoe, my illusions about your invulnerability are shattered.  I’m going off to mourn in sad and lonely splendor.

    • phrenk

      She looks so pleased with herself that I am coerced into giving this an IN.

    • http://www.facebook.com/joy.yeager Joy Yeager

      That crotch is INSANE, the jacket is too short on her and fits wonky, and her hair is so tight-it’s giving ME a headache…OUT.

    • demidaemon

      OUT. The proportions are all wrong here, and those pants look a size too big. I agree with the fellow commenters–it looked better on the model.

    • Joey Melliza

      its working but not WERQing — maybe she should’ve re-considered the pants.

    • Cheri Lee

      IN. I love the sunnies and the clutch with this look.

    • http://twitter.com/watchinginkdry Krysta

      Out.  

    • CassieLee22

      OUT

    • teensmom99

      would be better if her pants fit.

    • jw_ny

      OUT

      I could almost get behind this look if the pants weren’t so odd.  These remind me of cheap ’70’s men’s polyester pants, aside from the length, especially at the waist band.  Something more fitted may have been better, idk.   There are elements of the top that I like, but not really diggin’ the linebacker shoulders.

    • Beardslee

      OUT, on the principle that stylists should dress their clients in season.  That shirt is too heavy.
      Come January, all we’ll be seeing is strappy sandals and pastel chiffons.

    • Jennifer Hofstetter

      I would say the look is in, but the fit seems all wrong to me, so OUT.

    • Solokitty

      I think it’s an out for me  because it just looks more like a September outfit v. a June one. 

    • http://twitter.com/WDLFMemphis WDLF

      Those pants are dreadful on her.  I love her, but *lowering my voice to the tiniest whisper as to not arouse the slumbering fashion gods* it’s out.

    • ChaquitaPhilly

      You know, in the little cropped photo it wasn’t so bad but one look at those pants and its got to be OUT!
      The pants are so bad they make the top look good, and I’m not crazy about the top.

    • M Carlson

      In. I like.Sharp and sassy.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mary-Stone/100001328135240 Mary Stone

      big issue is the belly flash, it’s a cropped top sure, but it’s still too short for her, she’s got a longer torso than the model.  Also the pants do not fit, they’re a little too big in the waist, and I think the rise may be a bit too long for her as well. The combination makes them look baggy where they should be smooth.  Love the shoes though.

      It’s an out for me.
       

    • http://twitter.com/herong Heron

      LOVE.

    • crash1212

      I’m going with OUT. There were some interesting ideas here, but the execution is just….off. Everything looks too big – I know it’s supposed to be that way (maybe) – but here is just looks….too big. Also, the cut of those pants is just not very flattering. Colors are pretty – but – OUT.

    • HK4Seven

      OUT!  The pants are too big, the jacket is too short, and the strip of belly showing on something that to me reads winter wear is tacky.

    • saanrio

      OUT!  Vuitton is not impressing me, and sadly to say, neither is Zoe in this.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=601016544 Amy J Albin

      Love the top on her… the pants not so much.

    • Aly Light

      OUT

    • aimee_parrott

      OUT.  The fit on those pants is making me sad.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=713709401 Randy Noak

      No thanks.

    • Susan Crawford

      I think the problem is that the proportion is skewed. The top is wide-shouldered, embellished, and demands some balance on the bottom. The pants are great, but they seem too minimal, too skimpy and far less powerful to show off the top. I would have gone with a slightly fuller cut, a bit longer, and maybe in black to offset and balance the top.

      Love the shoes, love the sunnies, love Ms. Saldana!

      I’m giving this a lower-case “in”.

    • librarygrrl64

      Hate it if for no other reason than the proportions are off (or totally wrong for her). OUT.

    • TieDye64

      OUT. Model is wearing it better. Words I never thought I’d utter.

    • http://www.facebook.com/jahna.peloquin Jahna Peloquin

      The out-sized jacket and pulled back hair make her look like a pinhead, and she is swimming in those pants. OUT

    • Erin Nice

      I love it. A big IN.

    • nancy

      Out- nothing fits. The pants really ruin it, she looks like she has absolutely no hips, they bag & sag in odd places. The jacket has way too much stuff glomped on it. Glomped. But I love the shades. 

    • Ezmartin

      Zoe works her magic again. In. Would have been out on just about any1 else.

    • cleep1000

      Much more chic as seen on the model, with longer sleeves and belly covered. Zoe’s version looks like it has shoulder pads or is just much puffier in that area. The whole thing gives her a stumpy feel, and she’s definitely not a stumpy girl. OUT.

    • http://vhanna26.typepad.com Vera

      Sorry, Zoe. OUT.  Cool shoes, though.

    • Renaissance_Man_ATL

      IN!  My only critique is the pants don’t fit correctly.  The crotch is too long/big.  Otherwise, a lovely look.

    • bitterk

      This was a close vote?  Yikes!

    • yulaffin

      I like it but not on her.  Looks better on the model.

    • Arelis Víctor Garro

      In
      no matter the details she looks good

    • Giustina Pileggi

      IN! sassy and refreshing.