In or Out: Naya Rivera in Moschino

Posted on March 26, 2012

If we were going solely by first impressions, we would have shouted “OUT!” and be done with it.


Naya Rivera attends the 23rd Annual GLAAD Media Awards in New York City in a Moschino dress.

Moschino Fall 2011 Collection

Because our first impression was that it was a little “I want to be in America” with the red shininess and the ruffles. But the more we look at it, the more we kind of like what’s going on here.  We really love the way the dress looks from the back and that neckline’s really growing on us. The one aspect of the dress we could’ve done without (besides the shiny) is the ruffle along the hem. Everything else suits her quite well. The hair and makeup’s a little downplayed, but we suppose that’s for the best when you’re wearing a shiny red dress with ruffles. You don’t want to wind up looking like a fortune teller, after all. What really tips this over to the OUT column for us are the shoes. Those things are tacky as hell.


Vote Now!


IN! If any gal could pull off a shiny red ruffled dress, it’s Naya!

OUT! I can’t with those ruffles.



The minions liked Malin Akerman’s science textbook cover of a dress, but though the rest of the package looked a little messy, voting the look OUT.



[Photo Credit: Fernando Leon/Getty Images,]

    • Anathema_Device

      Out. I had the opposite reaction: I wanted to like it on her, but upon closer inspection, I noticed that the fit is terrible. She looks lumpy in all the wrong places, and that girl has a slamming body. The shoes are awful.

      • Susan Bullard Mayer

         Out.  What she said.

      • Aaminah Khan

        Exactly this. I just can’t get over how lumpy and poorly-fitted the whole thing looks. OUT.

      • tired_mommy


      • ballerinawithagun

        Out! I agree with everything, where did the beautiful draping go?

        • introspective

          I would actually say that the original dress was lacking to begin with. I dont see the draping as beautiful. its sort of a messy hybrid of ruffles and what seems to be almost but not quite ruching on the model. and then it gets even worse when it goes from the model’s body to Naya’s which petite as it is apparently has more curves to make the almost ruching just look like unflattering bunching. that, the plastic shoes and the neckline are making this a no. But her hair and makeup are really pretty. just not pretty enough to make up for this tragedy tof a dress.OUT 

      • Brittany Johnstone

        Ditto. It’s like she has two boob shelves. Bad, bad dress making Ms. Rivera look less than the perfection she is. 

      • JosephLamour

        agreed. those ruffled flaps on the back are too strangely fluffy. i like the neckline, but shes not only wearing a neckline. OUT.

      • judi townsend

        Out, what she said exactly!  Hate the dress on the model too. 

      • Alex Smith

        Yep, this. OUT.

      • Pinup Ghoul

         The shoes look like torture devices.

      • Brendan Foehr

         Anathema Device! I love Good Omens!

    • belfebe

      OUT. That dress looks sort of Chiquita Banana.  Beautiful woman.  Tacky dress.

    • Jenna Kuhmann

      I don’t like it.  She looks droopy all over.  OUT.

    • serenitynow02

      I like the neckline as well, and in another fabric, might have liked the dress very much. But, as is, that red satin is way too bordello for me. Anyway, I’d give her an automatic out just for the horrible shoes with toe cleavage.

    • Cautiously Pessimistic

      OUT.  If you’re going to wear red satin, it better fit.  There are way too many wrinkles across her midsection and she looks like she has no chest.  Frankly, it looks awful on the model too.

    • Jessica TallGirl Freeman

      If it fit like it did on the model this would have been a full IN For me.  But it just fits like shit on her, and with those shoes I just can’t.  And a ruffle slit? It looks like ruffle poop to me.

      • drdirection

        do those shoes have clear plastic on them?  How does she keep them on?  They barely cover her toes?   I don’t understand!!

        • Jessica TallGirl Freeman

          Oh yes, they are clear plastic.  Don’t people know you simply cannot own a pair of clear plastic shoes and someone not think “stripper shoes” regardless of what they look like.  

    • Kiltdntiltd

      The only thing I like is the color.  The back looks like she took a round ruffled tablecloth, wrapped it around herself, and pinned it together.  The less said about the shoes, the better.

      • emeazul

        Get OUT of my head, Kilt!!! I was going to post the EXACT same thing…I kept thinking I could make myself a pretty little dress with the flowered tablecloth my mom has from 1994!! (…maybe I would need two tablecloths though)

        • Kiltdntiltd

           Sorry, sometimes I just pick things up from the aether without thinking. I really need to work on blocking out stray thoughts better.  lol

      • Louise Bryan

        Tablecloth, that’s what it is.  Out.

    • Charlotte

      I like it on the model, but it’s a badly fitted mess on Naya. And the back is just tacky, OUT.

    • sarahofalessergod

      The more I look at it, the more I like the ruffle detail, and the color is fabulous on her.  I’ll go against the grain and say IN.

    • Greg Yoder

      It makes her look like her tits are pregnant.  OUT.

      • gabbilevy

        Seriously, I can’t figure out what is making the dress bulge like that!

    • Aerwyn

      In, despite the shoes.  She looks lovely; great color for her.  I’m not digging the hair, but I’m not sure what I’d suggest as an alternative.  The back of the dress is vavoom!

      Kinda surprised that I dig the hose on the model… Hope that’s not a sign of an upcoming trend.  I can remember the days when “power hose” were color coordinated with your shoes and suit.  (shudder)

    • RebeccaKW

      The shoes are terrible.  I like the hair and makeup.  I like the back and the color and don’t even mind the two ruffles so much.  But the fit is awful.  She looks like she has 2 rows of boobs and it’s pulling at her hips.  Also, matchy clutch.


    • VioletFem

      IN. The color is gorgeous on her. Although this dress has way more ruffles than I usually prefer, the overall affect is still very pretty. Could have done without the ruffly helm and a different pair of shoes though.

    • siriuslover

      Out. I can’t even deal with it this morning.

    • formerlyAnon

      Out. But I’m biased because I trend against ruffles.

    • Gus Casals

      Mmmm, it’s sadly an OUT. She’s pulling it off, but the dress is a mess ( the ruffles, honey, no…) and the color pattern and hair are indeed saying “hot latina stereotype”. 

    • AbbottRabbit

      Out. It doesn’t even fit her, and her hair is all wrong. And sorry, but it looks like what That One Aunt wore to your quincenera in the hopes that some of your dad’s coworkers are single. 

    • Alli

      OUT. She looks like an inflamed vulva.

    • R. L.

      I wish I could like it.  The fit on this tacky dress is not good.  Sigh.  Out.

    • Pupioso

      Out. The fit on the dress is odd. It’s like she’s all scrunched into it and it looks a bit disheveled. The shoes are fug.

    • Democracy Diva

      In for the Anita reference.

    • ccm800

      IN and then some. 

    • foodycatAlicia

      I hate the shoes. The rest looks good though. Scrolldown fug, but IN.

    • guestela

      Front looks terrible, back looks great, shoes are laughably bad. Out.

    • nannypoo

      Trust your first impression.

    • miagain

      There’s just too much happening with this dress… capelet, ruffles and shine shine shine… My system has overloaded!

    • mhleta

      Out. It looks like there’s and alien trying to escape from her solar plexus. Lady’s, take a flash snap shot of you in your dress before you go out. The flash does nasty things to shiny clothing. The combo of the color and ruffles with her Latina-ness definitely takes it into Rita Moreno territory for me. 

      • anon

        This. It makes her look like a caricature. The Anita reference is not a good thing.

    • Martova

      out. full stop.

    • LeBarron

      I’m going to have to go with OUT.  Too shiny, wrinkly, and ruffly.  Not digging the shoes or bag either.  She does looks great from the neck up though.

    • saanrio

      OUT.  The ruffles… all I see is Little Red Riding Hood personified… 

    • alyce1213

      Out, completely.  Girl needs some better undergarments, or maybe better tailoring, or both.
      Red satin can be deadly, and this is.

      Plus – Kourtney Kardashian hair?

    • Lenny Moses Breda

      Out. Maybe this is just the tendency of the fabric, but the fabric is pulling across her weird.

    • nancymae


    • Pants_are_a_must

      OUT. This is a badly made dress that looks awful on both Rivera and the model.

    • Elena


    • lalahartma

      Out, something is up with the fit and those shoes!

    • fireontiger

      Maybe it’s good on paper (minus those terrible shoes), but it just doesn’t look like it’s fitting her well. She looks lumpy, and Naya Rivera is NOT lumpy. OUT.

    • Gayer Than Thou

      It’s a little cha-cha. IN-ish.

    • LongTall_Sally

      OUT — she could do so much better.  Lumpy is never a good look.  

    • MilaXX

      Sadly it’s an easy OUT. Very rarely did satin dresses work and this wrinkly mess is no exception. The only thing I do like is the hair and makeup.

    • mellbell

      My feelings on the dress are just the opposite (love the neckline unconditionally, hate the back, think the ruffle adds balance), but I’m with y’all on the shoes. OUT.

    • Jennifer Peters-Ahnberg

      I feel enormously gratified that on first glance, I thought, “Hi Rita Moreno!” Here’s where we differ: love it from the front, hate it from the back. Out.

    • Laura Schultz

      OUT. Don’t like how it fits across the torso with all the folds and wrinkles. Don’t like the neckline. Love the back, though. 

    • Judy S

      OUT. Ruffles I don’t mind but the shiny and the shoes, ugh.

    • MzzPants

      Let me shout it for you:  OOOuuuuuTTTT!  The way it’s shaped in the back makes it look like she’s wrapped in a red satin bed skirt.

      Other items:  dress too tight, terrible shoes, matchy purse, yard-work hair, too much eye make up.

    • jw_ny

      Back and forth on this one, but ultimately OUT

      Good color on her, I like the top ruffle/collar and also like the dropped back.  Hair and makeup are pretty. 

      I am bothered by the fit, perhaps too tight, and how she appears to have a bulge under her breasts.  Maybe it’s an illusion due to the sheen and the way the folds are spaced…idk.  If the dress were looser and had more folds, as on the model, I think it’d have worked.   I don’t like the bottom ruffle and the way it slits up at the rear, also don’t like the sheen nor the shoes.

    • anon

      Out. That’s a hot mess of a dress, it doesn’t come close to fitting & it isn’t even seamed properly, you can see the puckering. Did she learn nothing from that satin Vera Wang that had exactly the same problems? And the hair & shoes are a disaster. Plus WTF is with the matchy satin bag? That’s so junior high.

    • Scarlet39

      OUT.  There’s just too much going on and the seams look tortured.    And it makes her look like she has an upper *and* lower gut, which she certainly does not! 

      I do think she looks great from the neck up, however.

    • AlexisPayne

      Out, too shiny

    • lifetime_student

      Out. The dress is interesting in theory, but that cheap looking material makes it look like a bridesmaids dress from the clearance rack at Penney’s. And those shoes are just tragic.

    • poggi

      I also like the back too, but if your dress requires you to back into a room, stand facing the wall, and coyly glance over your shoulder the entire night it’s probably an out.

    • janetjb

      The color is beautiful on Naya.


    • altalinda


    • MoHub

      Out. And can we please see an end to the just-below-the-knee hemlines? They make lower legs look like stumps. So much nicer when the hem hits at mid-knee or just above, where a natural break in the body occurs.

    • Terence Ng

      I hate the fabric, but I like her in it. There’s something I enjoy about it. IN.

    • Victoria Pavlova

      Out. It’s horribly wrong on so many accounts… And those pale lips do nothing for her. And clear plastic shoes are the devil.

    • Andrea Lane

      Ick. Out.

      That level of rufflage makes me shudder.

    • kirble

      It’s too blah for me to decide either way, but it kinda looks like there’s a little bit of puckering (as well as the bunching, which I guess is intentional) on the runway, too. Seems like there’s no way she could have made this work for still photos even if the fit had been better.

      Also, the collar is wilted, spoiling the one aspect of the dress that worked for me in the runway version. It’s like what happened to Laura Bennet when she had to bring her couture maid’s outfit back from Paris.

      IN for Naya, OUT for the dress.

    • Verascity

      OUT. The fit is horrible, and I can’t get past the neckline or the shoes.

    • NurseEllen

      Out.  That dress is yust rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrong.

    • prettybigkitty

      Out.  Shiny red bed skirt.  

    • Karen Stephens Bassett

      This is horrific.  She looks like she has two regular breasts and then a lower one between them.

    • BazoDee

      OUT – the ruffle at the bottom tipped it for me. 

    • marilyn

      OUt.  Too tight, and she is too short to wear it. The shiny and ruffles don’t help.

    • benjamin478

      Yeah that’s an OUT. Look at what it does to her body shape.

    • Nancer

      TLo – stick with your first impression, that was right on the money. Love this lady, but the dress is wearing her! And if you have to decompose a look to appreciate the parts, then it just isn’t working as a whole.

      • Nellie Wilson

        Well said. All I can add is OUT.

    • Lizzyisi

      Out. Hair & makeup are good. Color is gorgeous on her. Neckline is lovely; back of the dress (as noted by others) is T-A-C-K-Y. Hem ruffle lays better on the runway and is (in theory) a nice counterpoint to the neckline and important to the overall shape, but it’s too much. Shoes are awful; bag looks nice, maybe?

    • Gara St. James

      Out, it looks terrible even on the model.

    • TheLaurenJean

      Out. Tacky….

    • OhDoogs

      Out. This is reading very “Kardashian” to me.

    • korilian

      If I have to stare at a dress for fifteen minutes to see if it’s going to grow on me, it’s OUT.

    • DaringMiss

      I don’t like the fact that you can see her undergarments (a common trend among actresses these days).  The Spanx line at mid-thigh is just tacky.  Her stylist should have gotten her a bigger size so that the drape was fluid and elegant.

      “Love the girl, hate the look.”

    • CQAussie

      No sorry OUT.  I can’t even with those ruffles but her shoes were the worst.  Are those freaking clear shoes?  Oh hell no.  OUT.

    • sagecreek

      I love her, and it looks good from the back, but the front is a mess, and that hem ruffle went out with Lil Abner. OUT.

    • Lisa Weaver

      Bunchily, shine-ily, droopily, oh so sadly OUT. 

    • marywv

      Yeah. 100% OUT

    • TheOriginalLulu

      I don’t know. Looks like one big tacky feast from where I’m sitting.
      Eva Longoria would kill for this dress.

    • j_anson

      OUT. I love – well, like – this dress on the model, whose perfect proportions help keep it sleek. But it’s not doing Naya any favors.

    • jjfg

      I also like it on the model, but on her, it screams BRIDESMAID.  The only thing missing are DTM shoes.  OUT.

    • BrooklynBomber

      I think this is like one of those cleavage OR thigh-high slit situations, only in this case it’s business in the front OR the back, not both. Plus it fits the model perfectly but it doesn’t fit NR well. Out.

    • Stubenville

      J’adore matador. OUT.

    • Joyce VG

      OUT. Ill fitting and cheap looking.

    • P M

      IN. Very cute. Please don’t eat me.

    • VicD

      Feeling generous this morning. In.  Why not?

    • Aly Light

      The shoes are ignorable. IN.

    • unbornfawn

      OUT. Are you kidding me? She’s got a ruffle in her butt crack. The dress is too tight, shiny and pulling all kinds of funny. The dress makes her boobs looked squished and is giving her a pot belly. Toe cleavage and bad posture!  OUT! OUT! OUT!

    • HobbitGirl


    • PhillipWilde

      The dress is okay, but just too flouncy, and god, the TOE CLEAVAGE! I can’t. OUT.

    • HobbitGirl

      Out! She looks lumpy and even like she has some midsection flab, which has to be because of the appalling fit and shininess of the satin. This does her no favors at all. Good color, though.

    • lrhoff

      Out all the way…..

    • April

      FFS, it doesn’t fit, its completely the wrong size, & horror of horrors, you can see the line of her Spanx. Even they don’t fit her properly. Add in the Kardashian hair & shoes & the result is both she & her stylist are in need of a good smack of sense.

    • CatherineRhodes

      OUT. Tacky, tacky.

    • Anplica Fiore


    • sleah_in_norcal

      IN.  because she plays my favorite little latina lesbian cheerleader, and just LOOK at that butt!

    • Trevor Burroughs

      Out. I agree on “I want live in America.”

    •!/Space_Kitty Space Kitty

      I’d be willing to give her a provisional IN if the front of the dress fit as well as the back.  But as it is, oh honey NO.  OUTOUTOUT (I actually really do like her makeup here, though.)

    • Sara Munoz

      Ugh, THOSE shoes again?
      But IN nonetheless.

    • Kerry McCombs

      I can’t with the shiny. And those shoes just plain do not fit her. Out.

    • Aurumgirl

      I had those shoes about 30 years ago, got them for a dollar at a clearance sale–back then, the Chanel pump and all it’s permutations were a big deal, and the shoes I had, like these ones, were pretty much 100% plastic.  I used them for a Gangster Girlfriend costume though–looks like that might have been the thinking here, too. 

    • Judy_J

      OUT.  This little red dress is too shiny, too ruffly and too tight.  And those shoes should be taken out and burned. 

    • Celeste

      I read “maraschino” instead.. ’nuff said. So that’s an out for me.

    • meowing

      Sorry, guys, but a giant OUT; any dress that gives a tiny little lady a bi-level tummy is all kinds of wrong.  And even then, the upper-level tummy looks to be the same size as her bustline.  All the ruffles makes it look like cheap shower curtains.  And really tragic shoes.  Not much redeeming here.

    • alyce1213

      Looks like she got her dress stuck in her panties in the back when she went to the bathroom.

    • Julie Chase

      Too much froof. Out.

    • Fifi LaRoux

      OUT. I just can’t with the shoulder ruffle.

    • bellalozza

      IN. At least she’s not looking frumpy. 

    • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

      Well, hair and makeup are good, I don’t love the dress, but her ass looks spectacular.  And yeah, the shoes are bad.  Bad enough to push this over to an out?  I think so, unfortunately. OUT.

    • Larkin21

      Not just a ruffle hem but ruffle hem going up the butt. If anyone could pull it off, it’d be Naya, yes. But … she’s still OUT.

    • Merneith

      Out. I can’t see how anyone can look past the tackiness of the back of the dress and then complain about the shows.

    • Janie22341

      Error always addresses the passions and prejudices;
      truth scorns such mean intrigue, and only addresses the understanding
      and the conscience.

    • Sorana Tarmu

      Didn’t even notice the shoes. Impressive dress. IN.

    • another_laura

      oh no, OUT! OUTOUTOUTOUTOUT!  The dress is awful, and those shoes!  Clear plastic!  gaaaaaa!

    • Melissa Brogan

      OUT for not wearing a size that actually fits her. And those horrible shoes.


      I’ll do it for you; OUT. Done with it.

    • DinahR

      Her makeup is beautiful.  The dress is not flattering… and I assume that means it would not be flattering on anyone.  

      Also, her hair. It looks just like mine does when I go to pick up my son from school in the afternoon.  I didn’t know I was sporting a red carpet hair look.  Go me!  But I think this means we’re both OUT

    • Liana Brooks

      IN for having color and being unique. This is a one time Get Out Of Critique Free card. Don’t waste it.

      Considering the fit and everything it should be an out. *sigh*

    • Jessica O’Connell

      OUT. I don’t like the dress, I don’t like the shoes, and I don’t like that the dress somehow makes her look like she has to hold in her stomach all night, when we all know that her body is incredible. It’s just not flattering on her at all.

    • Ksagun13

      OUT.  Hate the ruffled hem, hate the shiny fabric, hate the shoes.  Naya, what were you thinking??

    • msftmargarita

      Out- I don’t like the dress at all. 

    • sleepycat

      OUT!! distaster! 

    • TheOtherChristina

      This is so close. I’m in complete agreement with all of your suggested edits — silk (or pretty much any other fabric) instead of satin, lose the ruffle on the hem, burn the shoes and salt the earth. With those changes this would be phenomenal, but that’s too many changes to give it an in. So, OUT.

    • Emily

      Out.  Love the front, but hate the back.

    • oatmealpie

      Out. Bridesmaid in a wedding with a “Fiesta!” theme.

    • BrightsideSusan

      No, no, no.

    • butterflysunita

      OUT.  Girl, that’s not anyone’s dress.  

    • mcglory13

      There are aspects of this that aren’t terrible, but out. 

    • Lisa

      Oh, wow, OUT.  So bad, so lumpy, ill-fitting and cheap looking.

    • MarissaLG

      Oh no no no no. OUT.

    • PeaceBang

      Good lord, no. OUT in every way.

    • Eovaai

      OUT. It’s really not flattering to her body and her shoes are beyond awful.

    • holdmewhileimnaked

      were i to only wear contemporary designers my wardrobe would be chock full of moschino [whenever i buy something new, cheap & chic tends to be very high on the list]. but this dress, oy, it really needs it to lay out the way it does w/ the wrinkles on the front in the manner of the model. elsewise it loses its everlovin oomph, if you will. & theres nothing to it but the collar & the ruffled butt-train, though a very nice ruffled butt-train it may be. i think it looks like a shiny red bag w/ fancy appointments on the starlet. so no.

      as an aside, i had those shoes several decades ago. clear w/ black heels & toes? only they were ankle boots, only i was about six years old. they were my favorite shoes at the time, but they dont go here. they might go better on someone under the age of nine. by ten yr almost a woman [or at least i was, probably through a combination of height & family responsibility & skipped grades & all sorts of the various nonsensii that comes w/ the abovenoted], so thats probably a bit too old.

    • Brendan Foehr

        Out, but I love the dress!

    • Cassie (C.M.W.)

      OUT! I can’t with the lumpy fit. 

    • miatamam

      Out.  It says “i wanna be a tablecloth” to me.

    • Tiger Gray

      Awful. It would be more flattering in the back without that weird ruffle, I think. OUT.

    • Cautia


    • littlemac8


    • JillK

      I had those exact shoes 15 years ago! Exact! That’s why they look so bad – they’re 15 years out of style!

    • Julia McLean

      Lumpy torso syndrome, this looks like a cheap Halloween costume. Plus SO HEAVY on the makeup foundation! Lighten up, girl! OUT

    • fashionablylate


    • Sophie Collier

      No.  It’s an interesting cut, but the cheezy red satin and those Shoes of the Devil (Shoe-cifer?) pretty solidly set this as an OUT.  This dress in a different fabric?  Possibly.

    • SatelliteAlice

      Out… the shiny is bad the dust ruffley bit is worse and it puckers in some odd places.

    • Tom Markiewicz

      OUT. she looks like a divan from a whorehouse trying to be expensive.

    • Mags

      Out. That is just fugly.

    • Paige Boerman

      Love the head. The head is good. Everything else, except the person wearing it, is out. I love Naya, but even she can’t work this. OUT.

    • DCSheehan

      In. I like the dress on her. I can see I’m in the minority though…

    • Sue Tyler

      I’m distracted by  what appears to be 3 boobs. out

    • Badriya Al-Badi’a

      OUT, onaccounta fit mostly.

    • GTrain


    • Shawn EH

      IN! It’s an updated classic.

    • AngelaGreen

      Out.  It makes her lumpy up front and she’s not lumpy.  Girlfriend is hot, and this dress is not.

    • TieDye64

      OUT. It’s looking worse the longer I look at it. I can’t with the ruffles, the fit’s not great and it’s just too damn shiny. 

    • butter nut

      tight, wrinkled, deflated & too shiny.  OUT!

    • Linderella

      My eyes, my eyes!  Out.  Way out.  Out even on the model, whom it at least semi-flatters.

    • ThaliaMenninger

      I can’t with those ruffles.

    • Jennifer Hofstetter

      Out. Aside from the ruffles and the shiny, it puckers in all the wrong places.

    • frankystein123

      The backside is gorgeous (why of course), but the front is kinda hideous.