In or Out: Leighton Meester in Prada

Posted on February 17, 2012

We’re so fashion’d out that we’re not sure we trust our instincts right now. After all, the runway is not the red carpet. So tell us, minions: do we like this?

Leighton Meester attends Miu Miu’s “The Woman Dress” premiere in New York in a Prada Spring 2012 dress.

And can someone tell us how she managed to make her boobs look airbrushed (and nipple-less) in candid shots? Please remember to show your work.


Vote Now!


IN! It’s fresh, unique and girly!

OUT! It’s awkward, weird, and boob-y!

Angie’s prim gown got an IN and Gabrielle Union’s uh…. anything BUT prim gown got an OUT. Clearly, the kittens are feeling puritanical this week, which doesn’t bode well for Leighton’s boobillusion dress.

[Photo Credit: PatrickMcMullan]

Please review our Community Guidelines before posting a comment. Thank you!

  • Suf Amichay

    IN. She looks great

  • Kyle Crawford

    i’m getting Wonder Woman teaches Sunday school…….with bows.

  • Sophie Collier

    She looks cute and is probably sporting those stick on nipple-subduers.  IN.  Could have don with some colorful shoes, but she looks pretty sweet nonetheless.

    • Anonymous

      Nipple subduers!!!  LOL!!  Love it!  I have never tried them, but I cringe just thinking about the removal!!!  Ouchy!!

      • Anonymous

         for a mammogram some techs use these stick on little markers with little metal pieces

      • Anonymous

        The lovely associate at the fancy lingerie shop where I did my bra-fitting informed me (with a straight face) that they are called “Dimmers.”

        P.S. – Out!

  • Anonymous

    No we don’t. Out.

    • Anonymous

      freaking awful

  • Anonymous

    No, you don’t like this.  It is awkward, weird, booby and just plain ugly.  OUT.

    • VicD


  • Heather

    OUT! Those kind of pleats always remind me of the Lawrence Welk Show.

    And… nipple-less and asymmetrical too? (I mean most of us are… but if you’re gonna make them look airbrushed you might as well go for symmetry.)

    • Anonymous

      I think the asymmetry comes from seeing the dress from an angle – from straight forward the boobage is (are?) balanced. I think she has a beautiful chest (sigh – to be that young again) and her hair and makeup are pretty. It’s the skirt that’s ruining it for me and looks geriatric.

    • Anonymous

      Swimsuit with Lawrence-Welk skirt. This is awful.

      • Anonymous

        Great description!

      • Anonymous

        Perfectly stated!

      • Heather

        I should clarify: I loved the Lawrence Welk show, especially when Bobby and Cissy would dance (and of course, Bobby was COMPLETELY STRAIGHT), but it’s disturbing to see Cissy’s skirt paired with Wonder Woman’s top, as another poster eloquently described it. Kind of like mixing Three’s Company with Dallas or something … just, like, entirely different genres.

  • Anonymous

    I think she looks beautiful, but that really is too much boobage–especially for daytime! Love her hair and her makeup!

  • bebo

    Needs a belt.

  • Anonymous

    OUT, the shoes killed the look. That was her chance to tie it all together.

    • Anonymous


  • Shannon Stewart


    And her boobs look like that as a result of a REALLY good make-up artist.  The nipples are just hidden behind fabric… and a LOT of boob tape to make sure they stay there.

    • Anonymous

       A few weeks ago I visited my friend at her school. She was about to go to a party, so she was dusting powder between her boobs to enhance her already prominent cleavage. I thought she was just being a big old ho (I say that with love), but that is a thing? Makeup on boobs? I feel so naive all of a sudden.

      • Anonymous

         It’s definitely a thing. Cage dancers, go go dancers, etc. never leave home without it. It’s also not unheard of amongst young women who aren’t getting paid to look sexy and dance.

      • Anonymous

         Totally. My friend & I did slutty convention costumes last year and low lighted the cleavage while highlighting the tops. Made average boobs look extra awesome. Not an every day thing for sure, but its fun when you’re going to boobtastic looks.

        • Shannon Stewart

          Essentially it’s the same process as highlighting cheekbones:)  A tad darker in the shadows, a tad lighter on the tops…

      • Shannon Stewart

        Oh yeah — my guess here would be that she had some powder shading to enhance cleavage with a luminescent powder on the areas where light hits the most. 

        And for a celeb, make-up EVERYWHERE that isn’t covered by the clothes is a thing.  You know that smooth, glowing skin?  On some of them, it’s natural… on others, it’s Maybelline.

  • Gus Casals

    Wha..? how…? NO. OUT.
    What’s with the neckline, boobage, barbie skin effect? And if you are going the sexy route, your face has to go with it.
    No, just no. 

  • Taija HU!

    I’d like it on someone else. But on her, it screams slutty sunday school which is surprisingly not as interesting as it sounds. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Yes.  It’s fab.

  • Anonymous

    Here’s a question in return  – is it a good idea to have your lips match your purse?

    • Karen


  • Anonymous

    Out. The beige-y color is all wrong against her skin, the v-neck is too wide, and those shoes are AWFUL. Plus I hate her bangs and hair color.

  • Anonymous

     Too many disparate elements. It just doesn’t coalesce. And that “neckline” makes me nervous. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Awkward, weird and booby would be my call. Auf with her head! I like the general shape of the dress (meaning at the shoulder and the pleats and silhouette below the waist), and if the whole thing had been yellow, I might’ve been willing to overlook the cut-to-her-navel thing. But flesh-colored and cut like that? Awkward, weird and booby says it all. Well, I do like her hair and makeup. But I HAAAAATE her shoes.

  • Anonymous

    You know how in a TV show or movie when someone needs to sex it up instantly and so they take a pair of scissors to what they’re wearing? That’s what this looks like. Way too much chest, her boobs look more like pecs than boobs, and then it’s attached to the world’s dowdiest yellow skirt that looks like it might be made out of terry cloth. Slutty bicycle jersey above the waist, matronly Easter dress from the waist down. A belt would have helped … but only to separate the two disparate (and equally ugly) halves of this dress. The child’s purse and apparently dyed-to-match her skin shoes only add to this trainwreck. Ick.

  • CQAussie

    OUT.  Her upper half looks like plasticine and then we have the yellow and yet more nude on the shoes front.  She just looks like a disjointed person with legs.  And random red panels on her sides + a red purse.  Not put together at all and what the hey is with that hair?  The whole look is a misfire.

  • Anonymous

    Sternum sternum sternum sternum, sternum sternum – sternum sternum sternum – sternum.  Sternum sternum.

  • Charlotte

    Too much cleavage, pleats, clashing colors and ugly shoes. She looks happy and smiling, but it still adds up to OUT.

  • monkeytoe

    Out–she’s all slutty swimsuit on the top and garden party on the bottom. Plus her shoes echo her cleavage v too closely. It is a little nauseating.

  • Anonymous

    Wow, that is an awfully low and wide neckline. And this is coming from a girl who loves a low neckline. Her poor boobs must have been shoved to the side and taped down in order to achieve this look, and I can’t sign off on that. In addition, that’s not her color and the dress itself does nothing for her shape. OUT
    I like that shade of lipstick for her, though.

  • Sandisan

    Ugh.  OUT.  Hate that dress.  She looks pretty, but that dress.  NO.

  • Anonymous

    Slutty Snow White. Out.

    • Anonymous

      LOL! Didn’t see this before I posted. Glad I’m not the only one who saw this!

      • Anonymous

        Right? All she’s missing is a couple of cartoon blue birds tying the bows! Or was that Cinderella? LOL

        • Anonymous

          I think it was every pre-80s Disney heroine. And possibly also Belle. 😉

    • Anonymous

      Gotta give credit to the original. That is a hilarious and accurate description.

    • Anonymous

      Haha I’m so glad i saw this before I commented. It’s EXACTLY what I thought!

    • Anonymous

      Exarctly. Out.

    • Rand Ortega

       You hit it. That’s it.

    • Anonymous

      Spot on.

  • Claire Haley

    The shoes are horrifying, but the dress looks great on her. IN!

  • Anonymous

    Out.  Those boobs are just gonna fly out and slap someone on the face if she’s not careful.  What’s with the weird epaulette bows?  And the shoes… THE SHOES!  They are the same color are her feet so it looks as though her toes are shaped like missiles.  She could stab someone’s shins if provoked.

  • Anonymous

    OUT, mostly for the fugly color combos on the dress.  Not a bad idea, but poor execution.

  • Anonymous

    It strikes me as Slutty Snow White for some reason (probably the yellow skirt and the red inserts). Out.

    • Anonymous

      “Slutty Snow White” That is a perfect description!

    • Anonymous

       That’s what I thought of, and yes, I think it’s the combo of the yellow, red inserts and red lipstick.

  • Anna James

    In! I think she looks fantastic. 

  • Lulu Lafurge

    Nonononononononono. Outoutoutoutout. Plunge neckline looks out of place with the rest of the top (maybe, just maybe, because the color is close to skin tone). Knife pleat skirt style totally clashes with the top, as does the color. (And don’t try to tie it in with that bit of yellow on the shoulders. I’m not fooled.) Plus the skirt would need a belt, or a waistband or something, wouldn’t it?

  • Anonymous

    LOL! Didn’t see this before I posted. Glad I’m not the only one who saw this!

  • Anonymous

    Out. The color on top is just not right. Too washed out. 

  • Anonymous

    I’m so tired of staring at shiny breasts. Could they please put them away for awhile? And the color change from bodice to skirt is perplexing. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    An odd combination of ladylike (the skirt, the purse) and brazen.  Out.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Her chest looks weird. Too narrow. Maybe the colorblocking on the dress enhances the Photoshop effect.
    And just last week you boys said she was gorgeous in person, that’s probably how the rest of the PS effect was achieved.

  • Slowlysarcastic

    Out, very out

  • Anonymous

    In – I like the frock, but as with all of your NYFW recaps, it boggles my mind how people are showing up to events in NYC IN FEBRUARY like they’re going out and about in Miami or something.  I live several hundred miles north of New York, but even still, I don’t think it’s warmer than 50 degrees there.  Which is still jacket weather.  

    So no idea how she manages not to have nipples here.  Unless they are taped to the nines.

  • bookish

    OUT. I hate everything about that dress. It’s like a ripped gymnastics leotard worn with a skirt. The bag is cute, though.

  • Anonymous

    AAAAAACK.  This is so ugly, it makes me question if Prada is waging a covert war on women.  It makes me sad for the people who had to sew it.  It should be ceremonially destroyed and the ashes paraded through the streets.

  • Anonymous

    OUT!!  The top and the skirt look like they belong on 2 different outfits and each is ugly in its own way.  I have no problem with the hair or makeup, but the dress is so odd that the rest of the look doesn’t matter.

  • Colleen Kay Sanceda Gadon

    hot mess

  • Anonymous

    Out.  Frankendress.  

  • Anonymous

    There’s 2/3 of a good dress there, but unfortunately the 1/3 that is un disastre is a flat-out boobstrosity. OUT.

  • Laura Schultz

    Hate. Stupid hair, unflattering neckline, strange color combo, shoulder bows are fug. OUT

  • Tracy Walker

    No likey. She’s a small girl and that those pleats are making her hips look HUGE. Plus, the illusion of shoes is not good enough for us – we demand color!

  • Jill Tracy

    OUT! the bodice matches her skin and it looks like an awkward expanse of skin. It’s oddly color blocked and needs a belt. It’s just wrong, ugh!!

  • Stephen Bornstein

    Top is like a bad one-piece bathing suit…bottom made from grannys window sheers. Ugly colors and way too much lipstick, botox those lips much?

  • Anonymous

    Hm. I don’t………I do…I guess it’s an in for me. It’s interesting, and weird, but she looks cute and feminine in a confused way. It’s kind of like a retro housewife, that has a secret life as a vampy superhero, and didn’t quite make the full change in the phone booth.

  • Christine Marie


  • Anonymous

    Nice: her makeup and handbag.
    Awful: one half swimsuit, one half ladies who lunch – I don’t think the two parts make much of a dress.
    Silly: putty shoes.
    Undecided: I don’t really know what’s going on with her hair.


    eta: out of season too

  • Jessie Melcher Brown

    Its a bathingsuit with a sunday school skirt over it.  No likey

  • Kathleen Morrison


  • Anonymous

    OUT, she looks naked from the waist up.

  • Ivona Foster

    Who put THAT top together with THAT skirt and thought “Hmmm…dress!” You should hold a guessing contest: how much body tape was used in the preparation of this look?

  • Lisa Weaver

    OUT – and here’s my work for the points: The purse and side panels on the dress? Too matchy matchy. That “flesh” colored top of the dress? Grrrr. Those same hued shoes? It looks like her toes melted together into a nail-less point. Bad. The pastel yellow and nude colored blows? Too twee even for Michele Williams. By far. Finally, I just don’t like how the skirt of the dress looks like an elastic waist dance skirt. Chip looking. 

  • bellalozza

    out. nude and red bathing suit w/ a yellow skirt. ugh.

  • Stan

    ugh no. bathing suit and cover up.

  • Anonymous

    Well, my knee-jerk reaction is, “Um??” I can’t tell. I feel like it should fit differently and have bolder colors. Also, I think those bangs are not her friends. So I’m going with OUT, even though I like the dress as a concept? Maybe?

    I’m not even the one who’s fashion-ed out…

  • Vaniljekjeks

    I don’t like it, and I hate the shoes, but she’s somehow making it work.  She’s in. 

  • Anplica Fiore

    Not a fan of the beige  – both in the bodice & the shoes.  Out.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. hate the shoes, needs a belt, chest area looks like a beige slice of pizza. . . 

  • victoria rodeno

    One is up and the other down. Breasts I mean. If they were equally up or down I think I would like it better.

  • Anonymous

    She has a lovely body and this doesn’t strike me as slutty as much as just wrongheaded. Nothing goes together save her bag and lipstick, which isn’t really what needs to go together. Shoes are a terrible choice. Blank chest is weird — neither sexy nor diva-dramatic. Also the beige and yellow look too disparate.
    Just no, basically. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    I got a Snow Whites cousin look.. Can you see it now at Disney World.. .. “Look kids, It’s Autumn Gold.. Snow’s white cousin!”   I can’t tell you how she airbrushed her boobs.. I’d love to have that look sometime.

  • Anonymous

    In. It’s weird but I like it. I can’t tell you why though, so deduct points.

  • Bethany Roullett

    Out.  Weird and boob-y, and it’s pulling funny.  Like the V of the neckline is landing at the wrong place.  I’m not sure what the right place is though.

  • Anonymous

    Forgot to add No- to anything that resembles a deconstructed Walt Disney World costume.

  • Lori

    Look what is going on with her breasts. One is fine and the other is all mashed down in a very weird way. There is no excuse for that. Even if that wasn’t true, she’s showing too much for day. Even if she wasn’t showing too much the dress is sort of unbelievably ugly. I suppose it’s supposed to be fashiony, but it fails and instead just seems like the top half if one dress was accidentally sewn to the bottom half of a totally different dress. The beige and the yellow look terrible together and the red inserts are giving it a slutty Snow White vibe. That’s not fashion, that’s a Halloween party totally lacking in imagination.

    In short, out, out out.

  • Zi Jie Tan

    Such an odd, tasteless n ugly dress! As if someone cut out a slice of strawberry meringue cake.. to reveal Leighton’s nipple-less torso. 

  • linda

    out, it’s just fugly

  • Francesca Lagmay

    In– suddenly love her bangs. Also, the dress is quirky, but fresh. I dig. 

  • Sara Munoz

    She is a truly gorgeous girl. Finally she is dressed in a manner worthy of her looks.
    That is to say, IN. For once. 

    But those shoes. Let’s just say I hate them.

  • Michelle Argento

    Love the top, but I hate that yellow skirt with a passion. I dont know. Half of an In?

  • K

    She looks great but I think if the skirt was a different color it would work MUCH better. As it stands it looks like the wrong top with the wrong skirt. But hair, makeup and the top part look great!

  • Liz Neale

    Awful shoes and I hate the weird two tones of beige (which wash her out anyway). Out out out.

  • Anonymous

    Yellow pleats. Need I say more? Well, I will: she looks like she’s ready to stand on the back of a pony and ride it around and around the ring for the happy circus-goers. A very confusing look. The boob situation is fascinating, though. OUT.

  • Kathrine Marlow

    I think I’d like it better if the skirt was in a different color, but the yellow is throwing me off OUT

  • Anonymous

    OUT. It’s weird.  The top doesn’t look like it belongs with the bottom and neither looks that good on her.

  • Anonymous

    I think she looks lovely; the dress, though, looks odd to me. The skirt and the top look like they don’t go well together. Why not a red skirt?

  • Anonymous

    NO no no. It hurts to look at.
    An inhuman torso above one of the ugliest skirts ever made.
    Please have pity on us and post no more of these.

  • Anonymous

    Out, she looks like a superhero cheerleader and her makeup is attacking me.

  • Anonymous

    No, we don’t like it. It’s ill fitting and unflattering, and the top looks like some kind of man-made molded material. Outsky.

  • leah besson

    it would be much prettier if it was not sooooo low cut.  

  • Joanna Schuth

    Ouuuuuut. Awkward is exactly the word for it. 

  • Jenna Ryan Boatman

    OUT. Want to like it, I love the shape and the skirt, but the whole nude leotard top is freaking me out with the shiny.

  • Anonymous

    NO. Even though she’s got a cute face.
    THAT V-NECK! *shudder*

  • Anonymous

    I think it’s an interesting dress and I like that she pulled out the red for her bag. Shame about those shoes. IN for me, though.

  • Anonymous

    Aaagh! I really want her to have a success, and I think she looks 60% good. Makeup, the yellow portion of the dress, the shape of the dress, and the bag all look good. Hair is okay. The nude bodice is too close to her natural skintone: this is a dress for a woman of color (if anyone, it’s pretty ugly even though I loved the collection). Shoes are awful.

    Sorry Leighton darling, Cs get degrees but Ds don’t. OUT.

  • Micaela Cannon

    Awful. A bunch of awful shades of beige thrown together without thought into a bizarre shape. ew.

  • Anonymous

    not even in the mood, OUT

  • Anonymous

    It’s half an idea but something rather awkward about it. Nude pointy toed (flats?) are dull. Face and hair look pretty.

  • Anonymous

    OUT,  because her upper body looks like a Barbie doll.  And because (a) it needs a belt and (b) I’m not entirely convinced the colors in that garment work together.

  • Anonymous

    On on the fence  with the dress. But her hair looks terrific. So in.

  • Nancer

    The colors in the dress just don’t work well together. I won’t say it’s a frankendress, but it’s close.

  • Anonymous

    Also, reminds me of this:

  • Democracy Diva

    Weird, but in the good way. Definitely surprising and lovely. In.

  • Erin

    OUT, but E for effort.  If the fit of the bodice was right, this would be really interesting: the lines of the fit, how super-smooth her torso looks (as you say about the boobies, TLo), and how the placement of the neutral body/bright accents highlights that.  The fit doesn’t quite work, though, and that screws it all up.  Also, I wish she hadn’t picked shoes the exact color of her skin.

  • Lynsey M.

    so out.

  • Anonymous

    The skirt and bodice bear no relation to each other whatsoever.  


  • MilaXX

    OUT. This may be a not your dress. I don’t like the way the top looks like body paint instead of fabric, the different color of the skirt feels odd. Perhaps a skinny belt would help. The bag is too casual and then we have silly putting pumps just adding to the overall weirdness of the look.

  • Jessica TallGirl Freeman

    OUT. The colors together are very bad, and obviously it needs something in the middle so it doesn’t look like they took some skirt and sewed it to a top from outer space.  She looks pretty from the neck up.  Though she is also looking a little like Rose Byrne in some….

  • Kari Den Otter

    In – but it’s kind of a strange Disney Princess meets reformed stripper kind of dress.  I like it, but she’s got a lot tape going on to her tatas in place.

    • Anonymous

      I had a similar thought–a tarted up Snow White.

  • Natalie

    In, it’s adorable. 

  • Sara Parker

    I don’t mind the boobalicious part (especially since they look great), but I do object to the nude/pale yellow color sheme, paired with those hiddy shoes. OUT.

  • Liana Brooks

    OUT – for both her and the designer.

    The side panels of the dress, her purse, and her lipstick are all the same color. Then she has nude on top with a buttercup yellow skirt? Was this a Project Runway reject? Did she lose a bet? Why is her hair channeling Heidi of the Swiss Alps? And nude point shoes???

    Try again!

  • Anonymous


  • Karen Stephens Bassett

    This is a hot mess.  Out!!

  • Anonymous

    OUT. It reads a little to bathing suit-y in the top. The pop of red isn’t enough to make it look interesting.

  • Rebecca Johnson

    No, no you do not like this. Ice dancer warm-up outfit.

  • Jessica O’Connell

    Looks like a slutty Snow White. SOOOOO OUT.

  • Aplomb Pomilio

    I do not like that dress. The colours are, at best, strange. It looks like a swimsuit with awkward skirt/cover-up. IF it were in attractive colours with a cute belt, then maybe it would work. But not as is. She’s gorgeous, but the dress is an OUT.

    • Anonymous

      I agree. Pretty girl, not so pretty dress.

  • Anonymous

    The skirt makes her look dumpy which she is not.  The top is a little weird as well maybe because of the skirt. Edited because I looked at the shoes-awful, they blend with her legs. OUT!

  • Cassie

    I think she looks really fresh and cute – IN.

  • Anonymous

    No, it is an Out, it looks as though it is two different dresses. And I don’t have an answer to why no nipples!! I am as flummoxed as you are!

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  The nude shade next to her exposed chest is like an extremely odd optical illusion.  You don’t like it.

  • Anonymous

    “Tell us minions, do we like this?” “No, no TLo, you do not.” Too lippy, too bangs-y, too chest-y, and too jaundice-y.

    Also, the beige cutout outlined in black on the bodice looks like one of those those t-shirts with the fake bikini body on the front.

  • Christy Cricow

    It’s an odd dress, yet, the woman wearing it looks really pretty so I guess I have to say IN.

  • aimee_parrott

    It’s all Sternum Barbie on top, and all Queen Elizabeth on the bottom.  OUT.

  • Aaminah Khan

    I love it. It’s really interesting without looking stupid. IN.

  • Katie Truax

    Like the top part, hate the bottom.  They don’t seem to work together.  Like the reds, hate the shoes.  Tie goes to the In.

  • Anonymous

    Hmmmm.  It’s a fairly good start, but that front is waaaaay to V’d.  So much for leaving anything to the imagination — and, yes, we know she’s pasted her boobs into this garment.  Better shoes and something around the waist would’ve been nice.  I like her hair and makeup, though.

  • Anonymous

    Ugh – too pale and wan, and not in a good way. OUT

  • Anonymous


  • Anonymous

    Out.  Boobage looks strangely unsymmetrical, and how can a size 0 person appear to have saddlebag hips?  Plus, top and bottom appear to belong to totally different dresses.  Plus, shoes are tragic.  Just my 2 cents, fashion basket case that I am.

  • Amanda Gun

    Out out out. It’s doing weird things to her boobs, especially from the side (the lighting is probably not helping there either), the colours don’t go with each other and hair and makeup look at least halfway terrible. And this might just be because I’m on my phone and the screen is tiny and low-res, but I feel like her shoes are closely matched enough to her skintone that they make it look like her feet actually are that pointed, which adds a layer of hilarity to the terribleness.

  • Anonymous

    No, you don’t like it. And neither do I. Out.

  • Anonymous

    The dress speaks for itself and it is screaming OUT.

  • Anonymous

    I saw a cut-down version of Cinderella ‘s dress (or maybe Sleeping Beauty – one of the Disney princesses, anyway) and by cut down, I mean whoa, Nelly, that is cut low.  OUT

    • Anonymous

       I was thinking Snow White-a very, slutty Snow White. 

      • Anonymous

        Of, of course, Snow White – I knew it was Disney.  And yes, very slutty.

  • Anonymous

    I like the top, but the bottom is so incongruous. and that horrid mellow yellow color D:

  • Laura O’Gorman

    IN! I think she looks adorable and eye-catching. She’s showing enough for some interest but not enough for THAT kind of interest.

  • Deitra S.

    OUT!  1) it looks like the top & bottom halves of the dress don’t match 2) naked shoes 3) that V is so broad and deep that it makes me think she has it on backwards.  No, no, no, no.

  • Robin Robinson

    OUT. It looks like a bad swimsuit with a pleated church-lady skirt pulled on over it.

  • Anonymous

    Joining the puritanical minions today, though this dress has problems that go beyond the boobiliciousness.   OUT!

  • butter nut

    oh fuck no OUT!  the top says, “naked leotard at the prom!”, while the bottoms says, “f’yeah! easter sunday!”  a crazy person made this.

  • Anonymous

    In. I agree that the shoes are disappointing but overall she looks great. She has a beautiful chest and probably one of few people in the world who could pull off this dress.

  • Dorothy & Michael n/a

    The soft pale yellow has absolutely no connection to the flesh/black/intense red design on the top. It looks like she’s wearing a cast off ice skating outfit, and pulled her great-aunt’s old skirt over the whole thing.  Makes me cross-eyed and a little sick at my stomach.

  • Judy S

    Somehow to my eye it’s a Snow White look. Snow White with snowballs. OUT. 

  • Anonymous

    Out. don’t like the dress and I don’t like it on her. I hate the yellow and beige fabrics together.  And the shoes make it look like her feet were horribly deformed in some kind of industrial accident.

  • Nellie Wilson

    You know those cards you got as kids, where you could mix one person’s head, with another one’s torso, and other’s feet? Well, that’s what this looks like. There are several things going on here, and none of them belong in the same room, let alone on the same person. OUT.

  • Melanie Cozad

    Love the bag and makeup. I’d like the top if it wasn’t so chestastic. Hate the skirt. Haaaaaaate.

  • Dr Skylaser

    No, we do not like this.  She looks great neck-up, but the dress gets none of that credit.

  • Anonymous

    I love the dress, I think it’s a fun little play on a Snow White type gown.  Don’t love the shoes, but overall, IN.

  • Anonymous

    OUT! Too matchy, what with the bag and the sidepanels and the top of the dress and the horrible shoes. It’s like two separate dresses. And if I hold my hand over the bottom separate dress, the hair looks like she’s competing for the gold in the floor exercise.

  • Anonymous

    Slutty Snow White.

  • Rand Ortega


  • Anonymous

    i can’t decide. Like the shape, but not the colors. Hate the shoes (how’d she get an exact match to her skin color? she looks like she has one long pointy toe?) but like the bag. It’s definitely attention getting and hair and makeup are good, so, IN.

  • Brad and Anne White


  • Mori Clark

    IN. this dress is confusing to the nth degree but her tits looks pretty fantastic, so. 

  • 1carmelita

    Oh my gosh. Hideous.

  • Anonymous


  • Anonymous

    Out! Her breasts look great, which unfortunately adds even more to the swimsuit with my elastic waist, pull-on skirt at the geriatric swimming pool look. And then there are the horrible shoes.   

  • Emily Smith

    out i just don’t like that at all.

  • Anonymous

    The proportions are off and the “colors” are practically non-existent. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    She had her nipples surgically removed in 2011?  I don’t know.  OUT.  It’s disturbing.

  • Brittany Johnstone

    IN. I finally don’t hate her bangs.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  I’m really not sure why, exactly, but my first, gut reaction was a vehement “OUT!  Good God in Heaven, O-U-T!”

  • evelina lundmark

    She looks like Snow White, and not in a good way. Also, waaaaay too matchy. Nude with nude, and red with red? And the hair? And that terrible shade of yellow? And the cleavage is just plain weird. OUT. So OUT…

  • Anonymous

    OUT! Just too weird.

  • Anonymous

    Out. The top doesn’t go with the lining with doesn’t go with the skirt. And the lips are just a bit too bright. It’s jarring.

  • Anonymous

    It’s definitely not a flawless look. But it’s interesting, and interesting in a way that suits her looks, so I’d go with IN.

  • Ann M. Erickson


    Why is the top the same color as her skin? Why is the skirt some other color that is almost the same but not? 


    Also, it is scroll-down fug.

  • Anonymous

    Did someone else wear this a while back, or do I have deja vu?

  • Anonymous

    OUT. If the skirt were in keeping with the top I think I could love it, but as it stands it looks like Peggy on Mad Men had a hot date emergency and took a scissors to the front of her dress. (Seriously, she had a yellow skirt that was almost exactly like this.)

    Also, I wish she would stop with the bangs. They don’t suit her.

  • Anonymous

    Is it just me or does the dress look like a slutty Snow White? And yeah, the boobs trick is pretty amazing. Not sure how she did that. But I vote OUT. It’s kind of silly, ultimately.

  • AbbottRabbit

    I like the top in a weird way, but not the skirt. I wish it continued the orange from the sides of the blouse, and was in a fabric that was less of a textural disjunction. 


  • Briarnoir

    Dear god. This is what happens when you combine a race car with a ballerina in a bad way!

  • Anonymous

    Out! Not for the expanse of beautiful skin, but because the dress is awkward. (See Kayceed’s descrip below.) I have big issues with the colors… that skirt color has nothing to do with the rest of it (the little shoulder bows do *not* succeed in tying it all together. Also, even imagining color schemes that actually work, the symmetry of this doesnt work on a human unless she was standing perfectly straight. See the fist pic, where her hips are slightly tilted; makes her look like she’s recovering from a back injury. end of rant. Out.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  No, you don’t like it.  But I’d be curious to see a photo of the model in the dress.  I’m not sure if it just looks ugly on LM, or if it’s just an ugly dress, period.  

  • Anonymous

    Out!  That is the ugliest Prada dress I have ever seen and Prada makes some pretty ugly dresses.

  • Allyson Wells

    IN -Very interesting dress! I think the colors look great on her, and I especially like the top. I would have preferred to see more different shoes though… even simple black ones would have looked better.

  • Anonymous

    uh… both? On the one hand, it sort of looks like she’s the only woman in the world who can wear it without falling out. On the other, I am blinded by sternum and it looks like it belongs on Ice Capades.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t like the colors together, don’t like the shape/pleating of the skirt, and don’t like where the waist is. OUT.

  • Anna Tree

    That neckline is crying out for jewellery. Great dress. Awful styling. OUT

  • Anonymous

    she looks so together and cute except for that… skirt.  which looks like it is visiting from another planet entirely.  so, out.

  • Anonymous

    While I would love to grade on a curve (because this really is better than many of her previous attempts – a brief look through Leighton Meester’s former fashion atrocities reveal some of the most heinous crimes imaginable, after all)… 

    I just can’t. The shoes, the matchy-match accessories and makeup… no. Out.

  • Miranda Neville


  • Anonymous

    OUT!! I don’t care for cleavage displays where you can have a cardiologist examine your sternum. The nude color isn’t flattering, the yellow color is even worse, the waist is funky and the pleats are not flattering. This is one of those “fashion” forwards that misses by a mile IMO -even if Diane Kruger were to wear it. 

  • Tadiana Walton Jones

    She looks like she’s on her way to perform in a dance recital.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    OUT! It’s ugly and it makes her look like she has a weird plastic Barbie chest.

  • Anonymous

    OUT, truly shudder worthy on all fronts…..

  • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

    OUT.  That is one of the weirder dresses ever reviewed on this blog.  The skirt doesn’t look like it goes with the top, the colors are bleah, I don’t like the shoes or the bag, and her hair looks shaggy, and not in a good way.  I do like her makeup, but that’s about it.

  • Merneith

    Out. The dress is weird and the shoes make it look like she has pointy flipper feet. Normally I don’t complain about clothes that have a nude illusion look but those shoes are over the top.

  • Paula Pertile

    No. Its as god awful as it gets.

  • Lexie

    IN: I really really like this on her, but I wish the plunging v-neck wasn’t so wide. Peeling all that lingerie tape off her tits is going to be a pain.

  • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

    I would love to see the Prada show this came from.  It is a truly bizzarre dress.

  • Anonymous

    Out: this looks like it’s 2 different dresses stuck together and it’s awkward and weird.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. The beige top that almost matches her skin tone make it look like her armpits are bleeding. The nude pointy shoes that DO match her skin tone make me think of that Roald Dahl book, The Witches, except they had square feet not triangles. Any color but that awful beige, and there may have been something here. But no, Witchy feet and bleeding armpits = OUT.

  • Cathy S

    I hate it. That may be the ugliest dress I’ve ever seen. 

  • MinAgain

    No, you really hate this.  The bottom doesn’t seem to go with the top.

  • Anonymous

    this is indeed a bit of a head-scratcher… but i think im coming down on the side of IN.
    yes the cleavage is a little much, and there is something ever so slightly off about the whole look.
    but its also unique and bold, and kinda fabulous.

  • Anonymous

    Just out!

  • Sara Leigh Merrey

    Absolutely hate the dress and shoes.

  • Nancy Marion

    Hate the shoes, but otherwise she looks fantastic!

  • Anonymous

    OUT..She looks like slutty Snow White! It’s not that I’m puritanical or anti-boobillusion, it’s just that this is an ugly and unflattering dress…cut and colors!  Her boobs look to be quite different in size, which I realize many women are, however it’s not something one wants to draw attention to.   Hate her hair, makeup, shoes and juvenile purse too.

  • Anonymous

    Out – the top and the skirt do not go together.

  • Lauren Dorsee Dillon

    OUT. She looks plastic.

  • Judy_J

    No, we do not like this.  OUT.

  • Samuel Joesph Donovan

    The top is actually pretty cool, but the skirt ruins it: out, I’m sorry to say.

  • Anonymous

    Okay, I am on the fence.  The shape works for her and hair and makeup look great but why is the skirt yellow?  Is there a reason that I just don’t understand?  I just scrolled back up and looked again, now I see the little yellow bows but that still doesn’t explain why.  I am all for things not being too matchy but that yellow with the cream and that orangey red just seems off to me. In I guess but not my favorite.

  • Nicky Pierce

    As a flat chested girl myself, I am happy to see an actress who doesn’t have huge breasts or feel the need for implants. It makes me feel represented.

  • erin l.

    i so want to LOVE this but i cant…. still in.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  The dress is DOA and the shoes and bag just pee on its corpse.

  • Anonymous

    OUT!  I hate it.  I thought for sure you’d post a close up of her feet – looks like she has a poor little pinky toe hanging out on the right foot.  Shoes are ugly AND painful.  Or too small.  It just looks ridiculous (the dress/chest).  How does she sit down?  

  • Shawn EH

    Her cleavage is cray cray. Out, even though her makeup and hair are super cute!

  • Anonymous

    Another case where an inch or three makes all the difference:  design of the bodice is just enough wrong that it looks accidental, as if the seam came apart on its own.  Eye-catching in the worst way.  
    This could’ve worked with a little stitching up (and of course a different skirt altogether – hah – what a haphazard garment this is!).
    Too much error to waste breath on the shoes. 

    That said (as they say ~ ), no denying Miss Leighton is a scrumptious creature. 

  • accidental housewife

    Oy. I had such hope when I saw the thumbnail. The top is highly revealing, but I’m OK with that. And she looks really pretty and sweet. But, good god, that skirt! Talk about scroll-down-ugly. It is horrible. Why am I surprised? It’s fucking Prada. Of course it’s horrible. OUT

  • Anonymous

    Home Ec failure.  OUT

  • Megan Sullivan

    The dress is weird and unflattering in my opinion, and the shoes are terrible. I also really don’t like her bangs (or this particular hairstyle), she always looks much better without them. As for makeup, don’t like the red lip, natural looks are better for her coloring. She is a beautiful girl, and she can look much better than this. Out.

  • Anonymous


    A bit exotic-gymnast-threw-on-a-skirt-for-dinner, but cuter on her than some of her past missteps.

  • Anonymous

    IN! She looks beautiful and better than she has in the past. 

  • Anonymous

    It’s like Snow White’s slip is showing – all of it.  OUT

  • Anonymous

    I actually made an involuntary sound of disgust when I saw the picture.  OUT

  • Anonymous

    interesting look, but she overall looks naked except for the yellow skirt. IN for impact; OUT for taste. 

  • Annie

    I think this is the best shes looked in a while!

  • Anonymous

    No!  No!  No!  OUT

  • Anonymous

    Overall, she looks naked except for the yellow skirt, though in the abstract, it’s still a beautiful outfit. IN for impact; OUT on taste. 

  • Anonymous

    Dear me, NO.

  • Martha Deutsch

    Out. She’s at a premiere for a movie called “The Woman Dress” – perhaps this dress is some kind of reference to the movie; if the movie is a biopic of Esther Williams, in which she combines the top of a 1940s swim costume and the bottom of a 1940s lampshade? And the hair of Princess Leia? 

  • AWStevens

    I thought it was Zooey Deschenel until I read the headline…  Looks like some stalker went up to her and ripped her shirt open and she just left it that way because she couldn’t be bothered.  One keeps waiting for a boob to pop out.  The bottom is way too lemon cream pie…  I don’t know where to start and end with this getup. 


  • Brooke Gasdaska

    It looks like some kind of less modest Snow White costume. Out

  • Anonymous

    the runway is cleared for landing! Sweet face, though. 

  • Anonymous

    Ew.  Out.

  • Aly Light


  • Linda Merrill

    She looks great but the dress is a va-va voom bodice and Easter Sunday skirt sewn together. The mullet of dresses – party on top, communion on the bottom.

    • Anonymous


  • Anonymous

    Out.  It’s tacky and the bottom belongs to a different dress.  The top looks like a swimming suit. Can’t fathom the totally missing nipples.  Surgery?

  • Anonymous

    Oh gawd, I didn’t even notice the shoes.  Couldn’t get past the awful skirt!

  • Anonymous

    I like the top half, but not the bottom… but I still think she looks good. IN. 

  • Elizabeth Rust

    OUT. That’s got to be the weirdest chestage that I’ve ever seen, at least that wasn’t on a Ken doll; doesn’t it look like she’s got a plastic (and oddly flat) upper chest area there? That kind of plunging neckline’s supposed to enhance the breasts, but it doesn’t seem to be working…

    Oh, yeah, the dress. Aside from the fact that I didn’t really notice it because I was making puzzled-dog looks about the non-cleavage, I don’t care for the style, colors, or fit. Looks like a fuggly thrift-store skirt thrown over an overstock-special swimsuit, or, well, something like that.


  • Anonymous

    I think her face looks AWESOME, but the dress is terrible. The boobs look good too, but yeah… can’t make up for that dress. 

  • Allison Woods

    We definitely do not like anything about this look.

  • jhkob

    We no likey.

  • blue

    NO, you don’t like this. It looks like two different dresses stitched together. Actually, it looks like grandma’s Easter skirt stitched to some olympian’s leotard. It’s not bad from the waist up though. Weird but not bad.

  • JillK

    We HATE this. It looks like Snow Freaking White. Hiddy.

  • Pamela

    You hate it with the white-hot heat of a thousand suns.  Two widely different dresses + one pair of scissors= This fugly mess.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  Too many shades of sherbert.

  • Anonymous

    I don’t think it’s Leighton’s fault.  This dress is HORRIFYING.  What is her fault is that she picked it in the first place.  Ugh ugh ugh. OUT.  

  • Anonymous

    Make up looks good!

  • Erin Leahy

    Sexy Snow White. Love it. IN.

  • Anonymous

    Absolutely LOVE her hair and makeup, and love the color palette, but that neckline is too much, the skirt is unflattering, and I loathe those shoes. Guess that makes it an OUT.

  • Sarah Marnell


  • Anonymous

    i think it’s lined but it could be breast petals. cut down & trimmed breast petals, come to think of it, cos of the neckline [or, rather, great lack thereof]. in other news, everything but the skirt works. she really looks like she has a crush on someone in fifth period so took a scissors to her gymnastics leotard’s collar & then just threw a skirt over it.

  • Jacquelina La Bomba

    Out. Emphatically. Also, this would have looked AMAZING on a tall, slender, very dark skinned woman with closely cropped hair and a bright lip. Ms. Meester, red lipstick aside, you are none of those things. Ergo, this is not your dress!

  • Mylynka Kilgore

    OUT – my first thought was “frankendress.” The top & skirt just look , to me, like they belong to two different outfits (even with the shoulder bow to “tie” the look together). The top also looks like a leotard… no bueno.

  • redsquidkid

    She looks great if I cover up the skirt. But since everyone else can see it — OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Out. It looks like two different dresses stuck together.

  • Anonymous

    She does have beautiful decolletage, doesn’t she?
    OUT, because that deep of a V just clashes with the primness of the skirt.  Plus, those shoes are wrong.

  • Vera E Sticker

    From the ankles up, it’s actually pretty fierce. Hate the shoes, but IN. 

  • Bobbi

    I think its hideous! OUT

  • Anonymous

    It’s weird and awful, but isn’t she just the prettiest thing you ever saw? Why can’t she master the simple task of putting on an attractive dress?

  • Anonymous

    It’s a gymnast’s leotard with a disgustingly unflattering skirt on top. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    I’ll give it in an IN. Ultimately, I’d have preferred red or black shoes with it though. 

  • WordyDoodles

    She’s got a terrific body and the makeup is pretty. But the dress. This dress is such a bad idea. I’m not quibbling with the fit, but I would have been more ok with it had the center panel not been so, well, nude-colored.  Reverse the colors of the side and center panels and it could have been stunning.

    And this might be the best example I’ve ever seen of TLo’s objection to nude shoes. They really do look like pointy hoofs here.

  • Anonymous

    out. it’s weird without being the least bit interesting. which is to say, it’s fugly. 

  • Sarah Veenstra

    we feel like we shouldn’t like this – so we LURVE it instead. Out-of-the-box IN.

  • DonKno

    Out. The top and the bottom do not work together.

  • Anonymous


  • Anonymous

    It’s making my brow furl and make a question mark form over my head…I’ve had too long of a week for this feeling so OUT just based on that feeling.

  • Emily

    Out.  Very ballet…

  • Anonymous

    Ick. OUT

  • emily mcginnis


  • Anonymous

    EWWW. Her upper body looks like a Ken doll’s private parts – all smoothed over and plastic. *shudder*

    • Anonymous

      This!  Just what’s wrong with it!

  • Helen C

    In.  Her makeup and hair are looking much better these days.  I like that she’s trying on new hair color and styles.  
    She looks sweet. 
    But it seems she’s taking a page from Boobs Legly’s book.  Honey, don’t do that. 

  • MandyJane

    Out. Her face and hair look great, but I hate that dress, and the shoes are hideous.  I’m think there’s some tape involved.

  • Anonymous

    NO, you do not like this at all. The booby thing going on is just weird.

  • Anonymous

    Her bangs drive me nuts. I just don’t think they’re right for her.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Figure-adhering beige reads body skimmer, or some other such foundation garment. And a buttermint yellow pleated skirt with bright red lipstick is a look I haven’t seen on anyone under the age of 75.

  • Anonymous

    No, no, no. We absolutely don’t like this.

  • TigerLaverada

    Nope, you pretty much hate it. It’s a crappy design in colors that are some how blah and repulsive at the same time. It looks shitty on her in general, and makes her chestage area in particular look very strange and a little creepy.

    Glad to help, boys. Lemme know if you need another opinion on something, I got tons of ’em.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Not one of Prada’s finer moments.

  • Thom

    I really dig this look for her, even if the neckline’s about 3 inches too plunging, and her shoes are non-existent. Mary Elizabeth Winstead better watch her back.


  • Anonymous

    AWFUL.  just AWFUL.

  • Anonymous

    Ugh.  NO.

  • MDH3

    Adorable from the neck up.  The rest of the outfit is an abomination. 

  • elzatelzabelz

    OUT- the dress is confusing. Is it Vegas or Utah schoolmarm?

  • Tiger Gray

    That is TERRIBLE. OUT. 

  • margaret meyers

    It’s everything I hate about Prada (they seem to think ‘unexpected’ is always a good thing), but this time it works.  The stretchy top with the pleated skirt (awkward), the beige and yellow (terrible idea), the little bows on the shoulders and the really plunging neckline?  It comes off as very innocent. 
    Maybe it’s Miss Meester with her darling hair arrangement and her sweet epression.

  • Hilary Sain

    Her shoes are a travesty, but hair and makeup look unreal and that dress is BANGING. Kinda love the way she’s holding that purse too.  

  • mediapileup

    She looks like Snow White got her dress ripped up in a barfight.

  • Anonymous

    In. Weird, but so pretty. Love the flats with it.

  • Anonymous

    I hate the color of the skirt, but it’s interesting and she looks comfortable in it.  IN.  

  • Jonika Tannous

    Out. The dress looks almost unfinished. But the boobs are pretty fantastic.

  • Anonymous

    Ick. OUT. Looks like the porn version of Snow White. I hate it with the white hot heat of a thousand suns. Her hair is shiny though.

  • Anonymous

    She has the face of a 70s porn star. Or a slutty Maria von Trapp.

  • Anonymous

    In the first shot I thought she had very well matched illusion fabric, but she must be glued in.  The top and bottom don’t go together Prada’s fault, not her’s.) If Prada was tossing clothes at me I would have put on a belt and a bright shoe – or a different skirt.

     Her make-up is lovely and I don’t mind the boobage.  Do it while you can ladies!!  In.

  • Anonymous

    OUT!  Weird bodice, and the skirt is completely unflattering, making her look very thick-hipped.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  Ewwww….

  • Karen

    Looks like she threw a skirt on over a swimsuit. So so OUT!

  • Anonymous

    The stock price of the company that makes double-sided tape just soared.  There is not one thing about her look that I can even grudgingly commend; it’s all awful.  O-U-T spells OUT.  Yuck.

  • Marcia Skarda Miller

    Yuck.  OUT

  • Anonymous

    Out – the skirt color and primary color of the top seems off, as do the bows and the mod stripes.  If you’re going to expose that much chest, some bronzer might be in order.

  • Anonymous

    Hideous.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    She does look like she was dressed by slutty little birds, doesn’t she? I think I love it.

  • M N

    Ew, gods.  It’s weird, mismatched, ill-fitting, makes her look thick-waisted, and the shoes are particularly awful.  I sure hope you don’t like it.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  That’s some creepy looking shit…sort of reminds me of Marilyn Manson’s old boob/breastplate.  It looked better on him.

  • Anonymous

    In. It’s super cute and she looks great, although I wish she had gone with a more modest-cut version of the neckline.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.. every time I look at the pictures I wonder what the hell is wrong with her chest. The weird cleavage almost makes her look androgynous, which i don’t think she was going for.

  • Anonymous

    Where’s the rest of the dress?

  • Richi Robilotto

    OUT. She looks like she has really pointy feet, and it is really freaking it out. Why are her shoes the same exact color as her skin? Why? WHY?

  • Dawn

    Eww. That’s all I’ve got.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Frankendress with too much tit.

  • Nora Mulllin

    OUT. It’s ugly and badly styled.

  • Dorrene BrownButterfield

    Out, out, out! This looks like a Lady Gaga reject.

  • Karen

    out, too booby and it looks like a bathing suit under a skirt rather than a dress.

  • Anonymous

    Why is she wearing a swimsuit with a granny skirt? Out.

    And, honey, if you keep taping your breasts that way, they’ll stay that way and start migrating toward your armpits.

  • a Studio by the Sea

    Porno Snow White costume.  So very, very out.

  • Anonymous

    OUT> I can’t even believe this up for consideration. And those shoes are monstrously ugly.

  • Alisa Rivera

    Wow, I don’t usually buck the tide like this, but this is an IN for me. Lovely makeup, her rack looks awesome and the dress really flatters her figure.

  • Alisa Rivera

    Wow, I don’t usually buck the tide like this, but this is an IN for me. Lovely makeup, her rack looks awesome and the dress really flatters her figure.

  • Elizabeth Denton

    SO cute except the terrible shoes. 

  • Elizabeth Denton

    SO cute except the terrible shoes. 

  • Delysia LaFosse

    That neckline is awfully wide. Actually, the whole thing looks like she pulled on a chiffon skirt over her leotard after recital. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Beautiful from the clavicle up. Ack from there down.

  • Anonymous

    It a weird dress, and on many would probably be terrible, but she looks good…IN

  • Depot'er

    OUT. just creepy weird. I thought she was going a super-hero thing, looks like a chest shield, is that real skin or plastic?

  • Anonymous

    OUT,OUT, and OUT

  • Anonymous

    Love the Top! The bottom looks like it fell off of a housekeeper in Miami.
    From the waist up she’s in.

  • Anonymous

    Out…… wow, i didn’t know they had invented real-time photoshop!

  • Anonymous

    All my complaints center on the skin tone front.  I don’t mind such a wide, open, neck.  But that color washes out all the contrasts.  She’s one color from waist to hair.  And the skirt is almost the same color.  One needs to be tan or darker to pull this dress off well. I do like the shoes the exact color of her legs though.  You don’t even see her feet. 

    I give this look the worst of grades:  Ignorable.  Not In, and not Out.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  Looks like she threw a skirt on over her bathing suit.  Makes her look chubby, which she surely isn’t.  And all that sterum!

  • Anonymous

    Yikes! OUT!!!

  • Anonymous

    I’m impressed, but it’s still ugly. Sorry Leighton, dear. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Out. When I scrolled down I had an immediate feeling of revulsion. Tim G. would be able to say something more profound, but I can’t channel his intelligence right now because my gag reflex is kicking in.

  • R. L.

    NO!!!!  She looks like she threw a non-related beach cover-up skirt on over her bathing suit.  Yuck. The colors are not good together.

  • Anonymous


  • Anonymous

    It’s the newest incarnation of the Frankendress, except that this variation is top to bottom instead of front to back or side to side.  And I hate her shoes.  It looks like she has mutated pointy feet.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    No. Please no.

  • Deen

    Looks like she’s got plasti-bewb inserts… Or that she threw a skirt over a swimsuit. Icky shoes.

    Not a fan. Out.

  • Anonymous

    It kind of looks like she’s wearing a breastplate. Yuck. OUT

  • Cassie (C.M.W.)

    Is that supposed to be a dress? And aren’t her breasts supposed to sit level? OUT.

  • Laura F.

    It seems like the skirt and bodice belong to two different dresses, and I dislike the shoes and bag with it.  Having said that, though, when I first clicked on this, I thought, “Doesn’t she look pretty!”  Which is a change with this one, so IN for me.

  • Anonymous

    out! this is awful!!

  • Jennifer Von B

    Horrible. out.

  • Chrissie

    In. I think it’s striking.
    I definitely like this fashion direction better for her than the more quirky stuff she has worn.

  • amanda lynn

    IN.  she’s been looking better!

  • Sabina Kallstrom

    love it, IN!!!!!!!!

  • Rain Jezek

    OUT. It’s awful. With a much higher or much lower waistline to the skirt it might work, but as it is the proportions are bad and the elements are unbalanced. As for the mystery nipples, I think the sacrifice of young peasant virgins is the likely answer.

  • Anonymous

     IN! Except for the shoes. But yeah, IN!

  • Sorana Tarmu

    Freaky outfit. Brrr… Those boobs look robot-like. Out.

  • Lisa

    Yeah, that awkward, weird and booby thing – OUT.  What weird pieced together colors – they don’t look like they’re even on the same dress.

  • Sue Tyler

    out, it has a werid snow white disney princess feel, well one whose had her shirt ripped off

  • Anonymous

    Out – Snow White’s sluttier sister

  • Anonymous

    I think she looks beautiful, except for the dress. It looks like a swimsuit top with a mismatched cover-up on the bottom. Out.

  • Anonymous

    That’s the most disgusting ‘garment’ i’ve ever seen, out

  • Eunice Tan

    OUT. Her top looks like a old-fashioned swimsuit ripped down the middle for exposure and really, I don’t even want to describe the catastrophe of beige, red and pastel yellow together.

  • Anonymous

    I love it from the waist up.  I admit I’m a sucker for Prada/MM’s current hot rod aesthetic.  Not liking the skirt or the shoes or the purse, but I’ll give her an IN because she’s wearing that challenging dress so well.  

  • Anonymous

    Out for me, but I appreciate she looks like she’s having fun wearing it.

  • Pennymac

    Any dress that requires subjugation of nipples by unknown means is an automatic out from me. Plus, beige = red= yellow = yuck.

  • Anonymous

    threw a skirt over a swimsuit.  A bad dangerous swimsuite. (You wouldn’t dare actually swim in something like this, you’d spend all your time sinking as you tucked yourself back in.)

  • Anonymous

    Ugly as sin dress. OUT.

  • Patricia Gillett

    Yuk. nothing works on this dress. It’s a bunch of bad ideas sewn together. In her defense, however, I maintain that NO ONE would look good in this. So at least there’s that.

  • Marlon Satchell

    That shade of yellow doesn’t seem quite right, but there’s something that I seriously love abut this look. IN!

    (And she’s very cleverly making use of fashion tape or pasties to keep her, um, boobs under control.

  • Anonymous

    Those shoes are BORING but continue the point-y nude aesthetic, so I understand the pairing. Her boobs look AMAZING, and thankful not pushed upon us in a ‘baby head’ way. I think a long, thin gold chain would have been the perfect final touch. IN nonetheless.

  • Keith Williams

    OUT! OUT! OUT!  It looks like some modern spin on Snow White.  That yellow is all the wrong color on her and the proportions are off by a few inches.

  • Samantha Irene

    In. I don’t think it should work, and I would have loved an earring or short necklace – but she still looks good – and interesting. 

  • Susan Crawford

    I know there are legions of young women who live and die for Miu Miu, but the whole aesthetic of this line just escapes me. Maybe that means that I’m an OFF (Old Fashion Fart), and I can accept that – I guess. Maybe it means I’m a WUHOF (Way Un-Hip Old Fart) and – I guess – I can live with that, too. But honestly, I really can’t get with this whole Miu Miu thing, and this dress, even on the lovely Ms. Meester, just looks criminally blech. OUT, with love from theWUHOF.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. It makes her look broad in the beam. And she’s not.

  • Anonymous

    She kinda looks like “The Wonder Years”´s Winnie Cooper gone wild. 

  • Jane Morris

    She looks really, really lovely. But that is an ugly dress. OUT>

  • Thomas Weiss

    I don’t know why I let it bother me so much, but it bothers me when celebrities where the following season’s clothes. 

    It’s February. While this may be a warmer February, it is by no means Spring 2012. 

    Stylists. So eager to be the first. 

  • Alana

    I want to hate it, but I can’t. Something about the boob area has me mesmerized. IN.

    • Rebecca

       Same here!

      I mean…how???

  • Nancy

    I absolutely detest the EXTREMELY low/wide-cut neckline. Ugh. Not pretty, not sexy… just ugly.

  • Anonymous

    Ugh. out out damned spots!

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  The dress is just not attractive to begin with and doesn’t look right on her. 

  • Anonymous


  • Anonymous

    Out. It looks like a Project Runway challenge involving a scuba suit and curtains. Definitely auf’d.

  • Charlotte Horseman

    Just a really ugly dress… she looks cute.  OUT.

  • rebecca

    In. I’m not crazy about the Eliza Doolittle hair, though.

  • Noelle Haland

    UGH, this getup is hiddy!  The proportions are terrible, the colors are nauseating, and it looks like her feet have morphed into some scary gnome feet or something.It looks like she grabbed her maw-maw’s Sunday best skirt and threw it over her weirdly tittified gymnastics leotard, then stuck some bows on it. YUCK.  So very OUT.

  • kvlm

    I heart Prada and all that but no.  OUT.  Color scheme, booby thing, matchy matchy red bag thing, tween hair, OUT.

  • Kirsten Kirsten

    Snow White’s clueless younger sister. Out.

  • ammjam

    No. Out. Poor shoes. Ankle strap silly putty too-pointy pumps?  No, sirs.  The skirt pleats remind me too much of 8X11 paper accordion-folded fans that we made in my non-airconditioned grade school classrooms, and that is not nostalgia you’re hearing.  And the yellow . . . it’s too  . . . I don’t know. Faded, dried out highlighter?  And now all I can think of is that dried out highlighter being used to color the whole fan, and that awful draggy sound it would make across the paper. What’s my deal with school supplies?

  • TieDye64

    hiddy and tacky.

  • Isana Leshchinskaya

    IN. <3 HER