In or Out: Naya Rivera in Rachel Roy

Posted on January 23, 2012

“What about this one?” asked Lorenzo, as he spun the laptop around to face Tom. On the screen, Naya smiled back at us. “Sure, let’s do that one. She looks awful.” “WHAT?” shouted Lo. “She does NOT. You’re just in a bad mood.”

Annnd scene.


Naya Rivera celebrates her 25th birthday at 1Oak Nightclub in Las Vegas in Rachel Roy.

And Lorenzo was right. Perhaps Tom was in a bad mood, because what looked like a spa wrap to him last night looks kinda disco-fabulous in the light of morning.


It’s awfully… we don’t know… askew? Bunched up? Maybe just a little bit of a mess? Because we don’t like the way the hem rises right where ladybusiness lies. And all that tucking and twisting in the bodice looks awkward. We think we like the idea of this dress more than we like the actual dress. The color’s great on her (although we can’t believe she matched her lipstick to it exactly) and the shoes are not only KILLA; they prevent this from looking a little too literally 1980 disco-fabulous. Hair and makeup are pretty too. We guess what we’re saying is, the dress itself has some issues, but the overall look is sexy and head-turning; more than the sum of its parts.


Vote Now!


IN! She can ring my bell. Ring my bell. My bell, ring-a-ling-a-ling.

OUT! Tragedy! When the feeling’s gone and you can’t go on.


Cameron Diaz’s too-tight dress and shock of bleached hair received a big ol’ OUT, to no one’s surprise.

[Photo Credit: Justin Paludipan/PR Photos]

Please review our Community Guidelines before posting a comment. Thank you!

  • Anonymous

    Sorry, I still think drag queen’s spa robe.

    • Sobaika Mirza

      It is! But that’s why I love it.

    •árez/100002964685796 Josefina Madariaga Suárez

      I was thinking Burlesque backstage robe, but yours is more accurate.

      Sorry, she’s OUT. It kinda looks sort-of-glamorous, but she looks old.

      • Anonymous

        I thought “about to unrobe for my playboy shoot” so burlesque backstage is pretty on target.

        She looks her usual amazing from the neck up, though.

    • Anonymous

      No drag queen would be seen in a robe so unflattering.

    • Anonymous

      I was thinking a drag queen’s spa robe… from when he/she was 10 years old.  WAAAAY TOOOOO SMALLL!!!

    • Democracy Diva

      OUT, but I can’t phrase it better then SherrieTee did, so I won’t even try.

    • Anonymous

      Exactly.  “Bathrobe” was my first thought.  OUT.

  • Liana Brooks

    Very Monet. I love the color, and it works at a distance, but the fine details aren’t so fine. OUT

  • Sobaika Mirza

    IN. I would love this more if it weren’t for the matching lipstick, but still: In.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  She looks plastic and un-real and that dress doesn’t fit well or drape properly.  She also has kind of a weird titsrecpancy.  Righty is looking sad and depressed and lefty is defying gravity in quite a splendid manner, even for a young hottie like her.  It’s overall wonky looking.

    • anon

      I think that’s because of the on again/off again boob job she had. 

  • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

    OUT.  It is a very nice hair coloring smock, but that’s as far as I’ll go.

  • Heather Johnson

    Out – looks like a bathrobe – with matching lipstick 

  • Gus Casals

    She’s 25 and in Vegas, she can pull it off (specially with those shoes!). She’s an IN.
    I agree that there are issues at the waist, but this is short by design, it’s a coochie dress that has no shame. 

  • foodycatAlicia

    I agree with T’s initial assessment. She looks a mess. A beautiful-haired, gorgeous-bodied mess. Miss Piggy’s bathrobe and matchy lipstick looks both cheap and aging.

    • Nellie Wilson

      Miss Piggy’s bathrobe – exactly! OUT.

      • amyw

        Agree with the Miss Piggy. Too much bathrobe for me. Out

  • 막내온탑 ヾ(^∇^)ノ

    disco bathrobe.

  • Chloe Stabler

    OUT.  She looks like a mess.  It’s a decent idea, but not executed.

  • Ramon

    Out. It’s a robe. Pretty, but a robe.

  • Anonymous

    It’s Vegas and her birthday, and she’s wearing a fun color.  I’ll be charitable and give her an IN.

  • Anonymous

    I want to like it but that lipstick is KILLING ME. She shouldn’t have asked Paz de la Huerta for make-up tips. A sad OUT from me.

  • Anonymous

    My first thought was that Naya left home with her chenille bathrobe on – a very fierce chenille bathrobe, mind you, but still, that  look is an OUT for me.

  • Anonymous

    T and Lo, is that you? I think someone has hijacked the blog…

  • Claire Haley

    Out! The pink lipstick is awful. And the dress looks like it was previously owned by somebody with gargantuan boobs.

    • anon

      Yes, her. She had them taken out recently.

  • Barbora

    Shes IN 

  • Anonymous

    She looks gorgeous but you are right, the dress is a bit too complicated for it’s own good.  Fault the dressmaker/designer,not the beauty inside.  FAB shoes…..

  • marianna

    She is super pretty, but it’s essentially a really sparkly, ill-fitting bathrobe. Out.

  • Anonymous

    OUT for me. It’s a sparkly bathrobe not tied correctly.

  • R. L.


  • Anonymous

    The dress is so unflattering from all angles – shows off her legs, but adds bulk to all else.  And I hate the lip color on her.

    I feel like the whole look is for a woman 10 to 20 years older than her for some reason.

  • Lize Kay

    No ways! That lipstick looks great on her, but the dress looks like a sparkly bathrobe. NOTHING fits- the sleeves are too long, they bunch around her wrists and sag and twist everywhere else. The hemline is doing something weird and it looks like it was made for someone with EE cup boobs. Nope. She’s gorgeous, but this dress is not good. 

  • Anonymous

    Out. Oh Tom, you should have trusted your gut on this one. The dress looks not only like a sparkly spa wrap, but a sparkly spa wrap that has been tapped to her boobs.  I’m not fond of the shoes, but I can see why you’d like them.

    I will say, though, everything else about her is very pretty here: hair, face, makeup, fabulous legs. So, I can see why you’d be swayed into thinking this is an In.

  • Trotter Roller

    IN!  Disco fabulous, bitches!

  • BerlinerNYC

    IN. I love the disco shorty-robe, and the matchy lipstick makes me like it even a bit more. So ridiculous and fun! She does need to “adjust herself” some, clearly. The dress isn’t sitting/hanging quite right, but that should take all of 2 seconds to fix. Go girl!

  • Anonymous

    Out.  It looks like a poorly made reject from the Miss Piggy challenge.

    • Stefanos Mantyla

      Provided that were not an All-Stars challenge.

  • Brian @ PWYJudges

    She looks like she wore that robe for hair and makeup then didn’t have time to get in her actual dress before it was time to leave. OUT!

  • Anonymous

    Out. It looks like a robe that a pornstar would probably wear before a scene.

  • Lynsey M.

    Out.  Definitely a bath robe.

  • Anonymous

    OUT!!! That frock is hideous!

  • Anonymous

    It looks better from the side, then you can’t see all the extra fabric up top…

  • Anonymous

    Jackie Collins’ latest best-seller, “Where Ladybusiness Lies”, explodes this fall on Lifetime Movies, starring Heather Locklear and Jennifer Love Hewitt!

  • bookish

    OUT. She looks way too much like she’s wearing a bath robe, which was my first thought on seeing this.

  • Ingrid

    I am not sure that color matches her skin tone that well. 

  • Anonymous

    it’s a perfect Vegas ensemble, for a mani/pedi….OUT (unless you’re in the spa)

  • Anonymous

    The bunchy draping/gathering and the matchy-matchy lipstick are making this an OUT for me.

  • Annegret

    Bordering on Snooki.

  • Vera E Sticker

    I hate it, and I’m surprised you like the color on her, because I think it makes her look wan and ashy. OUT. 

  • Anonymous

    No, she looks awful. But I’m in a bad mood too.

  • Judy S

    I will give her an IN, but only because I never heard of her so I see her as a pretty girl celebrating her 21st.  For once I am glad to see the high heels because it means she is not just chugging shots to celebrate being legal.  As celeb garb I think that dress is ugly.

    • Erin Semagin Damio

      It’s her 25th. :)

  • Aly Light

    It’s a bathrobe. In a color that doesn’t suit her. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Nope, your initial instincts were right.  It’s a sparkly pink spa robe.  Oh, and that matching lipstick is bad.  Out

  • Mariel S

    The shoes are glorious and while I’m not a huge fan of the dress I can see it working for a fun night on the town in Vegas but together with that make up and giant ring I am seeing pure play boy bunny. Out.

    But Happy Birthday girl!

  • Anonymous

    It’s a pretty color and the shoes are fun.. however  when you have floppy boob fabric, a coochie curtain and TONS of extra fabric at the arms it’s an out.

  • Anonymous

    Oh, honey no.

  • Anonymous

    I used to have a very similar terry bathrobe from Victoria’s Secret that was more flattering than this thing.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  The way it’s tucked around the middle makes her breasts look lopsided and saggy, and the baggy sleeves are giving her a broad-shouldered look.  The color isn’t bad, her hair and makeup look lovely, but… eh, all I could think was “bathrobe”, sorry.  Maybe with a better fit this wouldn’t look so tragic.

  • Amanda Royston

    I HATE the color! OUT.

  • Anonymous

    i want it to be in, but i can’t. OUT.

  • Sara L.

    Terrible. OUT.

  • Emily

    Ugh. That is an ugly, ill-fitting bathrobe.

  • Anonymous

    That lipstick!  Since when do we exactly match our lipstick to our dress? ARG!  OUT OUT OUT.

  • Heron

    Oh man, that bunching is bad.  

  • Anonymous

    Definitely an OUT.  weird draping, bad fit, looks like it’s about to fall apart (which may well be the point.)  Shoes are OK, but otherwise OUT OUT OUT.

  • Lauren Dorsee Dillon

    OUT. Askew spa robe plus matching lipstick (though I covet those amazing shoes).

  • Anonymous

    Tom was right the first time.


  • Loretta Gary

    Stick with your instincts, Tom! 

    She is indeed wearing the sparkly dress version of a forever lazy – which, now that I say that out loud, really is a brilliant idea, and who could blame the girl for wanting to be shiny and comfy on her birthday of all days… but alas, we have expectations. And this potentially cute and smart but oh so off and wrong dress simply aint cutting it. She is beautiful though and that matching lipstick is nothing if not an impressive show of effort. 

  • Sarah Bailey

    In, with some reservations. It is oddly bunched, but she has the attitude to pull it off.

  • Stefanos Mantyla

    So very OUT.

    Even for celebrating her own birthday there are better choices than this. Matching her lipstick to her dress makes even me slap my forehead. And I just do not know about the shoes. I just never got them, really.

    Need I say more?

  • Anonymous

    Sorry, OUT. Too bunchy and heavy and robe-like.

  • Mary McClelland

    Nah – she looks awful. Go with your gut, Tom! OUT

  • Jessica

    The color is fabulous on her!  Not an easy color to wear but it’s head-turning in the most fantastic way.  Agree about the shape and fit of the dress (like a 1982 dress made short?), but the it’s the color for the win!

  • Anonymous

    spa robe. out

  • Anonymous
  • Anonymous

    Vegas showgirl getting ready. 

  • Manon Eileen

    I wouldn’t ever wear this to my own birthday party, or anyone else’s, even if I got it for free. She looks ridiculous! Out.

  • Anonymous

    IN.  Because I need a shot of disco-fabulous right now.

  • kittenmasks

    Why did she match her lipstick to her gown? STOP TRYING TO MAKE THE 90S COME BACK! WE LEFT IT BEHIND FOR A REASON!

  • Terence Ng

    Naya Rivera in the post-show scene of the 2012 remake of Showgirl?

  • Anonymous

    I thought “Naya seems to be hiding her testicles today”.  I HATE the lipstick, and the dress, I’m pretty sure it belongs on a man.  Or, it makes her shape manly.  However, those SHOES!!!  I have to have them.

    Er….Out, though.  This gorgeous creature should never be a contestant on “guess the gender, win a prize”.

  • Anonymous

    In. Despite Joanna Coles insistence to the contrary, some starlets want to be comfortable when wearing clothes (especially on their birthdays).

  • Anonymous

    IN.  It’s a bathrobe, but I’m impressed that she looks so beautiful in a bathrobe.  And she’s in Las Vegas, where I think she gets cut some slack.  

  • Heather Waddell

    In. She just needs to give it a good tug and get it all back where it’s supposed to be. (I’m pretending that she’s been dancing and the dress has moved askew, don’t burst my bubble.)

  • Kiltdntiltd

    Out.  definitely.  The color is gorgeous, but the fit of that schmatta is appallingly bad.

  • Elena

    Definitely looks like a spa robe. Out.

  • Adina Miller Holmes

    Out.  I can’t help but think it looks like a spa robe.  Bleh.

  • Anonymous

    A glittery bunched spa robe is never in.  Not even in Las Vegas.  Out.

  • Susan Hutton DeAngelus

    Love the color. Hate the fit and lack thereof…

  • Anonymous

    Wow, she is really pretty, and that is a good color on her, and that is not a great dress.  Out.

  • Liane

    Out – the lipstick is actually distracting

  • Anonymous

    Mmmm -OUT. Too bunch bunch and I’m not loving the matchy lipstick -although overall she does look lovely and fresh in the face and hair department. 

  • Anonymous

    The dress is sloppy and it’s a color that no one should wear. She looks great anyway. I think she is really beautiful.

  • Anonymous

    OUT her lipstick matches her bathrobe!

  • Anonymous

    Great color on her, but it looks like there are extra breasts hiding just above her waste.

  • Anonymous

    I meant her waist.

  • Anonymous

    Hate the lipstick, hate the construction of the dress, but she looks beautiful, comfortable, and confident! IN!!

  • Anonymous

    She matched her lipstick to this sparkly lavender mess. NO. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    I’m giving it an IN for overall look, but I agree that what’s happening is the waist area is a shame.

  • Anonymous

    Out. My 8 year old niece had a “spa day” themed birthday party recently and I’m pretty sure all the girls wore the same exact thing. 

  • Anonymous

    OUT, but damn she’s got an amazing body.

  • Anonymous

    Is it made out of sparkle stretch velvet? Sparkle stretch velvet disco robe. In lilac.  Hmm. let’s see…

    • Anonymous


  • Jaime

    Spa robe.

  • Claire Hoogenboom

    If it fit better, I’d call it in but as it is it looks like a sloppily-tied bathrobe so dahling is O-U-T!

  • Anonymous

    OUT. The top is doing her no-doubt fabulous breasts no favors whatsoever and the rest seems to have obliterated her shape. Glittery bathrobes are still just bathrobes and should only be worn in the house.

  • Donna Lee


    If she just got done with her seaweed wrap and is off to her mani/pedi.  OUT if she’s going anywhere else.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  She’s adorable and way too young for this look.  Somewhere out there, a cougar is missing her favorite hunting outfit. 

  • Anonymous

    Dress is AWFUL. Out Out Out. (Love everything else though)

  • Anonymous

    Oh, honey.  No.


  • MandyJane

    The color looks wonderful on her, but it does look like a bathrobe… I am torn!

  • Alli

    Out. Even if it is the fanciest bathrobe on the West Coast.

  • Anonymous

    Looks cheap…and the lipstick is ridiculous….Out.

  • Donna

    She needs matching slippers and a towel around her head. OUT.

  • Anonymous


  • Anonymous

    Cute, but the fit on that dress is odd.

  • Bitsy Carver


  • Leslie Streeter

    Spa robe indeed. When the feelings gone and you can’t go on, and all you’ve got to show for it is a crazy gold medallion. And a Robin Gibb ’70s fro.

  • Kathrine Marlow

    Spa wrap…If it were in a different material, I’d be thrilled with it.  She looks like she forgot she had a party to go to and ran out of the closes spa and is trying to play it off as if this is her dress for the night.

  • Jonika Tannous

    out: can’t be in if I’m pretty sure it was her bathrobe…when she was five (I had one too).

  • Anonymous

    Her hair does looks pretty and once she gets out of her bathrobe, I am sure that the dress will be killer.

  • CQAussie

    IN!  I love that colour on her even if the dress itself is arranged rather messily.  I feel like tugging it out so it’s not to all over the place.  But I like the dress itself though!  Her shoes are fantastic, hair and make-up all working well.  Hilarious lippy – can’t believe she matched exactly either!

  • Jamie

    OUT – she needs to slip  out of that robe and into her dress before she heads out on the town

  • Anonymous

    Sparkly lavender terrycloth bathrobe?  Sorry — out.  Nice shoes.

  • Noelle Haland

    Now that someone mentioned the titscrepancy, I can’t UN-see it, and I wish the ladybusiness-area bunching was fixed (both would only take a second, Naya!), but — and I can’t even believe I’m saying this — I actually say IN.  It’s just disco-fabulous enough to be pretty fun, and from the side, she looks smashing. And I even like the matchy lipstick! ;-P

  • Anonymous

    Isn’t this a throwback to our childhoods where we danced around in our mom’s satin quilted bathrobe and we were pretty conviced that Cinderalla couldn’t look better?

  • Anonymous

    Too big on top, and looks like the bottom half was shortened improperly. Nice color though.

  • Anonymous

    Ill-fitting sparkly bathrobe + matchy lipstick = OUT.

  • Delysia LaFosse

    OUT. I like the color a lot, but I’m not convinced that I like it on her, and the matching lipstick is making me grind my teeth. The dress is too short and not flattering to her boobs. I don’t know what is going on with the weird pseudo-dolman sleeves; they’re like deflated leg-o-mutton sleeves. I don’t love the shoes, either.

    Yikes. Maybe I’m in a bad mood, too.

  • Britney

    ….it looks like a bathrobe that one wears in a prono. 

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Tom was right last night.

  • Anonymous

    it’s ridiculous and unflattering

  • Anonymous

    The lipstick KILLS it for me.  Pretty color, but kinda sparkled frump. barf. 

  • Anonymous

    Oh, and the matching lipstick colour; come on…

  • Zi Jie Tan

    Eww no. She looks like a 70-year-old on Disco Night at the retirement home

  • Anonymous

    Out. Love the shape of it, but – this sounds odd for such a tiny dress – but it looks like there is too much fabric in the construction.

  • Anonymous

    OUT…surprised there is even discussion on the matter. 

  • Anonymous

    I agree with all your critiques, but my math adds up differently.  Out.

  • Sara Leigh Merrey

    The dress is a mess.

  • Joy Yeager

    Out, Tom’s first instincts were right.  It’s disco bathrobe with matchy lipstick!

  • Taija HU!

    She looks like a porn-star Golden Girl. Out. Couldn’t be more out. 

    • Anonymous

      Perfect description! Out!

    • Anonymous

      “Porn-star Golden Girl.”  Hilarious.

  • Mary Gallagher

    I am in love with her though, so I may be biased. That lipstick is a shame.

  • Sara Munoz

    She looks great. But the dress looks like a work in progress.
    I think she knew it was a hot mess, and matched the lipstick to camp it up. So nice try, but still OUT.

  • Anonymous

    I love Naya and I love all the things you love about her look here but the unflattering boob area is enough to give this an OUT. So close, though.

  • Dave

    OUT- too bunchy.  It looks like someone selected the dress in Photoshop and did one of those weird art effects like “Swirl”

  • Ass Kicking Adviser

    I can’t say she’d OUT since this seems to be the type of thing one would wear to their birthday party in Vegas. That said, she looks tacky. Oh forget it, she’s OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Doesn’t fit right. So awkward. But Naya, honey, call me. I’ll make you feel better.

  • Anonymous

    Oh, LOOK!  She wore her favorite bathrobe to the red carpet! 


  • Anonymous

    out. it looks like it doesn’t fit. I love the fabric and the color but otherwise ew.

  • Micaela Cannon

    Glittered terry-cloth does not a club appropriate ensemble make. OUT. …even though I know it’s not actually terry cloth

  • Anonymous

    uh …. NO. Liked the shoes and the color of the dress, but she looks like she is wearing a robe. 

  • Athena Bast

    There’s something about the fabric that looks like glitter terry cloth. It’s freaky how the lipstick matches. It’s more of a meh with me. If the fabric didn’t look so odd I would love it, minus the matchy-match lipstick.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  do not like

  • rynerman

    Out, it’s like a beach coverup in Boca.

  • Felicitas Strautman

    out! those shoes look like they’re from bebe. 

  • Jenna Gordon

    out. it looks like she was working at a massage parlor giving a happy ending and the fire alarm got pulled. too much??

  • Anonymous

    I don’t hate it, but I don’t love it.  I think if it was a little longer and the fit in the bust was better, I would like it more.  The looseness and wonky hems at the crotch really makes it look like a bathrobe rather than a wrap dress.  The color is fab on the dress, not so on the lips.  The shoes are great.  I guess I’m going with Out here.

  • Geno Boggiatto

    OUT! She does look pretty great for the most part, but every way I look at it, that dress really does look like some sort of bath robe!

  • Anonymous

    Disagree fellas, this is all kinds of terrible. 

    Also, I don’t think there’s anything that could make up for the matching lipstick. Who are you and what have you done with our TLO?

  • Tom Shea

    IN. It is a little rumpled, but she looks fucking hot.

  • VicD

    Out.  Girl, that’s not your dress.  It’s Snooki’s dress.  It makes her breasts look like bolt-ons (which, I guess, they are – but you wouldn’t want them to LOOK that way).

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  Disco spa robe.  Next.

  • Anonymous

    This reminds me I have to make a spa appointment. Out. The only thing good here is the hair and the shoes.

  • Anonymous

    Sweet mother of OUT. 

  • butter nut

    she’s such a pretty girl.  she deserves nice dresses.  this is not a nice dress.  it is a hideous (flammable?) disco robe and it must die. OUT!

  • Judy_J

    Spa bathrobe.  Out.

  • Anonymous

    I could never ever ever ever not call Naya Rivera IN. 

  • aimee_parrott

    I hate the shape of the dress.  But that color is fabulous on her, love the hair and makeup (yes, even the matchy lipstick) and the shoes.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    I don’t know about you, but if I was having a 25th birthday party at The Mirage, I don’t think I’d want to go in looking like I just stapled a 10-year-old girl’s bath towel around myself. Out, with a nod to the shoes for being amazing.

  • korilian

    Looks like a bath robe. Maybe if it wasn’t bunching like that.

  • Claudia Berry

    She looks like a showgirl in her robe just before putting on her costume.  The color is fab, though.  

  • Lexie

    In. That color is amazing on her and those shoes are fab.
    Normally the matchy lipstick would bother me, but I don’t really mind it on her. I do wish the top of the dress wasn’t quite so baggy, I think that would have sent this from “in” to “IN!!”

  • Anonymous

    Great color, but I can’t with the sparkly twisted spa robe. Out. (But you two get points for the Anita Ward reference-LOL!)

  • Joyce VG

    OUT. Don’t like it.

  • Anonymous

    You had me at the ring my bell reference. IN.

  • Ellen Behm

    I only like the shoes. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    In, VERY MUCH more than the sum of its parts.

  • Anonymous

    the matching lipstick makes me twitch. I think the shoes with the outfit are kind of funny, because it’s like she knows she’s going for that tacky-looking aesthetic. However, I don’t like it. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. I’m with sherrietee. Drag Queen spa robe. 

  • allisankelly

    out. dress looks too big. shoes are horrid. her face and hair are the only things working for me here…I am ignoring the matchy-matchy lipstick 😉

  • Anonymous

    Uh-uh. Looks like she made a trip to the ladies’ room and didn’t straighten her dress out when she finished.

  • Anonymous

    Extremely OUT.

    It doesn’t fit. And she looks 20 years older.

  • MilaXX

    Sorry all I see is sparkly spa robe. Hair and makeup look great but they can’t overcome a bad dress. OUT

  • Anonymous

    We may be ignoring the larger problem in that SHE’S ONLY 25?? Wow.

  • Ana Cedillo

    IN! although I think its a little big on her, and the shoes ive seen at charlotte russe. but still in because her hair and make up look so good and thats a beautiful colour on her!

  • Anonymous

    Out.  She finished her hair and make up, and even put on the shoes, but hasn’t changed out of her bathrobe into her real clothes yet. 

  • Pennymac

    Not my favorite. Is it stuck in her Spanx somewhere? Cause it’s kinda wonky in the front….

  • Laura Schultz

    OUT. Tacky Spa bathrobe.

  • Rachel S.

    I have a raging ladyboner for her, so I have to say she looks fab. However, the matching lipstick is just too much.

  • Cathy S

    She’s gorgeous but she’s wearing a bathrobe. Out.

  • Anonymous


    You can’t look at that and tell where in all that fabric her boobs are.

    The Case of the Missing Boobs is no one’s version of “In.”

  • Bethany Roullett

    Have to go with Out.  Cause it looks like she’s been out for 8 hours already, and because I can’t stand the lipstick color.

  • Anonymous

    Out – looks like she’s draped to get her hair cut.  In 1986.

  • Anonymous

    So out. It’s not even a well done spa dress.

  • Anonymous

    In (though we appear to be in the slight minority!). Too short and not perfect but she manages to look fab anyway. Great colour on her too. I get the feeling this looks better in person than it photographs.

  • Anonymous

    Oh OUT

  • nicole seligman

    i literally like none of the things going on here.

  • Anonymous

    IN. it’s her birthday and she celebrating at a club in Las Vegas. What better than an absorbent fabriced (sp?) freeformish dress to wear when you know champagne bottles will be popping and spilling?! She looks great, she knows it (even with that unfortunate lip color) and she’ s off to rock the casbah.

  • Christina Brennan

    OUT it’s a fug robe.

  • Anonymous

    Tom, Tom, Tom. Also OUT, OUT, OUT. It’s a too-short bathrobe that isn’t even well-cut.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. I think this is Pam Anderson’s spa wrap, not Naya’s. Way too old for her.

  • Anonymous

    Out….it’s a robe, for sure.

  • Ebba Svantesson


  • Anonymous

    I really appreciate the direction in which she’s headed, but that dress simply does not fit her well. I also don’t love the color. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    it looks like she was getting a pap smear, suddenly remembered she had a red carpet to go to, bedazzled the fuck out of her gown and ran out the door.

  • Natasha Fairweather

    Glittery bathrobe. OUT.

  • Denise Alcantara

    This looks like something Blanche Dubois would wear minus the leggings and Naya is no golden girl just yet – OUT!

  • Donna Lee

    Girl, that is not your bathrobe.

  • sweetlilvoice

    Looks cheap, out.

  • Anonymous

    Okay, you guys, it does not fit her!  I mean, cute color and shoes blah blah blah, but LOOK at her!  There is something very stretched-out-worn-out-Studio 54-hag appearance to the look.

  • mcglory13

    Now that you’ve said bunched up spa robe, that’s all I see. Out.

  • Anonymous

    Looks like she’s taking tips from Snookie

  • Anonymous

    Out. Awkward robe vibe.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Not your dress, Naya.

  • Anonymous

    Out-looks like a bathrobe and makes her look old or something.

  • Anonymous

    Dress and lipstick – out.  Shoes – in

  • Jane Morris

    Disco spa wrap not wrapped right. OUT.

  • Kendrs Allen

    Not only are those shoes killer, but they are only $42.50 from Charlotte Russe.  Way to go Naya!

  • Meghan Phelan

    OUT!  I couldn’t hate that dress more.

  • Anonymous

    An unenthusiastic in.

  • LaDonna Carpenter

    OUT! Can’t get past the spa robe, and when I look at it just from the waist up, I see Golden Girls chic. 

  • Anonymous

    In. Good color on her. 

  • Merneith

    Out. I think my Grandmother bought me that bathrobe – thirty years ago.

  • Samantha Irene

    It’s good from afar, but far from good. Great color, love the idea – but no dice. OUT

  • Anonymous


    It does look like a spa robe, and a sparkly tacky one for an 8 year old at that.  Her boobs look saggy, deflated and lopsided, and the askew hem is odd and too short too.  It’s a mess.  Other than that mess of a dress…she looks lovely, except I hate the matchy lipstick to dress.

  • Florrie Brafman

    Out.  Spa.

  • Anonymous

    I love her dearly. But this is an OUT. Mainly because the lipstick matching thing. But on closer look, the material of the dress looks like a fancy towel. Jeez, I love her dearly. I hate giving her an out. 

  • P M

    Dang. It’s a grumbling out. Okay, so I’m biased against purple lipstick, but I’m going to stick by my (few) principles.

  • Anonymous

    Wait, isn’t she just backstage waiting for her turn on the pole?  OUT

  • Renee Thomas

    Sparkly bathrobe with tacky shoes.
    Her face and hair look nice though.

  • Me Again

    For the venue – her 25th birthday at a Vegas hotspot – it’s perfect!  IN!

  • Anonymous

    It’s too short nd bunches weirdly. Too bad, it’s out

  • Anonymous

    OUT! Even if its purple. Too sparkly and too bunched up. 

  • Anonymous

    It looks like a glittery bathrobe to me. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Sparkly bathrobe.

  • Jessica O’Connell

    not a fan of the “dress” *cough TOO SHORT ROBE cough* nor of the lavender lipstick… Her hair does look great and I love the shoes but… OUT.

  • Allison Woods

    Oh dear, no, no, NO! What is that, a wadded-up bathmat? BARF!

  • Anonymous

    OUT. That dress is too much of a mess.

  • Anonymous

    Love a good wrap dress, but this isn’t one. Seems like maybe the designer was trying for a blouson effect (ack! Blouson tops!! Go the hell away!), but it looks, as sherrietee so aptly put it, like a drag queen’s spa robe.

  • Anonymous

    Out! Sparklicious terry bath robe is bad enough but then to put on the matching purply lipstick! Horrid! The shoes are a slightly more interesting form of beige pump. Blah.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. The dress looks like a scrunchie I had in the 90s, and it’s making her look heavier than she is.

  • Emily Rose

    I….actually find myself liking the matching dress and lipstick. I must have hit my head or something, but I think it works really well. IN.

  • Anonymous

    Fun color, not great fit between the waist and her boobs. In only because it’s Vegas. Anywhere else the color wouldn’t make up for the bad fit.

  • Santa


  • Anna Tree

    Your lipstick should never match your dress. OUT

  • AWStevens

    I hear they are giving those bathrobes away free at every Radisson…

    The shoes ARE killah but the lipstick matching that bathrobe are a no-no!  OUT

  • AWStevens

    I hear they are giving those bathrobes away free at every Radisson…

    The shoes ARE killah but the lipstick matching that bathrobe are a no-no!  OUT

  • natalia h

    bathrobe and matchy-matchy lipstick. Why have you forsaken us, guys? You taught us it was the wrong thing to do!

  • Anonymous

    More Disco Hangover than Disco Fabulous to me.

  • Anonymous

    It’s all floppy up on top–and she’s not.  Out.

  • Anonymous

    Pretty color and the shoes are great, but it doesn’t fit.  I’m curious what it is supposed to look like.  Out.

  • Tom Markiewicz

    OUT. horrendous, she looks broader across the shoulders than she really is, and shapeless everywhere else. disaster.

  •!/Space_Kitty Space Kitty

    That color is divine on her, but I have no idea what’s going on with the fit of that dress.  I mean, we don’t want her to go Princess Lea naked but this hides nearly all of her hotness.


  • Marieka Elizabeth


  • Aaminah Khan

    All that bunching up in the front just looks too wrong to me. I love Naya Rivera, but this is OUT.

  • Anonymous

    There is some potential in the dress- I do love the fabric and that colour on her but the bunching is just hideous as is the lipstick. As it is, the outfit is very unflattering. OUT

  • Anonymous

    eh, it’s all all right. Did she get a boob job?

  • Anonymous

    In.  I don’t know why really, because it looks like a shortie robe, but I love the color on her.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Disco bathrobe.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Disco bathrobe.

  • Anonymous

    Nope, don’t like it, don’t like the shoes with it.  And I LOVE disco, so that ain’t it.

  • Anonymous

    I can’t get over the weird fit, the bunching up front makes her boobs very lopsided.  Not flattering. 

    It also looks like it’s from forever 21.  and made from terry cloth

  • Bethany Fairbrother

    Too short and she looks llike she has three boobs.  P.S. No bling and hate the shoes.

  • Anonymous

    i own that bathrobe so… out

  • elzatelzabelz

    OUT-Disco dowdy. All together too shiny.

  • Anonymous

    ahhh this is a hard one. I’m gonna say OUT because at the end of the day, i guess i just don’t like the dress…and the matched lipstick is awful.

  • Anonymous

    In. Just. Seriously, I wanna be a hollywood stylist – I mean if you can take a girl THIS effing lovely I mean she is a GORGEOUS child and get her to not look A plus fantastic every single time and still have work…well that’s a pretty easy job. I mean how do they miss with her? I dont get it but they consistently do.

  • Tiger Gray

    OUT. She looks like a My Little Pony. 

  • Sorana Tarmu

    OUT – spa robe.

  • Lisa

    The shoes are awesome, and the color is gorgeous.  BUT, the dress doesn’t fit, and I HATE the matchy-match lipstick!  Gotta give it an OUT.

  • Jillian Liszewski

    In…  but the matchy match lipstick must go.

  • Elena

    In. (But please, don’t let matching lipstick be a thing.)

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Spa robe, schmatta. What’s going on with her right breast (implant)?

  • Carrie L. Boram

    Gak – that “garment” adds at least 20 pounds to her midsection with all that lumping bunching and bumping. It’s a Project Runway “unconventional materials: make a robe using only staples and a disco lavender bed sheet challenge.” She’s in the bottom three and in danger of being auf’d.

  • Anonymous

    On size fits most and it doen’t fit her.  Out.

  • Grace Ritt

    Out. Too bunchy and weird.

  • Anonymous

    I can’t get past feeling like she’s wearing a bathrobe. And the matching lipstick just seals the deal. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    OUT, ugly.

  • Anonymous

    Definitely out! That hem hits in all the wrong places, and the shoes are a little too hoofy.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  She’s a teeny-tiny person, and this robe makes her look like she’s got humongous jugs and is trying to hide a paunch.  Not good.

  • Praggya R. Barretto

    Out. “I’m ready for my centerfold shoot!”

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  What an awful color!  What an unflattering fit!  What a ridiculous thing to wear in public!

  • Anonymous

    The dress does have some fit issues but her hair, make up and shoes are so fabulous that I’m declaring her IN.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  I LOVE the shoes but the rest just irks me.  I think it needed to be a little more uniform in the hem and it just looks a teensy tiny bit too short.  I could have gotten over that if it weren’t for the lipstick which as a makeup artist makes me just angry.  Your makeup should never and I do mean NEVER match your clothing exactly.  In fact, it shouldn’t even match.  It should go with your face and possibly coordinate a bit with your clothing maybe but never ever match.  EVER.

  • Fifi LaRoux

    From the neck up and the ankle down she looks amazing! The middle part however means she’s OUT.

  • Michelle Campbell


  • Anonymous

    OUT! I still think she looks awful.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Looks like Blanche DuBois’ bathrobe. Love the shoes though.

  • Cindi Tracy Aune

    Go with your first instinct. She looks awful.

  • Jessica

    So close! If the top fit her better this would be a fantastic look (minus the matchy lipstick). I adore those shoes though, and overall I still have to say IN.

  • Emily

    In. Love the color.  Maybe it’s just a little too big….

  • Anonymous

    Eh, it’s not the best dress ever, but her body looks good and the color is great on her. IN.

  • Anonymous

    on the one hand the color is great and she looks beautiful and i love her and her legs.  on the other hand as i scrolled down i screamed “where’s the rest of the dress?”  the top is just too big for the bottom and makes it look like a bed jacket.  sorry, my latina darling, i have to say out.  don’t spank me…..ok if you really want to.

  • Jen L.

    OUT.  It looks like a sparkly bathrobe.  Good color on her, though.

  • Sophie Collier

    Out.  That dress is a mess and the lipstick looks awful.

  • oohsparkley!

    She’s almost making an ugly dress look cute.  Not bad enough for an out, not good enough for an in.  Don’t make me choose.  I’m not used to seeing that bright orchid color.  I love a bright hot pink or magenta, so I could probably learn to like it.

  • Anonymous

    I don’t like the proportions, the fabric, or the lip color. OUT.

  • Amanda Gun

    It breaks my heart to do this, but I have to say OUT. I completely agree with last-night Tom that it looks more like a dressing gown than an actual dress. A fabulous dressing gown, for sure, but only if you don’t leave the house! She’s gorgeous and I love her, but she needs to take that thing off.

  • MusingsFromManhattan

    Out. shapeless, makes her boobies look saggy,and looks like a purple astro-turf robe

  • Anonymous

    This is why disco gets a bad rap.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Bathrobe. OUT

  • Anonymous

    OUT. The shoes are the only thing that kept me from stabbing the computer screen

  • Alexandria N

    IN! lavender delight!

  • Anne Rinaldi

    If this dress was longer it would look like something Mrs. Roper would wear out to dinner. I don’t like the shoes with it either. Yikes.

  • frankystein123

    Great colour, awful execution.