In or Out: Zooey Deschanel in Erin Fetherston

Posted on December 27, 2011

Oh, kittens. Such is the lack of red carpet fabulosity (or even crack-smoking) this week that we are forced to give you a picture of a gal in a white dress and black pumps and ask you to discuss her style.

 

Zooey Deschanel in Erin FetherstonZooey Deschanel attends “The X factor” season finale in an Erin Fetherston dress.

Zooey Deschanel in Erin FetherstonErin Fetherston Resort 2012 Collection/Model: Wang Xiao

Zooey Deschanel in Erin Fetherston

Zooey Deschanel in Erin Fetherston

Zooey Deschanel in Erin Fetherston

The dress is about as simple as a dress gets. It’s cute, but we don’t love the uneven hem. You couldn’t wear a sassy pair of red pumps or something, girl? Also, why are you wearing Paz de la Huerta’s makeup? Does she know? Okay, maybe those aren’t the muddy brown shades we’re used to seeing from Paz (who we’re pretty sure uses Duncan Heinz chocolate cake mix for all her makeup needs), but you sure did spackle it on Paz-style. We have to say, we’re happy you’ve toned down the “coalminer’s daughter” hair just a skosh. It was getting a little close to campy there for awhile.

But all of this is just conversation-making while we avoid discussing the one thing we know the kittens will want to discuss above all else: NUDE HOSE, BITCHES. It’s coming back, whether you’re ready for it or not.

 

Vote Now!

 

IN! Simple, girly, pretty holiday dress, bitches!

OUT! HER KNEES ARE MELTING!!!!

 

Jennifer Morrison’s very tight Stella McCartney dress was voted IN, with quite a few reservations. Namely, that it’s a Stella McCartney dress.

[Photo Credit: Andrew Evans/PR Photos, elle.com]

Tags: , ,

  • Leslie Streeter

    Duncan Hines cake mix. You are always genius.

  • Anonymous

    Ugh. It’s cute, but she’s so hipster she makes me want to puke into my PBR.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=610791985 Aniela Marie Perry

      Seriously. And if you’re going to make the effort to put on false eyelashes, the whole no-effort drab hipster style looks even more absurd.

  • http://profiles.google.com/anplica Anplica Fiore

    In!  I actually really like this dress, although red shoes would have made this better.  

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1046681022 Paula Berman

      Any color shoes would have been better! 

      • Anonymous

        I’m thinking green spangles, to pick up the flower-petal motif of the skirt & hem.

        • foodycat

          I’m just grateful she didn’t break out the Miu Miu glitter pumps again.

      • Anonymous

        I’m thinking green spangles, to pick up the flower-petal motif of the skirt & hem.

  • http://profiles.google.com/mrs.krause314 Mrs. Krause

    She looks like a 6th grader at a band recital.  I don’t like the shoes with this dress. 

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=12500056 Joseph Lamour

      I like the hem, but adding that satin sash to that dress made it look like she’s at her first communion. Which I guess fits for her.

      • Anonymous

        It’s hard to see in the runway pic, but the sash has always been there.

  • http://twitter.com/LianaBrooks Liana Brooks

    It’s Zooey, she’s cute and she gets a pass even in a petal skirt. What else would a pixie wear? IN

  • http://twitter.com/wednesdaydreams Natalie

    this is one boring outfit. i actually don’t mind nude hose though.

  • Anonymous

    She slept in that, and put on the shoes nearest her bed. But I like the hose.

    Out anyway.

  • http://twitter.com/jaythenerdkid Aaminah Khan

    She looks like she left the house in a slip. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    That is a lovely nightie she is wearing.  

    Can anyone explain me, why are hose “in” or “coming back”? why are they considered a fashion item as opposed to a mere utility garment?

    • MilaXX

      Because a few years back the fashion gods decided that bare legs year round, even in cold weather was the only way to go. Apparently they have now changed their minds and hose are now acceptable?

      • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

        Thank god!  :)  I will never give up my hose!

  • Sara Leigh Merrey

    She needs to start wearing clothing more in keeping with her age. This dress just looks too childish for her.

    • foodycat

      It is a very sweet little dress, but although I don’t think Zooey is buxom, this just looks like her aunty bought her a Communion dress and didn’t know she’d hit puberty.

  • Anonymous

    Zzzzzzzzzz.  Out?

  • http://heartprintandstyle.blogspot.com Vivi N

    The dress is cute but she really needs like a statement necklace or something.

  • Anonymous

    She’s wearing her PJs, it appears…..so much for making an effort.

  • Judy_J

    Hooray for the nude hose!  I mean it….I’m tempted to give her an IN just for that alone.  Lord knows, the rest of her ensemble is pretty snooze-worthy.

  • Anonymous

    cute dress. want. could have used some punch and pow somewhere, but still pretty and IN.

  • Anonymous

    In. It could have benefited from colorful shoes or accessories, but the look is fine.  I am totally in favor of nude hose.  I am a middle-aged women who lives in the Northeast – in the summer after a week at the shore, I look fine in a dress without hose, but the rest of the year, my legs need some help.

    • Anonymous

      I’m middle-aged, and even tho’ I live in the sunbelt, no amount of sun will color my albino legs.  In fact, I think I’m so pale that the sun’s rays just bounce right off me.  Love that hose won’t make me look like an inmate at the local nursing home.

      • Anonymous

        Younger-aged, but same deal! I adore nude hose, it balances my pasty legs to match my slightly tanned arms & face. But really, anything that helps cover veins on my pasty pale legs is just awesome.

  • Alisa Rivera

    The woman is 31 years old. So why is she wearing Elle Fanning’s dress?

    • Shannon Twigg

      she’s 31?!?!?

    • Anonymous

      I was wondering how old she was. I think I had a dress like that when I was 6.

    • Anonymous

      Thanks for posting her age. I gave her an Out anyway, but knowing that ahead of time would have reduced the length of my deliberations.

    • Anonymous

      I’m really glad you posted her age, because when I saw her in this photo, I thought, “Zoey honey, you’re not going to be able to get away with that little girl look for very much longer.” I happen to like her, but I think she’s got to move on gracefully to the next phase and let the Polly Pockets go.

      • http://vhanna26.typepad.com Vera

        She’s adorable and all, but she needs to age up a bit. She’s sorta like Xtina in reverse.

  • http://twitter.com/ILikeShiny Cindi Williams

    Oh my goodness, I am so fucking bored by this outfit.

    • Anonymous

      I am so fucking bored by Zooey Deschanel.

      • Melvis Velour

        Amen honey…

      • Melvis Velour

        Amen honey…

  • Anonymous

    It’s just Zooey being Zooey. I don’t think it merits an In or Out.

  • Anonymous

    I have to say I do love her hair here, it’s very cute and bouncy. As for the rest, well it’s Christmas so I’m just going to leave it there.

    • King Dex

      I think that’s it – this dress has that holiday quality with its little bit of satin in the sash. It’s appropriate. Probably too young for her, but I do think she still looks good (I think her hair looks beautiful too, just bouncin’ and behavin’). 

  • MilaXX

    This is so boring it’s almost hard to tell. I like the dress. It’s cute and it fits the Zoey persona. Hair looks better than it has in a minute, but the makeup is a fail. I don’t even mind the nude hose. I am annoyed by the shoe. It’s a white dress! That’s as close to a blank canvass as you can get. She couldn’t find a red or fiercer shoe of any color? OUT

  • Anonymous

    I know nothing about this person except for what I read here, but something about her just rubs me completely the wrong way. She’s way up there on my irrational celebrity hate list. So yeah, OUT, but more because of who she is than what she’s wearing, though what she’s wearing is incredibly boring.

    Also I am pro-hose. I almost never wear skirts, but when I do it’s always with hose. I was too well trained by my mother to go out without them. I find nude ones kind of boring, but they certainly have their place.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1046681022 Paula Berman

      I don’t like her either, and I think my reasons are threefold: 1. Her voice.  It’s annoying, even though apparently she’s a famous singer as well as an ingenue.  2.  I will never forgive her for “The touch, the feel, of cotton– the fabric of our lives!” 3. She’s just so precious it makes my teeth hurt, in that hipster, ironically Loretta Lynn-haired way.

    • Anonymous

      AMEN to this. She bugs and I’m so glad I’m not alone having an irrational celebrity hate list!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

    In. The dress is really cute – but red or any other color shoes would have worked so much better.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7NGUZXK7KI3C3FX2YWBWDK3XCU Trixie

    Boring. OUT.  I’ve always been a fan of nude hose and welcome their return.  But this look needs something – ANYTHING! Jewelry? Clutch? Interesting shoes?  Belt?  IMHO, hair still has a ways to go.

  • Anonymous

    OUT

    I realize this is just the X Factor season finale…so casual RC is ok, but this look is just too light and summery for this time of year, even for LA.  It’s also quite a snore and too twee. 

    Also…so much hair!  He wee neck just couldn’t bear the weight of it all in that first picture.  poor dear.

  • Cathy S

    I think she looks cute, although I prefer the model’s shoes. Still, In!

  • http://profiles.google.com/katelynsypher Katie Sypher

    I want Zooey hair.

    But I also want to find the poor flower girl from whom this dress was stolen and give it back. She’s a great chanteuse. I wish she’d remember to dress like one.

  • Anonymous

    For the life of me, I do not understand all this nude hose nonsense.  First and foremost, my grandmother always told me….Hose are for firemen and gentlemen…. ladies wear stockings!!  Wise words, Nana!!
    But really, it’s winter, a woman wants to wear a dress, then a woman needs to wear STOCKINGS to stay warm.  And don’t tell me it’s a trend…. ggrrrr… I love you guys, but really…. this is ridiculous!!!

    • foodycat

      Far be it from me to contradict your grandmother, but some women find pantihose more comfortable than stockings, plus it is hard to find a garter belt that is intended to keep stockings on all day, rather than just for the bedroom. But then, I have never claimed to be a lady.

    • Onika K Morris-Alleyne

      my legs don’t get cold enough to bother

    • Anonymous

      …is there a difference between hose & stockings? I’ve always heard the terms used interchangeably, tights are very different, but I’m honestly confused by hose vs. stockings.

      • Anonymous

        PANTYhose and stockings are different, but it is correct to use hose and stockings interchangeably. Hose/stockings have been around for men since at least the 15th century but were not popular for women until the 1920s. Pantyhose became popular in the early 60s after fashion adopted the dancer trick of sewing stockings to underwear to keep them up.

        • foodycat

          I tend to think in modern parlance hose is just short for hosiery, being as how we don’t often look up a girl’s skirt to see if they are stockings or pantihose.

  • Susana Reyes

    OUT!

  • Anonymous

    And, believe it or not, the first thing I noticed (non-fashion maven that I am, but I’m growing thanks to   TLo) was the nude hose. Oh, and what beautiful eyes she has! Other than that, yeah, it looks like a first Communion dress.

  • Anonymous

    I am apparently looking at an entirely different set of pictures than the rest of the bitter kittens, because I think she looks fabulous.  Sure, it’s a lot of hair, but that’s how she wears her hair.  And the dress is certainly youngish, but that’s how she dresses.  It’s adorable and it fits and we can’t see her lady parts or anything personal, so that’s good.  The shoes are not exciting, but they appear to fit and there’s nothing inherently wrong with them.  The nude hose are really the only possible choice here.  And, best of all, look how she poses for the camera – she doesn’t look like she has to pee, no body part is being thrust out unnaturally, no hands in pockets, just a pretty woman standing naturally to have her picture taken.  What’s wrong with that?

    • Sara Dee

      I agree. She looks great to me.

  • Anonymous

    Just as long as she doesn’t sing.

    • Anonymous

      OMG, amen!!!

    • Anonymous

      Why?  I love her voice.  Like a throwback to an era where people actually sang without aid of a computer.

      • Anonymous

        Well, I guess Zoey is like cilantro, either you love or hate it.  “The touch the feel of cotton…in my mouth…”

    • Jasmine Moten

      That commercial makes my ears bleed. She can’t sing for shit!

  • Anonymous

    She definitely needed a shoe with color.  I really like the ones the model is wearing.

    I don’t mind nude hose in theory…like, when you are wearing a dress and it’s cold outside.  But isn’t the X Factor filmed in LA?

    • Anonymous

      It’s not always 80 degrees in L.A. One of the things that makes the climate agreeable is that it can be hot w/o humidity, and that means the temperature can drop considerably in the evenings. In the winter it can go down to the 40s (and occasionally lower, depending where you are) at night.

  • Anonymous

    Slap a crown on her head and she’s ready for Toddlers ‘n Tiaras. (Out)

  • Call me Bee

    No matter what–Zooey can do no wrong in my book.  Adorable. (But Paz and the cake mix?  Brilliant!) 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/MaryJo-Gerwe/1619633090 MaryJo Gerwe

    i’ve always thought that the nude stockings cover a lot of sins at the knees. Knees are knobby, bumpy, unlovely things,
    no matter who the celebrity is.  IN  although I find her cuteness irritating.

  • http://twitter.com/stellaphone Stella Zawistowski

    Pretty please can we have some jewelry? OUT.

  • Anonymous

    i love zooey. i love this. in yay

  • Anonymous

    For some reason I read ‘NUDE HOSE’ as ‘HUGE NOSE’.

    I thought ‘I know they don’t like Zooey but sheesh, that’s unnecessary’.

    • Anonymous

      …Oh, on the subject of the dress I give it an ‘IN’.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1326120071 Gaby Ripoll

    Out. Her Tweeness gets on my nerves – liked her at first but now just find her insipid. This is the most boring combo ever and I am ashamed of Her Tweeness for not finding suitably twee shoes to brighten up the look. Meh. 

  • Anonymous

    I agree Zooey, I wouldn’t want to be there either.

  • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

    I think she looks cute. And not at all crazy. Major props for not showing her nipples. Don’t know how she managed that trick. IN.

  • Sara__B

    I’m too bored to vote. Snore.

  • https://profiles.google.com/104791269167429064986/about?hl=en Judy S

    IN. but your comments are fun anyway.

  • Anonymous

    My issue with nude hose is that the range of shades offered doesn’t work for everyone. For instance, fair-skinned Zooey has total ice skater legs.

    Also she really needs cuter shoes with this.

    I covet her hair.

    Sorry for the stream of consciousness posting, but I’m off my game as you guys have been in recovery mode! ;-)

    Okay, Out. Boring dress, bad shoes. Coulda been an in with some better styling/accessorizing.

    • Anonymous

      Yes! Ice Skater Legs!  I said they looked like support hose that you wear post surgery but I love “ice skater leg” much better.  I also covet her hair.

  • Haley Buchanan

    The nude hose dont bother me so much but the fact that its so BORING does.  Zooey, you’re way cuter, artsier, and more stylish than this black and white snore-fest.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    NUDE HOSE!  I saw them in two movies this weaken, Young Adult and The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo.  Gross.

  • Anonymous

    Wow, the more times she hits the red carpet this year, the more I’m certain small doses of her are better. That is an elementary schoolgirl’s dress. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Out.

    Too boring.  Too young.  Too much work to come up with anything more.

  • Renee Thomas

    “who we’re pretty sure uses Duncan-Heinz chocolate cake mix for all her make-up needs” = HAHAHAHHAHA! Awesome.

    Anyway, I don’t find anything wrong with this to declare it out, but I can’t find anything particularly right with it to call it in. On the out side, it’s boring, too summery, and the shoes don’t add anything. On the in side, it is light and fresh and she overall looks pretty.

    In, I guess. 

  • Anonymous

    Cute and quirky. In. Though the shoes are boring.

  • Anonymous

    In. For her, that’s elegant.

    (Shoes should have had some color)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GFRKTKRR6FKE2G4QO4MQNGL6DY Carol

    It’s nice to see a young woman in the entertainment (or related) spotlight not using boobage front and center (and side) to get attention or posing like she’s hoping to get a call from Playboy. IN.  And nude hose are not the enemy.

  • Joyce VG

    IN! Adorbs!

  • http://twitter.com/amndad amanda lynn

    is that all of her hair, do you think?  or is it extensions beyond belief?

    • foodycat

      All her hair, I imagine. That’s pretty much what my hair looks like (different colour) when I’ve been to the salon and they’ve dried it curly.

  • http://twitter.com/delysia_lafosse Delysia LaFosse

    I think this is a case where some colored opaque tights could have been really cute. I probably would have even taken sheer black hose with a nice bright pump. But this white dress, nude hose, black shoes thing just isn’t doing it for me. She’s so cute that she still manages to look good here – even with several more pounds of makeup than she needs – but from a style perspective, she’s OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Aw, I think she looks cute. I do agree that she should have injected a little fun and color into the outfit with some great shoes.
    Zooey child, listen to TLo. Never take makeup advice from Paz dLH. NEVER.  

  • Anonymous

    Uh, where is this ‘dress’ we are voting in? All I see is a woman in her underwear. So out.

  • bloodshothalfblind

    meh it’s so boring i can hardly be bothered to OUT it.  i’m not a fan of either zooey deschanel & her forced quirky girl routine, or erin fetherstons tediously nothing dresses

  • Anonymous

    I love hose.  I know, I’m old school.  However, THESE NUDE HOSE LOOK HORRID.  The dress is so light and floaty that it screams for bare legs.  It’s short and pretty and lovely and then WHOMP.  Nude. Hose.  These even look like thick support stockings.    And then the shoes.  Grandma Goes to a Funeral Shoes.  OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Girls with boobs shouldn’t wear shapeless dresses. It’s not that she looks bad, but she could look so much better if she had a waistline. Her eyelashes are a little much in that up-close shot but nowhere near Paz territory… so IN. She looks fresh and comfortable.

    Besides, it’s the X factor. The boys are probably all wearing ripped jeans.

  • Anonymous

    There has not been a mad lib post in a while.  Lampshade was the first thing that popped into my head.  

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1129137319 Paula Pertile

    Are those cheap grocery store grandma pantyhose? 
    Duncan Hines cake mix – Love.

  • Anonymous

    Cute. 

  • Anonymous

    Nude hose, sheer black hose, any hose but white. About damn time.

    Sweet Zooey is always so twee, it makes my teeth hurt. I’d like to see her sister, Emily. I don’t think she’s ever appeared in this blog.

  • http://twitter.com/#!/Space_Kitty Space Kitty

    Nude hose?

    No. 

    I won’t and you can’t make me.

    (OUT.)

  • Anonymous

    I like the dress, it could be a little longer, maybe about 2 inches.  The shoes are kind of a bore but the dress is a simple look.  Too much makeup or maybe loose the extra sets of eyelashes.  Pretty hair, pretty girl.  I just enjoyed watching her again on Elf.  She needs some jewelry, maybe some bracelets or something or some beaded necklace and push a 2O’s vibe.  The hose?  In theory a yes.  I would want to wear hose with this dress so I don’t feel like I’m out half dressed.  Those hose are not the best but its a start.  I think Michelle Williams would get away with this look easier.

  • Anonymous

    Grudging in. Next time, I want to see some accessorizing style Zoe!

  • Anonymous

    This lily-white Irish gal is thrilled to see that sheer hose are back.

    As far as the outfit, I’ll give it an OUT just for the lack of… well, anything.

  • Anonymous

    Love that hose are coming back–it’s about time, for us color-challenged kittens.  About her hair:  if it’s truly all hair that grows from her head, I’m majorly jealous.  If it’s extensions…yawn.

  • http://twitter.com/Merneith Merneith

    I love the dress. I don’t think it’s her dress. She’s too old for it. (Seriously, Zooey. You’re thirty years old.) I’m old enough that I never stopped wearing nude hose in the first place so I’m not surprised they’re coming back. I don’t mind her makeup as much as her hair. Bangs are not cute. Bangs were never cute. Oh hell, it’s Out – but on Chloe Moretz this dress would be swoon-worthy.

  • http://twitter.com/iraki86 Ira Ioannidou

    IN because I love nude hose!

  • Anonymous

    NUDE HOSE. NO. NONONONONO. I WON’T.

    Anyway, the major effect of this post aside from The Unmentionable Legwear (I’m gonna treat this shit like Voldemort, I swear to god) rearing its ugly head is to make me want to go look at the designer’s lookbook, because that image is really charming.

  • Anonymous

    I just almost spat out my coffee laughing that hard. Duncan Hines cakes mix indeed, sirs. And yet…I still feel a fetching fondness for Paz’s sheer Paz-dom. She makes me smile every time she rolls through something.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Style? What here is styled? Everything about this — hair, makeup, dress, shoes, HOSE — makes her look like she’s going to her high-school graduation dinner with her parents wearing the outfit that will be under her robe.

  • http://twitter.com/rgmx Mercy

    Out, I dislike her on principle and this outfit does nothing to salvage my opinion.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1316070988 Roey Thorpe

    I personally like nude hose for their smoothing effect as well as warmth, but frequently see women choose hose darker than their skin tone, which is where the problem comes in.  Nude is okay, suntan unless you have one… no.

  • Anonymous

    I don’t like hose, but I will defend celebrites’ rights to wear them with a fiery passion, as having perfectly hairless, veinless, and cellulite-free legs is not actually in their job description. 

    Zoey is always out until she cuts those stupid little-girl bangs.  Ugh.

  • Anonymous

    The dress looks adorable on the model, less so on Zooey.  And it seems a bit too summery for a December event, even in LA.  It’s not a bad party dress but she could have been so much better with some different shoes and killer accessories.  Unless she’s heading out to her job at the bank or a law firm afterwards, those pumps are awful.  Hair and makeup are fine.

    I’ve always hated wearing hose in hot weather and stopped doing so a long time ago.  But this trend of bare legs in the dead of winter was just ridiculous.  I’m glad that sheer nude hose are making a comeback, when seasonally appropriate.  I like to wear dresses year round and sometime black tights just won’t do.

  • Anonymous

    This dress is way too babydoll for her. Now what were you saying about nude pantyhose? NO WAY.  I threw them all out a couple of years ago!

  • Anonymous

    IN

  • http://www.wordydoodles.com WordyDoodles

    Nude hose:
    1. Never/rarely work on women of color. I’ve yet to find a great pair. If anything, sheer black is better.
    2. Are kind of ugly anyway. IMHO, Zooey’s legs would have looked better here without them.
    3. MIGHT be cool with the tatoo prints on them. I might try those, if they don’t make my legs look weirdly light.

  • http://twitter.com/susanpcollier Susan Collier

    Who let Katy Perry out in such a boring outfit?

  • http://twitter.com/Bloodisea Barbora

    Its really simple, but for me IN! 

  • Anonymous

    It’s the wrong time of year to wear that dress.  I suspect the nylons went on because without them she’d be freezing.

  • Anonymous

    not fucking pantyhose. excuse me.

    i think part of this particular segment of this particular generation’s identification of cute, if you will, is doing things wrong. i think when they consider it, if they consider it, they consider it insouciant, if they think about insouciantness/insouciantitude [neither of which are likely to be words, just consider their use insouciant of me]. otoh, i imagine the current definition of all of the above is a combo of saucy & callow, even if it isnt quite to me. then again, again [there must be another then again in here someplace], it’s not precisely à la mode to know anything these days, is it?

    as an aside, if i note that the very à la mode manic pixie dream girl thing is nothing more than the sign [in the manner of sign -> signifier -> signified] of something thats existed in its exact same form for at least over a hundred years, more, perhaps i will start the yelling now?

    oh, the dress is okay. i’ve already forgotten the shoes. she doesnt actually bother me much, i way prefer her to katy perry. probably always will. the stink of odious emanating from that originally Xian singer just doesnt wipe away that easily. anyway.

  • Anonymous

    Zzzzzzzzzzzzz. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    IN. A paler shade of nude would’ve been better, but still, she looks cute. I salute and celebrate the return of hosiery, nude, sheer black, all of it!

  • Alloy Jane

    She sounds like a Muppet and here, she looks like a puppet, so sure.  in.  Because not all Jim Henson creatures dress outlandishly.  Some of them don’t wear clothes at all.

  • Jolene Barnett

    Those contacts make her look possessed. Or maybe she is possessed, and that’s the explanation.

  • Mary McClelland

    So OUT and not just because she annoys me. 

  • Anonymous

    IN. She looks OK. Not great, not bad. So much she could have done to give this outfit some spark. I know not everyone is a fan of the pantyhose. However, I do think most women’s legs look better in a good pair. And what is not to enjoy about criticizing the gals when they  pick bizarre shades of nude pantyhose to wear?

  • http://profiles.google.com/fade131 Fade 131

     It’s a cute dress, but couldn’t she have done… something? Anything? Jewelry, a colored shoe, I’d even take something silly in her hair if only she looked festive and not… boring. So boring. OUT.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=12500056 Joseph Lamour

    I like the hem, but adding that satin sash to that dress made it look like she’s at her first communion. Which I guess fits for her.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Kinda boring, especially for the holidaze.

  • http://twitter.com/mellafe natalia h

    Meh.

  • http://twitter.com/mellafe natalia h

    Meh.

  • CQAussie

    Oh bland bland bland.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    A while ago she did an ad for the Cotton Council. I don’t know if they were her clothes but they did have a kind of vintagey style that sort of suited her. She is such a pretty girl I kind of wonder why she chooses to dress quirky/ugly?

  • Anonymous

    She is cute but I think she’s pushing the doll thing just a tad too far. OUT!

  • Anonymous

    I freakin hate this girl and there’s not a thing she can do or a thing she can wear to change my mind. I hate the way she licks (potentially, not having ever seen her lick) stamps. So she’s an out for me before I even look at her. GO AWAY, MANIC PIXIE DREAM POSEUR!!!!

  • Ruth McGivern

    OUT. The nude hose are an abomination and those shoes are so boring I fell asleep before I could finish the post.  Zzzzzzzzzzzzzz

  • Sophie Collier

    The dress is cute but needs something to jazz it up for a red carpet occasion.  Jewelry, sparkly shoes, something.  

  • Anonymous

    I don’t get all the hate – I think she looks cute and is certainly less annoying than a lot of other celebs. Yeah, she can be a little twee sometimes, but for the most part I think she’s pretty down to earth (well, down to earth using the celebrity scale, which goes from One to Kardashian). I do think this outfit is a little boring, but it’s not so bad that it deserves an out. I give it an IN.

    And I always wear nude hose whether it’s in or not – my legs are far too white to be seen without them.

  • Anonymous

    She’s just so cute. But is it in? Well, it’s not out. Kinda boring and I am frightened of the nude hose.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  Way too close to Baby Jane Hudson territory without a trace of humor.

  • http://twitter.com/anacedillo Ana Cedillo

    this is pathetic, no comment. other than to say this is NOT hipster, and she is NOT hipster.

  • Anonymous

    NO on the nude hose! Gah! My legs feel hot and itchy just looking at them!

    Also, give me back my 9-year-old’s dress, sheesh.

  • Anonymous

    In

  • http://toodles.yelp.com AWStevens

    She is going through a divorce during the holidays but that is NO excuse for wearing an early 20th century undergarment as a dress… Boring mofo shoes too!  OUT

  • Wrenaria

    In! I think she looks super cute.

    And I don’t get all the drama about hose. I have no problem with whether people choose to wear it or not.

  • Anonymous

    I like the dress on her.  I don’t like the shoes–the dress calls for something better than the heavy black pumps.  But at least they’re not putty shoes.

    Therefore, IN.

  • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

    In.  Cute dress.  A bit too much eye makeup, but the hair is gorge.  I would have paired the dress with bright fun shoes, instead of black.

  • http://twitter.com/TigerLaverada TigerLaverada

    She seems to naturally gravitate to a little girl/twee look, and she’s getting too long in the tooth for it. OUT.

  • http://summerborn.livejournal.com/ Summer Born

    Ugh, OUT. The dress could have been saved by styling but this is not it.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Boring. She did nothing to make the outfit sing.

  • Anonymous

    Hose!!!! YAY!!!! I don’t get putting bare feet into dress shoes. Sweaty, they stick, they smell. Ugh. Plus, most of us have legs with some flaws. When I was 18 and tan, I didn’t need hose. Now, I do. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/samuel.j.donovan Samuel Joesph Donovan

    No.

  • Anonymous

    Ummm, it’s hard to say, but I’ll say it:  in!   And hose are back due to the Duchess of Cambridge.

  • oohsparkley!

    In.

  • Anonymous

    It’s fine. Like something anyone could wear. In, as it seems like too much to give it an out. Though those bangs really makes me rethink that decision. . . 

  • Anonymous

    In. This dress needed a little pizazz: a tasteful but eye-catching bit of jewelry, different shoes perhaps but there’s nothing real offensive here.

    Except of course those freaking hose which are out but better than a pair of obnoxious colored tights.

  • Lies L.

    I approve of this outfit – IN. She looks cute and fresh and pretty, and I like the black shoes with the white dress. I want her hair. Also, nude hose are a good good thing.

  • Anonymous

    IN please. She looks fresh and pretty. And I’m all for hose coming back.

  • http://canadiangiftguide.com/ Brittany

    In. She could’ve done more, but I’d wear it.

  • Jacqueline Wessel

    YAY, Nude hose…YAY Yes, I know I’m 3 days behind.

  • Anonymous

    OUT

  • Deborah Heath

    >>
    NUDE HOSE, BITCHES. It’s coming back, whether you’re ready for it or not.<<

    I have been ready and waiting for this since they fell out of favor. Now I can wear dresses again.  

  • Anonymous

    >>NUDE HOSE, BITCHES. It’s coming back, whether you’re ready for it or not.<<

    I've been ready and waiting since it fell out of favor. I can finally wear skirts and dresses again!

  • Anonymous

    Is that woman EVER without her false eyelashes? Also, OUT.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_66KPZ36LMHMRQOX3HIJGHRNNUA MandyM

    IN (and I like the hose)