In or Out: Tilda Swinton in Haider Ackermann

Posted on September 13, 2011

We love you, Tilda Swinton! We want to breathe your air and gaze at your coolly unnerving androgyny all day.

Tilda Swinton in Haider AckermannTilda Swinton arrives at “We Need To Talk About Kevin” Premiere at Winter Garden Theatre during the 2011 Toronto International Film Festival in Haider Ackermann.

Tilda Swinton in Haider Ackermann

Tilda Swinton in Haider Ackermann

Tilda Swinton in Haider Ackermann

But it pains us to say, we don’t love you in this. We’re two gays that love a good coat dress. We’re even two gays who can get behind a coat dress over a pair of slim pants or leggings. But honey, this is something you throw on to run to the dry cleaners to pick up the dress you were supposed to wear that night. This isn’t a coat dress; it’s a coat serving as a dress. Too bulky and sloppy-looking. Great color, though.

 

Vote Now!

 

IN! She’s TILDA SWINTON. She was BORN “IN!”

OUT! She looks like I do when I go out at 7 am to get the paper!

 


Voting on Salma Hayek’s unfortunate “Warrior Trophy Wife” look is still open, kittens.

[photo Credit: Getty, elle.com]

    • Anonymous

      She looks like a young Hugh Hefner. Out?

      • Sobaika Mirza

        My exact thought when I first saw these. 

        • Anonymous

          Me too, actually!

          • Anonymous

            Add me to the list.  Really bad belting going on there.  OUT!

            • http://twitter.com/NC_Meg Megan

              That was also my first thought! “Is she getting ready to play Hef in a biopic or something?”

      • Anonymous

        Gah! I wish I’d read the comments before I posted because Hef is exactly the person who sprang to mind. And he’s never someone to emulate – unless you want to look like a pervy old skeez.

      • http://profiles.google.com/anplica Anplica Fiore

        Amen…and not a good look for a striking lady!  Out.

    • aussiegal77

      Ooohhh…painful….OUT.

    • http://twitter.com/Verena_Hafner Verena Hafner

      I couldn’t have said it better, hence copy/paste: IN! She’s TILDA SWINTON. She was BORN “IN!”


      blog.verenahafner.com

      • Anonymous

        unquestionably in.

    • Elena

      In. She’s making it work as she does.

    • http://smalltownbigwardrobe.wordpress.com Catherine

      Shut up. It’s Swinton. IN.

    • http://profiles.google.com/phyllis.craine Phyllis Craine

      Did she come right from the hair salon?!

    • Anonymous

      Wow, this is the closest I’ve ever come to giving her an Out….Get it together girl!! In but narrowly, next time not so lucky.

      • Anonymous

        As much as I love La Swinton, she has done better than this…

    • Anonymous

      There is no IN or OUT. There is only SWINTON.

      • Anonymous

        Preach!

      • Anonymous

        Exactly.

      • Anonymous

        I agree.

        This outfit is clearly an out, however.  The only logical conclusion is that this person is not actually Tilda Swinton.

      • Sarah Dickerson

        THIS.  She’s always IN!

      • http://nobeatenpath.com Forrestblogging

        Exactly Jellybish. And the colour looks amazing on her (in these photos at least) so on a lesser mortal that would probably scrape it in anyway.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IHWCJIMARF4OOW6PQZQS3RFOOA JillK

      Oh good lord. What the hell is she doing out in my grandfather’s silk bathrobe?? It’s ugly. It’s ill-fitted. It’s unflattering. It’s sloppy. It’s a big, fat mess. I’m sorry, but no amount of Tilda love could turn this atrocity into an IN for me. OUT! outoutout!

      • http://profiles.google.com/singingraisin ali meowmeow

        I entirely agree. Definite OUT.

        … But… I’ll let you go tell her. I’ll be hanging back here. She scares me more than a little.

      • http://profiles.google.com/singingraisin ali meowmeow

        I entirely agree. Definite OUT.

        … But… I’ll let you go tell her. I’ll be hanging back here. She scares me more than a little.

      • Anonymous

        Agree – and it looked fabulous on the runway in white.  Too bad – she really swung and missed on this one.

    • Anonymous

      100% agree with your comments. Great color. Sloppy garment. 

    • http://twitter.com/ReignOfApril The Real Me

      Why wasn’t it tailored for her?  It’s so sloppy and makes her look frumpy and much bigger than she is.

      • Anonymous

        Is she wearing makeup? I thought I read somewhere that she never wears makeup, even on the red carpet. 

        • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

          She’s obviously wearing a bit of blush and a lip gloss, but not much more.  With her skin, she doesn’t need much more!  She must avoid the sun like the plague!

    • Anonymous

      sigh….OUT

    • http://profiles.google.com/trashilove { edi } ilovetrash

      gorgeous color, doesnt fit.

      • Anonymous

        Oh my God, I was THISCLOSE to saying I was getting a Man Who Fell To Earth vibe from her hair and makeup. 

      • Anonymous

        Oh my God, I was THISCLOSE to saying I was getting a Man Who Fell To Earth vibe from her hair and makeup. 

    • Anonymous

      sadly…OUT.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002173039987 Deb B-Rocker

      Have to say it: IN    —   this is what I think of when I think of Tilda Swinton. Odd outfits that somehow work b/c it’s on Tilda. And wow!! that color matches her eyes???!?!?!? amazing…….

    • Anonymous

      It pains me to say this, but…OUT. I love the color, but it’s just too sloppy. If it had been a bit more fitted/tailored, I think that would have worked better. 

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_C65IT4K6RYN4TWRMFJOI3VUDAI Olechka Milashka

      I never get Tilda and I especially don’t get her now.  I think she forgot to take off her coat for the photographs.  OUT

      • Anonymous

        I have to agree with you, although it is very hard to admit this among the crowd here.  I try to appreciate her for the unique being that she is.  But she is just too far out there for me to understand.  Abut 1/3 of the time I can find her “interesting” even if it is not to my taste, but in this case, when she looks rumpled and bulky, she is just OUT.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_P2A3RYQVKJZKZNKS5W2ASCAKSI Lynne

      Bath robe!!!!   …. OUT

      • Anonymous

        I was just about to say the same thing — bathrobe!!  Out!!

      • Anonymous

        I was just about to say the same thing — bathrobe!!  Out!!

    • Anonymous

      Out.  Beautiful color.  I would not mind having a robe that color and fabric to go out to get the paper in the morning, but its not for the red carpet.

    • Anonymous

      Oh no, Tilda left home in her bathrobe!  But she does have a fabulous bathrobe, in a beautiful color.  I give it an In if she’s on her way to the shower, an OUT anywhere else.  

    • Anonymous

      IN! Okay, I was going to say out until I realized that it reminded me of a post-modern smoking jacket, or something. Now I can’t help loving it, even though I know it’s wrong.

    • Grace Ritt

      Out. That is a silk robe.

    • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

      I love Tilda, I really do. The rules of mere mortals do not apply. But it’s a bathrobe. I cannot get behind a bathrobe, I am sorry. Ms. Swinton will have to cope with being OUT for once in her life. 

    • Anonymous

      A robe tied in a “bag lady chic” manner?  Out.

    • Anonymous

      Well, she IS Tilda Swinton, and that counts for a lot. The thing looks like she’s swimming in it, though. It’s huge on her, too huge I think. So, out I’m afraid. 

      Love the color, though, and the pants and shoes.

    • Anonymous

      It’s too sloppy. But damn, she’s gorgeous. Out Tilda–next time don’t wear a bag. We like to see you.

    • Anonymous

      do we see silent apology in her eyes?  I think she knows she’s o.u.t.

    • Valerie Owens

      IN is in her name… SwINton.

    • Anonymous

      The Thrifters blog LOVES this woman….. she is beyond STYLE…
      http://www.thethrifters.net

    • Judy_J

      Sorry, Tilda.  OUT.  That coat dress is just sloppy.  I’m particularly disturbed by the lapel which is not lying in its proper place.  I do love the color, though.

    • http://profiles.google.com/shannonlstewart Shannon Stewart

      It does feel disturbingly like a VS robe… OUT

    • Anonymous

      I want to straighten her collar.  And what is that thing she’s holding in her left hand?  It matches the coat dress.  Is it a hood?  or a cape?  or a purse?  or the extra fabric which they included, just in case, and she decided to bring it with her as a seat cover?  BTW, OUT!

      • http://profiles.google.com/hawkeye1978 Kristin Hanson

        Exactly the questions I was formulating.  I am concerned that the extra flouncy thing might be attached, but I am unsure.

      • http://profiles.google.com/hawkeye1978 Kristin Hanson

        Exactly the questions I was formulating.  I am concerned that the extra flouncy thing might be attached, but I am unsure.

    • Anonymous

      Oh Ms. Swinton… I love your unearthly being looks but this looks like Hef’s bathrobe.

      It pains me so, but OUT. 

      • Anonymous

         My first thought was of the Hef robe too.  Oh, Tilda, why are you putting me through the agony of having to say this?  OUT.

      • http://profiles.google.com/trashilove { edi } ilovetrash

        i thought you said hell’s bathrobe, what you wear when you make waffles in hell’s kitchen.

        either way, it’s about the same.

      • http://profiles.google.com/trashilove { edi } ilovetrash

        i thought you said hell’s bathrobe, what you wear when you make waffles in hell’s kitchen.

        either way, it’s about the same.

        • Anonymous

          Hell’s Bathrobe, LOL!

          This look shall forever be dubbed as such.

          The minions apologize in advance for their inappropriate remarks and laughter toward the Goddess Swinton, T-Lo.

    • Melanie S.

      Looks like a cross between a smoking jacket and a housecoat.

    • Melanie S.

      Looks like a cross between a smoking jacket and a housecoat.

    • http://stitchingincircles.etsy.com Tina

      too Hefnerish for Swinton. OUT!

    • http://stitchingincircles.etsy.com Tina

      too Hefnerish for Swinton. OUT!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1414091387 Florrie Brafman

      I’ve heard SWINTON talk about the film festival that they have in her small town, which includes screenings that everybody attends in their pajamas.  Maybe she’s become convinced that all film festivals should be attended in robe and pjs.

    • Anonymous

      Oh, Tilda, Tilda, Tilda. I has a sad.

    • Eclectic Mayhem

      That colour really is fabulous on her though so it pains me to say – out.

      Can’t do it! The girl is, was and will always be IN

    • Anonymous

      I love her, but OUT – she’s a Keebler elf!

    • Anonymous

      I love her, but OUT – she’s a Keebler elf!

    • http://twitter.com/RobertSanchez36 Robert Sanchez

      If the coat were tightly belted, it would look sharper. The shoes are nice, but don’t add anything to increase the look’s ‘in’ potential. As is, though, I hate to say, out.

    • Anonymous

      Tildaaaaaaa IN

    • Anonymous

      Tildaaaaaaa IN

    • Joyce VG

      OUT! But omg her eyes are piercing my soul.

    • Joyce VG

      OUT! But omg her eyes are piercing my soul.

    • Anonymous

      I love the shoes! Everything else is way OUT!

    • Aly Light

      Gah. OUT.

    • Anonymous

      Oy. Out. But her bathrobe is nicer than mine.

    • http://twitter.com/DresswithAplomb Aplomb Pomilio

      oh yeah, no. Out.

    • Anonymous

      “Too bulky and sloppy-looking”

      Yeah, sadly OUT.

    • Anonymous

      Out.  Ditto the Fashion Godfathers.

    • Anonymous

      Out.  Ditto the Fashion Godfathers.

    • Anonymous

      It looks as if she will enter the venue and hand her trench to the coat-check girl. It’s outerwear. There should be a real outfit underneath it.

      Also, too big and blousy, totally killing the whole “long, lean, androgynous” look she usually rocks. MAYBE she could get away with it if she really, truly was wearing a raincoat, but it’s doubleplus ungood as a dress.

      Sadly, gotta give it an OUT.

    • Anonymous

      It looks as if she will enter the venue and hand her trench to the coat-check girl. It’s outerwear. There should be a real outfit underneath it.

      Also, too big and blousy, totally killing the whole “long, lean, androgynous” look she usually rocks. MAYBE she could get away with it if she really, truly was wearing a raincoat, but it’s doubleplus ungood as a dress.

      Sadly, gotta give it an OUT.

    • Anonymous

      Sob. 

      OUT.It’s a luxurious bathrobe!

    • Anonymous

      Sob. 

      OUT.It’s a luxurious bathrobe!

      • Anonymous

        oh good gawd, yes, it’s pinned!  But I think pinned to the ‘jacket’ to keep the belt from wandering to dead center.  I think I”m choking.

    • margaret meyers

      So, she woke up and wanted to stay in her jammies all day.  She’s Tilda Swinton for pity’s sake. IN!

    • margaret meyers

      So, she woke up and wanted to stay in her jammies all day.  She’s Tilda Swinton for pity’s sake. IN!

    • http://twitter.com/yup_lester lester

      She is never out!!! IN IN IN IN INININI

    • http://twitter.com/yup_lester lester

      She is never out!!! IN IN IN IN INININI

    • Anonymous

      On anyone else an automatic out, but on SWINTON? You said it, she was born IN.

    • http://twitter.com/MandySCG MandyJane

      Out, looks like a baggy bathrobe.

    • Anonymous

      Fantastic color. Poor fit (unless, God forbid, it’s SUPPOSED to fit like that.) Love the cut and color of her hair. Is she wearing makeup? IN.

    • http://magical-sword.blogspot.com Photographer_Leia

      Her eyes are stunning with this dress color though.  You’ve got to give her that.

    • http://twitter.com/qrter Alexander Peterhans

      Yikes. She looks like she’s ready to punch anyone who comes too close. OUT.

    • Anonymous

      I am very sorry to say that this looks chip in a chip way and is therefor Out and I can’t believe I just wrote that.  I swear, T Lo, if you also show us a sorry-looking Cate Blanchett at this event the world may start to go dark….

    • Anonymous

      I can’t in good conscience give this an in. OUT, and fix your lapel.

    • MilaXX

      I love Tilda, but the coat needs to be more from fitting up top. This looks like a giant smoking jacket. OUT

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_6PUVFQ7YCZZFZRIER6BEJ4HVYE Amye

      Ew…. sorry Tilda.  This is an Out.

      And yeah, that *does* look like Hugh Hefner’s smoking jacket.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_6QOQTTDCU5YU266LX2Q7NYSKRA E

      Can Tilda BE out? I think not.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lauren-Jean-St-Martin/504251897 Lauren Jean St. Martin

      Out.

    • Anonymous

      Someone please photoshop Tilda into any or all of the Miss Universe National Costumes, just for shits and giggles.

    • Anonymous

      Agreed. C’mon Tilda, we’ve seen better. OUT.

    • Anonymous

      OUT. But the color does play up her amazing eyes.

    • mc90

      Tilda is Tilda is fearless is in.

      –Emmylou

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1344922354 Eric Scheirer Stott

      That would be beautiful casual wear at home- but not for an event. She looks like she’s waiting in a bedroom to seduce an innocent young boy.

      • Anonymous

        I do think this is sexier than her usual wear. Maybe because one must avert the eyes from the garment and concentrate on her amazing eyes? Set in that austerely amazing head?

    • http://joyouslifesf.wordpress.com Kiltdntiltd

      “with her hair in a net, in a towel wringing wet, I don’t care! IN is where, she should be!”
      (with appropriate apologies to the actual lyricist)

    • Anonymous

      out, its a robe.  *sigh*

    • Anonymous

      out, its a robe.  *sigh*

    • Anonymous

      IN. Tilda Swinton.

    • Anonymous

      IN. Tilda Swinton.

    • Anonymous

      Out. It is lacking that Swinton fierceness.

    • Anonymous

      Oh, no, Tilda.  You disappoint.  Going out in your dressing gown?  Even for you, that’s a no-no.

    • http://twitter.com/purpleflamingo4 Natasha Ann

      Yuck! She’s Tilda Swinton… she should know when she looks like she just rolled out of bed. OUT!!!

    • Anonymous

      OUT, She’s looking like Hugh Heffner here.

      • Anonymous

        Yes to this. I wrote something similar before I read your comment.

      • Anonymous

        Yes to this. I wrote something similar before I read your comment.

      • Anonymous

        Yes to this. I wrote something similar before I read your comment.

    • Anonymous

      I’m sorry, but that woman scares the shit out of me. But regardless, you never go out in a satin bathrobe. OUT.

    • Brooke Unti

      Of course it’s way too big! Note the safety pin hiding behind her belt in the close-up. Much as I love her, it’s an out for me.

    • Anonymous

      La Swinton is never out, never wrong when she brings “it.”  Sadly, I don’t think she brings the “it” with this one.  Even so, I cannot do it.  Swinton is in, but not in all caps.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=27432316 Ally Monge

      Can I have her flawless complexion please? Hideous dress, but God that woman has a deal with the devil for that skin. OUT

    • Anonymous

      She looks like a middle age man in a bath robe.  Alas, she is out.  It pains me to say so.  

      • Anonymous

        Her resemblance to an insanely sleek middle aged man is part of her appeal, I thiink. (Though she IS out, IMO).

    • Anonymous

      Want to say exactly what bitterk below said.  But bitterk said it best.   OUT. 

    • irielle

      I’m willing to accept a world of difference from Tilda but this bathrobe is OUT.

    • Anonymous

      Look what this color does to her eyes.  Beautiful.  The outfit is a catastrophe, but the color is spectacular.

    • http://robot-heart.tumblr.com heartbot

      It’s like a bathrobe over leggings. What?

    • http://profiles.google.com/clumsy.chord k c

      Tilda may have been born in but she’s visiting the dark side. This is a definite OUT. (The size? The lapels? The sloppy looking seams up the arms? The whole entire thing?)

    • http://profiles.google.com/clumsy.chord k c

      Tilda may have been born in but she’s visiting the dark side. This is a definite OUT. (The size? The lapels? The sloppy looking seams up the arms? The whole entire thing?)

    • http://profiles.google.com/clumsy.chord k c

      Tilda may have been born in but she’s visiting the dark side. This is a definite OUT. (The size? The lapels? The sloppy looking seams up the arms? The whole entire thing?)

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Catherine-Rhodes/602850414 Catherine Rhodes

      Gotta disagree on this one, guys. I think she looks true to herself and her unique esthetic. The problem is that sans makeup and jewelry, it does give off a “bathrobey” feel. But she still looks chic enough for me to vote IN.

    • Anonymous

      I was hoping something fabulous was hiding under her over-sized coat.

    • Anonymous

      OUT! She looks like I do when I go out at 7 am to get the paper!
      That line says it all!!!!

    • Sara__B

      As others have said, she’s neither in nor out. She’s Swinton. But she’s close to OUT this time — my dad had that bathrobe and that hair (but not the heels) on many a Sunday monrning.

    • Anonymous

      So sad. So close. OUT. With her aesthetic, every detail has to be right.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Micaela-Cannon/1465504041 Micaela Cannon

      Awful.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

      Out.  But I do LOVE the shoes.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

      Out.  But I do LOVE the shoes.

    • Anonymous

      Are her eyes really that green? They are mesmerizing.

      I wish I could see this coat on the model. Is it supposed to be so bulky? That’s what’s throwing me off — Tilda plays around with proportions a lot, but I seldom think she looks sloppy, and this is what this coat/dress is doing to her. Tilda, YOU are never out. But the coat/dress is out.

    • Anonymous

      Are her eyes really that green? They are mesmerizing.

      I wish I could see this coat on the model. Is it supposed to be so bulky? That’s what’s throwing me off — Tilda plays around with proportions a lot, but I seldom think she looks sloppy, and this is what this coat/dress is doing to her. Tilda, YOU are never out. But the coat/dress is out.

    • Anonymous

      Her name is swINton it is all in the name, IN!

    • http://profiles.google.com/sleepneeded Greg Polansky

      OUT

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Emily-Smith/12431153 Emily Smith

      In.  The color is le perfect.  I turn a blind eye to the fit since all my eye is drawn to is the shoulders and up.

    • Jenna Gordon

      so very out. she looks like she just got out of the shower. where the hell are her gays and why did they let her out in public wearing this?

    • Anonymous

      OUT. It’s a look that only Tilda Swinton could wear. And even she can’t wear it.

    • Dave Carter

      Sorry – I always have to give her an IN – it may not be the best thing she has worn, but she still looks like Tilda Swinton in a fabulous way. IN IN IN!

    • Anonymous

      I love Tilda, but honey, no. Just no. Way too big for you, for one thing. OUT.

    • Mary McClelland

      Love her.  Love Haider Ackermann.  Hate the look. Meh.  OUT. 

    • Mary McClelland

      Love her.  Love Haider Ackermann.  Hate the look. Meh.  OUT. 

    • http://twitter.com/jessie_liz88 Jessica Rodgers

      OUT! Even by Swinton standards.

    • http://www.myblackfriendsays.com myblackfriendsays

      Hmmm…Present?

    • Anonymous

      You rock that gender bender shit, GRRL!  IN.  Tilda has no rules.  Tilda needs no rules.

    • Anonymous

      Just picture Hugh Hefner wearing this. Like so:

      [IMG]http://i53.tinypic.com/21cbjnq.jpg[/IMG]

      OUT

    • Anonymous

      It looks like she’s wearing her grandfather’s bathrobe. OUT.

    • Margot Brose

      SHE’S TILDA SWINTON. If I give her an Out, she will come and destroy me with fabulous rays. Have mercy, TLo! In!

    • Anonymous

      OUT. Nice color though and love the shoes.

    • Caitlin Gozdecki

      love the color and the hair/make up. part of me wants to give her an IN because she’s tilda, but she looks like she is drowning in that coat, and the leggings seem unnescessary…

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5LU5C262WB3Z5F4WZ6QGKXLNLE JaneM

      I think she forgot to get dressed. Like Nick Nolte. He goes out in his pajamas. And I mean out…like to the theater and such.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5LU5C262WB3Z5F4WZ6QGKXLNLE JaneM

        Hey…I put a picture in my profile…how do I make it seen?

    • Lisa

      Nope, sorry.  I just can never get on board with Tilda.  She weirds me out every time.

    • Tim Wong

      IN! She’s TILDA SWINTON. the only time she gets an out is when she decides to throw on a strapless ball/goddess/fishtail gown with a lot of sh*t on it…

    • Anonymous

      She’s amazing. She’s fierce.  But… She’s left the house in her jammies! Out.

    • Anonymous

      OUT.  There is just something completely wrong about this, beyond even what has already been mentioned…

    • Anonymous

      OUT.  There is just something completely wrong about this, beyond even what has already been mentioned…

    • Anonymous

      I was lucky enough to have seen her

      • Anonymous

        Thanks for the on-scene report.  My faith is restored. Movement makes all the difference sometimes.

        • Dee

          No problem! I live to serve Queen Tilda. ;D

    • Anonymous

      IN! She’s TILDA SWINTON. She was BORN “IN!”
      Not original, but you took the words out of my mouth.

    • http://twitter.com/jennawaterford Jennifer Ford

      First thought: “Is she wearing a bathrobe?!”

      A sad little Out.

    • C S

      so very OUT
      It looks like a bathrobe, and she looks like she just got out of the shower.  I do love her glowing skin and the tiny touch of makeup, but with that hair it just adds to the whole 1/2 dressed picture.  

    • http://twitter.com/SanjuShampur Sanju Shampur

      IN

    • Anonymous

      IN! she’s Tilda, she can do whatever she wants….

    • Anonymous

      SWINTON! is never OUT

      IN! She’s TILDA SWINTON. She was BORN “IN!” 

    • Anonymous

      Swinton could wear something ten times uglier than this and still be IN, because she transcends such mortal notions. CALL ME, TILDA.

    • http://twitter.com/asciident Melissa Della

      OUT! Eek. Maybe her suitcase got lost on the flight there. Right? Maybe?

    • Anonymous

      Hugh Hefner looks fabulous!  Tilda is  OUT

    • Anonymous

      Screw the dress-coat-droat. I’m curious what’s going on in the back of the shoes.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3CGY36NG25QFIZQOLMH7SQTKLU andrew

      Yeah, its an OUT.  As you say, the color is fab, but that’s it for positives.

    • http://twitter.com/jennsaysmeow Fifi LaRoux

      Out. So very out.

    • Anonymous

      Clothes that make skinny people look like bloated, chemo patients are always OUT.

    • Anonymous

      OUT.

    • Anonymous

      In from the neck up.  So very out below.  I got satin bathrobe.

    • Anonymous

      I want to give her an IN just for her amazing skin. But I’m distracted by that FRICKING COLLAR WOULD SOMEONE PLEASE STRAIGHTEN IT???

       

    • Anonymous

      I’m not worthy to whip-stitch her granny panties. Some are just beyond this kind of critique.

    • Anonymous

      Out. I think Hef wants his smoking jacket back.

    • http://karensbooksandchocolate.blogspot.com/ Karenlibrarian

      Beautiful color, but sadly, OUT.  It’s just too baggy and shapeless.

    • Anonymous

      OUT! But…I can imagine her striding down the street in it and maybe it’s not really an out. Maybe it’s just an OUT photo.

    • Anonymous

      This is so close to the line, I am tempted to let her coast to ‘in’ on hair, makeup, shoes & yes, even leggings & color.

      But that would be wrong. 

      Out

      She knows how to do better (though really, as if she cares for my opinion? Piffle!)
       

    • Anonymous

      OUT. The only thing good about it is that it’s SWINTON.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BA6BTBV4V3MQRX6K2HDEL7Y7TU MerridithK

      You are so much better than this, Tilda Swinton!  OUT.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BA6BTBV4V3MQRX6K2HDEL7Y7TU MerridithK

      You are so much better than this, Tilda Swinton!  OUT.

    • aimee_parrott

      swINton!

    • Anonymous

      Way OUT.

    • Anonymous

      She is Tilda, and she was born IN, but since she looks like a boxer heading for the ring, in this look she is OUT.  For the first time. And, I hope, the last.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IQLI7NTDM22M7DLPNE7HWMH25A Al

      I think its bold, odd, off and a fucking housecoat, but I still think its fabulous. IN yesterday, tomorrow and forever.

    • Vaniljekjeks

      As much as I love her, this bathrobe is not flattering to the figure at all.  Out. Sorry. 

    • http://twitter.com/VicksieDo Vickie Lord

      Bathrobe, OUT

    • Anonymous

      Love her, hate what she’s wearing. (But as always, eager to see whatever is next. Even the stuff I hate is interesting, at least, so heaven bless her!!)
      OUT

    • http://profiles.google.com/paperpunchaddiction Kim Score

      would it kill her to wear some make-up?  lord knows she needs it.

    • Anonymous

      OUT. This looks like my Victoria’s Secret silk robe that’s hanging behind my bedroom door. Don’t get me wrong; I love my silk robe and it makes me feel fabulous, but I’m not Tilda Swinton and she’s not me.

    • http://www.facebook.com/shawn.eric.hill Shawn Hill

      OUT! Tragic proportions, tragic because the color is so wonderful on her.

    • Anonymous

      In – She looks like Tilda Swinson: In, In, In.

    • Anonymous

      I know she’s a “style icon” and we’re all supposed to swoon whenever she appears in anything, but I refuse to swoon when she wears a bathrobe and leggings. OUT.

    • Anonymous

      I know she’s a “style icon” and we’re all supposed to swoon whenever she appears in anything, but I refuse to swoon when she wears a bathrobe and leggings. OUT.

    • kim i

      it’s tilda.  she doesn’t NEED to be “in.”  and make-up?  tilda with make-up is cate blanchett.  nothing wrong with it, but there’s already one of those.  tilda’s eyes, the angular lines of her features, her clean and clear sculptural face needs no mortal enhancement.  lmao.

    • Anonymous

      Ugh, OUT

    • http://dearauntnettie.com/museum dancinfool

      Out. Clearly this is a bathrobe.

    • Anonymous

      OUT> Ugly, ill-fitting, and sad. What has happened, Tilda?

    • oohsparkley!

      Out.  Even Tilda and Ackerman can get it wrong. Although, in those heels she’s too cool to be just getting the paper. Maybe she has something fabulous under the coat?

    • Anonymous

      Face: gorgeous.  Hair: fabulous.  Clothes: what?  Satin too big trench coat?

    • Anonymous

      She needs a pipe, and Barbie Benton.

      • Anonymous

        I was just going to say that. “Hef, you better get back to the mansion! Heidi’s going to be so mad that you missed curfew.”

    • http://www.facebook.com/sorana.tarmu Sorana Tarmu

      Bathrobe all the way, sadly. So OUT.

    • vmcdanie

      You tricksters. I always look at the page before the jump and say “___________ is automatically in.” And then I click thru and behold.

      You are right, it’s a great color especially for her. But OUT. These are plus-size pajamas.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1303837450 Lauren Dorsee Dillon

      OUT. Oversized smoking jacket/lounging robe.

    • Anonymous

      IN

    • Patricia Biswanger

      OUT.

    • Anonymous

      I usually love her, but OUT, from head to knee. The pants and shoes look fine.

    • http://www.facebook.com/charlotte.horseman Charlotte Horseman

      Out!  Looking way too much like my father in law on sunday morning – just without the wrinkles.

    • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

      I can’t do in or out as regards Tilda Swinton.  She is another who is so rare and unique, she is above ins and outs.  Yes, she has looked better, but she’s beyond in or out.  That’s my opinion, and I’m sticking to it!

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1017585103 Kanani Fong

        Agreed. She’s just pretty incredible, and I’m willing to overlook a really bad shot.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LIISVMJ5GVCU4FT4DYXI6Q3INA sdreamer82

      Umm yeah OUT.  I agree with the others, looks like she borrowed the smoking jacket from Hugh Hefner. Wrong fabric. Coat dresses need to have good structure and fabric choice to work.

    • Anonymous

      awww, man. no. out

    • Anonymous

      Out.  Color isn’t enough.  You need style too.

    • Pat Pending

      TLo, sweetnesses, do you recall saying this?: “First Iman, then Cate, and now, Queen Helen of Fuckinfantastica has taken a wrong turn. No reports on Swinton yet, but the world waits to see if she can save us all.”
      First the scientists, then the economists, and now the fashionistas. We’re screwed. Proceed now to the next available exit and/or minibar.

    • http://profiles.google.com/ballinger.jl Jessica Ballinger

      OUT.  The only good thing about it is it sets her eyes off really nicely.

    • http://tinroofpress.wordpress.com/ J

      I don’t even care. She can wear a sack. I LOVE her.