In or Out: Emma Stone in Dolce & Gabbana

Posted on September 06, 2011

If we were Emma Stone’s best gay pals, we know exactly how we’d react if she came out in front of photographers looking like this:

Emma Stone in Dolce & Gabbana
Emma Stone at “The Help” Photocall during 37th Deauville American Film Festival in France.

Emma Stone in Dolce & GabbanaWe’d shout “SWEETIE, NO!!!!” and then leap in front of the cameras like a Secret Service agent taking a bullet for the president.

Emma Stone in Dolce & Gabbana
Emma Stone in Dolce & Gabbana

Why such a melodramatic response (aside from the fact that it’s fun)? Because a best gay pal would never allow his gal pal to appear in public when she’s obviously either depressed or in the throes of her period and doesn’t give a shit what she looks like.

Then, we’d usher her behind the scrim, pull her hair back into a neat ponytail, grap a sassy belt off a passerby, unroll the sleeves, tie the little pussy bow, force a Midol down her throat and then lightly slap her and say “Everyone wants to be you or do you. Now get out there and be a STAR.”

But alas, we weren’t there to save her from herself.

 

Vote Now!

 

IN! Sometimes a girl just doesn’t give a fuck, T Lo.

OUT! Did she sleep in that thing?

 

Voting on Selma Blair’s salute to hospital scrubs is still open, darlings.

 

[Photo Credit: Francois Durand/Getty Images]

Tags: , , ,

  • Anonymous

    Out for all of the reasons you said.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jude-Brown/1350939326 Jude Brown

      Is it just me, or does that pleated skirt make a nice skinny actress look as though her hips are wide receivers?

      • http://twitter.com/pinup_ghoul Pinup Ghoul

        The combination of the blouson top and the pleated skirt do tend to give it a boxy shape. I think it could have been just killer if it had been seamed and fitted to the waist. It would have a more delicate quality, too, as opposed to  a business-casual feel.

  • http://twitter.com/warontara Tara

    Oh no..honey. I know Jim Carey is creepily lusting after you, but working AGAINST your good looks is not the answer! Out.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=816120314 Chason Dailey

    Can I hire y’all to just do that to me every morning?

    • Anonymous

      That was almost word-for-word my first thought!

  • Ruth Preston

    The combination of the rolled-up sleeves and the tags on the shoes proves it: SHE HAS NO GAYS. Bless.

    • http://profiles.google.com/denise.alden Denise Alden

      Yikes, those tags!  OUT.

    • http://www.facebook.com/CatherineKatz Catherine Katz

      I was thinking how much I liked the shoes, then I read your comment, Ruth!  Dang if there aren’t tags on those shoes!  For that alone, Out.

    • http://twitter.com/1carmelita 1carmelita

      Good eye, I totally missed the tags!

    • Anonymous

      Maybe she has gays who don’t like to shop.  Those are my gays.  They could give a shit what I’m wearing most of the time.

  • Anonymous

    Out–it’s a great dress, but she does look like she pulled it on because the door rang while she was in the shower. She’s not ready to go out yet. But cute shoes.

  • Anonymous

    i am feeling contrary today so i vote in. i think the look is cute  and love the shoes. a belt and better hair would have upped the look but i like  the casual take.

    • Anonymous

      I quite agree. It doesn’t actually inspire the horror it seems to have engendered in the others. I mean, I think she’s fabulous, so she automatically elevates everything she touches, but it’s really not bad. I covet the shoes (sans tags, bien sur). And her hair is a tad limp.

      • Anonymous

        I agree too. The only thing that reallly bugs me is the tags on the soles of shoes. Oh and the scraggly hair. But I’ll still give her the IN.

  • Anonymous

    I…am strangely unbothered by this.

    Is it awesome? Of course not. But I think the skirt length is great on her, and I don’t mind the hair. I’m giving her a lukewarm IN.

    • Anonymous

       Yeah, same here.  But maybe I’m biased because I adore her so much.

      • Isadora Paiva

        Agreed with both. I think she looks fresh, though not great, so lukewarm IN. I might be biased because I think she’s awesome, but mostly because the very negative TLo comments made me immediately go “What? It’s certainly not that bad”, which solidified my positive response which could have been swayed towards the negative by less forceful commentary.

        • http://beautyforrealgirls.blogspot.com/ accidental housewife

          Yes, I’m with you. The boys’ reaction is extreme. Get rid of the bow altogether, and scrape the tags off the shoes. She has a funky, hippie vibe about her, so I don’t expect her to be perfectly pulled together, especially in a dress like this. Clean up this look too much and she’ll look like she wants to be Taylor Swift.

          A big IN from me.

    • Anonymous

       Yeah, same here.  But maybe I’m biased because I adore her so much.

  • Anonymous

    Oh no!  How you can you permit yourself to go on a red, er blue carpet looking like that!  So OUT.  

  • http://twitter.com/bredalot Breda Smith

    …I am so bad at details. I looked at this and went, “Huh? Cute dress. I know The Rules say a girl this fair-skinned shouldn’t wear white, but I think she’s pulling it off.” And this is why I will never be a stylist. (Belts are basically beyond me.)

  • Victoria Sharoyan

    Completely disagree. Sure, they caught her with a couple of less-than-enthused expressions, but I find the outfit head-to-toe adorable. As for the period jokes, Emma Stone’s got enough sass to say no to any stylist insisting on putting her in a delicate white number during her time of the month.

  • Anonymous

    She looks as if she weren’t fully dressed, but someone yelled “go!” and she did.

    At least she didn’t forget her shoes and lipstick to put on in the car.

  • Meredith Blixt

    While I agree with all your points, boys, I give her an IN because it’s kicky, the shoes are awesome despite the tags, I love her, and I’m scared if I criticize she’ll go blond again.

  • Vaniljekjeks

     Emma Stone is gorgeous and has fantastic presence.  She DESPERATELY needs gays.  Out.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Well, the shoes aren’t bad. The rest is ho-hum.

  • Anonymous

    Wow, tough one.  Cause I think she looks cute but a little unkempt.  I think she’d look better with your changes, definitely.  And I don’t think your changes take it into uncomfortable territory (seriously, I 6 week postpartum mom should NOT be forcing her body into what Selma Blair is doing – i know it’s her job, but we really expect too much – she should be comfortable, for pete’s sake, particularly if she is (and I hope she is) nursing).  So I sort of want to give her a lukewarm in, becasue it’s not terrible and you can see the glimmer of what could be.  

    But instead I’ll give her the out.  Because what it would take to move this look from ok to fab is not too onerous.  

  • Anonymous

    OUT. 

  • http://twitter.com/RobertSanchez36 Robert Sanchez

    She needs to stay away from white altogether, she’s too porcelain-skinned to wear it. Hair bad, shoes wrong. Out. 

  • http://twitter.com/PsychicMuppet Bitsy Carver

    Yeah, she could use a sassy belt but I think you’re being a little harsh. She’s still very cute. IN

    • Anonymous

      Seconded.

    • Anonymous

      Seconded.

  • Lauren Maier

    OUT.  
    The skirt is too short and she looks really washed out.  Go home, honey, try again.  

  • Anonymous

    My eyes hurt from the glow

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BCWREI3XJ6YMYJBOBI5ZUXD53E Jury

    I agree with TLo’s recommended changes (except, maybe, the ponytail because I love her hair). BUT, I feel like period can’t possibly be the reason for the lack of attention to detail ’cause I can’t imagine a woman wearing that much white when her time of the month is at all an issue.

    But yeah, this could’ve been so much better if it weren’t so sloppy. Out.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BCWREI3XJ6YMYJBOBI5ZUXD53E Jury

    I agree with TLo’s recommended changes (except, maybe, the ponytail because I love her hair). BUT, I feel like period can’t possibly be the reason for the lack of attention to detail ’cause I can’t imagine a woman wearing that much white when her time of the month is at all an issue.

    But yeah, this could’ve been so much better if it weren’t so sloppy. Out.

  • scottyf

    First pic: I wanna know why J Lo and her booty crashed the photo shoot? Dayumn! I got Sir Mix A Lot playing in stereo in my brain.

  • scottyf

    First pic: I wanna know why J Lo and her booty crashed the photo shoot? Dayumn! I got Sir Mix A Lot playing in stereo in my brain.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

    OUT.  I could have mustered an IN but those black hanging ribbon things are making my eye twitch.  Either tie the pussy bow or take the damn thing off! 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

    OUT.  I could have mustered an IN but those black hanging ribbon things are making my eye twitch.  Either tie the pussy bow or take the damn thing off! 

  • http://twitter.com/mdlnzppl Madeline Zappala

    I think she looks good! IN

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QA5N7E3V45GRANLIXDPR6EGAQE dsgv

    Yo Emma, don’t go all Julia Roberts on me.

  • Judy_J

    Could be a cute little dress, but it’s a total mess.  She looks like she just got out of bed.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    That dress is not flattering at all. In fact, it is so unflattering, that in the first picture, my eye went to the great ass sticking into the frame. Whomever that ass belongs too is one lucky girl.

    –GothamTomato

    • Anonymous

      Good Eye, Ms Tomato!  I hadn’t even noticed.

  • Anonymous

    Can I just say, MWAH!!! You guys make me laugh. Every. Single. Day. Honestly, you truly perform a public service with these posts.

    Oh, and she’s definitely OUT.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QCJEZMOV4VYMXC5WJALLZNYEB4 Mari Rose

    I don’t know, TLo. I’m getting a JBF vibe from her. Just look at that shit-eating grin. The tousled hair. The dress partially undone and ever-so-slightly askew.

    JBF is always IN.

    • http://twitter.com/IslandMo Mo Wilson

      you see what I see

    • http://twitter.com/IslandMo Mo Wilson

      you see what I see

    • http://twitter.com/IslandMo Mo Wilson

      you see what I see

    • Anonymous

      Amen to that.

      • http://beautyforrealgirls.blogspot.com/ accidental housewife

        Hallelujah!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=20401589 Michelle Jackson

    My biggest problem here is the price tag under her shoes. Ew.

  • Valerie Owens

    Hahahaha! Oh you guys make me laugh :-) And OUT

  • Anonymous

    While I agree with (and laughed at) everything you said, I think she’s adorable.  She’s my new favorite actress of the under thirty crowd.  I think just the hair brushing would help.  She’s smiling pretty well for someone who’s depressed.

  • Anonymous

    I didn’t know she was 7 feet tall.

    Lukewarm in, a bit twee and unfinished, as you said.

  • Margot Brose

    To rely on cliche, she looks really effortless and pretty here. The studded shoes + the wispy dress is nifty. IN~

  • http://twitter.com/sully27 sully27

    I’d also recommend taking the price stickers off of the bottom of the shoes.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Aldona-Dye/216300255 Aldona Dye

    Seriously??  IN.  The sleeves bother me a little bit, but the dress would look so stuffy if the bow were tied, and she’s wearing killer shoes, and the black and white looks great with her hair, and the dress itself is totally cute.  I don’t understand the violent reaction to this in the slightest.

  • aussiegal77

    Yuck. OUT.

  • aussiegal77

    Yuck. OUT.

  • http://twitter.com/LaurenJeanSTM Lauren St. Martin

    In! Sometimes you guys are just way to picky. Though all of those would have been an improvement….

  • http://twitter.com/LaurenJeanSTM Lauren St. Martin

    In! Sometimes you guys are just way to picky. Though all of those would have been an improvement….

  • Anonymous

    I think she looks adorbs.

  • Anonymous

    I think she looks adorbs.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  I actually really like the dress…but her zero-for-effort cancels out its cuteness.  I do like her lip color, but that’s the only thing that doesn’t look half- (or quarter-) assed.

  • bookish

    I don’t think she looks that bad… The sleeves are terrible and I don’t know why she would leave the black pieces hanging like that, but still…she looks fine to me. And I envy her perfect, smooth skin.

  • bookish

    I don’t think she looks that bad… The sleeves are terrible and I don’t know why she would leave the black pieces hanging like that, but still…she looks fine to me. And I envy her perfect, smooth skin.

  • Anonymous

    I think she looks cute! IN! So there!!

  • Anonymous

    You’re so right.  She’s clearly having a ‘fat day’.  I’m not a fan of the white dress against her pale skin either.  OUT.

  • http://profiles.google.com/misslauraschultz Laura Schultz

    Now THAT’S a sad sash. OUT

  • Anonymous

    I think she is boring Nina!  Neither in nor out, just “Meh.”

  • Anonymous

    I love her, but the proportions of the dress are all wrong, especially with the shoes, which are great, but not with that floaty dress.  Hate the rolled up sleeve.  Hair looks cute messy, but not with this dress.  Hate to sayit, but OUT.

  • Anonymous

    IN!  I agree with your sentiments about a belt and rolling down the sleeves, but I rather like the casually mussed hair and the untied bow and overall thinks she looks adorbs.

  • Anonymous

    IN. It’s a pretty dress with a great length. Rolled-up sleeves were a mistake, perhaps, and she does need a belt. Shoes are great, but how do you forget to take off the tags? I like her hair and makeup. But mostly what sells this for me is her attitude–I love the shit-eating grin. That will carry you in any situation. 

  • Anonymous

    I like this look.  Its a photo call, not a red carpet,  She could have combed her hair a little more, but the dress is cute and I hate pussy bows.

  • Anonymous

    IN!  Although I do love your reaction.  I suppose I’m just feeling contrary today, but I think the dress is pretty cute.

  • Anonymous

    My dears. If you are not aware that any woman on her period would RUN away from white like this, you are no way faking your preferences.
    Out, because she really deserves the rest of that treatment, even if she doesn’t need the Midol.

  • Anonymous

    I’m going for a lukewarm IN as well. It’s not great, but I don’t think it’s bad enough to warrant an out. There’s no excuse for the tags left on the shoes though. 

  • http://www.myblackfriendsays.com myblackfriendsays

    too short. and ugly. the shoes suck too. OUT.

  • http://twitter.com/IslandMo Mo Wilson

    What? She is not doing the walk of shame?

  • http://twitter.com/IslandMo Mo Wilson

    What? She is not doing the walk of shame?

  • http://twitter.com/IslandMo Mo Wilson

    What? She is not doing the walk of shame?

  • Anonymous

    Dear Emma, One teensy bit of advice from someone who is old enough to be your mother: Do not go to a red carpet event looking like  you just woke up in the bed of a man whose name you cannot remember–and still wearing the same clothes you had on when you met him. It’s not ladylike dear and I’m afraid you are OUT. (But I still think you are as cute as a button.)

  • Anonymous

    Dear Emma, One teensy bit of advice from someone who is old enough to be your mother: Do not go to a red carpet event looking like  you just woke up in the bed of a man whose name you cannot remember–and still wearing the same clothes you had on when you met him. It’s not ladylike dear and I’m afraid you are OUT. (But I still think you are as cute as a button.)

  • Anonymous

    Dear Emma, One teensy bit of advice from someone who is old enough to be your mother: Do not go to a red carpet event looking like  you just woke up in the bed of a man whose name you cannot remember–and still wearing the same clothes you had on when you met him. It’s not ladylike dear and I’m afraid you are OUT. (But I still think you are as cute as a button.)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2O3ZW6TD4PTPK6EDT7DB2XE2O4 colleen

    I think she’s kinda cute here, although her whole look seems unfinished.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2O3ZW6TD4PTPK6EDT7DB2XE2O4 colleen

    I think she’s kinda cute here, although her whole look seems unfinished.

  • http://twitter.com/#!/Space_Kitty Space Kitty

    Wow, really?  I think she looks completely and utterly adorable.

  • http://twitter.com/#!/Space_Kitty Space Kitty

    Wow, really?  I think she looks completely and utterly adorable.

  • Anonymous

    It’s sort of awful, and yet I sort of like it.
    Ix-nay on the shoes, though.

  • http://profiles.google.com/dkbbmail Dorrene BrownButterfield

    Even if sometimes a girl doesn’t give a fuck (and lord knows how true that statement is!), if you’re puttin’ yourself out there in the public, you need to at least give a damn. OUT!

  • Megan Patterson

    She can’t be on her period she’s wearing white.

  • http://twitter.com/1carmelita 1carmelita

    The waistline on her dress looks oddly high. Otherwise, I wouldn’t mind the dress too much. But please, dear, brush your hair.

  • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

    Looks like somebody’s been raiding Kitty Romano’s lingerie drawer.

    But really, I am just not bitter enough because I think she looks comfortable and cute. In.

  • margaret meyers

    I think all she needs is some help with her hair and the right accessories.  In!  I love that dress.

  • Anonymous

    Out – this dress is too short waisted to salvage. 

  • Anonymous

    Her hair is a mess.  The bow and the sleeves are sloppy… but I don’t care how many feminine hygiene commercials show otherwise, white is NOT your Go To outfit when you have your period.

  • Mariah J

    Not her dress. Washes her out. Bad hair. OUT

  • Sara__B

    Was she late? Did she have an unplanned afternoon quickie? Her styling (or lack thereof) screams “last minute rush”. IN anyway, but just barely.

  • http://profiles.google.com/trashilove { edi } ilovetrash

    why did she leave the price tags on the shoes?

  • Anonymous

    OUT! She needs you, she really needs you.

  • Anonymous

    She needs you, she Reeeeally needs you!~

  • Anonymous

    IN.  I like it.

  • Anonymous

    You know, yeah she looks sloppy and it could use a belt and god forbid there be tags on shoe, but you know she doesn’t look uncomfortable or like she doesn’t like how she looks.  She looks like she likes it.  But just because sometimes a girl doesn’t give a shit, doesn’t mean the people looking at her don’t.  So, OUT.

  • Anonymous

    yeah this isn’t so bad in my opinion.
    not perfect (far from it), but not bad enough to deserve an out
    so IN from me

  • Anonymous

    From top to toe, this feels like a “walk of shame” look.  You know the drill: Went out last night around 9 pm, freshly pressed, with the cute dress and “I’m gonna get some” shoes on.   Five Cosmos and ten hours later, the details are fuzzy.  Wake up with that hot guy you’ve been flirting with at the coffee shop.  Can’t find your belt (did you lose it at the bar or is it somewhere tangled up in these sheets? Never mind), but cut your losses so you do not have to do the awkward morning thing.  Slink back to the apartment hoping none of the neighbors will see.  Crap, the nosy lady from across the hall just did.  That’s why we’re rocking the “yeah witch, I know you saw me last night in this same outfit and I look a little worse for wear, so what of it?!?” smirk.

  • Elena

    In. Not a particularly resounding in, but I think she looks okay.

  • Anonymous

    It is a shame these poor girls can’t afford a hairbrush. I feel terrible for them!
    And I had to look twice to make sure she was NOT wearing white sheer hose. This is another example of why you should not wear a dress that matches your skin tone. OUT!

  • Joyce VG

    Ahh I see your vision.  I like the dress but this whole look could have been so much MORE.   I give her an IN. (she’s adorable)

  • Phillip Wilde

    Eh, I think she looks cute and nonchalant.  IN despite all your valid points.

  • Anonymous

    IN. Not every outfit needs a belt; celebs can experiment with different ways to finish a look, and this ends up looking casual, comfortable, and airy without it. Though leaving the bow ribbons there but not tying them WAS a step too far in that direction; tie ‘em or cut ‘em off, Emma!

  • Anonymous

    IN. Not every outfit needs a belt; celebs can experiment with different ways to finish a look, and this ends up looking casual, comfortable, and airy without it. Though leaving the bow ribbons there but not tying them WAS a step too far in that direction; tie ‘em or cut ‘em off, Emma!

  • Anonymous

    IN. Not every outfit needs a belt; celebs can experiment with different ways to finish a look, and this ends up looking casual, comfortable, and airy without it. Though leaving the bow ribbons there but not tying them WAS a step too far in that direction; tie ‘em or cut ‘em off, Emma!

  • Anonymous

    love the details on the heels and that’s about it. out.

  • Anonymous

    love the details on the heels and that’s about it. out.

  • Anonymous

    love the details on the heels and that’s about it. out.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Catherine-Rhodes/602850414 Catherine Rhodes

    IN. Although I hate short hems with skyhigh heels. Always looks trashy.

  • http://twitter.com/RozSeven Roz

    TLo, I think you’ve just created a new category for In or Out–can we call it Tweaked By a Gay? It’s when all the raw material is fine, girl just needs her hair brushed her bows tied…

    Voting OUT on Emma but must say she looks so delighted with her disheveled get-up.

  • Anonymous

    In. She looks good and like she just had a sexy romp in her limo.

  • Presumptuous Insect

    In.  I kinda like it. Simple and sweet. Often these celebrities seem so uncomfortable or unnatural in their clothes that your butt clenches just looking at them.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Your remedies would not have been enough to make this a great outfit, but they’d have improved things to borderline territory.

    That hair is most heinous of all. It’s like the anti-hair for the mood of this dress.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  Even her Fashion Godfathers couldn’t save this mess…

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=27432316 Ally Monge

    Was just thinking the shoes were the saving grace, and there she went leaving the tags on… OUT

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=27432316 Ally Monge

    Was just thinking the shoes were the saving grace, and there she went leaving the tags on… OUT

  • http://twitter.com/HotMessHousWife Sammi M

    In. Compared to most disasters you guys post about, this is NOTHING. Plus I love Emma – the only thing I see wrong is that she needs to tie the “pussy bow”.

    On a side note, can I hire you guys to do that little ritual or me every day? I think I might have to make that my motto… and put it on a t-shirt I sleep in so it’s the first thing I see when I wake up. xD

  • http://twitter.com/HotMessHousWife Sammi M

    In. Compared to most disasters you guys post about, this is NOTHING. Plus I love Emma – the only thing I see wrong is that she needs to tie the “pussy bow”.

    On a side note, can I hire you guys to do that little ritual or me every day? I think I might have to make that my motto… and put it on a t-shirt I sleep in so it’s the first thing I see when I wake up. xD

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3CGY36NG25QFIZQOLMH7SQTKLU andrew

    SO OUT!  It could have been so adorable, that dress on that girl, if only… If only she had not rolled up the sleeves. If only she had tied the little bow instead of leaving ribbons hanging down her chest.  If only she had worn a cute little belt.  If only she had done SOMETHING with her hair.  If only she had managed to find at least one piece of jewelry to wear with this.  Sigh.  

  • http://twitter.com/jennsaysmeow Fifi LaRoux

    Out. Even on her period a girl shouldn’t look like crap.

    • Anonymous

      Whew. Good thing you can’t see me today! I’m wearing sweats and a scowl.

  • Anonymous

    OUT

    she does look like she doesn’t care..so why would/should we. 

  • Anonymous

    did she pair spike-studded heels with a floaty white dress? oh you tee OUT!

  • Anonymous

    It looks like she dashed out of the house before she finished getting dressed, or she changed clothes in the car on her way over. Like the time my daughter went straight from a soccer game to a piano recital. I had to show her how to do a quick pits, face, and neck clean up in the public bathroom. So, if that’s what I think of when looking at a (most likely) professionally styled starlet, then Out.

    I think the dress is pretty cute, but it does need a belt and an overall less rumpled approach.

  • http://twitter.com/BeantownMrs Praggya R. Barretto

     The shoes + the dress = out. P.S. How rushed are you that you can’t tie those front ribbons into a bow. Seeing them dangling like that makes my eye twitch.

  • http://twitter.com/mollynoodles Molly Harrington

    OUT. Even though I love her and the shoes, minus the annoying tags, are a vast improvement on the usual RC footwear of choice. They’re quite lovely actually.

  • http://twitter.com/mollynoodles Molly Harrington

    OUT. Even though I love her and the shoes, minus the annoying tags, are a vast improvement on the usual RC footwear of choice. They’re quite lovely actually.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EYYAY25W7VS5BYCOCTK62SSUBI tw125

    My only issue is that her legs and upper arms are the same color despite the fact that she’s wearing sheer white sleeves and she doesn’t appear to be wearing hose.

  • Anonymous

    I so love Emma – she’s the cutest on all the chat shows, BUT she’s OUT here….for all the reason you state. Cute dress badly done.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1077090078 Megan Sullivan

    I don’t really think it looks that bad. In.

  • Anonymous

    IN. I knoowww, all of your suggestions would improve things greatly but she still looks super cute here. The untied bow is annoying but I’m sure she tried it and that ribbon is so light it probably would have made for a very sad and limp pussy bow.

    The tags on the shoes. Ugh.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JQSQJRAL4YYWB2OZNHNUHKZAEY Christopher

    she’s so pale,  she shouldn’t where white like that,  out

  • http://twitter.com/democracydiva Democracy Diva

    She’s been on so many goddamn photocalls for this movie, I almost don’t blame her for looking so lackluster. But the only thing I really hate is the untied black bow, so iN.

  • http://twitter.com/DaggerMitten Laur.

    Us see-through-gals should never wear items of clothing that match our skin tone…NEVER. Out!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Elaine-Lang/100000366510311 Elaine Lang

    Part of her beauty is her porcelain skin…the b/w colour scheme does her no favours.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sorana.tarmu Sorana Tarmu

    OUT indeed.

  • http://profiles.google.com/richixcore Richi Robilotto

    It looks like a female version of a man’s undone shirt and tie, no? Like the undone pussy bow and the rolled up cuffs make me think of a man’s shirt.

    Oh why not, I’ll give her an in. It’s not that bad. 

  • MilaXX

    OUT! It looks like lingerie.

  • Summer Capet

    I like it because it looks exactly how I dress (on my “dressy” days). But I also shop at thrift stores…

  • Anonymous

    TLo…you made me ink!

  • Katey Phillips

    gonna have to go against you guys and say IN. the rolled up sleeves bother me a little but other than that, i think it’s a great look. dress is so cute. hair looks fine to me, but to be honest, i have NEVER understood your guys’s stance on hair. perfectly fine hair is apparently a disaster. oh well. either way, i love the dress.

  • Josefina Madariaga

    So OUT. Love the shoes, though.

  • Josefina Madariaga

    So OUT. Love the shoes, though.

  • Anonymous

    I gotta’ go with Barbarienne and the others. This look is working for me. I usually harshly judge the starlets who try to pull off the ‘I just got back from the beach’ look. But Emma S. can work that look like no other and I guess I am just so glad to see someone sans tight bun, Marchesa tutu dress and mickymouse shoes that I have gotta’ give her an ‘in’ for the effortlessness.  She looks awesome.

  • Anonymous

    Well, TLo, sometimes a girl really just doesn’t give a fuck.  But she’s still OUT!

  • Anonymous

    O.O
    Shoe tags  (grabs pearl necklace)
    out

  • Anonymous

    O.O
    Shoe tags  (grabs pearl necklace)
    out

  • Anonymous

    I disagree with most of the page 1 comments and give he an IN!  I think she looks cute and perfectly dressy-casual, which works for this event.  Who knows, maybe she had a late night and just wasn’t feeling being perfectly put together and went with easy-breezy.  I think it works!

  • Anonymous

    I disagree with most of the page 1 comments and give he an IN!  I think she looks cute and perfectly dressy-casual, which works for this event.  Who knows, maybe she had a late night and just wasn’t feeling being perfectly put together and went with easy-breezy.  I think it works!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JSGAZPEESHQT47ATH55GNOHHBY Erin

    I am undecided on the in or out, but would you two PLEASE come over the next time I have PMS?

  • Anonymous

    I have to go against the grain, too, and give Miss Emma an IN.  Yes, it’s a messy look but it’s pretty much ALL slightly messy, which somehow makes it work to me… giving a look that’s akin to the dressed-up version of wearing nothing but mussed-up hair and a man’s white dress shirt.  She’s also glowing like she just had hot monkey loving in the car on the way over. 

    The tags on the shoes, however – that sin just might be unforgivable.

  • Anonymous

    OH, and the shoes just do not go with that dress whatsoever.  OUTOUTOUT!

  • Anonymous

    This can be fixed.  She just needs a belt and a comb.

  • http://twitter.com/lauralexis Laura

    She either needs colour, or something that fits and preferably both! And sassier hair while we’re at it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/robin.layton Robin D. Layton

    I love HER but I hate this look.

  • http://twitter.com/qrter Alexander Peterhans

    Oh lord NO.

  • Nicole Merrill

    I hate to say it, but IN; she looks super cute, and I want her dress.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BEV2WB3MZRJHA4KD5DK4QY6FQQ Dinah

    It she had softly pulled back hair, a belt, a pussy bow and unrolled sleeves she’d look so cute!  It is a wee bit maddening.  

    I’m still saying an IN because I really love the dress and her makeup is lovely.  There is something kind of endearing here to me. 

  • Warmheartedgirl Seattle

    I vote out.  She looks wilted — like the humidity is really bad and it is doing terrible things to her hair and the dress.  The rolled up sleeves are not helping.  The tags on the shoes are the ultimate nail in the coffin.

  • BuffaloBarbara

    Could you get out a pair of scissors and cut off the pussy bow instead of tying it?

    Maybe the sleeves were too long.  But couldn’t she have gotten that fixed?  (If that can’t be done to a loaner, I’m beginning to understand the popularity of sleeveless dresses and very short sleeves.  I wear them myself because I have stumpy little arms and all pre-made things are too long on me, but I figured people who had occasion to walk red carpets could see tailors about that sort of thing.)

    A big belt might help the shapelessness, but it would cut the flower print, which would also make it look off.  No… this is just a badly planned dress from D&G.

    Out.

  • Anonymous

    Those shoes are totally wasted on that pitiful dress. OUT.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YMEB3XKJCE4WL62SKN473LWBXQ Frank

    hahaha you guys are soo bad!! but its true. Gonna hafta say OUT on this one even though she seems like such a fun girl!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YMEB3XKJCE4WL62SKN473LWBXQ Frank

    hahaha you guys are soo bad!! but its true. Gonna hafta say OUT on this one even though she seems like such a fun girl!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1303837450 Lauren Dorsee Dillon

    I used to have a repetitive dream that Jim Carrey was stalking me and never could watch his movies because of that. Now, he’s doing this to her in real life. I’d do my best to look grungy, too. Go away, Jim!

  • Anonymous

    I’m just ignoring everything from the ankles up and digging those amazing shoes. But, OUT.

  • Anonymous

    In! I say, I think she looks cute….

  • http://www.facebook.com/shawn.eric.hill Shawn Hill

    In! She’s making it werq for huh!

  • Anonymous

    OUT – someone has likely already said this but WHO LET HER KEEP THE STICKY TAGS ON THE BOTTOM OF HER SHOES??? WHA???

    • Anonymous

      and is there a way to zoom in to see how much her shoes cost?

    • Anonymous

      I wanted to call this an IN and was mustering my arguments, but now that you mention it, the tags on the bottom of the shoes are all that I can see. So OUT.

    • http://twitter.com/MajorBedhead MajorBedhead

      That’s what crossed my mind, too. Dood. Take the stickers off your shoes!

  • Anonymous

    Oh my word.  OUT.
    The shoes are fierce though.

  • Anonymous

    She looks disheveled like she slept in that outfit and did not comb her hair. Out!

  • Anonymous

    OUT. LMAO

  • Anonymous

    She looks cute in a jbf or maybe i-was-about-to-bf way.  The dress could use a belt, but IN.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. It looks way too twee, and she can really do much better.

  • Anonymous

    OUT! Maybe she needs to give Evan Rachel Wood’s gays a call.

  • http://www.facebook.com/rachel.council Rachel Council

    IN. What can I say? I like it.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

    In.  But love what you’d do for her!  All of those things would have definitely improved the look!

  • http://twitter.com/CheriCPat Cheri Patrick

    I have to go with out, even though it is a really cute dress – it does look like she left the house before she finished getting ready, and I don’t know why that would happen to someone who doesn’t punch a time clock.  Your suggestions are just right, but I am struggling with admitting that, because I am offended by your comments about periods and Midol.  Too sexist, too condescending, and too middle-school.  Hope you have a better day tomorrow, I can loan you some Midol if it will help.

  • Anonymous

    From the back, it actually looks like it has some shape to it. Probably just because she’s in motion, though. If the dress had actual shape (front and back), I’d probably like the look. I think that off white looks good on her and I like her hair. But no shape equals OUT for me.

  • Anonymous

    She’s too white for that white dress.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Clydette-Wantland/673315286 Clydette Wantland

    OUT!!!!!

  • Anonymous

    Miss Emma makes all this work, even if she is PMS-ing.  That smile makes me forgive a lot of otherwise unforgivable fashion sins.  IN.

  • http://profiles.google.com/mercbubble42 Jessica O’Connell

    …I think she looks cute and breezy… It’s bad that she didn’t take the tags off the shoes, but all-in-all, I think she looks good. IN. Please don’t hate me for going against your wise opinion, TLo?

  • Anonymous

    IN because she’s sporting that cat-ate-the-canary expression that looks like she had a fantastic time last night and is finally on her way home in her cute dress. 

  • sweetlilvoice

    In, but then I’m on the Midol too. I just love her, this movie and the book which I can barely put down.

  • http://twitter.com/shinobi42 Shinobi

    God you’re so right!  I wish someone would explain to me how to make an outfit better like that.  I look at that and I have no idea what the problem is.

  • Anonymous

    Eh, her hair could be neater, and she needs a belt, but I think she looks cute. She really does need to get those tags off her cute shoes though. I think she’s still in.

  • Anonymous

    Out. I feel slightly insulted on behalf of the film festival. Press tours are grueling, but she can at least pretend to care a little.

    ETA: A belt would help a lot.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AYQCICXEN2CCDBFV5HED4Z2RUA Dee B

    IN I don’t care.  I approve her disapproval of the pussy bow

  • http://www.facebook.com/devin.christopher17 Devin Christopher

    Are you guys serious? I love her and I love this look. Its very easy, breezy! I think these photo call looks should be very casual and stylish. I think she looks relaxed yet chic. I give a BIG IN! <3

  • http://www.facebook.com/devin.christopher17 Devin Christopher

    Are you guys serious? I love her and I love this look. Its very easy, breezy! I think these photo call looks should be very casual and stylish. I think she looks relaxed yet chic. I give a BIG IN! <3

  • Anonymous

    OUT, especially for the hair. Even PMSing she could comb her hair.

  • Anonymous

    OMG TLo I agree with all the adjustments you suggested! OUT.

  • Anonymous

    OMG TLo I agree with all the adjustments you suggested! OUT.

  • Mary McClelland

    Out. That is not her dress and the hair is so lackluster.  Get it together, girl! 

  • http://www.facebook.com/brendan.foehr Brendan Foehr

    In. It’s no great shakes, and your points are as valid as they always are, but this isn’t exactly a travesty. Just boring, like seeing a painting that looks good at first, but the longer you stare at it the more tired, half-assed, unoriginal and banal it becomes.
    I know I just compared Emma Stone to an inanimate object, but it was a hypothetical work of art. Do I get points for that, or is it still offensive?

  • http://phantomminuet.blogspot.com/ MinAgain

    Cute dress, but it definitely needs a belt.

  • http://profiles.google.com/elw0214 Elaine Williams

    OUT!  Really Emma?  Why would a lovely girl with a great figure wear what looks like a paint splattered First Holy Communion dress?  Get a better stylist who likes you!