In or Out/WERQ: Dianna Agron

Posted on August 02, 2011

It’s a historic moment here at T Lo Worldwide Style Consulting, Ltd. You see, our bitchcups runneth over and we have two distinct looks from the same actress worn within days of each other – and we have opinions about BOTH LOOKS.  Can you feel the excitement, darlings? Brace yourselves.

 

LOOK #1:

Dianna Agron attends the Ella Moss 10 Year Anniversary Celebration in West Hollywood in an Ella Moss dress.

Okay, it’s obviously a casual event and clearly an Ella Moss dress was called for, so the dress is a decent, if not particularly exciting choice. Wouldn’t have been our choice, but the good thing about it is it’s easily styled and can be dressed up or down. She chose “down.” We’re not gonna ding her for not wearing enough jewelry because neither the event nor the dress really called for it. One simple statement-making necklace and a kickass pair of shoes is all the look really needs. What a shame she picked a necklace that looks like it came out of a vending machine and shoes that look like they were bought at an estate sale.  And sexy, tousled, JBF hair is a fine thing when it’s done well. This hair looks like she got out of the shower and let it air-dry while she got dressed. Not a crime by any means, but even a casual red carpet event calls for a little more work than that.

VOTE NOW!

IN! She looks casual, young, and totally L.A. chic, you cranky east coasters!

OUT! She looks like a senior citizen on a bus trip to Atlantic City!

We sadly concluded that, despite her beauty and the opportunities coming her way right now, she’s always been something of a boring dresser; too demure and too mature.

But then, a funny thing happened…

 

LOOK #2:

Dianna Agron arrives for the “Late Show With David Letterman” at the Ed Sullivan Theater in New York City in a Stella McCartney dress.

Stella McCartney Fall 2011 Collection/Model: Sara Blomqvist (VIVA)

Yow! Dominatrix in Minnie Mouse’s fuck-me pumps! Now THAT’S more like it, girl! She still looks like a sweet good girl (which appears to be important to her) from the neck up, but she’s all “You’ve been a very bad boy” from the neck down – and she does it without looking remotely slutty or too exposed. This is a look that required no more than what you’re seeing here; jewelry would have just been distracting. It’s all about the dress, the body in the dress, and the shoes. A striking, sexy, potentially game-changing look for her. You WERQ that shit, girl.

 

In other IN/OUT news, there was extensive discussion of Jessica Alba’s star-spangled pregnant snowman look, but we think the final vote came down to OUT, no matter how pregnant she is.

[Photo Credit: Buckner/Wireimage, WENN, elle.com]

Tags: , , ,

  • http://profiles.google.com/thisiscelia Celia

    Look #1: OUT. The dress is pretty, but the lame black necklace and frumpy black sandals ruin it. Also, sloppy hair in her face.
    Look #2: IN. Hot and cute. Love the hair, love the dress on her.

  • http://profiles.google.com/thisiscelia Celia

    Look #1: OUT. The dress is pretty, but the lame black necklace and frumpy black sandals ruin it. Also, sloppy hair in her face.
    Look #2: IN. Hot and cute. Love the hair, love the dress on her.

    • Anonymous

      What Celia said…for all the same reasons….except I really, really, really HATE the shoes in Look #1. Really.

      • Anonymous

        I’m with crash. Those shoes are so horrible. And the necklace is lame.

      • Anonymous

        Exactly.

    • Anonymous

      Will Celia all the way.

  • http://twitter.com/Merneith Merneith

    Honestly, I can’t get past the fairy wings. I know – it’s on the wall, but someone deliberately told her to stand there. And honestly, the fairy wings and antenna … actually sort of help that dress. And I guess it’s a butterfly. But since that look only works if someone follows her around holding up a poster or something with the wings on it, I’m going to have to call this an Out. As for the second look, it’s smoking, but it’s really better as a night-time look I think. In though. Maybe it’ll be night when she leaves wherever she is.

    • Anonymous

      Oh, God, that’s exactly what I was thinking. How the hell do I rate the outfit when FAIRY WINGS ANTENNA BRAIN FREEZE ACK.

    • Anonymous

      I didn’t notice them until I read your comment, but now its all I see — hilarious!

    • MilaXX

      Look number 2 was what she wore on Letterman which airs at 11:35pm

  • http://twitter.com/Merneith Merneith

    Honestly, I can’t get past the fairy wings. I know – it’s on the wall, but someone deliberately told her to stand there. And honestly, the fairy wings and antenna … actually sort of help that dress. And I guess it’s a butterfly. But since that look only works if someone follows her around holding up a poster or something with the wings on it, I’m going to have to call this an Out. As for the second look, it’s smoking, but it’s really better as a night-time look I think. In though. Maybe it’ll be night when she leaves wherever she is.

  • Anonymous

    I like both.  Although I wish she didn’t look like she was growing antennae. 

  • Anonymous

    I like both.  Although I wish she didn’t look like she was growing antennae. 

  • Anonymous

    Horrible styling for look 1 – so so so OUT. So so so WERQ for look 2. Sigh – to be young, beautiful and rich.

  • Anonymous

    Horrible styling for look 1 – so so so OUT. So so so WERQ for look 2. Sigh – to be young, beautiful and rich.

  • Aly Light

    It may not be the greatest necklace in the world, and I do think a different pair of shoes were called for, but those are minor details. She looks nice. IN.

  • Aly Light

    It may not be the greatest necklace in the world, and I do think a different pair of shoes were called for, but those are minor details. She looks nice. IN.

  • scottyf

    I think the butterfly wings and antennae really add to the look. The BUGGALOOS rocked!

    • Anonymous

      Saturdays just aren’t the same without Sid and Marty, who obviously wanted us pre-adolescents to understand the fun of taking hallucinogenics without all the nasty side effects.

      • scottyf

        ROTFLMAO

        Right on! And as a young Fairy in Training myself, gave me my first Dvia Idol: Martha Raye.

      • muzan-e

        Oh, but I suspect that Boobah might’ve taken up the slack….  :)

    • MilaXX

      I loved the Bugaloos .

    • http://twitter.com/lbcubbison Laurie Cubbison

      Doctor Who and the Bugaloos – reasons beyond the obvious for why I love this blog (and yeah, the Bugaloos were my first thought too!)

  • scottyf

    I think the butterfly wings and antennae really add to the look. The BUGGALOOS rocked!

  • Anonymous

    wow, she looks so different in both pictures, the second look is way better than the first

  • Anonymous

    wow, she looks so different in both pictures, the second look is way better than the first

  • http://phantomminuet.blogspot.com/ MinAgain

    The first dress is just a bad dress.  I hope that ”sheer dress hanging several inches below the lining” is not going to be a new look.  It’s just plain tacky.  I don’t mind the shoes, but they’re too dark for the dress.  Hate the necklace, hate the hair.

    The second dress is stunning, and she looks stunning in it.  Brava!

  • Anonymous

    I’m giving both outfits a big, ol IN. The only thing I’d change is the necklace and heavy shoes in the first outfit. As one who dresses way older than I am, I support this. 

  • Anonymous

    #1 OUT! Sooooo boring.
    #2 IN! Yowza!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1179147626 Jeanne Mulcahey Bryant

    Look one was a begrudging IN until I saw look 2!  She looks very fierce there — not just the dress, but her expression. Looks like she feels great.  Look one: Meh.  Look two: IN.
    Oh, and the butterfly wings and antenna were just weird.  Did they pose everyone at the event in that way?

    • Anonymous

      My thoughts exactly – first look is too meh to even call it a definitive in or out.

      2nd looks is mega IN, even though I don’t care for the huge platforms.  This should be a lesson to . . . whoever it was (Emma Stone?) on how to wear foofaraw on your hips and have it look good.

  • http://twitter.com/rachelruthlee Rachel Lee

    In! I think she looks really cute in that dress, and her shoes aren’t nude. And they look comfortable, which is no crime. 

  • http://badkittyknits.blogspot.com KittyKnits

    Look #1:  Dress is cute, but HATE the hair = OUT.
    Look #2:  Hot as all get out, even with the “cut-out” velvet front and unfortunate shade of pink lipstick.  IN.

  • http://twitter.com/asciident Melissa Della

    Out on the first look. It’s like her stylist figured the dress was a no-brainer so she could phone it in on the rest.

    It’s such a clear decision with the second look being right under it–I don’t know this starlet very well, and honestly if you boys hadn’t told me it was the same girl, I would not have noticed.

  • Anonymous

    Totally agree with you, TLo. First look is out. Second look is excellent.

  • http://twitter.com/herong Heron

    I like both, but they seem like totally different people.  I would prefer to hang out with Diana 1, who’s fun and low-key and kinda dorky.  But Diana 2 is definitely a rock star with bigger things on her mind.  Like her shoes.  

  • Anonymous

    She looks like she has butterfly wings growing out of her head in the first pic…OUT

    She looks stunning in the Stella McCartney dress…IN

  • Anonymous

    Look #1, I like the butterfly fairy wings coming out of her head, it softens the look. Cute. In.
    Look #2, Black velvet in August is so completely wrong (and it looks like stretch velvet too). The dress does look good on her, really good. I’m waffling on the fence on this one. I suppose the kick ass shoes are pushing it to a slight little lower case in.

  • https://profiles.google.com/104791269167429064986 Judy S

    Look #2 is classic WERQ: I don’t like that dress in itself, but she is getting an amazing amount of mileage out of it. #1 is nice enough but boring, OUT.

    • Anonymous

      With you on look #2. I actually don’t care for the dress (clothes that have stuff on the front and plain backs always remind me of those tuxedo t-shirts) but she is certainly rocking it, and her hair looks great.

      Look #1 doesn’t bear talking about.

  • http://twitter.com/warontara Tara

    I give her a lowercase in for the first look, I think she looks cute and comfy, and appropriate fo the event, even if the hoes are a little heavy (and I am probably just being suckered in by her posing just-so in front of the butterfly picture lol I sort of love it and I don’t know why). And I LOVE and want the second dress. She looks stunning!

  • Anonymous

    I just can’t with the hair in the first look. I can’t. It physically hurts me. I like the dress itself, but everything else is just so bad that I can’t bring myself to look at her for longer than five seconds. Sooooo OUT. The second dress however…hot damn! That Stella is singing a symphony to her ass. I’d say I don’t know how I feel about her makeup, but who the hell is looking at her makeup? WERQ it Dianna!

    • Diana Ye

      I love it: “That Stella is singing a symphony to her ass.” What more could a girl ask for from her clothes?

  • Anonymous

    I love look #2.

  • Anonymous

    Look #1: A cute look, if not a bit uninspired.
    Look #2: She looks absolutely amazing! That dress is doing great things for her arse. 

  • Judy_J

    Look #1: Out. Dress is cute, hair is AWFUL! She does look kind of dowdy.  She should have left off that horrid necklace. Look #2: IN. Fabulous!  That dress fits like a glove.  Hair and makeup are great, too.  Love that lip color.

  • Anonymous

    #1 is meh dress wise but the styling is lazy.  Out.
    #2 is Wow!  In.

    hahahahaha…..still laughing at the wings

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lauren-Jean-St-Martin/504251897 Lauren Jean St. Martin

    I say IN!!! She looks adorable.

  • Anonymous

    Totally OUT for the first look.  It’s hard to believe the two photos are even of the same person.  I hate the sheepdog bangs, shapeless dress, vending machine (so true!) necklace and ugly shoes of the first look.  Cute hair, flattering bodyhugging dress and great shoes in second look.  

  • Anonymous

    IN for both

    1st – cute & casual, nod to boho chic.  Sandals are too earthy though.  Hair doesn’t bother me.  Hate that she/they chose to stand in front of the butterfly…corny.
    2nd – glam.  Her butt looks amazing.  I kind of dislike the 2 tone look here…think it should have been more subtle. 

  • Anonymous

    Look #1 just needed better jewelry, hair and shoes. What was she thinking? I feel like she would look cuter if her hair were about shoulder-length. The length she has now just looks like a little girl who got gum in her hair and her mother cut it out with a pair of kitchen shears, especially in the first look.
    Look #2 Wow, she looks amazing! I’m still not convinced that this is the best hairstyle for her. MAD props for wearing (fabulous) shoes that actually fit!

  • Anonymous

    I really like the Ella Moss dress.  It looks like something you could throw on and wear around town doing errands, meeting friends for lunch, going to a museum, etc, all while looking cute and being cool and comfortable.  But it may be too casual for even the most casual of red carpets, though.  The necklace is boring and the shoes look like she raided Grandma’s closet.  The hair is awful and makes her look like an 8th grader (albeit one in orthopedic sandals).  Neither in nor out – just a meh.

    The Stella McCartney dress is witty and makes her look fierce.  But black velvet in August is just all wrong.  And the shoes are loathsome.  I can’t wait for the dominatrix/fetish shoe fad to die.  Still, she’s very much IN.

  • Anonymous

    Ugh.  That FIRST look.  If one, even a thin actress with a fabulous body, is going to wear a just below the knee, full-ish skirt (esp if it has lace-like elements), one must wear fabulous and high shoes to overcome the intrinsic dowdiness of the dress.  She looks so old lady in that dress that I can’t believe it. Quadruple out

    And the second–well what a treat!  I normally am not a Stella fan, but wow does she look unbelievably good here.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Look #1, The hair pains me. Seriously, pains me. But I like the dress and the rest of the look… Sorry us casual west coast girls have to stick together. IN.
    Look #2, WERQ it, she looks so hot! IN.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QCJEZMOV4VYMXC5WJALLZNYEB4 Mari Rose

    The shoes seem a little heavy for such a light and airy dress, but I’m going to give her an in. It’s nice to see a Hollywood starlet doing non-slutty casual.

  • Anonymous

    I like the dress and the shagtastic hair in #1.  The shoes and necklace are throw-aways and should be thrown away, but otherwise I like it.  Marginal IN.

  • Vaniljekjeks

    She’s out the first one.  She just doesn’t make it work.
    Look 2 is incredible.  Like jaw dropping gorgeous gorgeous.  She needs to wear this all the time. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2CNDPMVO4W23R5TVC2QMTJ5BZE Heather

    #1: OUT. TJ Maxx. But I do think the wings and antennae in the background are cute.
    #2: IN. Slutty Minnie Mouse = always good.

  • Anonymous

    Look 1 was a tentative in until I saw look 2: while I quite like the shaggy hair, the dress and the shoes are really not doing it for me. OUT!

    Look 2 is fantastic. I have to feel sorry for her, though, wearing velvet in summer. IN anyways!

  • MilaXX

    I think both looks are IN. She does lean towards safe, mature looks which is why I like both looks. I like the messy hair in the first pic & the glam in the second shot. I may change my mind once I view this on the pc, but for now I like.

  • Margot Brose

    First one is out, no matter how much she WERQs her second look. The accessorizing is awful, which is a shame, because the dress is gorge. I think she could have gotten away with the hair if the shoes hadn’t been so frumpy.

    However, the second look is GORGEOUS! WERQ!

  • http://heartprintandstyle.blogspot.com Vivi N

    Look #1: Completely OUT. O U T out. It’s just sad to look at.
    Look #2: Completely IN. I N in. She looks amazing. 

    Summary: Dianna is a beautiful young lady. I’m not much of a “Glee” fan but I do admire her outside of the show. I think she has the look and personality to cross over to the big screen. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=683312424 Anonymous

    First of all, I think she’s adorable and looks good in just about anything.  That being said… Look #1 – I actually like the dress but the styling is off.  The hair could have been straightened and slightly feathered and looked lovely with the dress.  The messy, as you put it, “JBF” look doesn’t work for her (or anyone, I think — Heidi wore this hair a lot in Season 8 of PR and I hated it every time).  Look #2, however… WOWZA.  The curves of the dress fit her curves perfectly.  It looks like the dress was made with her in mind.  And I love the styling — the hair, perfect, the makeup, perfect… she wowed me here.  I bet Letterman nearly fell out of his chair when he saw her.

  • Laura Korth

    In, In!

  • Anonymous

    Look 1: Those shoes, hon. No.
    Look 2: OMFG. Yes!

  • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

    Look#1: OUT. I think the butterfly backdrop is cute though.

    Look#2: Yep, that’ll do! The ladies come to the Letterman show expecting to be ogled, and have learned to dress the part. Without the caption, I would have been able to tell you where she was headed. 

    Apparently Dianna has a part-time stylist.

  • Anonymous

    Look 1: Out.  The dress is cute as a button, but the styling and yeek hair drop it down
    Look 2: Out.  She looks like she’s dressing up from mom’s closet, and mom hasn’t bought anything new since 1989.  Plus, it’s August.  Who wears velvet in August?

  • Anonymous

    The first look is too boring to comment. But I think she needs to beat the shit out of whoever thought she should pose at that exact spot. Seriously she had to look like she was wearing antennae and butterfly wings? 

  • Anonymous

    The first look is too boring to comment. But I think she needs to beat the shit out of whoever thought she should pose at that exact spot. Seriously she had to look like she was wearing antennae and butterfly wings? 

  • Joyce VG

    Both looks IN.  Because she was comfy and cute in look #1 and va va va voom in Look # 2.

  • Anonymous

    1st look is an Out for me, which is a shame. I like the idea of a celebrity looking low-key and approachable but polished, but she didn’t quite pull it off. The necklace, hair, and shoes are bad.

    2nd look is certainly a WERQ. She took a very 1980s look and worked the shit out of it without looking slavishly retro. Broken record time for me here, but a bracelet or earrings would have helped the look a little bit. But still, she looks great.

  • Anonymous

    The first look is totally ruined by the grungy cousin Oliver hair. **OUT**

  • http://twitter.com/LianaBrooks Liana Brooks

    #1 – Are the wings part of the outfit? I don’t think so, which is a pity. The wings drew my attention. She didn’t OUT
    #2 – Love! Cute, stylish, fun… IN!

  • Anonymous

    Look 1: OUT.  Thanks for playing, come again!
    Look 2: WERQ!  Perfect balances all around!

  • Jennifer Hofstetter

    I think she looks adorable in the first outfit.  I like the hair.  Her accessorizing isn’t great, but it’s not terrible.  I’ll say IN.

    HATE THAT VELVET PIECE OF WTF CRAP.  You two are crazy.  She may look fantastic, but black velvet in the summer time?  REALLY?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Susan-Maguire/1286325876 Susan Maguire

    amazing contrast between photos… in for me…BTW…when is black nail polish going to end???…

  • margaret meyers

    At the one event she was going to be seen by a million people on TV.  Since it was publicity, she probably also got studio support for the whole look, but especially hair and makeup.  She went full out and she looks really great.
    The other event was much smaller. The dress was probably sent to her, she made a nice effort at home and she looks good.  yeah I wish we had better shoes and accessories, but, I think the styling was DIY.

  • http://twitter.com/HotMessHousWife Sammi M

    #1 – I like it. But I’m a West Coast girl, so that might be bias talking. IN.
    #2 – DAMN, GIRL. I have never thought of her as hot, but I might need to do some rethinking. YOW.

  • Anonymous

    Wow. Is she schizo? She looks like such a Debbie Downer in the first photo and smoking hot in the second. I don’t mind the dress in the first post, but the hair, shoes and pitiful necklace kill the look. Not a fan of velvet in summer, but that young lady is WERQing the heck out of that dress, Minnie shoes and all. out/IN

  • Anonymous

    Look #1: ALMOST an IN. Love the dress, but the hair, necklace, and shoes conspire to shift the look to the Atlantic City bus trip.

    Look #2: IN!  Wow!  You nailed it, boys, when you said she looks sexy “without looking remotely slutty.”  A photo of her in this outfit should be added immediately to the Slutty Hollywood Starlet’s Book of How It Should Be Done. 

  • Anonymous

    How I wish the backdrop in the second look was a set of bunny girl ears.  

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_N3GA2TTX752OYSKBWWXQVFM2HI katie

    look 1 is out- she looks like she’s going to the grocery store. 

  • Anonymous

    In for both. Except points off for the necklace in first one.  I can live with the shoes..they’re very much a style I would choose.

    • Anonymous

      The shoes:  yeah, maybe me too, but I’m over 55 and live in an older demographic suburb where there really ARE estate sales (i.e., death sales) all the time.  For her, she’s young, beautiful and rich, so she should live it up and pay the price for shoe choices when she’s my age (i.e., bunions and calluses…but I wore some *bitchin’* shoes!)

  • Anonymous

    Love her in the “Stella McCartney” dress very chic.  

  • Mariah J

    #1 is cute enough, I say in…also there is a butterfly coming out of her head, which I really enjoy looking at.

  • sweetlilvoice

    I like them both, love her little wave at the camera. She has such a pretty face.

  • http://profiles.google.com/mercbubble42 Jessica O’Connell

    Look #1: OUT. I just can’t get behind ugly heavy sandals and an entire dress of paisley. I just can’t.
    Look #2: Agreed on the WERQ (those shoes look deadly and awesome) but HATE her lipstick. Just saying.

  • Nicole Merrill

    IN for both; the first look is a little frumpy, but I’ve always loved that, and the second is sexy and wonderful.

  • http://profiles.google.com/anplica Anplica Fiore

    Not the biggest fan of the shoes, but she’s cute and it’s a great summer look.  In.

  • Elena

    She looks cute enough in look #1, but it depresses me a bit, so OUT. for look #2, however, I have to give out a WERQ for that girl.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t mind the first look.

    But wow the second one – and a Stella McCartney to boot?   Excellent job Diana

  • Anonymous

    Like many people, I was going to give the first look a  begrudging IN because she looks better then a lot of girls on the red carpet these days… that is, until I saw the second look. All I can say is if she can look that good when she puts her mind to it, then she has no excuse for showing up looking like she did in the first look. So, first look: OUT. Second look: IN. 

  • Anonymous

    1. The dress is ok, but the shoes are really mumsy. It isn’t bad (for nipping to the shops), but it’s bland – so an out.

    2. Fabulous, can’t fault it. Fits her like a glove, the shoes are perfect for it and her hair and make-up are good.  IN

  • Anonymous

    She should wear Stella McCartney all the time, even to bed.  Wow, what a transformation from Look #1 (which is so snoozy it’s hardly a “Look” at all…more like a “Don’t look at me, I’m trying to fade into the butterfly wallpaper.”

  • Anonymous

    I actually like the ugly one more than the WERQ one. 

    So basically, OUT/NO!

  • Anonymous

    Look #1 – I like that dress a lot, it is very breezy, summery.  HATE that necklace with a searing passion.  And the hair is just awful.  OUT
    Look #2 – I hate that dress with a searing passion but the hair, the shoes, the make-up are all SLAMMIN!  And, speaking of slammin – that body!  All over comes yet another ridiculous Stella McCartney dress.  IN

  • Anonymous

    Look #1 – I like that dress a lot, it is very breezy, summery.  HATE that necklace with a searing passion.  And the hair is just awful.  OUT
    Look #2 – I hate that dress with a searing passion but the hair, the shoes, the make-up are all SLAMMIN!  And, speaking of slammin – that body!  All over comes yet another ridiculous Stella McCartney dress.  IN

  • Anonymous

    That first dress does have some potential, but the styling is indeed puzzling. I seriously think my mom’s friend (who is in her late 60s) has those shoes. I think the hair is kind of cute and I get what she was going for, but it’s all wrong with the rest of the accessories. Definite OUT. 

    However, the second look is totally WERQ-worthy! I think that’s the best she’s ever looked. Sexy, classy, and youthful – not always easy to pull off all three at once and she does it wonderfully here. Love it!

  • Anonymous

    I can’t even believe that’s the same person, much less the same gays!  

  • aussiegal77

    Look #1 – Love the dress, puzzled about the necklace and the shoes.  The hair is not good.  Overall – Look #1 is an OUT.

    Look #2 – HELLO!  Missy Miss brought it here big time.  LOVE her hair here and the make-up, it is all fab.  The dress I do like because it’s sexy and classy.  One quibble – the sweetheart neckline on the front makes my eye twitch.  But considering her butt is all kinds of hot in that dress – I’m thinking the back and side view makes up for the front view =D   Bitch.

  • Anonymous

    IN. She looks cute in the first look and awesome in the second!

  • http://twitter.com/wednesdaydreams Natalie

    Look 1- OUTTTT. Very frumpy and sloppy.
    Look 2- Fantastic. Very elegant and classic

  • Anonymous

    I like them both. She has good taste & style. It might be “boring” (or safe, maybe) but she always looks like she thought about what she was putting on. And I’ve never seen her wearing anything I’d describe as truly tacky, garish, ugly or tarty. The top photos made me laugh because I couldn’t tell, at first, if she was *wearing* butterfly wings or not. Thank god it was just the backdrop. LOVE the stella mccartney, by the way. Though, truly, I love Dianna best when she’s wearing her vaguely-vintage gear.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sorana.tarmu Sorana Tarmu

    OUT. Ouch!

  • Anonymous

    IN

  • Anonymous

    Like the hair in the first look, but can’t get past the granny shoes – OUT.  LOVING the second look, head to toe!!

  • Patricia Biswanger

    LOOK # 1 — so OUT.  The necklace, shoes and hair kill the whole look.

    LOOK # 2 — so IN.

  • Anonymous

    don’t know that person and I can hardly believe the 2 photos represent the same girl !
    she looks a bit large and mature in the first look (yes, that’s an OUT, if only just for the grand’ma shoes) while she’s stunning in the second : lean, slim but well proportionned, hair and make up nicely done and killer heels.
    Are you sure it’s the same girl ?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Catherine-Rhodes/602850414 Catherine Rhodes

    OUT

  • http://summerborn.livejournal.com/ Summer Born

    OUT and then WERQ – are we sure this isn’t her evil fairy lazy twin in the first pic??

  • Anonymous

    Out – she does look like a senior citizen on a bus trip to Atlantic City, especially the shoes and necklace, and the hair.  The dress could be better with better styling, but as it is, it is out.
    The second look is fabulous.

  • Anonymous

    OUT, I’m too sick to type why, but.. out.

  • Anonymous

    I would have guessed she was recovering from bunion surgery given the shoes in that first look, but then she shows up in the Minnie Mouse pumps for Dave; so now I’m thinking she stopped by Grandma’s on her way back from yoga, forgot she had the thing to go to and just grabbed something out of granny’s closet.

  • http://twitter.com/democracydiva Democracy Diva

    1. OUT. HAIR. AWFUL.

    2. IN. SEX. LOVE IT.

  • elzatelzabelz

    The 2nd dress gets a WERQ. The 1st is a tragedy from tip to toe.

  • http://www.facebook.com/suzie.vazquez Suzie Vazquez

    In is so much fun and fabulous :) Werq!

  • Anonymous

    Wow, love Look #2, almost makes up for the mess that is Look #1….I just can’t get past the hair in #1. I’ll give her an In on the aggregate.

  • Anonymous

    I was going to say she looks very mid 90s in look #1.  I guess that means OUT, because it’s 2011.

  • Anonymous

    God, I hate the trends in shoes right now. Shoes in #2 look like those that would be worn by a club-footed dominatrix. 

  • Haley Buchanan

    IN and IN.  The hair is way cute, and Quinn Fabray wouldn’t wear either outfit – which just may be enough of a reason to like it.

  • Judy Raddue

    May I add about #2 – the makeup is perfection.

  • Anonymous

    She it TOTALLY on her way to Atlantic City.

  • Anonymous

    Look #1 – OUT. Blech
    Look #2 – Holy shit is that the same girl?! IN!

  • http://profiles.google.com/phyllis.craine Phyllis Craine

    Were the butterfly wings and antenna intentional?

  • http://twitter.com/kpluslease Kaylise Algrim

    #1: OUT. I feel like her mother, all I want to do is get a bobby pin to get her bangs out of her eyes. BUT YOU HAVE SUCH A PRETTY FACE, WHY DO YOU WANT TO HIDE IT?

    #2: She looks fantastic, obviously.

  • Anonymous

    Well, once again you called it right down the line, TLo.  Look #1 is an OUT (although if she got that necklace from a vending machine, I’d like to know where it’s located…….”Emergency Fashion Accessories” in a vending machine sounds like a killer idea).  Look #2 is 100% WERQ.

    Like many others, I also hate the butterfly backdrop in the first photos.  How ridiculous to make everyone who poses for the press stand in front of an ugly insect logo.

  • Cheri Lee

    OUT!  So out that its amazing she was able to come back IN after that.

  • Cheri Lee

    OUT!  So out that its amazing she was able to come back IN after that.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Nestor.Chocolato NesTtor Chocolato

    IN IN

  • http://www.facebook.com/Nestor.Chocolato NesTtor Chocolato

    IN IN

  • http://twitter.com/jennsaysmeow Fifi LaRoux

    She’s out!

    She’s hot! Damn!

  • http://twitter.com/capt_shiny Mags

    OUT to look #1. She looks dumpy.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

    Hippy look – Out — the shoes ruin the look.  And that other look is so fierce.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=768540908 Badriya Al-Badi’a

    The Ella Moss look–out, she looks like she’s trying to be Courtney Love but doesn’t quite dare, and so can’t even pull off hot mess well.

  • Anonymous

    Out to Look 1. Not only is she styled horribly but her skin looks terrible

    In for Look 2. Absolutely everything is working here. Even those platform skyscraper shoes that I normally detest. 

  • http://needtherapy.tumblr.com skadi1

    I love how in look 1, the sign behind her makes her look like she’s got wings and antenna.  But look 2 is MUCH better, even with the odd-for-the-season velvet panel.

  • oohsparkley!

    I’m going with a little in for the first due to the old, old lady sandals.  IN for the second look.

  • http://twitter.com/applecocola Stacy

    HOLY SHITAKE MUSHROOMS, are they even the same person!?! well, obviously she is, but the transformation is ridiculous. Dianne, please never wear such sad shoes as you did in the first outfit, your dress is cute, but the shoes are hiddy. The second look is the one you should aim for.

  • Anonymous

    The first dress is actually pretty and summery, but 2″ too long for her body; it would look less old ladyish if it landed at the top of her knee instead of just below. The shoes are HIDDY, and ruin anything nice about the dress.
    Granted the second look is hot, but the dress is really a little TOO tight (notice pulling). Hot, but a little trashy. I DESPISE hoof-shoes.

  • Anonymous

    look #1  she looks like a flapper from appalachia who lost her hat but not her hat-hair.  does anyone else hate that it looks like she’s wearing an old lady’s slip underneath?
    look #2 wowie zowie, don’t whip me catwoman!

  • frankystein123

    Oooo, punish me.