In or Out: Emma Stone in Giambattista Valli

Posted on July 19, 2011

It’s times like these when we really feel like we’re doing God’s work here by bitching at unseen stylists for falling down on the job. Because when a girl as pretty as Emma Stone goes out in public in a multi-thousand dollar borrowed outfit chosen for her by a self-proclaimed expert and she looks like this:

Somebody needs to get sued.

Emma Stone attends the ‘Friends with Benefits’ premiere at Ziegfeld Theater in New York City in a Giambattista Valli dress paired with Christian Louboutin nude shoes.

Giambattista Valli Fall 2011 Collection/Model: Hanne Gaby Odiele (ELITE)

Oh, you silly stylists. When will you learn that some items look good on a runway worn by a hungry model for 3 minutes but don’t necessarily work on people who aren’t thin for a living. Even if they’re almost as thin. Airbags on the hips? Save it for the editorials; no woman can make that work without either airbrushing or a strict diet of meals the size of a baby’s hand.

Not that Emma can’t make this work because she’s not thin enough. Heavens, no. It’s just that this dress is unflattering in a rather aggressive way (Waist? What waist? Look at my inflated hips instead!) and unless she’s willing to spend the night popping and locking like a runway model (and only spending a few minutes in view at a time), it’s never gonna work on her.

Also, stylists? “NUDE” SHOES DO NOT GO WITH EVERYTHING. They merely don’t clash with anything and that’s a huge difference that most of you don’t seem to get.

VOTE NOW!


IN! It’s sassy and bright! Lay off her!

OUT! I just want to cover her in a blanket and get her away from those mean photographers!


The Minion Opinion on Rosie Huntington-Whitely’s runaway boobs dress was a loud and near-unanimous OUT, which pleases us.

 

[Photo Credit: Jemal Countess and Stephen Lovekin/Getty Images, elle.com]

Tags: , , , ,

  • Vaniljekjeks

    Out!  It’s like with Rosie in the last post.  She looks absolutely stunning, but the dress is terrible and ill-fitting.  And seriously… enough with the shiny beige heels.  

  • Anonymous

    this is just really terrible. not only does the dress do nothing for her colouring, not to mention figure, those shoes, to my eye at least, manage to be utterly nondescript AND clash with her skintone. also her hair is painful. also also, she looks miserable.

  • Anonymous

    Ughl Ugly even on that skinny model. WTF with putting those two colors together. And then tossing them on a pale redhead? Kookoo-bananas!
    Out!

    • Anonymous

      Agreed. It doesn’t even look right on the model. And when I was a small child a century ago, I was taught not to mix red and pink—especially orangey tomato red and hot blue-pink. The rules may have changed, but it still looks terrible.

    • Anonymous

      The awful shape of the dress aside, I completely agree on the horrible color combo.  

      That would be an obvious OUT.  You can see it in her face that she agrees.

    • Anonymous

      The awful shape of the dress aside, I completely agree on the horrible color combo.  

      That would be an obvious OUT.  You can see it in her face that she agrees.

    • Anonymous

      For me, this color combo could work really well.  It’s off beat and striking.  What this needs is a strong belt, maybe black patent or dark purple.  Do a totally different shoe and make those “airbags” into a peplum that goes all the way around and you have an outfit.

    • Anonymous

      For me, this color combo could work really well.  It’s off beat and striking.  What this needs is a strong belt, maybe black patent or dark purple.  Do a totally different shoe and make those “airbags” into a peplum that goes all the way around and you have an outfit.

      • Anonymous

        I like the colour combo too.

  • Anonymous

    OUT!  It doesn’t flatter her at all and she is too cute to look this badly.

  • http://twitter.com/Littlegrr Mary Nau

    She does look miserable.  That dress is a bad joke.

  • Anonymous

    OUT for the dress – it’s horrible – but I think the shoes are OK. 

  • Anonymous

    In the pics I’ve seen of her lately, it seems like she is playing dress-up.  So many of the looks don’t suit her.  She is young and hopefully she is just experimenting with different looks and won’t continue on this trend.  She is on the cover of some magazine right now and I think she looks awful there too.  That would seem difficult given her genes.

    And that skirt is HI-DE-OUS!!!

  • http://twitter.com/danielleRwest Danielle West

    That dress is just ugly.  And something must be said for Emma Stone not saying to the stylist–that she is paying–”no.  I will not go out like this.  I look like an asshat.”

  • Jenna Kearns

    OUT OUT OUT. Aside from the hugely unflattering shape of the whole thing, the color combo of pink and red is a horrid one, and especially for a redhead.  And while the stylist who thought this one up was demented, I have to put some of the blame on Ms. Stone, who actually agreed to wear it.  Honey – just say no.

  • Anonymous

    Also, be careful how you stand as your ribs can look like a third boob.  Nude shoes are becoming downright lazy.

    • Christine Campbell

      “Nude shoes are becoming downright lazy.” This.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.
    I love her hair and the colors of the dress are great for her, but Jeezus, even on the swizzle stick model it looks like total crap.  The bunched peplum is ill considered and badly placed.   The whole nude shoe thing reminds me of the “back in the day” period when wearing shoes with lots of colors were the way to go because they went with everything.  That didn’t really work either.

  • Anonymous

    Both the shirt and skirt are hiddy. I think mixing red and pink should be left to Emilio Pucci.

  • Judy_J

    So, so OUT.  That dress doesn’t even look good on the model.

  • Beth G

    LOVE her – hate this.  Out

  • Anonymous

    out! and those shoes… never have i seen more washed out legs!

    • Anonymous

      Her legs only look washed out because she has (I’m so happy) eschewed spray tan.  I say, brava!  but NOT WITH THOSE SHOES

  • k_skenes

    HORRIBLE>  Worst deployment of nude shoes I’ve ever seen.  OUT.  In contrast, she looks beautiful, vibrant and healthy. 

  • http://pleasewelcomeyourjudges.com/ Brian @ PWYJudges

    I saw pictures of this and immediately thought “I can’t wait to read TLo ripping this look apart.” Glad I didn’t have to wait long. OUT!

  • Lena Bea

    Out. It’s a little on the bright side and is not flattering on her body type.

  • Anonymous

    Those nude shoes are the worst!  I think she looks great (physically) in this horrible frock.  It’s just a silly dress.. that being said, she should have gone all out and worn a colored shoe and a fun clutch. 

  • Anonymous

    Out.  And the lipstick….ewwww.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PMAPJYMO5AC6GMONR6NQFURAXE bebo

    I like the color combination and that’s it. horrible dress

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PMAPJYMO5AC6GMONR6NQFURAXE bebo

    I like the color combination and that’s it. horrible dress

  • http://profiles.google.com/thisiscelia Celia

    Voice of dissent here…I like the clash of red with this particular pink here (especially on a redhead). I don’t find it too objectionable (maybe my vision is going), though the water-wings on the hips have got to go.

  • http://profiles.google.com/thisiscelia Celia

    Voice of dissent here…I like the clash of red with this particular pink here (especially on a redhead). I don’t find it too objectionable (maybe my vision is going), though the water-wings on the hips have got to go.

  • Anonymous

    Oh no.  A serious OUT.  I love Emma Stone.  She seems smart and funny and just deserves better than this hideousness.

  • bookish

    OUT. That skirt is terrible. She has pretty damn flawless legs, though, doesn’t she?

  • Anonymous

    Also, while some redheads can wear red or pink, this one can’t wear this red or this pink. You just couldn’t have put a less flattering outfit on a very, very pretty girl.

  • Anonymous

    Oh, c’mon.  This is a joke, right?  Right? 

    (For the record, that’s an “out” for the sake of your tally.)

  • Anonymous

    I think it is actually worse on the model, whose shoes, hair and facial expression all contribute to an even more hideous viewing experience. 

  • Anonymous

    OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Honestly? I don’t even think it looks good on the runway. That dress is just really ugly and unflattering and those two colors together are hurting my eyeballs. As a matter of fact, I think I had this dress for one of my Barbies when I was a little girl. 

  • http://twitter.com/geokaii Christopher Torres

    OUT! sad

  • Anonymous

    Oh no, I hadn’t realized the poor woman had gone blind.  That’s terrible.  

  • Anonymous

    I kind of love this! It’s interesting. IN.

    The shoes, however, are miserable. Would it kill stylists to find some shoes that aren’t nude or black pumps?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=12500056 Joseph Lamour

    Sirs, it most certainly DOES NOT look good on the model.

  • Jennifer Coleman

    It’s not so much about whether is looks better on a very superskinny model vs a very skinny actress, it’s that the model has a much longer torso & broader shoulders, which makes this unfortunate dress look a skoch better. It’s very annoying and lazy when designers create clothes that only a model can get away with for 3 minutes.

  • Anonymous

    Firstly, the woolen sweater in July makes me want to burst into itchy flames. The front peplum is also rather oddly placed. I still don’t think it would look bad on her if she didn’t look so uncomfortable. She is definitely NOT working it.

    Sewing Siren

  • Anonymous

    It doesn’t even look good on the model. What a failure of a dress. And the shoes on the model are equally offensive.

  • Anonymous

    Oh, if by Sassy & Bright you meant ASSY & a BLIGHT, then In. Otherwise, OUT, waaaay OUT.

  • http://twitter.com/merrigator merrigator

    NOOOOOOOOOOO!  Out.

  • Anonymous

    Well, she has the security of knowing that if she falls into a deep body of water, those little inflatable thingies just might save her life. 
    But it’s an Out anyway.Her face looks very pretty.And– I HATE NUDE SHOES. HATE THEM. ALL THE TIME. There, I got that off my chest. Have a nice day everybody.

    • Anonymous

      Thank god there’s someone else out there with a visceral aversion to nude shoes.  To me they always look like someone is too timid to make an ACTUAL choice.

  • Anonymous

    I’m pretty sure that dress would be hideous on anyone. OUT

  • Jennifer Hofstetter

    OUT.  Just…OUT.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=513945580 Megan Patterson

    That sweater would be good with jeans though. And her hair is back!!! Can she get an in just for that?

  • Anonymous

    Beyond hideous. But at least she’s prepared for falling into a pool or colliding with crazed fans with those floaties/airbags to protect her baby maker. Safety first kids!

    And I don’t think those colors ever went together, even in the 80s. So far OUT, she’s orbiting Uranus! And nobody wants that.

  • Wendy Wetzel

    Out…. she looks like she’s anticipating a water landing with those floation devices.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Cookie.Taz Aisa Ginger Jake Psenicnik

    I don’t think that dress looks good on anyone. 

  • Anonymous

    Out. I love her, but this dress only works for a small number of people in a small number of situations. 

  • Anonymous

    Out. I love her, but this dress only works for a small number of people in a small number of situations. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/WendyLKaufman Wendy Kaufman

    Oh so sad. I WANT to like that fun mix of colors, and odd silhouette. I really do. Deeper yoke on the skirt would help, as well as smaller air bags. Fun can be pretty. I am the champion at that, but this is just unflattering.

  • http://www.facebook.com/WendyLKaufman Wendy Kaufman

    Oh so sad. I WANT to like that fun mix of colors, and odd silhouette. I really do. Deeper yoke on the skirt would help, as well as smaller air bags. Fun can be pretty. I am the champion at that, but this is just unflattering.

  • http://twitter.com/enuma enuma

    I’m almost tempted to say “in” just because I’m thrilled that her red hair is back.

    Almost.

  • http://twitter.com/enuma enuma

    I’m almost tempted to say “in” just because I’m thrilled that her red hair is back.

    Almost.

  • https://profiles.google.com/104791269167429064986 Judy S

    Except for the fact that the peplum seems to be misaligned, I think it looks better on Ms. Stone than on the model. I actually like the colors on her. On the other hand, the peplum is a horror AND misaligned, so OUT.

  • https://profiles.google.com/104791269167429064986 Judy S

    Except for the fact that the peplum seems to be misaligned, I think it looks better on Ms. Stone than on the model. I actually like the colors on her. On the other hand, the peplum is a horror AND misaligned, so OUT.

  • http://summerborn.livejournal.com/ Summer Born

    Oooh, definitely OUT.  The color combination seems bad but not outside the realm of possibility, but then there are PILLOWS sewed to her HIPS. 

  • sweetlilvoice

    Agreed, a pretty girl like Emma should never look so bad. I do love that she’s auburn again!

  • Anonymous

    It’s ugly on the MODEL. Why would any lady want to hang flaps on her hips? I can’t think of one single reason to do it.
    Beyond OU!!

  • Anonymous

    Luv her (she looks a bit like a young Marg Helgenberger in these photos)…the dress should never be spoken of again…..she gets an in but the dress is a total OUT…..

  • Terence Ng

    It looks great from the side, but from the front, it’s a mess.  In for the side, out for the front. OUIN.

  • Anonymous

    I think you should start a subset of “In or Out”, devoted to those memorable (?) creations that are so hideously awful that they leave scars on the retinas.  “Way Out”, perhaps?  I’m sure you can think up a witty and catchy moniker.  When you do, immediately place this horror on it.  Absolutely no redeeming qualities at all–a misery. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lauren-Jean-St-Martin/504251897 Lauren Jean St. Martin

    Why does she have a 3rd boob? Why? WHY?

  • http://www.facebook.com/c.d.barney Chrissy Barney

    The color combination is fun in a Crayola kind of way, but the proportions of this outfit are completely off. She looks really uncomfortable, and that’s a guaranteed OUT. It’s too bad, ’cause I adore her.

  • Anonymous

    Oh, Emma. How could you let them do this to you? You’re so much better than this!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

    OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT!! That is horrendous! 

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Poor girl looks so bummed out too. It reminds me of a dress I had for my Barbie.

  • Anonymous

    I have a huge girl-crush on Emma Stone, and it makes me sad that someone did this to her. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Out.  Is it Fall already??  She looks hot – as in too warm.

    That’s one ugly dress and her shoes clash.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. My eyes hurt.

  • aussiegal77

    Wow.  Awful.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Big OUT!

    really ugly outfit!  I don’t even think it looks good on the model.  I’m all for mixing colors that one wouldn’t normally pair, but don’t think these colors and fabrics/textures work here.  The air bags are ridiculous.  The nude shoes DO clash…but what does it matter when everything else clashes too.  Makeup…not working for me either…looks a bit too heavy and I don’t care for the colors.

    Her hair looks nice. 

  • http://twitter.com/wrenaria Kimmy Hescock

    She is such a pretty girl. Auf wiedersehen to the outfit though. Super OUT.

  • http://twitter.com/ShelfAfterlife Shelf Afterlife

    It looks like she’s growing another boob just above her hand.  I don’t like anything about this.  OUT!

  • Anonymous

    The look on her face shows that she just FEELS ridiculous. Emma, honey, I’m sorry they did this to you. Out.

  • http://profiles.google.com/withano Loren S

    If, over the course of the evening, she ever finds herself lost at sea, her skirt will double as a flotation device.

  • Anonymous

    Out. Not only is the dress awful but these are not her colors. At least not that pink. That pink is really making her legs look ashy white. And the hair and make-up are just sad.

  • Tom Shea

    Out. Without the airbags it’s fine. And she is slammin’ on her own. But  yicch. And I’m also tired of the nude shoe, esp a shiny nude shoe.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1303837450 Lauren Dorsee Dillon

    OUT. You can tell even she doesn’t like this. Don’t the celebs have any say in their red carpet wardrobe? Jeez.

  • Anonymous

    Out. For all the obvious reasons. And those shoes are so close to her natural skin color she looks like she has  Barbie feet.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1077090078 Megan Sullivan

    Yes, BUT, she has the most talked-about look out of everyone at the premiere, and that is brilliant, since she’s got a couple of her own movies coming out soon. I also almost like this look, or at least the color combination.

  • Alyson Lamble

    She looks rather like a young Melinda Clarke in those first two pictures.  And an Emma Stone/Melinda Clarke collaboration is something I could definitely get behind.

    As for the outfit, none of it works.  Not the dress, not the shoes, not the hair.  Out.

  • Alyson Lamble

    She looks rather like a young Melinda Clarke in those first two pictures.  And an Emma Stone/Melinda Clarke collaboration is something I could definitely get behind.

    As for the outfit, none of it works.  Not the dress, not the shoes, not the hair.  Out.

  • Anonymous

    Ya know that thing people do where they pull their pants pockets inside out as a gesture saying “I’m Broke!”?  Yeah that.  **OUT**

  • Anonymous

    Ya know that thing people do where they pull their pants pockets inside out as a gesture saying “I’m Broke!”?  Yeah that.  **OUT**

  • Anonymous

    Oh, and btw, shoulder pads in a sheer skin tight knitted top?  Yeah THAT’S a great idea.  Kills the shape of the shoulder line even on the runway model. bleah 
    Can I vote out again?  Or is it one to a fawn?

  • Joyce VG

    OUT! I DO want to cover her in a blanket to get away from meanies.  This dress is not even that pretty to me.

  • http://elle-oh-elle.tumblr.com Elle

    I think she looks fucking fantastic, right down to the shoes.

  • http://www.facebook.com/kati.irons Kati Irons

    Ugh. Maybe hot pink and red can go together but like this it just looks like her stylist is color blind as well as taste free. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/suzie.vazquez Suzie Vazquez

    So IN! I love it and she looks great!

  • http://www.facebook.com/suzie.vazquez Suzie Vazquez

    So IN! I love it and she looks great!

  • http://twitter.com/HotMessHousWife Sammi M

    So OUT. Eugh.

  • http://twitter.com/HotMessHousWife Sammi M

    So OUT. Eugh.

  • MilaXX

    Fired? Somebody deserves a beat down for this mess. This is wrong in so many ways. First of all, pairing red and pink is difficult under the best of circumstances and this look is far from the best of circumstances. Then you have that top that looks like nothing more than a stretchy bodysuit. The skirt with the saddlebags certainly brings no pretty to the party so why not top it with a pair of boring nude pumps. Hair is makeup is fine, but really isn’t enough to salvage this look. I like Emma, but this is OUT.

  • Anonymous

    peplums can only be worn succdessfully  in very limited instances.  This is not one, not simply because of Emma Stone’s size but the clashing colors, which in other circumstances could have been used quite successfully, here  make the peplums seem even larger than they are.  Like party balloons. 

    • Anonymous

      Well, for the record, those two pouffes do not a peplum make. A proper peplum drapes around the back, comes around the sides, and may or may not meet in the front. The appendages on that skirt are nobody’s peplum.

  • MilaXX

    I agree the colors can work if done right, but if you add a belt, you need to remove the saddlebags altogether, not change them into a peplum. The 2 different elements would be fighting for attention.

  • http://twitter.com/80nine CAMERON

    IN – I liked this ensemble with the peplum waist. Agree on the shoes though, pale gals should avoid nude

  • Anonymous

    Please.  So out.

  • Anonymous

    Poor thing looks so uncomfortable.

  • http://twitter.com/Stevesotherhalf Svanhild Salmons

    Of all the terrible nude pumps in the world, those are particularly awful.

  • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.parker Sara Parker

    Blurg.  I hate it on the model as well, I don’t think it’s that she’s not thin enough– this thing would make Skeletor look hippy.  Also, I agree with @twitter-36324101:disqus , I love her perfect pale skin but the nude shoes are not her friend.

  • Anonymous

    It hurts because I have such a girl crush on her but out.

  • Anonymous

    I think it looks like crap on the model too.  I could deal with the color combo if the textures weren’t so jarring.  Wrong fabric choice.  They look angry at each other.

  • Anonymous

    That is a travesty.

  • Anonymous

    I did not even notice the peplum.  I was too distracted by the horrid, eyeball-searing color combination.  As a redhead, I am offended on so many counts! OUT

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=583342965 Melody Sellers

    OUT! This outfit makes me sad and someone does need to be sued. And normally I don’t hate on the nude shoe as much as you guys but enough is enough.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=816120314 Chason Dailey

    Emma best be pistol-whipping her staff with her cellphone and firing her stylist. Out.

  • Anonymous

    That dress looks terrible on her and she looks like she knows it. It’s out.

  • Lenora Dody

    Wow, this is just completely out! Nothing good about it.

  • Lauen newman

    I wonder who the hell thinks accenting your hips like this is a good idea. I mean, come on! There are some fashion rules to live by: Carefully select orange colored garments, try to make your shape look the best it can, and for the love of God do not put airbags on your hips!  Common sense! Out. Get with it! If I had designers throwing their latest at me, I would at least make sure it looked flattering.

  • Christine Marie

    I mean, it’s not the most horrible thing I’ve ever seen. . . . but it’s kind of like the nude shoes thing. Just because it isn’t aggressively awful doesn’t make it great.

  • Anonymous

    Ew.  OUT!

  • Anonymous

    Out, ugh!

  • http://twitter.com/DaggerMitten Laur.

    Out! I agree with @lizajane1776:disqus Koo-koo bananas indeed! The only thing I like here is the color of her lipstick. Sad Face.

  • Elizabeth Denton

    I’M SO CONFUSED BY THIS POST. I’m obsessed with this dress and how she looks in it. It’s amazing. Sometimes, it’s not about being FLATTERING as much as it is about wearing a really fun dress. (Yes, the nude shoes suck.) Team Emma’s stylist.

  • Anonymous

    Nothing to add but OUT!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OYWH5NAGE3TS2MWXRAVBSWBSZA Brittany

    Out, although from the neck up, in. She’s what LiLo could have been :(

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  Her eye makeup looks nice, and I don’t mind the deployment of the nude shoe here, but that’s all I can say about this ensemble that is good.  I don’t know if she doesn’t have a waist, or if the dress is just obscuring it, and you should never have to wonder that.

  • Rand Ortega

    So, pontoons are now in fashion? Floaties are on trend? Love her, loved “Easy A”, but her stylist should get a resounding bitchslap for that dress.
    Outre!

  • Crystal Thomas

    What is up with “high end” fashion designers apparently not being able to afford a decent backing to materials such that one not be able to see the model’s nips (or the shoulder pad outline) through the fabric? Lazy, la..

  • http://profiles.google.com/mercbubble42 Jessica O’Connell

    Oh the poor dear… and her hair and makeup look so pretty too. What a shame.

  • Anonymous

    I disagree.  That dress doesn’t even look good on the model.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_C65IT4K6RYN4TWRMFJOI3VUDAI Olechka Milashka

    the last one was too much boobs, this one made me question ” where are her boobs?”  So unflattering!
    And red with pink?  Oy
    OUT

  • Anonymous

    Out. But to be fair, her face is flawless.

  • Anonymous

    Out. But to be fair, her face is flawless.

  • Anonymous

    Even Emma herself looks pissy wear that dress! It look as if it was designed for a color blind barbie. O to the U to the T.

  • Mariah J

    This is really really bad. What happened to stylists??

  • Anonymous

    Out. Duh.

  • margaret meyers

    That’s bad. 
    It wasn’t even fitted for her.  Maybe if it had been fitted…
    Nah.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    out out out!  Out, damned spot of hideous orange and green!  And with nude shoes!   Gaaaaaak!!!

  • Anonymous

    OUT OUT OUT OUT. Good Lord but that is an awful dress. I was over nude shoes months ago so I have no comment on those. The only good thing I can say is that her hair is somewhat cute.

  • http://www.facebook.com/samuel.j.donovan Samuel Joesph Donovan

    I actually think this is a rather good use of nude shoes–it makes them look like a blush tone to go with the pink and red dress, and the orange hair.  I say IN, tentatively.

  • http://twitter.com/pag_baj Paige Boerman

    Oh no. I wish I could get her back to the limo and redo everything. OUT.

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  Even the model looks like a red and pink kangaroo.

  • Elena

    Poor Emma, it’s really too bad about those flotation devices.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Pretty until you reach the saddlebags, which ruins the whole look. If only someone intelligent (i.e. a stylist–or maybe not with the current state of the occupation) had decided to alter the look and remove them.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Pretty until you reach the saddlebags, which ruins the whole look. If only someone intelligent (i.e. a stylist–or maybe not with the current state of the occupation) had decided to alter the look and remove them.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Nicole-Walraven/527225623 Nicole Walraven

    well yeah. Out. poor thing. also, I say all of TLo’s minions band together and destroy all plasticky looking nude shoes. the time has come for those things to disappear. we can send them into space and make a new satellite called PuttyShoe01. 

  • Anonymous

    I’m not even going to vote, everyone else said it for me.

  • Anonymous

    The color combination is IN (I’m a redhead and I like to wear bold color combinations like this), the dress itself is IN (for an editorial), but on her the dress is OUT (I just can’t get behind it for the real world.)

  • Anonymous

    OUT – that dress couldn’t look good on anyone and judging from the expression on her face, she knows it. 

  • http://twitter.com/VicksieDo Vickie Lord

    That is the ugliest outfit I’ve seen this year, which PAINS me, because I adore Emma Stone.  ::pouts::

  • http://twitter.com/Merneith Merneith

    There’s so much bad here and you didn’t even talk about the awful makeup and the I-just-got-out-of-bed hair. Out. What a horrible dress. It looks awful on the runway too. Stone’s nude shoes are bad, but not as bad as the model’s black booties.

  • Anonymous

    The whole top half of the dress is nearly as unnattractive as the hip-bags.
    OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Out! That is every kind of wrong I can think of – side saddles, amazingly wrong hues of red and pink, bad texture, and seriously ugly shoes. Patent Leather nude stilettos? Really? And a ponytail?

  • http://twitter.com/asciident Melissa Della

    OUT.
    Interestingly, the New York Times Style Mag has dubbed this a ‘style of the moment’ on their Tumblr.

  • http://korilian.livejournal.com/ korilian

    I actually laughed when I saw this XD.

  • Anonymous

    Out! She doesn’t even look happy in ths mess. Imagine how this thing would look on a normal woman.

  • Anonymous

    If it weren’t for the nude shoes and the weird saddlebags, I’d think she looked very cute. I like the clashiness of the red and pink.

  • Anonymous

    I give it an OUT no matter who’s wearing it. Blech.

  • Anonymous

    Out, of course!

    But it doesn’t actually look good on the model, either.

    • Lisa

      True!

  • http://www.myblackfriendsays.com myblackfriendsays

    No. Out. 

  • Anonymous

    Man, that is one hiddy outfit. She’s probably a size 2 but in this dress her ribcage looks huge.  And those shoes. Not just nude, but nude PATENT LEATHER. Yuck. Pink and orange can be a very fabulous combination but not this time. 

  • Lisa

    Oh, what a shame! And she’s such a pretty girl! OUT – this is like “The Worst of the 80s”!

  • Anonymous

    I actually have a bigger problem with the top than the skirt. It makes her boobs just disappear and so the whole proportions are off. At the very least if it were a V neck or scoop neck, it might already be better. And I agree about the shoes, the scourge of the nude shoe has to be overcome.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=610791985 Aniela Marie Perry

    You said it. Out.

  • http://twitter.com/lauralexis Laura

    I am usually pro-nude (shoes and otherwise) but these are very nearly the exact shade of her legs and it’s very, very distracting. I love pairing pink and red, but this silhouette does NOT work.

    OUT.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

    Sorry girl, but it’s out.  She looks like she knows it too.

  • http://twitter.com/rgmx Mercy

    She looks divine, what are you two on?  Hair is dumb though, just pull it all the way back.  IN

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CQPXLNCBM5CZSHZZXJDHPVFS7E Buffy

    This dress is out no matter who wears it.  It’s really ugly!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Micaela-Cannon/1465504041 Micaela Cannon

    Hey stylists….just because a designer produces a piece of clothing, doesn’t automatically mean that it’s good fashion, it’s just fashion. Designers get reviews too, maybe you should see what the consensus was on this hideous ensemble?

    Oh ps OUT. love her though, and that’s a really pretty shade of red shes sporting on her head

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Micaela-Cannon/1465504041 Micaela Cannon

    Hey stylists….just because a designer produces a piece of clothing, doesn’t automatically mean that it’s good fashion, it’s just fashion. Designers get reviews too, maybe you should see what the consensus was on this hideous ensemble?

    Oh ps OUT. love her though, and that’s a really pretty shade of red shes sporting on her head

  • Anonymous

    Errrrr…I think she looks adorable! I mean, I can understand where the OUTs are coming from because it’s an unconventional and not incredibly flattering silhouette, but she’s making it work for me. IN.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sorana.tarmu Sorana Tarmu

    Also the hairdo is not working at all. Clear OUT.

  • Anonymous

    looks like those awful pillow valences from the 80s – OUT miss on the red and pink pairing – very difficult to pull off as illustrated here.

  • Anonymous

    the outfit is crap from the door. Hell no.

  • http://profiles.google.com/decapod73 T.S. Alexander

    Out.

  • Anonymous

    This dress is hideous and would look good on no one. It is an ugly dress, period. OUT, obviously.

  • http://twitter.com/jennsaysmeow Fifi LaRoux

    Oh honey, no!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_33EG4UF7CPFFYRL7LEVSGM2M5I Dawn

    OUT!  I can see that, and I’m an engineer.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. The dress doesn’t even look good on the model.

  • Anonymous

    OUT! No doubt about it. The dress obviously is hideously unflattering, but the shoes. Who thinks these fugly shoes make the legs look longer??? They’re just ugly. She is too pretty for this dull garbage.

  • Liana Brooks

    Out – It wasn’t a good look on the model and it does nothing to flatter her.

  • Anonymous

    Oy, OUT. That dress is horrible. So unflattering. She’s beautiful. The dress should just not be worn. Ever.

  • Anonymous

    OUT, wtf is that under her boob, does she have a third boob?  She should get that thing looked at.

  • http://twitter.com/qrter Alexander Peterhans

    Horrible. OUT.

  • http://profiles.google.com/aislingoconnor Aisling O’Connor

    IN. And I hate disagreeing with TLo.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_T24URKJGBLJQPBWCRPU37IIHLU Krab Louse

    I remember when the move to “more exotic looking” models came about when there was a move from the “All American blonde haired blue eyed” Christie Brinkley looking model to Kate Moss and others like her.  Now, things are getting ridiculous because that model wearing this outfit on the runway looks like The Predator.  Steady on.

  • Anonymous

    Out… so, very out.

  • http://profiles.google.com/sauchih Sau-Chih Feng

    That dress doesn’t even look that good on the model…. Seriously, just because you can shop and call designers to borrow dresses doesn’t automatically make you a stylist. So many stylists seem so lazy, pairing nude shoes with everything. Out, but it’s not your fault, Emma. it’s your stylist’s fault.

  • Patricia Biswanger

    OUT!

  • Anonymous

    Good lord that’s ugly on both women. It couldn’t possibly be un-ugly on any woman.

  • Anonymous

    OUT!funny dat i thought it worked,now that I see the close ups,its just terrible.

  • Anonymous

    OUT!funny dat i thought it worked,now that I see the close ups,its just terrible.

  • http://twitter.com/Unclassical Alexandria N

    so OUT it hurts. TLO I undertand that the outfit was so bad that was all you bare to talk about, but I must point out you neglected to mention the superbad hair. which is extra sad cause she usually has such perfect hair. love love emma but this is icky icky

  • Adella Thompson

    No… just no. Is she expecting to fall into the deep end of a wading pool? Out.

  • Shawn Hill

    Horrific color blocking attack on an innocent pretty girl.

  • Karen Ostertag

    Oh, OUT OUT OUT.  And PLEASE don’t say she’s not skinny enough– she looks borderline anorexic, with those ribs.  I think it’s just that the model’s broader shoulders and hips give her more of a nip to the waist.  But no, hair and makeup are the only things to like on this outfit.  Those shoes MUST GO.