In or Out: Kate Winslet in Victoria Beckham

Posted on June 22, 2011

After a night up with our colicky baby (i.e., our facacta servers went down) we are AWAKE, darlings! Bright-eyed! Bushy-tailed! Running on fumes! But the beautiful thing about bitchery is, it actually gets easier when you’re really tired.

Kate Winslet attends “Yo Dona” International Awards 2001 in Madrid in a Victoria Beckham gown.

Victoria Beckham Fall 2009 Collection/Model: Shaila Gonzaga

The funny thing about Vicki Beckham’s designs is whenever anyone puts one on, they turn into Vicki Beckham, right down to the severe hair and lemon-sucking facial expressions. We suspect her fashion business is a front and she’s really amassing an army of Vickis to take over the globe some day. But not today. So lets rips this look.

Well, not much to rip, really. We like the dress and the array of bottle openers thoughtfully installed on her stomach. It’s the look as a whole that leaves us less-than thrilled. Sure, she looks gorgeous, but she also looks a bit like a vampire. We imagine that one would almost be required to wear one’s hair up or back with this dress but she didn’t have to go all zombie queen on the makeup. We can’t really nitpick this one; we just aren’t crazy about the overall look. We always say that Kate Winslet goes out looking like anyone but Kate Winslet, but this is her look now; this slightly severe, highly polished veneer. We can accept it, but that doesn’t mean we like it.

VOTE NOW!

IN! Polished to pristine perfection!

OUT! Don’t let the scary lady get me!

The Minion Opinion on Hailee Steinfeld’s “biker chicklet” look was a resounding IN.

[Photo Credit: style.com, Getty]

Tags: , ,

  • http://profiles.google.com/shannonlstewart Shannon Stewart

    Something about this is off to me.  There’s something about the dress that just isn’t working, though I can’t figure out what it is. 

    IN, because I can’t find a good reason for an out!

  • Anonymous

    Well, I like the dress on her. So in I guess…..but her face looks like a waxworks combination of Angelina Jolie and Bridget Nelson.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NMIFZ6A7BHP66M546AO77BWVQ4 Bonnie

      I’m still wonderfing where the “real” Kate Winslet went-her face looks so strange now. 
      I will confess to be struck by TLo’s vision of an army of Victoria Beckhams taking over the world.
      bitchybitchybitchy

  • Anonymous

    I’m on the fence about this one, but I’m thinking OUT. You’re right she does look like Vicki and if I remember, Vicki wore this already and better.  Also, this isn’t Kate’s fault, but Vicki’s dresses seem to be designed mostly for the stick skinny.  Overall, just not feeling it.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. That little doohickey right above her stomach pulls attention there and, since it doesn’t go all the way across her like it does on the model, it looks like she’s much larger than I’m sure she is. Something about the way the fabric photographed is also off; like it looks cheaper on than in the professional photo.

    –M

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

      • Anonymous

        i agree with your agree.  Out

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • http://twitter.com/Siedhr Dana

      My thoughts exactly. It’s an OUT for me. Also, what’s up with the eyebrows? She looks like she’s auditioning for some evil witch.

    • Anonymous

      Doesn’t look to me as if the doohickey goes all the way across the model’s midriff either (though it does go farther!), she’s just standing at an angle.  I could be wrong.

  • margaret meyers

    Severe and aging.  sorry.   It’s a complete and polished look, so I can say “out,” but it isn’t a best look for Miss Winslet.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brian-Lipinski/2201190 Brian Lipinski

    A definite OUT.

  • Anonymous

    She looks gorgeous, IN.

  • http://www.facebook.com/smpatt01 Shannon Patterson

    Out. Vicki dresses Vickie’s body, so it looks better on the model. It’s two sizes too small on Kate, causing uniboob. The shoulders don’t look exaggerated enough on her body. They almost look like they’re misshapen by a clothes hanger.

  • http://profiles.google.com/anplica Anplica Fiore

    The dress shows off her curves to perfection!  In.

  • Anonymous

    Are you kidding me?!?! This is a WERQ! INNNNNNNNNN

  • Vaniljekjeks

    In!  

  • Anonymous

    To me her look says, “just TRY and look this good with two kids, betches.” In, most emphatically, IN.

  • Anonymous

    Out. This look ages her considerably and the dress isn’t doing a thing for her figure. Worst of all, it’s bland.

  • http://twitter.com/PhDKnitter marlie

    Love it…  **IN**!

  • http://twitter.com/PhDKnitter marlie

    Love it…  **IN**!

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • http://verenahafner.wordpress.com/ Verena

    IN! I’m a bit of a goth, I like severe.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    Don’t care for the bag.  I think an updo was required.  I really like the dress.  But the poor thing looks tired.  Like she was up for 26 hours then realized she couldn’t crash, she had to put on a dress and get her picture made. 

    Overall, my issues are minor and even tired-looking she’s beautiful.  IN.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=608416678 Jenny Jackson White

    I am quite afraid of her, but love that she is a woman with a real woman’s figure.  A guarded IN…..

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://profiles.google.com/vispreeve Daniel Vispreeve

     Although, she looks cold and evil-queenish (or like Vicki)  I say IN. 

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • http://twitter.com/A_SmallFry AC

    I like it. Its simple, sophisticated and polished. She does look a bit tired as some others mentioned, but overall I like the look. IN.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    It pains me terribly to say this but OUT.  I adore, adore, adore Kate and I think she has the ability to look amazing but here, she just doesn’t.  The dress is a touch too tight on her and makes her look heavy.  The midriff detail shouls have extended further on the sides to elongate the waist, as is it is just a block of bottle caps.  Her boobs are squished together into a uni-boob. The hair is too severe.  I can’t go on, sorry Kate.  I still love you.

  • Anonymous

    In. I like the severity, though she missed a bet, this would have set off Simple but Major jewel earrings beautifully. The only thing really wrong, IMO, is the hair. (If she perked up the make-up without perking up the hair, I think she’d look like a bad job by the undertaker.)

    • Anonymous

      By perking up the hair, I don’t mean anything too exuberant – still a pulled back up-do, but it should have come off of her face with a soft wave, IMO. Still elegant verging on Evil Queen, but more flattering.

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • Anonymous

    This is an angular dress meant for an angular woman, which our Kate is definitely not (not a slam: her body is more than fine by me) — so on her, it’s another dress altogether.  A perfectly fine dress but not nearly as striking.

    However, she looks less Out than usual (it may not fit perfectly, but it suits her better than most stuff she’s worn recently — and the hair & makeup don’t bother me that much) . . . so IN with an asterisk?

  • http://profiles.google.com/rosatcollege Ros Clarke

    OUT. Kate always looks better with a smile and if the dress doesn’t make her smile, she shouldn’t be wearing it.

  • Anonymous

    A fresher face is called for, but I disagree about the dress not being right for her body–looks amazing on her curves. IN!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1325734955 Robin K. Osterberg

    Oh come on … It looks like she’s had a car radio installed just under her breasts…. 

  • Aly Light

    It’s not the most exciting look in the world, but it has some drama to it, and she looks undeniably good. IN.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_64HSRZWCSJ5RBFGCWDLFQOICYM G

    IN.  Shows off her glorious womanly shape.. love the sun-kissed hair/pony tail… her purse looks interesting…  She is (usually) the queen of simplicity on the RC, and this is a just fine with me!

  • Anonymous

    In. I don’t love her shiny, severe look, but you really can’t fault this. 

  • http://twitter.com/artfulhome1 Christy Bishop

    Come on, folks. She looks womanly, pretty, and elegant. I think I especially like it on her because it IS unusual for her. If these red carpet looks aren’t there to create a character, in a way, what ARE they for?

  • Anonymous

    In.  I like it, even though the dress is a bit tight.  But I have to complain about the un-seasonability of this dress on a summer day in Spain!

  • http://profiles.google.com/ellenbehm Ellen Behm

    In

  • Anonymous

    I like it, i suspect i would have loved it madly in blue.
    IN non the less.

  • aimee_parrott

    I miss the old Kate Winslet.  OUT.

  • Eclectic Mayhem

    Love, Love, LOVE Ms Winslet but the dress is too tight.  Out.

  • http://twitter.com/sylvia_warren Sylvia

    In! I confess a deep and powerful attraction to Posh’s designs. However, I think this dress looks best on someone with…smaller breasts. I know, I know, very hard to reduce natural breast size, but it’s just the high straight neckline is best on A/B cups. 

  • Anonymous

    Sure, it’s got a definite WWW (“Wicked Witch of the West”) vibe, but I think she looks really good. This dress really shows off what a great figure she has and it’s styled well. No, Out from me. She’s all the way IN.

  • http://profiles.google.com/angelarosesarno angela rose sarno

    I love that she is showing off her body- it’s not hollywood thin, but it’s definitely a hot one by any name.  I also happen to think she is about as beautiful as they come (when they haven’t airbrushed her within an inch of her life in some ad campaign).  But there is no way around it, this is one ugly dress.  Sorry Lady Kate- OUT.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=167100010 Meghan Young

    In. She can’t be English Rose all the damn time, and she looks great. What’s wrong with her makeup? She’s fine. IN IN IN. 

  • Anonymous

    I like the dress on her, but there is something off about her face.   I don’t know if it’s the makeup or what exactly. She just looks off from the neck up.

  • Stacy Clarke

    I feel she SHOULD be in.  She looks like she could be, and should be, working the shit out of it, and look great.  But she’s just not.  She just decided to show up and say, “Yeah, here I am” instead.

  • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

    Oh, she’s IN!
    I really like this look. But is the belt askew on the model or does it just look that way because of her pose? I kind of like it better that way. Actually, looking again, it seems askew on Kate, but not as much and that bugs me. Either off to the side or straight-on. Not almost-straight.
    But anyway, she looks fantastic, love the hair, love the earrings. 

  • MilaXX

    It’s nice but very safe looking and a bit aging.

  • bookish

    I want to like it (mostly because I adore Kate Winslet), but somehow I just don’t. I think it’s mostly the length of that detail at the waist. I feel like it should go all the way across her front, from side to side, instead of just a couple inches across the front. As it is, it makes her look wider than she really is because it’s like a belt that’s too small or something. Maybe that’s just me.

    Tentative OUT.

  • Anonymous

    Sleek and modern, even if I hardly recognized her.  IN.

  • http://twitter.com/asciident Melissa Della

    I’m not hugely fond of the studded stomach panel, but it’s a minor nitpick. I actually think Kate looks pretty great–IN!

  • Anonymous

    Out, something isn’t working and I can’t put my finger on it.

  • Anonymous

    I give it an IN. I can totally see Posh Spice wearing this dress. I think it looks great on Kate. I’m almost not loving the hair but overall the look is great. I like the bottle opener belt!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UH5XQGXDKLXDSVGB626B53KXBA linda

    out

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

    IN, even though it’s a little tight across her hips.

  • Anonymous

    Oooh.  As much as I hate to say it because I lover her, but OUT.  It just looks…kinda…wrong somehow.

  • Anonymous

    I’m basically with you guys–not a lot to rip, but I’m already having trouble waking up this morning, and this dress isn’t helping.

    Okay, okay, specifics: Kate, the severe hairstyle is not for you.  It doesn’t do a thing for your face, and combined with a dress that’s also severe to the point of looking like a night out on the town in Salem circa 1692… well, Goody Winslet, thou hast sinned in thy fashion.

    I mean, I may be one of the rare people out there who admits liking the Puritans, but even I don’t think they’re a great fashion inspiration (which they’d certainly take as a compliment about their priorities being in better order than mine).

    Out.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Dress is too long on her, waist/belt lands too high on her, and color is too severe for her.

  • http://twitter.com/lizaboowears Lizzy’s Closet

    It is a bit severe–very dramatic–but I think it is ultimately flattering to her shape. Her hair color looks wrong to me–brassy and unflattering–but I really like that she didn’t go “dark lip, dark nail” with this dress because it’s unexpected to go “pink lip, natural nail” with such a dramatic black gown.

    I agree that Victoria Beckham’s dresses are all designed for very skinny women who do not flare out at the hips and can look completely wrong on woman with broader hips, but in this case, I think Winslet pulls it off with style.

  • http://twitter.com/QuincyTKatz Quincy Katz

    Hate the sin, but love the sinner.
    The severity of the look ages her. Considering she is a movie star with access to any designer she’d like to wear, and a cadre of hair and make-up people, I’d expect her to look young, fresh and amazing.
    She does not- so OUT!

  • Anonymous

    It’s too “grande dame” on Kate, and it really needs to feature the extreme hourglass shape with the train spread out at the bottom, as in the model picture.  For me the problem is that the dress itself is architecturally very interesting, but it doesn’t do anything for either of the women wearing it here.

  • Noah Exum

    i love the dress, just wish she’d do something with her hair. preferably something less blonde.

    IN

  • Anonymous

    Wow – I think she looks great.  Victoria is surprisingly talented as a designer.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FQ27CHTSKMYBYZGLWKQR6BAS3I Sonya

    WERQ it, Kate! Love, Love, Love it.

  • http://www.manoneileen.com Manon Eileen

    In, I think she looks gorgeous and sleek. 

  • Anonymous

    Fierce.  In.

  • Anonymous

    It’s not a complete out, but she needs to have a better bra.  Her tits look saggy.

    • Anonymous

      Or they just look that way because the dashboard thingy is kind of high.  Also, there’s definite uniboob, as others have mentioned.  So, saggy uniboob?  Bad Bad Bad news, Kate. 

  • http://twitter.com/aStudiobytheSea Jody Lee

    Out, alas.  Simply put, it makes her look chunky, the panel in front looks cheap, and did she just turn 50?  It’s an outfit from a Joan Crawford melodrama.

  • Anonymous

    I kind of dig her Vampira look, I say IN

  • Anonymous

    OUT.  This look is…boring.  Just a black sheath dress with a bottle cap belt.  Only good thing about it is the bag.

  • Anonymous

    IN, I think she looks great. It’s nice to mix it up sometimes. I also like how the dress accentuates her curves (not a euphemism for anything).

  • Anonymous

    *in*
    I can’t find anything major to fault with this, though I can understand some other posters’ issues. So small letters. I do like what I can see of the purse, and the understated earrings. The woman clearly knows how to pose, with poise.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1264609232 Samantha Ritchie

    IN but the make-up is not doing it for me at all

  • Anonymous

    Out. Somehow looks like Cruella de Vil to me.

  • Amie Curie

    IN. She’s GORGEOUS.

  • Amie Curie

    IN. She’s GORGEOUS.

  • Amie Curie

    IN. She’s GORGEOUS.

  • http://www.facebook.com/luv2birdie Elana Bryan

    When I first saw the picture I thought she was Sharon Stone – I think that means her makeup is too harsh.  Love the dress though.

  • Ella B. Mudge

    It’s not my favorite look of hers — a bit severe — but it’s still an IN!

  • http://profiles.google.com/rachelruthlee Rachel Lee

    Out. Something about the dress makes her look thick waisted, and that’s never flattering. I like the big exaggerated shoulders on the model. That didn’t seem to come out much in Kate’s dress. 

  • Joyce VG

    Torn!  Too severe, but I adore her.  IN.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=637520850 Madison Chua

    Kate Winslate has never looked less than Kate. And never looked more dated.  And it’s strange that she looks so hefty in a black dress.

  • Anonymous

    I vote for IN. She looks great in the dress, but from the neck up she’s very sad. Her hair’s too severe, her face is too pale–like others said, she looks really tired. But she’s rocking the dress so IN she is.

  • http://robot-heart.tumblr.com heartbot

    Has she had some work done on her face? =

  • aussiegal77

    Looks great although make-up is a bit on the severe side.  IN.

  • http://vhanna26.typepad.com Vera

    It’s not her best look; Vickie don’t dress for anyone with curves, but it’s not out either. IN.

  • Anonymous

    IN

    I like it a lot…she looks like a glamorous movie star.  Her face is a bit on the whitish side, which makes her smokey eye makeup look severe…so the zombie comment seems fitting.  I’m gonna blame it on bad lighting! ; )   It seems like she’s standing under a bright light, the way it’s shining on the top of her hair and the shadow of her head on her chest…plus the flash of the camera is probably not helping. Hair and accessories are ok.

  • Anonymous

    Since the divorce, she has looked sort of severe and unapproachable.  OUT.

  • Anonymous

    in. gorgeous.

  • Anonymous

    The problem with this dress is the neckline.  Those boatnecks are always problematic to anyone larger than an “A” cup.  You just end up with a huge expanse of fabric between the neck and the waist that gives the unfortunate saggy uniboob look no matter how smoking hot the bod underneath.  Mentally change it to a v-neck or a scoop and she instantly looks better.  I give it a reluctant “IN” because she does look pretty impeccable otherwise. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=506473106 Mori Clark

    OUT- this dress is designed for an extreme hourglass shape, and as gorgeous as kate is, her middle just looks awkwardly wide in this. the model even has to turn in order to get the intentioned look out of the dress- just standing straight at the camera completely negates that effect. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VIYL3EWWRXX4PFV3VRYDCM255U Stephanie F.H.

    Out.  I love the dress on the model, but it just seems… off on Winslet.  Maybe it’s the shoulders not working right, or the metal… thing needing to be stretched more.  I can’t tell you the exact reason, but I don’t like it on her.

  • http://twitter.com/danielleRwest Danielle West

    The length of the dress bothers me a bit, but she’s still an IN.  Nowhere near bad enough to be an out.

  • http://www.kittenmasks.com/ kittenmasks

    I actually like this look. Her facial expression? Not so much.

    http://www.kittenmasks.com

  • Anonymous

    Oooo! She looks ready to do another re-make of a Joan Crawford movie! Scary but I like it. IN.

  • Anonymous

    Oooo! She looks ready to do another re-make of a Joan Crawford movie! Scary but I like it. IN.

  • Anonymous

    In. Kate looks very polished here but not so happy.

    The dress looks little heavy looking for summer in Madrid.

  • Anonymous

    IN! 

    Nothing wrong with Kate Winslet as a vampire!

  • Sara__B

    In, but don’t let the scary lady get me! (That soul-less frozen smile is really getting to me.)

  • Mariah J

    I don’t like it. It makes Kate look wider than she is, which is weird because it’s black.

  • Tom Shea

    Small out. The dressisn’t suited to her body type. And if I have to choose between Kate’s body and Posh’s, it’s Kate all the way.

  • Anonymous

    Out. I think Kate’s put on a few pounds and is using this dress and some spanx to cover it up. And – it’s way too matronly. Remember, this gal is only 36.

  • http://twitter.com/monsterhoodie laurel fiske

    To quote The Duchess ” I just want to rip that thing right off the front!”  Distracting and waist-widening. OUT.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PKEMUFJDBZL5KUVSXY22FFS3EM Deborah

    My only objection to this look is that I want Kate Winslet to look warm and sweet and approachable, and I think she looks like a Heather here. It’s the only thing I can put my finger on that I don’t like. Otherwise she looks awesome.

  • Anonymous

    Winslet looks exhausted and unhappy, like she lost her best friend. It looks like something bad is going on in her life, look at her eyes. They are red and exhausted looking.
    Sad.
    Out.

  • Anonymous

    IN.  I’m just not seeing the zombie queen in her makeup, I think it looks fine.

    • margaret meyers

      Yeah:  not her best look, but not so bad it’s an OUT.

  • Anonymous

    This is an in, but I would just love for Kate to show up in a more relaxed style now and then. I think she looks her best when she’s just out on the street with less makeup and less done hair. Obviously that’s not appropriate for this event but she has been looking SO severe for quite some time now, it would be nice to see her in something that isn’t supposed to be “dramatic!” and “striking!”

  • Anonymous

    This is an in, but I would just love for Kate to show up in a more relaxed style now and then. I think she looks her best when she’s just out on the street with less makeup and less done hair. Obviously that’s not appropriate for this event but she has been looking SO severe for quite some time now, it would be nice to see her in something that isn’t supposed to be “dramatic!” and “striking!”

  • http://profiles.google.com/cracklerod Jasper Peng

    OUT – her eyes are red. is she high?

  • http://profiles.google.com/cracklerod Jasper Peng

    OUT – her eyes are red. is she high?

  • http://joansbooks.blogspot.com/ lilithcat

    The problem is the relationship between her boobs and that belt.  They’re too close together.  She needs to lower the belt, or get a foundation garment that lifts her boobs.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Nestor.Chocolato NesTtor Chocolato

    hate the makeup, ammm  i think  OUT

  • Anonymous

    In, and for her a definite step forward that should be encouraged.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jennifer-Blais/682440192 Jennifer Blais

    It looks as if her breasts are sitting halfway down her torso. I’m going to blame this on a combination of a bad neckline and a poorly fitting (or absent?) bra. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1374511853 Sara Yungwirth

    Out…
    This dress on her just isn’t working for me. It looks better on the model, in my opinion.
    I don’t really like the pony tail, though I’m really not a fan of pony tails on the red carpet (i think they’re for working out, doing housework, or fast food)
    And the expression on her face looks almost like she’s smelling something bad
    I just don’t think she’s working it.

  • http://pleasewelcomeyourjudges.com/ Brian @ PWYJudges

    Not digging the makeup, but the dress is fabulous. IN!

    (sidenote: it would take a LOT for me to give Kate an OUT….)

  • Anonymous

    WTF is it with celebrities looking older than they are?  She looks like a well preserved 50 in those photos.  I don’t hate the dress but it makes her look matronly.  Out.

    • margaret meyers

      Even little Bristol Palin looks older — the plastic surgery, the hair extensions, the bad clothing choices.  She’s the world’s oldest looking 20 year old.

    • http://profiles.google.com/trashilove { edi } ilovetrash

      but she’s a lot closer to forty than twenty.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PFPESDH4EDCW3UEDVNWWSHB4XQ Michaela T.

    oh god, no, why?

    She looks like Ursula the sea witch. I’m sorry, but NO. Her make up makes her look ten years older than she actually is, the hair is laughable, and the dress doesn’t suit her at all. Pretty much the only thing I like here is the purse.

    Kate, come back :(

  • Anonymous

    Eh. Boring. Out.

  • http://profiles.google.com/trashilove { edi } ilovetrash

    she looks fine. the hair’s not great, the lipstick’s not great–but: okay. still: she’d look a lot better if she put a merrywidow on it under it.

  • Anonymous

    In, but barely.  Not a good neckline for her.  Bateau necklines are better on the Audrey types.

  • Shawn Hill

    In. Sexy. Vampires = good.

  • Anonymous

    wow. Joan Crawford Lives. In.

  • http://twitter.com/DJButtons Breanna

    I’m down, actually. Fully IN. Love the clutch in particular, would have liked a little more “oomph” with the makeup, and the hair is only so-so for me, but you can’t deny she looks good.

  • Anonymous

    in

    • margaret meyers

      Yeah, a lower case “in” is what I’m thinking. 

  • Lattis

    You know what, I give her an in. But, with Veronica Lake hair, she’d be IN.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Catherine-Rhodes/602850414 Catherine Rhodes

    OUT. Not Kate’s dress whatsoever. She’s trying for elegant but achieving frumpy. FYI: she has a lemon-pucker look on her face from wearing wall-to-wall Spanx under that dress. She can’t wait to go home and peel it all off.

  • http://twitter.com/iraki86 Ira Ioannidou

    IN!

  • Serena Chen

    She looks oddly like Mila Jovovich or Pink in the 1st pic…something I never thought I’d say.  Too severe…she usually looks a bit more vivacious than this.

  • Anonymous

    IN. But her hair should be darker to wear this dress with that makeup. It just doesn’t look quite right with that weird blonde.

  • Jessica O’Connell

    I hate her hair and make up and I think the dress makes her look bigger than she is. OUT.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_N3GA2TTX752OYSKBWWXQVFM2HI katie

    out- this makes her look thick.

  • Anonymous

    OUT. Dress is only OK and the hair needs to be softened.

  • Haley Buchanan

    In.  She look’s positively curve-tastic!  I think the metallics in the accessories keep it from crossing the line to Morticia Addams.

  • Anonymous

    In! She looks sleek and gorgeous.

  • http://twitter.com/pag_baj Paige Boerman

    I love it. IN.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sorana.tarmu Sorana Tarmu

    This Morticia look really works on Kate. IN.

  • Anonymous

    Ick. Makeup’s bad, hair’s bad, and that metal crap on her belly is just ugly. OUT.

  • Angela Green

    In, though I agree about the hair.
     

  • Anonymous

    It’s the black-all-over look that is forcing me to give an “out” even though, really, the dress is fine, the styling is fine.  KW just isn’t a woman who wears black well.

  • Anonymous

    In – somewhat severe, but basically in

  • Megan Sullivan

    I just don’t like the way her face looks in these pictures…….. but I like the look in general, so IN.

  • Anonymous

    Have to agree that the hair and eyebrows are too servere, but those nitpicks aside, I think she looks great.
    IN.

  • Erica Moon

    Love it – I think her curves suit the dress and she looks BETTER than Victoria Beckham.  IN.

  • Anonymous

    I say out. Kate’s got a fab figure obvs, but this seems too tight. Just looking at it is giving my lungs sympathy pains.

  • Anonymous

    I say out. Kate’s got a fab figure obvs, but this seems too tight. Just looking at it is giving my lungs sympathy pains.

  • Nicole St. Germain

    IN she looks fantastic! 

  • Anonymous

    Do not like, she looks sort of sad and desperate or something, can’t quite put my finger on it. Out!

  • http://twitter.com/thelilerin erin l.

    in. kate hasn’t failed in years. i get what you’re saying about her face/hair/posture, but it’s demure and classic more than victoria-esque.

  • Zubair Ghumro

    OUT!! I think this is not a dress for Kate. She is neither tall or petite like the model or the designer intended the wearer to be . Its slosh too tight and she looks like stifling her breathe. Giselle Bundchen might would’ve rocked it.  

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kelsey-Albrecht/100001647200441 Kelsey Albrecht

    OUT. Hate the bleached hair and the dress isn’t flattering to her.

  • Diana Martinez

    OUT!  She just looks….. I don’t know.  But she’s prettier than this is letting her be.

  • Anonymous

    Um, she looks GORGEOUS. I wish that waist panel was one or two inches longer because I think it would be more slimming, but seriously – Kate is IN!

  • http://twitter.com/Unclassical Alexandria N

    OUT! COLOR! Hello! It’s PRIDE month for oprah’s sake!

  • Anonymous

    shes taking a sharon stone turn lately and its not good.

  • Anonymous

    In. Classic.

  • http://profiles.google.com/sleepneeded Greg Polansky

    Out. It pains me to say this. . . but she does not have a thin enough waistline for this dress.

  • Glen Coleson

    the problem with the studs is that they didn’t scale it up with the rest of the dress, so on anyone bigger than a size 0 its going to look bad because the ‘belt’ doesn’t go all the way across her waist. It’s very bad design. Kate gets an IN for working it regardless; Madame Beckham gets a stern OUT for producing it.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VW5XHSH45FBZ2ZEZJARYHILIZQ Leah

    You know what, it’s the angle of the shot. She’s straight on. The appeal of the dress and her curves is their combined ability to make her look really chic and narrow in the waist. Unfortunately, she’s facing the camera dead on, so we just get the wide shot…not that she’s wide, but you know what I mean. Look at the model!

  • Anonymous

    Dress = “IN” Haircolor = “OUT”

  • Anonymous

    IN. I think she looks great. I have nothing to criticize here.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

    In.

  • Anonymous

    In.  Beautiful and flattering dress.

  • Anonymous

    Come ON! It’s an in – so obvious! (disclaimer – big KW fan here – she always comes across as quite real and normal)

  • Anonymous

    OUT.

    There’s nothing wrong with Kate and there’s nothing wrong with the dress (I take it back…I hate the bling… what’s up with that?) but the two of them don’t go together. 

    Vicky’s dresses are meant to be worn by skeletons, not full figured gals.  Like TLo says:  “Gurrrl….this is someone else’s dress.”

  • Anonymous

    IN. She looks just fine.

  • Anonymous

    I thought it was Sharon Stone.

  • Grace Ritt

    I think she looks awesome and edgy! IN!

  • Anonymous

    nay..it ages her…her hair appears to be heading the way of peppy-la-pew, even though i know it is an illusion of the photo…maybe a bit of a softer hairstyle and shorter hem would have done it for me….

  • Hilary Sain

    She looks gorgeous and fierce!!! IN

  • http://summerborn.livejournal.com/ Summer Born

    OUT. I love her and I love her body but this dress is not right on her. The hips… ew.

  • http://twitter.com/marared Jaime

    Out. She’s too wide for that dress – at least not with that little embellishment calling attention to her waist. (Which is not to imply that I think she’s fat; she’s gorgeous and should always remain on the voluptuous side, but that particular dress does not do her any favors.)

  • Anonymous

    Victoria Beckham has turned out to be quite a good designer.  Who’d a thunk it?  

    In.  Kate looks killer in the dress, but a softer look up top would have provided better balance.

  • Jaeda Laurez

    i love it- she looks dynamite!

  • Anonymous

    oy, poor thing cant breath… looks like black saran wrap. out

  • Anonymous

    She’s almost working it, but her boobs are really too big for a neckline that high. I know of which I speak. I miss her vaguely retro sweetheart-neckline gowns. Come back PrettyKate! SevereKate is making me nervous…

  • akprincess72

    I don’t hate this.

  • http://blue-again.myopenid.com/ blue

    OUT. Dress is uggo. It doesn’t even look good on the model

  • Anonymous

    I love Kate but this is an OUT.  She looks completely uninterested, and the dress is something pulled from the closet of Morticia Addams.

  • sonictofu

    IN – Kate looks better than the model.  Enough said.

  • Anonymous

    IN + WERQ! Girl looks fierce!

  • Anonymous

    love it. 

  • Anonymous

    Borrrring. Out!

  • lilibetp

    I kind of like the design of the dress, but not the color of the dress.  Maybe Kate needs navy or burgundy or something, but I don’t really dig her in black.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_C65IT4K6RYN4TWRMFJOI3VUDAI Olechka Milashka

    In

  • http://twitter.com/kmc1138 Kathleen Coyle

    In.  I love a thicker girl in a va-va-voom dress that doesn’t go all T&A.  A different (maybe less bored?) expression would have made this a WERQ for me.

  • Anonymous

    This is an OUT. Yes, as an Actor you want to wear the dress, not have the dress wear you, but there’s some middle ground between black matte and sequins, you know?

  • oohsparkley!

    IN.  I think it werqs, but I prefer her looking a little softer, not like she’s going to bite me or throw a phone at me.

  • Patricia Biswanger

    OUT.  Too Brigitte Nielsen-ish.

  • Samantha Irene

    I wish that if she sticks with the whole ‘high polish’ thing that she starts bringing out more dramatic dresses – at least give us something fun to look at.

    Out

  • Anonymous

    Y’all can say “Vicki” all you want, she’ll always be “Posh” to me!

    By the way, I say IN, for what that’s worth.

  • Margot Brose

    This is an epic dress, but this is not her dress. THe interesting little silver thingees on the front draw eyes right to the fact that it doesn’t fit over her bell well v_v. One size up, baby, but this IS an IN

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Heather-McIlrath/673340132 Heather McIlrath

    …she scares me now. she looks so angry! where did everybody loves kate go?