Yea or Nay: Tilda Swinton’s Roger Vivier Shoes

Posted on May 12, 2011

Tilda Swinton showed up at the Cannes photocall for We Need To Talk About Kevin wearing Roger Vivier Spring 2011 shoes. Oh sure, she wore other things as well, but they weren’t all that interesting. It is an alarming development in the world of Tilda Swinton that we can characterize her red carpet outfit as “not interesting,” but everyone has an off day and maybe she was cranky and retaining water and didn’t feel like giving the world the full Swinton treatment. Fair enough.

Rose N’ Roll Paille, Roger Vivier

 

But the shoes are pretty freaking, fabulous, right? Well, we think so anyway – and we normally hate ankle straps. You’ll have to let us know what you think, darlings. Lucky for you, you only have to shout out one syllable. Never let it be said that we don’t make is as easy as possible for you to be a bunch of opinionated bitches.

 

Tilda Swinton’s Rose Toes: YEA or NAY?

 

[Photo Credit: wireimage, getty, rogervivier.com]

    • Aunt Dee

      Yea! And perfect for Cannes in the summer.

    • Aunt Dee

      Yea! And perfect for Cannes in the summer.

    • Anonymous

      Love the ankle straps, hate the roses. The vote is Nay.

    • BlondettaChick

      Love the ankle straps, hate the roses. The vote is Nay.

    • anon

      Yea. Perfect for the Riviera: espadrille-referencing heels.

    • KB

      Big Yea!

    • anon

      Yea. Perfect for the Riviera: espadrille-referencing heels.

    • KB

      Big Yea!

    • anon

      yea!

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

      Yay…I really like the picture of just the shoe, and I think they just look more awkward b/c she has on her business attire with fun summer shoes.

    • http://profiles.google.com/jasminemg Jasmine Guillory

      YAY! Those shoes are amazing.

    • Anonymous

      I normally don’t like ankle straps either, but Tilda is exactly the kind of person (and the only kind of person) that ankle straps were designed for.

      –GothamTomato

    • anon

      yea!

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jessica-TallGirl-Freeman/1043623567 Jessica TallGirl Freeman

      Yay…I really like the picture of just the shoe, and I think they just look more awkward b/c she has on her business attire with fun summer shoes.

      • http://profiles.google.com/laura.jane.ogorman Laura O’Gorman

        Kind of agree.

    • http://profiles.google.com/jasminemg Jasmine Guillory

      YAY! Those shoes are amazing.

    • http://www.thirteen.org/program-content/downton-dish-season-3-episode-1/ Gotham Tomato

      I normally don’t like ankle straps either, but Tilda is exactly the kind of person (and the only kind of person) that ankle straps were designed for.

      –GothamTomato

    • http://twitter.com/AnnaPBrittain APB

      Yea! I love them.

    • mallory

      Yea for summer swinton!

    • Colleen

      YAY!!!!!

    • http://twitter.com/AnnaPBrittain APB

      Yea! I love them.

    • mallory

      Yea for summer swinton!

    • Colleen

      YAY!!!!!

    • Janine

      They are so different for her. I love them!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=583342965 Melody Sellers

      Yea, Fab shoes!

    • SWINTON

      So good.

    • Janine

      They are so different for her. I love them!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=583342965 Melody Sellers

      Yea, Fab shoes!

    • SWINTON

      So good.

    • Vispreeve

      YEA!

    • Anonymous

      Yuck.

    • Anonymous

      Yuck.

    • Vispreeve

      YEA!

    • http://www.lippsisters.com/ Deborah Lipp

      Yuck.

    • manionista

      Love those heels, hate her legs. The vote is Yay.

    • Breeze

      YEA!

    • manionista

      Love those heels, hate her legs. The vote is Yay.

    • Breeze

      YEA!

    • KellyK

      yea!!

    • Thig85

      Yea

    • KellyK

      yea!!

    • Thig85

      Yea

    • http://twitter.com/anibellee Lynsey Martin

      Yea! The cutest shoes with the end of a dog bone on them that i’ve ever seen. gotta love some SWINTON!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RK5MAF2VNT32ULNYFIXDANTEC4 Terence

      A definite YEA.

    • Anonymous

      YEA! Even if the heel height looks perilous even for a Swinton!

    • http://twitter.com/anibellee Lynsey M.

      Yea! The cutest shoes with the end of a dog bone on them that i’ve ever seen. gotta love some SWINTON!

      • Kristheot

        Oh, I liked these shoes until you mentioned the dog bone. Now I can only see rawhide. Nay!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RK5MAF2VNT32ULNYFIXDANTEC4 Terence

      A definite YEA.

    • suzanne77

      YEA! Even if the heel height looks perilous even for a Swinton!

    • Kathleen

      With the correct outfit. totally yah! But you have to know how to wear them.

    • Caaro1947

      YAY.

    • http://twitter.com/tylka5 K S

      Yea and now I want!!!

    • Kathleen

      With the correct outfit. totally yah! But you have to know how to wear them.

    • Caaro1947

      YAY.

    • http://twitter.com/tylka5 K S

      Yea and now I want!!!

    • http://twitter.com/alienspouse Jen Alien-Spouse

      YEA and also WANT. Even thought I couldn’t walk in those.

    • http://profiles.google.com/laurenjeanstm Lauren St Martin

      Nae

    • zanna6

      Girl could sure use some spray-on color/concealer, but the shoes are great

    • http://twitter.com/alienspouse Jen Alien-Spouse

      YEA and also WANT. Even though I couldn’t walk in those.

    • http://profiles.google.com/laurenjeanstm Lauren St Martin

      Nae

    • zanna6

      Girl could sure use some spray-on color/concealer, but the shoes are great

    • http://profiles.google.com/singingraisin ali meowmeow

      NAY. Are you kidding me with those rosettes? I think y’all are just blinded by the Tilda of it all; were anyone else attempting those shoes, you would have them reduced to tears in seconds.

    • Guest

      NAY. Are you kidding me with those rosettes? I think y’all are just blinded by the Tilda of it all; were anyone else attempting those shoes, you would have them reduced to tears in seconds.

      • obiwan2011

        Let me clarify.  Tilda’s Tildaness that makes this shoe werq…She’s like an older version of those tall, androgynous, almost ugly with great cheek bones exotic models, and her perpetual mood is one of proud apathy to fashion standards of mere mortals. She’s made for experimental fashion.  

        Tan, happy, people pleasing girl next door cheerleaders like Blake Lively or Jennifer Aniston, don’t have the ladyballs to wear this shoe. Their “trying too hard” would soooo be showing and this shoe would be definitely nay. 

    • Ginger

      Hell yea.

    • Ginger

      Hell yea.

    • Mandy

      Yea for sure.

    • SBG

      YEA! How could anyone hate ankle straps. Love them.

    • Mandy

      Yea for sure.

    • SBG

      YEA! How could anyone hate ankle straps. Love them.

    • Angiecakes

      Duh… yea! Tilda is statuesque enough to pull off the ankle straps because you can’t stumpify legs as long as hers. Love the rosette, too!

    • Angiecakes

      Duh… yea! Tilda is statuesque enough to pull off the ankle straps because you can’t stumpify legs as long as hers. Love the rosette, too!

    • tom

      I love the enitre outfit, head to toe! That blouse and skirt are both so understated daytime glamour and the perfect foil for those amazing shoes. It would have been nice if the shoes fot her feet, they appear very loose in the heel. Love the hair!

    • tom

      I love the enitre outfit, head to toe! That blouse and skirt are both so understated daytime glamour and the perfect foil for those amazing shoes. It would have been nice if the shoes fot her feet, they appear very loose in the heel. Love the hair!

      • fursa_saida

        I think it’s because, like me, Tilda has very wide feet across the ball and narrow heels. Look at the picture where you can see her feet from the front: in order to accommodate her foot with the strap in the front, she probably had to go up to a size that’s maybe a bit too long. Been there a thousand times. (Actually, it looks like she might have bunions, which my mother and I both also have, and let me tell you, that only makes the “wedge-shaped foot” problem you were born with a thousand times worse. Oy.)

    • Anonymous

      Love Roger Vivier. Love Tilda Swinton And they go great together.Yea.

    • SewingSiren

      Love Roger Vivier. Love Tilda Swinton And they go great together.Yea.

    • Amanda in Austin

      Take off the little cinnamon rolls on top, and I’d say Yea. As they are, it’s NAY.

    • Amanda in Austin

      Take off the little cinnamon rolls on top, and I’d say Yea. As they are, it’s NAY.

    • Gillian

      Yea! Although how come Tilda’s don’t have the espadrille heel like the picture? I like them a little better with the espadrille heel.

    • Gillian

      Yea! Although how come Tilda’s don’t have the espadrille heel like the picture? I like them a little better with the espadrille heel.

    • Erin

      Is it me or are the to small for her feet? Her foot seems to be hanging off a little there – and the roses are fug!

    • Jane

      I could never wear the shoes because I need the length of leg that the ankle straps cut off; however they are ab/fab shoes that look ab/fab on her delicate ankles.

    • jbdc

      Yes!

    • Miranda

      I disagree – her shoes look like a couple cinnamon rolls somehow got stuck to them. The proportion or shape or something about the roses is just not good.

    • Erin

      Is it me or are the to small for her feet? Her foot seems to be hanging off a little there – and the roses are fug!

      • ItsDicey

        It’s just her bunions…they do that.

    • Jane

      I could never wear the shoes because I need the length of leg that the ankle straps cut off; however they are ab/fab shoes that look ab/fab on her delicate ankles.

    • jbdc

      Yes!

    • Miranda

      I disagree – her shoes look like a couple cinnamon rolls somehow got stuck to them. The proportion or shape or something about the roses is just not good.

    • marlie

      YEA!

    • Anonymous

      Yea on the shoes and the entire ‘fit. Understated daytime glamour, indeed!

    • marlie

      YEA!

    • minnye

      Yea on the shoes and the entire ‘fit. Understated daytime glamour, indeed!

    • Limnadhappy

      I like the shoes in spite of *these* straw flowers. The shoes are killa, and the straw flowers are good in theory, but I would’ve liked the flowers made smaller and with a more ‘organic’ touch. These flowers just look kinda crafty to me.

      I won’t lie, though, that outfit is egregiously styled. I love the skirt (maybe in a different shade, though…?) but HATE the blouse and that sloppy tuck. That blouse speaks of a ‘just-laid-off’ bender, and Tilda (or any other celebrity, for that matter) should be above that.

    • Limnadhappy

      I like the shoes in spite of *these* straw flowers. The shoes are killa, and the straw flowers are good in theory, but I would’ve liked the flowers made smaller and with a more ‘organic’ touch. These flowers just look kinda crafty to me.

      I won’t lie, though, that outfit is egregiously styled. I love the skirt (maybe in a different shade, though…?) but HATE the blouse and that sloppy tuck. That blouse speaks of a ‘just-laid-off’ bender, and Tilda (or any other celebrity, for that matter) should be above that.

    • Carolyn

      Yea!!!!!! I. Must. Have. Them. NOW.

    • Merrigator

      OH HELL YES!

    • Jill

      YEA!!! The fabulous bitch.

    • Carolyn

      Yea!!!!!! I. Must. Have. Them. NOW.

    • merrigator

      OH HELL YES!

    • Jill

      YEA!!! The fabulous bitch.

    • Anonymous

      Nay. Looks like she’s carrying grain to market. On her shoes.

    • ThaliaMenninger

      Nay. Looks like she’s carrying grain to market. On her shoes.

    • PostsYouCanDanceTo

      Yea!

    • PostsYouCanDanceTo

      Yea!

    • http://twitter.com/elizonthelam elizabeth

      Yea! Particularly with the toned down outfit. Makes the shoes fab rather than too much going on.

    • Kira

      Nay. Too big, too tall, too nobby, and too black. She’d step out of the shoe without the strap – next time ask for Tilda’s size. They look excruciatingly uncomfortable due to their height. The heel nob just throws the look completely off. And, finally, black is not a friend to the pale.

    • elizonthelam

      Yea! Particularly with the toned down outfit. Makes the shoes fab rather than too much going on.

    • Kira

      Nay. Too big, too tall, too nobby, and too black. She’d step out of the shoe without the strap – next time ask for Tilda’s size. They look excruciatingly uncomfortable due to their height. The heel nob just throws the look completely off. And, finally, black is not a friend to the pale.

    • Tanotice

      Love the shoes. SWINTON is one of the very few who cannot be stumpified, even by an ankle strap. Her feet aren’t terribly attractive close up, but I’m really not a foot person (shoes yes, feet no). Adore the thorn on the heels.

    • Tanotice

      Love the shoes. SWINTON is one of the very few who cannot be stumpified, even by an ankle strap. Her feet aren’t terribly attractive close up, but I’m really not a foot person (shoes yes, feet no). Adore the thorn on the heels.

    • Jlk1980

      Yea! Although ankle straps are not for everyone.

      And are naked or naked-looking toenails a thing now? Because it makes me want to vomit.

    • Jlk1980

      Yea! Although ankle straps are not for everyone.

      And are naked or naked-looking toenails a thing now? Because it makes me want to vomit.

    • Miss Heather

      YEA. Plus I love that she’s a tall girl in heels.

    • Krakoa10

      Gorgeous!

    • Anonymous

      Absolutely not. At least not with that awful rose thing on the front. Without the rose, it looks pretty good.

    • Miss Heather

      YEA. Plus I love that she’s a tall girl in heels.

    • Krakoa10

      Gorgeous!

    • Cathy S

      Absolutely not. At least not with that awful rose thing on the front. Without the rose, it looks pretty good.

    • http://profiles.google.com/fionna13 Cassandra McCraw

      Freakin’ fabulous.

    • http://profiles.google.com/fionna13 Cassandra McCraw

      Freakin’ fabulous.

    • CAT

      Yea.

      I think the proportions of the outfit keep it interesting.

    • ask

      NAY

      Pretty shoes that do not fit and that you cannot walk in. out

      umm they don’t look like they fit. It is like her feet are sliding forward and the strap is forward away from the heel cup. All of these celebs who borrow too big shoes – could that be why she has those bunions? The close up looks like the shoes are not wide enough (but too long).

    • Kitty13_x

      Bleh.

    • MzzPants

      Yea.

      I think the proportions of the outfit keep it interesting.

    • ask

      NAY

      Pretty shoes that do not fit and that you cannot walk in. out

      umm they don’t look like they fit. It is like her feet are sliding forward and the strap is forward away from the heel cup. All of these celebs who borrow too big shoes – could that be why she has those bunions? The close up looks like the shoes are not wide enough (but too long).

    • Kitty13_x

      Bleh.

    • mjude

      YEA!

    • Barbara

      Yea for the shoe itself, but it looks like her bunion is screaming to get out of there!

    • mjude

      YEA!

    • Barbara

      Yea for the shoe itself, but it looks like her bunion is screaming to get out of there!

    • Brittany

      Yea!

    • Brittany

      Yea!

    • Mag

      Nay. And Tilda, honey, nylons are your friend.

    • wadieo

      She shouldn’t go bare legged. Ugly vein-y legs. Shoes are ok.

    • Mag

      Nay. And Tilda, honey, nylons are your friend.

    • sstarcko

      Yea! 100% heart those shoes

    • Kimberley

      It was good up until that rose thingie. A good shoe ruined. Nay.

    • sstarcko

      Yea! 100% heart those shoes

    • Kimberley

      It was good up until that rose thingie. A good shoe ruined. Nay.

    • Tam

      YAY. LOVE that high-waisted skirt.

    • Tam

      YAY. LOVE that high-waisted skirt.

    • MilaXX

      yay on the shoes, nay on the rest of the outfit. It’s as secretarial as Christina’s,

    • Vaniljekjeks

      Yea! She is wearing the heck out of those shoes! Ankle straps work in certain situations, and this is definitely one of them.

    • MilaXX

      yay on the shoes, nay on the rest of the outfit. It’s as secretarial as Christina’s,

    • Vaniljekjeks

      Yea! She is wearing the heck out of those shoes! Ankle straps work in certain situations, and this is definitely one of them.

    • MyBigKitty

      I love ‘em! I just don’t like the way the look against her legs. Can’t get past the veins. Bleh!

    • JosephLamour

      No. The roses are too big. If they were a skosh smaller maybe. And, if anyone other than a fashion plate like Tilda Swinton were wearing them, you all would probably make fun of them for wearing ridiculous shoes.

    • Anonymous

      I love ‘em! I just don’t like the way the look against her legs. Can’t get past the veins. Bleh!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=12500056 Joseph Lamour

      No. The roses are too big. If they were a skosh smaller maybe. And, if anyone other than a fashion plate like Tilda Swinton were wearing them, you all would probably make fun of them for wearing ridiculous shoes.

    • elle

      Yea, but not on her. I don’t get the love for Swinton.

    • littlestars

      Yea!

    • elle

      Yea, but not on her. I don’t get the love for Swinton.

    • Anonymous

      Yea!

    • chemkk

      Nay. Hate the rosette, hate the fit on the back.

    • chemkk

      Nay. Hate the rosette, hate the fit on the back.

    • http://twitter.com/lucadrina AJ

      They’re pretty fabulous, but they still look like cinnabons

    • http://twitter.com/lucadrina AJ

      They’re pretty fabulous, but they still look like cinnabons

    • Karen

      Yea! I love ankle straps, but my short little legs can’t deal with them. Her stems can handle an ankle strap!

    • Karen

      Yea! I love ankle straps, but my short little legs can’t deal with them. Her stems can handle an ankle strap!

    • Betsy

      Hell to the yea!

    • Addis R. Pérez

      The shoes, for me, are a NAY. I don’t like the roses; I do find interesting that the shoes have an espadrille-feel, but, alas, I don’t like espadrilles, either.

      Tilda Swinton, however, will always get a YAY!

    • Miss Fern

      YAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY beautiful, i covet.

    • Betsy

      Hell to the yea!

    • http://www.deathbywhippedcream.com/ Addis R. Pérez

      The shoes, for me, are a NAY. I don’t like the roses; I do find interesting that the shoes have an espadrille-feel, but, alas, I don’t like espadrilles, either.

      Tilda Swinton, however, will always get a YAY!

    • Miss Fern

      YAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY beautiful, i covet.

    • Erin Nice

      A very enthusiastic yea! They’re gorgeous.

    • Erin Nice

      A very enthusiastic yea! They’re gorgeous.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1427462000 Heather Hartmann Furr

      It’s a YEA. Tilda is saving up the awesome for the premiere, this is just the photocall and usually less casual than red carpet. Can’t wait to see what she wears that makes these shoes look casual enough for photocalls.

    • Lib

      Yes! Yes! Yes!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1427462000 Heather Hartmann Furr

      It’s a YEA. Tilda is saving up the awesome for the premiere, this is just the photocall and usually less casual than red carpet. Can’t wait to see what she wears that makes these shoes look casual enough for photocalls.

    • Lib

      Yes! Yes! Yes!

    • Sara__B

      Nay. I like everything about the shoe except the humongous flower. From a distance it’s more like a unicorn horn for the little toe. Or a giant corn.

    • Sara__B

      Nay. I like everything about the shoe except the humongous flower. From a distance it’s more like a unicorn horn for the little toe. Or a giant corn.

    • Sarita

      Ah, YEA! fabulous. I want them. And btdubs, all you ppl being mean about her legs, don’t be mean. i like that she rocks the pale English skin!

    • anon

      MFYEA!

      Serious off day for her, though. Not that I’d want to be the stylist who tells her she could really use some tinted moisturizer on those legs…

    • Gelcat

      forget the shoes! she needs to work on something to smooth out those legs! (they’re great in form, but the veinage is distracting a bit – yes, toned downed for The Swinton, not on board with the straw flowers – too large, me thinks – if they were any other material, would we give them a break?

    • Gelcat

      forget the shoes! she needs to work on something to smooth out those legs! (they’re great in form, but the veinage is distracting a bit – yes, toned downed for The Swinton, not on board with the straw flowers – too large, me thinks – if they were any other material, would we give them a break?

    • http://profiles.google.com/trashilove { edi } ilovetrash

      very nice.

    • http://profiles.google.com/susanvmayer Susan Mayer

      Super cute! But in the world of SWINTON, they’re so normal!

    • holdmewhileimnaked

      very nice.

    • http://profiles.google.com/susanvmayer Susan Mayer

      Super cute! But in the world of SWINTON, they’re so normal!

    • uh huh

      TLo runs a SWINTON yea-or-nay? I suspect this is a sneaky test on their part… It’s THE SWINTON, therefore it is yea until proven otherwise.

    • uh huh

      TLo runs a SWINTON yea-or-nay? I suspect this is a sneaky test on their part… It’s THE SWINTON, therefore it is yea until proven otherwise.

    • http://profiles.google.com/starstattootoo kane watkins

      I would have preferred the straw Cinnabons be somewhat smaller.

    • aussiegal77

      YAY!!! Oh freaking YAY. I love those shoes!!!

    • Kane Watkins

      I would have preferred the straw Cinnabons be somewhat smaller.

    • CeeQ

      YAY!!! Oh freaking YAY. I love those shoes!!!

    • Anonymous

      I’m torn, but leaning towards YEA

    • mozzer0906

      I’m torn, but leaning towards YEA

    • Puggerpete

      The shoes are fine except for the sombreros they’re wearing. Poor dear looks like nanny playing with the Mistress’s shoes.

    • Puggerpete

      The shoes are fine except for the sombreros they’re wearing. Poor dear looks like nanny playing with the Mistress’s shoes.

    • http://vhanna26.typepad.com Vera

      YEA!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

      Nay on the rose. I like everything else.

    • http://vhanna26.typepad.com Vera

      YEA!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3AJ237ND3GAHDQJZ4TLCO4WLRA Emily

      Nay on the rose. I like everything else.

    • Anonymous

      I love these. And Tlo, I aesthetically understand your argument against anklestraps. However, as a woman who cannot for the life of her keep slingbacks on and who thinks that one-strap-across-the-top heeled sandals lead to clip-clopping, I have come down on the side of anklestraps. Preferably flesh-toned straps (ymmv on what “flesh-tone” is).

    • Chaiaiai

      I love these. And Tlo, I aesthetically understand your argument against anklestraps. However, as a woman who cannot for the life of her keep slingbacks on and who thinks that one-strap-across-the-top heeled sandals lead to clip-clopping, I have come down on the side of anklestraps. Preferably flesh-toned straps (ymmv on what “flesh-tone” is).

    • Anonymous

      I’m enjoying the espadrille elements on both genders’ shoes this season … pretty creative. This pair is great, elegant fun — as our dear Swinton usually is, but I sure wish her poor feet looked better – particularly as the shoes draw the eye straight to them.

    • Lilak

      I’m enjoying the espadrille elements on both genders’ shoes this season … pretty creative. This pair is great, elegant fun — as our dear Swinton usually is, but I sure wish her poor feet looked better – particularly as the shoes draw the eye straight to them.

    • Breeze

      I have already given them a “yea”, but how do people walk in those things? How do they keep from sliding off/ from twisting their ankles? Very gingerly is my guess. These look like an accident waiting to happen!

    • Kaycee

      Nay! I like design elements that look more integrated – those roses look an after-thought.

    • Breeze

      I have already given them a “yea”, but how do people walk in those things? How do they keep from sliding off/ from twisting their ankles? Very gingerly is my guess. These look like an accident waiting to happen!

    • Kaycee

      Nay! I like design elements that look more integrated – those roses look an after-thought.

    • ~K~

      I just don’t get it…I know y’all love this girl but she is ugly! Fix your hair, put on a little make up and get a pedicure and then come talk to me….the shoes however are to die for! Especially the ones in the picure with the straw on the heel part too. I now get why this yea or nay stuff is a little dicey…lots of grey areas.

    • annrr

      Yay. Summer fun shoe! So not loving with that outfit.

    • annrr

      Yay. Summer fun shoe! So not loving with that outfit.

    • Angela Capello

      YEA! Fan-fucking-tastic!

    • Angela Capello

      YEA! Fan-fucking-tastic!

    • blogless

      Nay. Unless you have perfect feet and I doubt they’d let 8 years old wear them.

    • blogless

      Nay. Unless you have perfect feet and I doubt they’d let 8 years old wear them.

    • Kristen

      I want to be able to vote on a poll btw. But obvi they are fabulous.

    • Kristen

      I want to be able to vote on a poll btw. But obvi they are fabulous.

    • Kellybelly59

      YEA YEA YEA.

    • Kellybelly59

      YEA YEA YEA.

    • aimee_parrott

      Yea!

    • Kiddo

      A million times yea. How fabulous.

    • aimee_parrott

      Yea!

    • Kiddo

      A million times yea. How fabulous.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=705110178 Kyle ‘Deepdish’ Stevenson

      Yea to the shoes, meh to the outfit look

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=705110178 Kyle ‘Deepdish’ Stevenson

      Yea to the shoes, meh to the outfit look

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000357883139 Lynzee Michelle Lamb

      I didn’t know they were making a movie of that book. I read some of it but never finished because I thought the writer’s style was really pompous and over all a chore to read. The story had a great premise though so I might enjoy the film.

      Also: YEA! Those are fabulous shoes.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000357883139 Lynzee Michelle Lamb

      I didn’t know they were making a movie of that book. I read some of it but never finished because I thought the writer’s style was really pompous and over all a chore to read. The story had a great premise though so I might enjoy the film.

      Also: YEA! Those are fabulous shoes.

    • KayLow

      Yea!

    • KayLow

      Yea!

    • Karen Talluto

      Yea!!!!

    • Karen Talluto

      Yea!!!!

    • http://profiles.google.com/thecarlsons1991 Michelle_Randy Carlson

      Wow, for a minute there I thought you were going to give them an “OUT” and I was going to be shocked. They’re fabulous. :)

    • MrsBug

      Wow, for a minute there I thought you were going to give them an “OUT” and I was going to be shocked. They’re fabulous. :)

    • Kimmeister

      YEA! I just wish they weren’t a size too big for her.

    • SeriousStyle

      So much YEA!!!

    • Kimmeister

      YEA! I just wish they weren’t a size too big for her.

    • SeriousStyle

      So much YEA!!!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IHWCJIMARF4OOW6PQZQS3RFOOA JillK

      I LOVE the shoes! But the woman has enough money that she can afford to see a podiatrist to fix those MEGAHIDDY™ feet of hers! ::shudder::

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IHWCJIMARF4OOW6PQZQS3RFOOA JillK

      I LOVE the shoes! But the woman has enough money that she can afford to see a podiatrist to fix those MEGAHIDDY™ feet of hers! ::shudder::

    • http://catherinerhodes.com Catherine

      YEA. I actually love the whole outfit.

    • http://catherinerhodes.com Catherine

      YEA. I actually love the whole outfit.

    • Anonymous

      Like them!

    • celandine

      nay nay nay there is no oufit that can make a giant wart growing from your toes look good.

    • sweetlilvoice

      Like them!

    • celandine

      nay nay nay there is no oufit that can make a giant wart growing from your toes look good.

    • http://pleasewelcomeyourjudges.blogspot.com/ Brian @ PWYJudges

      YEA!

    • http://pleasewelcomeyourjudges.com/ Brian @ PWYJudges

      YEA!

    • Anonymous

      100% Yea on the shoes.

      Are you SURE we can’t discuss the outfit? Because I have so many bitter kittenish things I could say…..

    • http://www.facebook.com/izzzyy Dixie Murphy Ross

      Yea.

      Oh dear God I cannot believe I like those.

    • http://www.ellenciompi.com/ NurseEllen

      100% Yea on the shoes.

      Are you SURE we can’t discuss the outfit? Because I have so many bitter kittenish things I could say…..

    • http://www.facebook.com/izzzyy Dixie Murphy Ross

      Yea.

      Oh dear God I cannot believe I like those.

    • Ittybitty

      Yea!

    • Ittybitty

      Yea!

    • Anonymous

      The shoes are great, but can we talk about the skirt/blouse? J’adore!!!!!

    • Emily

      Yea! FAB-U-LOUS

    • GorgeousThings

      The shoes are great, but can we talk about the skirt/blouse? J’adore!!!!!

    • Emily

      Yea! FAB-U-LOUS

    • JanClare

      I love the skirt and top- and despise the shoes. NAY. Her toes look twisted, those “cinnabons” on the top are hiddy,

    • JanClare

      I love the skirt and top- and despise the shoes. NAY. Her toes look twisted, those “cinnabons” on the top are hiddy,

    • wannabe

      Nay. Love the straps, hate the roses. They look like miniature honeypots and I expected a Pooh character to show up on them. Ridic.

    • umjudis

      Nay – my initial reaction was they’re a takeoff of Philip Treacy hats — that rose will be sprouting feathers next….

    • wannabe

      Nay. Love the straps, hate the roses. They look like miniature honeypots and I expected a Pooh character to show up on them. Ridic.

    • umjudis

      Nay – my initial reaction was they’re a takeoff of Philip Treacy hats — that rose will be sprouting feathers next….

    • Walk It Good

      WANT.

    • Walk It Good

      WANT.

    • Katie

      Yea!

    • Katie

      Yea!

    • Dan

      Yea! I just love her. Those shoes rock.

    • Dan

      Yea! I just love her. Those shoes rock.

    • Val

      YAY! beautifully springy! LOVE!

    • Val

      YAY! beautifully springy! LOVE!

    • http://profiles.google.com/projmgr70 Andrea Gault

      Yea! Want!

    • http://profiles.google.com/projmgr70 Andrea Gault

      Yea! Want!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_MNMVM2GPVUEIOJXBOSLCXKAW4U judy brown

      Up close, kinda interesting and cute. From a distance, some sort of growth, hopefully not cancerous.

    • Joyce

      YEA!

    • http://twitter.com/pamplemouss Benjamin C.

      Yea, and she’s killing it.

    • judybrowni

      Up close, kinda interesting and cute. From a distance, some sort of growth, hopefully not cancerous.

    • Joyce

      YEA!

    • http://twitter.com/pamplemouss Benjamin C.

      Yea, and she’s killing it.

    • bookish

      Yea!

      As soon as I saw them I thought, “Is this even a question? They’re gorgeous! OH…. ankle straps…TLO hates that.” Hah!

    • bookish

      Yea!

      As soon as I saw them I thought, “Is this even a question? They’re gorgeous! OH…. ankle straps…TLO hates that.” Hah!

    • bookish

      Yea!

      As soon as I saw them I thought, “Is this even a question? They’re gorgeous! OH…. ankle straps…TLO hates that.” Hah!

    • bookish

      Yea!

      As soon as I saw them I thought, “Is this even a question? They’re gorgeous! OH…. ankle straps…TLO hates that.” Hah!

    • elleg929

      Yay! Her fashion isn’t my cup of tea but those shoes are gorgeous!

    • elleg929

      Yay! Her fashion isn’t my cup of tea but those shoes are gorgeous!

    • tbk

      I want to be her.

    • tbk

      I want to be her.

    • Michael Jones

      It’s Tilda Swinton. There is no “nay” and there never will be.

    • Michael Jones

      It’s Tilda Swinton. There is no “nay” and there never will be.

    • CPK

      absolutely YES!

    • http://www.joannao.blogspot.com JoannaOC

      Cute, but they don’t fit! blisters, ow ow!

    • Sandy

      Vote nay for one reason only…ugly feet don’t show well .

    • CPK

      absolutely YES!

    • http://www.joannao.blogspot.com JoannaOC

      Cute, but they don’t fit! blisters, ow ow!

    • Instant Karma

      I kind of like them, but upon first glance, I thought she had croissants on her shoes.

    • Instant Karma

      I kind of like them, but upon first glance, I thought she had croissants on her shoes.

    • http://profiles.google.com/laura.jane.ogorman Laura O’Gorman

      Kind of agree.

    • Nancy

      She is fabulous. IN.

    • Nancy

      She is fabulous. IN.

    • Raurie

      The roses make it impossible for me to like these shoes. Nay.

    • Raurie

      The roses make it impossible for me to like these shoes. Nay.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DO54ICWQLRD2STHRSELEATLSKY Cindy

      I do like them.. no of course they aren’t that practical for my use though. I wonder if the flower is itchy on the foot…

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DO54ICWQLRD2STHRSELEATLSKY Cindy

      I do like them.. no of course they aren’t that practical for my use though. I wonder if the flower is itchy on the foot…

    • Where am I?

      Yea

    • Where am I?

      Yea

    • Karen K.

      I’d like the roses more if they weren’t made out of straw. She looks great though. I love her hair.

    • Karen K.

      I’d like the roses more if they weren’t made out of straw. She looks great though. I love her hair.

    • Alf

      Yea. Tilda is truly fabulous.

    • Alf

      Yea. Tilda is truly fabulous.

    • Alf

      Yea. Tilda is truly fabulous.

    • ChelseaNH

      Yea! (Like, duh)

    • ChelseaNH

      Yea! (Like, duh)

    • http://profiles.google.com/tarabrock tara brock

      Very nice but they look very painful.

    • http://profiles.google.com/tarabrock tara brock

      very nice but they look very painful.

    • http://profiles.google.com/tarabrock tara brock

      Very nice but they look very painful.

    • http://profiles.google.com/tarabrock tara brock

      very nice but they look very painful.

    • Anonymous

      Yea x10! Did you even need to ask? ;-)

    • librarygrrl64

      Yea x10! Did you even need to ask? ;-)

    • Anonymous

      Close up they are cute, I find that thorn detail very clever. But the roses look from far like the shoe grew warts,

      so NAY.

    • http://twitter.com/skinnyrhodes Kate Skinner

      Big huge YEA!!!

    • ElisaSchmetterling

      Close up they are cute, I find that thorn detail very clever. But the roses look from far like the shoe grew warts,

      so NAY.

    • http://twitter.com/skinnyrhodes Kate Skinner

      Big huge YEA!!!

    • Lisasabatier

      On her, yea!

    • Lisasabatier

      On her, yea!

    • http://twitter.com/RocknLox Khadijah James

      I’m not feeling it. A wicker rose? Meh…

    • RocknLox

      I’m not feeling it. A wicker rose? Meh…

    • http://twitter.com/RocknLox Khadijah James

      I’m not feeling it. A wicker rose? Meh…

    • SMM

      Yea!

    • SMM

      Yea!

    • SMM

      Yea!

    • Guest

      Not really interested

    • Guest

      Not really interested

    • Michelle Shields

      oh hell yea!

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Michelle-Shields/1200782178 Michelle Shields

      oh hell yea!

    • tee

      Yes!!! She’s a badass.

    • tee

      Yes!!! She’s a badass.

    • Jesinalbuquerque

      great shoes. HOWEVER, I’ve never seen a woman past say, early 20s, who has the legs and feet to carry off bare legs and naked sandals. Buy some host, for pity sake.

    • Polyethylenepam

      NAY. flowers are just too big.

    • Polyethylenepam

      NAY. flowers are just too big.

    • Terri in SF

      YEA! I actually liked the whole look.

    • ask

      Looking at them again… so not wearable. Look how low that heel “cup” (cap?) is. And in the shoe alone view the ankle strap is raised away from and in from the back with a thin strap across basically just the toes and 5-6″ spiky heels. (And worn on cracked, holey stone ground?) And on top of that they don’t fit?

      So many women here saying how great they are. No wonder there are so many unwearable women’s shoes.

    • Terri in SF

      YEA! I actually liked the whole look.

    • ask

      Looking at them again… so not wearable. Look how low that heel “cup” (cap?) is. And in the shoe alone view the ankle strap is raised away from and in from the back with a thin strap across basically just the toes and 5-6″ spiky heels. (And worn on cracked, holey stone ground?) And on top of that they don’t fit?

      So many women here saying how great they are. No wonder there are so many unwearable women’s shoes.

    • http://www.tomandlorenzo.com/ Tom and Lorenzo

      Kittens, just a reminder that this is a post asking your opinions on Tilda’s shoes; not on her feet, legs or skin.

    • http://www.tomandorenzo.com Tom and Lorenzo

      Kittens, just a reminder that this is a post asking your opinions on Tilda’s shoes; not on her feet, legs or skin.

    • marciekr

      NAY!

    • http://beautyforrealgirls.blogspot.com/ accidental housewife

      I guess if anyone can get away with them, it’s SWINTON. But, still, NAY.

      She is pullling off My Favorite Look That I Cannot Wear: High-waisted skirt with a loose, tucked-in blouse. I don’t often bemoan my body, but it pisses me off that I can’t wear that look.

    • marciekr

      NAY!

    • Anonymous

      I guess if anyone can get away with them, it’s SWINTON. But, still, NAY.

      She is pullling off My Favorite Look That I Cannot Wear: High-waisted skirt with a loose, tucked-in blouse. I don’t often bemoan my body, but it pisses me off that I can’t wear that look.

    • Megan

      Nay for me, but yea for Tilda.

    • Megan

      Nay for me, but yea for Tilda.

    • jw_ny

      Yea

      Simple outfit so as to place all attention on the focal point…the shoes. Killah!

    • Anonymous

      Yea

      Simple outfit so as to place all attention on the focal point…the shoes. Killah!

    • Anonymous

      It’s just her bunions…they do that.

    • ItsDicey

      Nay. Not digging the shoes but she looks really fabulous otherwise.

    • Anonymous

      Nay. Not digging the shoes but she looks really fabulous otherwise.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=630305365 Leah Smith McGregor

      So. Much. Yea!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=630305365 Leah Smith McGregor

      So. Much. Yea!

    • Suzanne

      Yea!

    • Suzanne

      Yea!

    • MmmmmmmmK

      BIG YEA.

    • Anonymous

      BIG YEA.

    • http://twitter.com/Unclassical Alexandria N

      YEA!!!! Jeasus, Oprah, & Beiber! is that a flowered shoe that doesn’t look like it was ripped off the foot of a sorority bridesmaid? Halleluja!

    • http://twitter.com/Unclassical Alexandria N

      YEA!!!! Jeasus, Oprah, & Beiber! is that a flowered shoe that doesn’t look like it was ripped off the foot of a sorority bridesmaid? Halleluja!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PHBN5RJ6BJHC72S22IIP3J437E Jae

      YEA!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PHBN5RJ6BJHC72S22IIP3J437E Jae

      YEA!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3CGY36NG25QFIZQOLMH7SQTKLU andrew

      Nay– sorta. Love the shoes but hate them on Tilda’s feet.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3CGY36NG25QFIZQOLMH7SQTKLU andrew

      Nay– sorta. Love the shoes but hate them on Tilda’s feet.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1401197785 Jennifer Peters-Ahnberg

      That would be an AWWWWW Yea!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1401197785 Jennifer Peters-Ahnberg

      That would be an AWWWWW Yea!

    • https://twitter.com/LisaF1163 Lisa

      They would be a YAY for me! Normally, I just hate her style, and she’s still not rocking it for me otherwise, but the shoes are fabulous!

    • Lisa

      They would be a YAY for me! Normally, I just hate her style, and she’s still not rocking it for me otherwise, but the shoes are fabulous!

    • SatelliteAlice

      Yea!!!

      Gorge shoes! Seriously.

    • Anonymous

      Yea!!!

      Gorge shoes! Seriously.

    • Ben

      Yea! I was convinced you guys were going to say Nay though when I saw them at first.

    • Ben

      Yea! I was convinced you guys were going to say Nay though when I saw them at first.

    • formerlyAnon

      Shoes, YEA. But she could have used some stockings.

    • Anonymous

      Shoes, YEA. But she could have used some stockings.

    • Momzilla

      Yea… but where is the basket weave on that tiny heel cup?

    • Momzilla

      Yea… but where is the basket weave on that tiny heel cup?

    • Spcl K

      Have never like ankle straps, but this is a good shoe for the right person.

    • Spcl K

      Have never like ankle straps, but this is a good shoe for the right person.

    • andyleigh

      Regarding the clothes, if by “not very interesting” you mean butt ugly, then they are indeed not very interesting clothes. That skirt is hiddy, that blouse is inexplicable and together they make a combo that makes my eyes roll back in my head from the awfulness of it all. I don’t think it’s inappropriate to call this outfit “Ew!”

      That said, the shoes are fantastic. Bony ankles and thin ankle straps are a painful combination, but I’m not wearing them so I can look on them as the gift she gave us to try to trick us from looking upward at that mess she’s wearing. I hope it was just a bad day, I really do. Let’s hope tomorrow is much better for her.

      The shoes are IN!

    • andyleigh

      Regarding the clothes, if by “not very interesting” you mean butt ugly, then they are indeed not very interesting clothes. That skirt is hiddy, that blouse is inexplicable and together they make a combo that makes my eyes roll back in my head from the awfulness of it all. I don’t think it’s inappropriate to call this outfit “Ew!”

      That said, the shoes are fantastic. Bony ankles and thin ankle straps are a painful combination, but I’m not wearing them so I can look on them as the gift she gave us to try to trick us from looking upward at that mess she’s wearing. I hope it was just a bad day, I really do. Let’s hope tomorrow is much better for her.

      The shoes are IN!

    • yan

      Yea!

      Hate that blouse, though. Even on her.

    • yan

      Yea!

      Hate that blouse, though. Even on her.

    • http://profiles.google.com/jgonz85 Jasmine Gonzalez

      yea!

    • http://profiles.google.com/jgonz85 Jasmine Gonzalez

      yea!

    • Lauren

      Yea- Adorable.

    • Lauren

      Yea- Adorable.

    • Josh

      YEA!

    • Golden J

      yea, but they would have been YEA X A MILLION if they didn’t have those silly tumors on them.

    • Josh

      YEA!

    • Golden J

      yea, but they would have been YEA X A MILLION if they didn’t have those silly tumors on them.

    • Rosterberg1

      would someone please slap some color on her face… she always looks like an alien :P

    • Rosterberg1

      would someone please slap some color on her face… she always looks like an alien :P

    • http://twitter.com/mariacarson Maria Carson

      Love them!

    • Zippypie

      NAY – I hate this espadrille look on more formal shoes. Yuck. Reminds me of strips of burlap sack. The potato sack challenge from PR. Just not pretty.

    • http://twitter.com/mariacarson Maria Carson

      Love them!

    • Anonymous

      NAY – I hate this espadrille look on more formal shoes. Yuck. Reminds me of strips of burlap sack. The potato sack challenge from PR. Just not pretty.

    • Kristheot

      Oh, I liked these shoes until you mentioned the dog bone. Now I can only see rawhide. Nay!

    • Kcjamison

      Best shoes I have seen in a while. They almost fit her. Don’t you know she had on her outfit on and some PR person shoves the shoes at Tilda and say you have to were these. There is no other reason for this devine summer shoe to be with this buiness lunch outfit.

    • Tenley

      oh god no

    • Kcjamison

      Best shoes I have seen in a while. They almost fit her. Don’t you know she had on her outfit on and some PR person shoves the shoes at Tilda and say you have to were these. There is no other reason for this devine summer shoe to be with this buiness lunch outfit.

    • Tenley

      oh god no

    • Lorelei

      Love the shoes, do not love that they don’t appear to fit her that well. If she’s taking the onto the red carpet, she merits a pair that fits.

    • Lorelei

      Love the shoes, do not love that they don’t appear to fit her that well. If she’s taking the onto the red carpet, she merits a pair that fits.

    • SweetCaroline

      These shoes are one of those thinks that are Pretty In Theory. In practice, they’re the PITs!

      The picture makes them look gorgeous, but on her feet, they’re just akward.

      NAY

    • SweetCaroline

      These shoes are one of those thinks that are Pretty In Theory. In practice, they’re the PITs!

      The picture makes them look gorgeous, but on her feet, they’re just akward.

      NAY

    • SweetCaroline

      I think I’m going to change my vote. I looked at them again, and while I know, I – or most mortals – couldnt pull it off, this is SWINTON we’re talking about here. She’s doing a cheeky, high fashion secretary look, and I think she’s pulling it off. I spoke too soon

      YAY SWINTON!

    • SweetCaroline

      I think I’m going to change my vote. I looked at them again, and while I know, I – or most mortals – couldnt pull it off, this is SWINTON we’re talking about here. She’s doing a cheeky, high fashion secretary look, and I think she’s pulling it off. I spoke too soon

      YAY SWINTON!

    • http://summerborn.livejournal.com/ Summer Born

      YEA!

    • Dreamwell157

      I like them on the rack, but ouch. Her toes look all crunched in the closeup. Not an attractive look.

    • http://summerborn.livejournal.com/ Summer Born

      YEA!

    • http://summerborn.livejournal.com/ Summer Born

      YEA!

    • Dreamwell157

      I like them on the rack, but ouch. Her toes look all crunched in the closeup. Not an attractive look.

    • Dreamwell157

      I like them on the rack, but ouch. Her toes look all crunched in the closeup. Not an attractive look.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1628254116 Lisa Renninger

      LOVE them! BTW, did you see Gaga’s p@#%s shoes on American Idol? Fox had to censor them!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1628254116 Lisa Renninger

      LOVE them! BTW, did you see Gaga’s p@#%s shoes on American Idol? Fox had to censor them!

    • Mary

      I must confess – I absolutely adore them.

    • guest

      Yea!
      Wish they fit!
      Water retention! She looks sllliiimmm.

    • Mary

      I must confess – I absolutely adore them.

    • guest

      Yea!
      Wish they fit!
      Water retention! She looks sllliiimmm.

    • Altissima

      LOVE the shoes. Don’t love the pale blotchy mottled legs and feet. Never heard of sandle-toe stockings Tilda??

    • Jrittenberg

      The gold rose is perfect! YEA!

    • Jrittenberg

      The gold rose is perfect! YEA!

    • LittleKarnak

      Yay on the shoes but she really needs to get that bunion addressed!!!!

    • MeganPatterson

      love it, love them, love her. 

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=513945580 Megan Patterson

      love it, love them, love her. 

    • iambilljr

      Nay.  They look great empty.  They look like a rafia craft project with a foot in them.

    • Anonymous

      Nay.  They look great empty.  They look like a rafia craft project with a foot in them.

    • Alex

      Yea!

    • Alex

      Yea!

    • Dan_In_NYC

      yay,

    • Anonymous

      yay,

    • PrunellaV

      Those shoes make me want to go on vacation!

    • Prunella

      Those shoes make me want to go on vacation!

    • Leslie S

      yay! she can pull them off ’cause she’s tilda-motherfucking-swinton!

    • Leslie S

      yay! she can pull them off ’cause she’s tilda-motherfucking-swinton!

    • Anathema_Device

      Yay! 

    • Anonymous

      Yay! 

    • Ann Chatterton

      Yay

    • Ann Chatterton

      Yay

    • Ann Chatterton

      Yay

    • Chaka

       Yea.  I would marry those shoes.

    • Chaka

       Yea.  I would marry those shoes.

    • http://twitter.com/IfIwasasculptor Erin Leahy

      Nay! I love ankle straps, but hate flowers made out of stupid shit.

    • http://twitter.com/IfIwasasculptor Erin Leahy

      Nay! I love ankle straps, but hate flowers made out of stupid shit.

    • StL K

       Nay. They look silly and painful. I like the outfit.

    • StL K

       Nay. They look silly and painful. I like the outfit.

    • Caity

      YEA!

    • Caity

      YEA!

    • PatBiswanger

       YEA.  But my feet hurt just looking at them.

    • PatBiswanger

       YEA.  But my feet hurt just looking at them.

    • fursa_saida

      YEA VERILY YEA. The way the ankle strap connects to the main body of the shoe in the back is so much more elegant and interesting than the usual “it’s a circle that accidentally bumped into the back of a pump” strategy. It’s like a mini-t-strap in reverse, almost, and the resulting lower back of the shoe makes her ankles look freaking gorgeous from the back. (I don’t think I’ve ever considered what ankles looked like from the back before. One more thing to worry about while getting dressed, now. THANKS A LOT, SWINTON.)

    • Anonymous

      YEA VERILY YEA. The way the ankle strap connects to the main body of the shoe in the back is so much more elegant and interesting than the usual “it’s a circle that accidentally bumped into the back of a pump” strategy. It’s like a mini-t-strap in reverse, almost, and the resulting lower back of the shoe makes her ankles look freaking gorgeous from the back. (I don’t think I’ve ever considered what ankles looked like from the back before. One more thing to worry about while getting dressed, now. THANKS A LOT, SWINTON.)

    • Anonymous

      What on earth is wrong with her legs?

    • Anonymous

      I think it’s because, like me, Tilda has very wide feet across the ball and narrow heels. Look at the picture where you can see her feet from the front: in order to accommodate her foot with the strap in the front, she probably had to go up to a size that’s maybe a bit too long. Been there a thousand times. (Actually, it looks like she might have bunions, which my mother and I both also have, and let me tell you, that only makes the “wedge-shaped foot” problem you were born with a thousand times worse. Oy.)

    • Laurieroz

      YEA!  I especially love the little thorn on the heel!

      • Deborah

         Nearly 6 full pages of comments and I think you are the first to mention the little thorn. I say YEAH! Though the thorn makes them a bit “themey,” I still think they are pretty fab.

    • Laurieroz

      YEA!  I especially love the little thorn on the heel!

    • Nariya

       Yea! And Yay! Swinton!

    • Nariya

       Yea! And Yay! Swinton!

    • paginatrix

      Yea yea yea, oh God yea!

    • Anonymous

      Yea yea yea, oh God yea!

    • Kriky

       Yea!

    • moohoop

       The rosette looks like a pillsbury cinnamon roll… which means they are DELICIOUS.

    • Anonymous

       Yea!

    • Anonymous

       The rosette looks like a pillsbury cinnamon roll… which means they are DELICIOUS.

    • girliecue

      Nay. I hate flowers on shoes the way you two hate ankle straps. I’m even going to find a way to blame those flowers for causing the veins on Ms. Swinton’s legs to pop out. She didn’t seem to have that problem with other shoes. Just sayin’.

    • girliecue

      Nay. I hate flowers on shoes the way you two hate ankle straps. I’m even going to find a way to blame those flowers for causing the veins on Ms. Swinton’s legs to pop out. She didn’t seem to have that problem with other shoes. Just sayin’.

    • Anonymous

      Let me clarify.  Tilda’s Tildaness that makes this shoe werq…She’s like an older version of those tall, androgynous, almost ugly with great cheek bones exotic models, and her perpetual mood is one of proud apathy to fashion standards of mere mortals. She’s made for experimental fashion.  

      Tan, happy, people pleasing girl next door cheerleaders like Blake Lively or Jennifer Aniston, don’t have the ladyballs to wear this shoe. Their “trying too hard” would soooo be showing and this shoe would be definitely nay. 

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=704416981 Peter Anthony Ryan

      NAY

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=704416981 Peter Anthony Ryan

      NAY

    • MP

      Nay…if feet can age a woman like hands can, these feet shots do it to Tilda.  

    • http://moodring54.livejournal.com/ moodring54

      Yea! Are they suppossed to fit like that though? It doesn’t change my vote, but it’s interesting.

    • http://moodring54.livejournal.com/ moodring54

      Yea! Are they suppossed to fit like that though? It doesn’t change my vote, but it’s interesting.

    • demidaemon

      YEA!!! 

    • Anonymous

      YEA!!! 

    • Christine Marie

      It’s something that Tilda Swinton is wearing. . . . is that even a question? Silly bitches

      YEA

    • Christine Marie

      It’s something that Tilda Swinton is wearing. . . . is that even a question? Silly bitches

      YEA

    • alyce1213

       The shoes are brilliant! Unlike youse guys, I love ankle straps. But they are 1/2 size too large for her, can’t you tell?

    • alyce1213

       The shoes are brilliant! Unlike youse guys, I love ankle straps. But they are 1/2 size too large for her, can’t you tell?

    • ubiquitous

      A bit too big in the back, but drop-dead stunning shoes.

    • ubiquitous

      A bit too big in the back, but drop-dead stunning shoes.

    • Brendan

      Yea!

    • Brendan

      Yea!

    • http://www.facebook.com/sorana.tarmu Sorana Tarmu

      I am sorry, but why on earth would I want to look like I stuck a choux-a-la-creme on my …well, shoe. I like the little bump on the heel, though. Still NAY.

    • http://www.facebook.com/sorana.tarmu Sorana Tarmu

      I am sorry, but why on earth would I want to look like I stuck a choux-a-la-creme on my …well, shoe. I like the little bump on the heel, though. Still NAY.

    • Tropbelle

      YEA. There is very little TS can do without me falling in love with her all over again.

    • Tropbelle

      YEA. There is very little TS can do without me falling in love with her all over again.

    • http://profiles.google.com/cracklerod Jasper Peng

       nay — the shape and colors really match the outfit and the occasion, but that looks like two garlic rolls glued onto her feet, but that looks like two garlic rolls glued onto her feet

    • http://profiles.google.com/cracklerod Jasper Peng

       nay — the shape and colors really match the outfit and the occasion, but that looks like two garlic rolls glued onto her feet, but that looks like two garlic rolls glued onto her feet

    • NewtonGOTbeaned

      I don’t know.  I can’t get over how freaking uncomfortable they look.

    • NewtonGOTbeaned

      I don’t know.  I can’t get over how freaking uncomfortable they look.

    • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

       I love the little thorn in the back.

    • Diane_G

      I’d buy the knockoffs at Target. I use Tilda oftentimes as a reference because I’m tall, straight and leggy as well.  Yup, I can wear it. IN.
      But what that shirt? Droopy sideboob much? Blech.

    • http://profiles.google.com/sara.e.munoz Sara Munoz

       I love the little thorn in the back.

    • Anonymous

      I’d buy the knockoffs at Target. I use Tilda oftentimes as a reference because I’m tall, straight and leggy as well.  Yup, I can wear it. IN.
      But what that shirt? Droopy sideboob much? Blech.

    • kaycem

      i agree ~ they’re fab and she’s working the shit out of them… i’m sure many BKs will disagree, but i think this is one of the FEW times espadrille-esque shoes look chic or even wearable.

    • kayce.

      i agree ~ they’re fab and she’s working the shit out of them… i’m sure many BKs will disagree, but i think this is one of the FEW times espadrille-esque shoes look chic or even wearable.

    • KC

       She looks like she has a growth on her foot…

    • KC

       She looks like she has a growth on her foot…

    • Pingback: Kentura » Tilda Swinton in Silk Blouse: Our Look of the Day

    • http://www.mikellestreet.blogspot.com/ Mikelle S

       I’m not loving the rose so much.

    • http://www.markese91.blogspot.com Mikelle S

       I’m not loving the rose so much.

    • Lulu

      Looks like she dropped her knish on her shoe.

    • Lulu

      Looks like she dropped her knish on her shoe.

    • Eve

      Yes!  Especially the rosettes.  So there! 

    • Eve

      Yes!  Especially the rosettes.  So there! 

    • http://twitter.com/MidnightHarlow Jackdee Baptiste

      Yea! But couldn’t she slap some polish on those toes..a nude, a sheer pink, cotton candy color or something.

    • http://twitter.com/MidnightHarlow Jackdee Baptiste

      Yea! But couldn’t she slap some polish on those toes..a nude, a sheer pink, cotton candy color or something.

    • Theresaharnisch

      yea – and love the thorn detail!

    • Theresaharnisch

      yea – and love the thorn detail!

    • ScottHesterJohnson

      The bland outfit up top demands that you pay those shoes the respect they deserve. Kuh-dooz.

    • Anonymous

      The bland outfit up top demands that you pay those shoes the respect they deserve. Kuh-dooz.

    • Anonymous

      The bland outfit up top demands that you pay those shoes the respect they deserve. Kuh-dooz.

    • Perry

      Hells to the Yea! 

    • Perry

      Hells to the Yea! 

    • AudreysMom

      Yea. But Tilda demands nothing less. 

    • Anonymous

      Yea. But Tilda demands nothing less. 

    • Bmgurru

       KILLA!

    • Bmgurru

       KILLA!

    • Snarla

      Yea! 

    • Snarla

      Yea! 

    • Andres

      yea!! 

    • Andres

      yea!! 

    • Victoria Sharoyan

      When did Cinnabon get a line at Payless?

    • Victoria Sharoyan

      When did Cinnabon get a line at Payless?

    • Say What

      Nay because they don’t fit her.

    • Say What

      Nay because they don’t fit her.

    • Magnolia

      Very easy Yea for me. I like the outfit a lot; it’s subtle but classy, the color combination is nice on her, and it sets off the shoes, which she wisely chose as the point of interest, quite well.

      But forget that – I just figured out, after years of seeing her here in TLo posts, and wondering why I have the nagging suspicion she reminds me of someone, who that someone is. This bitch could be David Bowie’s twin!

    • Magnolia

      Very easy Yea for me. I like the outfit a lot; it’s subtle but classy, the color combination is nice on her, and it sets off the shoes, which she wisely chose as the point of interest, quite well.

      But forget that – I just figured out, after years of seeing her here in TLo posts, and wondering why I have the nagging suspicion she reminds me of someone, who that someone is. This bitch could be David Bowie’s twin!

    • Deborah

       Nearly 6 full pages of comments and I think you are the first to mention the little thorn. I say YEAH! Though the thorn makes them a bit “themey,” I still think they are pretty fab.

    • Niandra

      Her foot erupted with a straw tumor. Nay

    • Niandra

      Her foot erupted with a straw tumor. Nay

    • Michelle*

      Ok, I’m late to the party on this one but really Tilda can do no wrong in my book.  That being said, I have a question:  Do we no longer wear hose/pantyhose?  Am I dating myself by asking?  Yeah, I’m an older lady (55) so maybe I am but if we don’t wear pantyhose/stockings anymore what do we do?  Leg makeup???  Anyone?

    • Michelle*

      Ok, I’m late to the party on this one but really Tilda can do no wrong in my book.  That being said, I have a question:  Do we no longer wear hose/pantyhose?  Am I dating myself by asking?  Yeah, I’m an older lady (55) so maybe I am but if we don’t wear pantyhose/stockings anymore what do we do?  Leg makeup???  Anyone?

    • Carrie W

      Yea!!

    • Carrie W

      Yea!!

    • http://profiles.google.com/mjmillersbb marcia miller

      Nay!  EEEEEEEEEEEKK!!  Don’t like the flower growth.

    • http://profiles.google.com/mjmillersbb marcia miller

      Nay!  EEEEEEEEEEEKK!!  Don’t like the flower growth.

    • Scuba Otter

      The shoes are a yea, though I think nylons or nude airbrushing is called for to cover those blue veiny legs. 

    • Scuba Otter

      The shoes are a yea, though I think nylons or nude airbrushing is called for to cover those blue veiny legs. 

    • Judy_J

       I know I’m weighing in too late, but I just have to voice my opinion, ’cause that’s the kinda gal I am.  Cute shoes, but PLEASE, please make sure they fit before you wear them.  

    • Judy_J

       I know I’m weighing in too late, but I just have to voice my opinion, ’cause that’s the kinda gal I am.  Cute shoes, but PLEASE, please make sure they fit before you wear them.  

    • Gorengirl

      I love the whole look. Beautiful blouse….. and I am not a Swinton fan.
       

    • Anonymous

      I love the whole look. Beautiful blouse….. and I am not a Swinton fan.
       

    • Foxy

       Shoes are great but they are too big on her and her feet are not pretty so the close-ups are not good.

    • Foxy

       Shoes are great but they are too big on her and her feet are not pretty so the close-ups are not good.

    • http://profiles.google.com/mochizukisan kyasarin mochizuki

       YEA in theory, but, in actuality, on actual human feet (well, as human as Tilda Swinton can claim to be), I must say NAY.

    • http://profiles.google.com/mochizukisan kyasarin mochizuki

       YEA in theory, but, in actuality, on actual human feet (well, as human as Tilda Swinton can claim to be), I must say NAY.

    • EEK/STL

       Yea! Love them. Queen Tilda can do no wrong, even when she does wrong.

    • EEK/STL

       Yea! Love them. Queen Tilda can do no wrong, even when she does wrong.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3DHL7N5EW3MAOBF7GF22OTQBSM ShawnH

      Yea times 5000!!!!

    • http://twitter.com/Carolcdt Carol Terry

      Yea. Usually dislike ankle straps. And not sure how many could pull it off. But on her: yea.